4 ms·
GMO is harmful: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetically_modified_food#Health_and_safety https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetically_modified_food#Heal... Bio/o
by fsflover 4y ago
GMO is harmful: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetically_modified_food#Health_and_safety https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetically_modified_food#Heal...
Bio/organic food is healthier than the regular food: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organic_food#Health_and_safety https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organic_food#Health_and_safety
- lamontcg 4y ago> currently available food derived from GM crops poses no greater risk to human health than conventional food What if "conventional food" is bad and has been bred for things like appearance and shelf-stability over nutrition?
- ollien 4y ago> Bio/organic food is healthy This is misleading from the link you sent. > There is little scientific evidence of benefit or harm to human health from a diet high in organic food, and conducting any sort of rigorous experiment on the subject is very difficult It would be more correct to say "healthier than non-organic food". I read your message at first thinking you meant organics were unhealthy :)
- fsflover 4y agoYou are right, thanks. I edited my post.
- magillax 4y agoYeah I don’t think you can say that about GMOs - besides the issues of seed patenting/subsequent litigation and self terminating seeds - the EPA was just ordered to re assess the safety of roundup. And there’s plenty of studies that show round up probably isn’t great. https://enveurope.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s12302-020-0296-8 https://enveurope.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s12302-0...
- djbusby 4y ago[deleted]
- Loughla 4y agoWhat? What corporation would order that? That's such a crucial, money making chemical that the EPA buried the problems with it the first time. What are you trying to get at with this statement?
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoRoundup is an herbicide.
- Loughla 4y agoWhich is easily and widely used because of Roundup ready crops, GMO's.
- flaviut 4y agoThe paper you link isn't a study, it is a "discussion", and the author also states the following: > The emails further demonstrated that since 2005 Monsanto has attempted to destroy my team’s work and reputation, in particular by recruiting third-party, supposedly independent experts at the highest levels to voice ghost-written and biased arguments (Henry Miller or Wallace Hayes, for instance [10,11,12]), who did not, however, publicly disclose their links with Monsanto I'm not saying that the author is wrong, or that their criticisms of the other study are meritless (I have 0 experience in this field), especially with the widespread ethics concerns they point out. But this particular paper doesn't draw any conclusions.
- magillax 4y agoI never said it draws any conclusions - I'm just saying that "GMOs are harmful" has not been conclusively invalidated by data by any means - and there's definitely plenty of data out there to cause concern IMO. I don't buy organic food because I think it's healthier either btw. I do it because of the environmental impacts - same reason I buy local as much as possible via CSAs for my meat and veggies - whether they are certified organic or not (you can usually find a local farm that has practices just as good or better than certified organic anyways). It's super ironic to me that people think they're being environmentally friendly or saving the earth with GMO non-organic food just because it isn't meat. For all the conspiracies around Bill Gates I think his ideas of using tech to save the environment are scarier because it's actually ignoring science.
- rglullis 4y agoWeird. Both of these should be textbook examples of how to tell lies using only "scientific" truths. It's very easy to look at both at these data points and think "oh, so it's okay to just go and support GMO and ignore organic farmers". In reality though, the criticism against GMO is how its wide-scale adoption destroys genetic diversity, and how this lack of diversity is a huge potential source of systemic risks.
- mickael-kerjean 4y agoGMO was banned in France after a study was made on rats showing all sort of health issues: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5044955/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5044955/
- lobocinza 4y agoYeah but of the thousand of times I heard "GMOs are bad", 999 were followed by "to your health".
- fsflover 4y agoYou did not provide any links.
- rglullis 4y agoWhat links do you need?! By definition, GMO crops all come from the same genetic seeds.
- aidenn0 4y agoLinks showing that the primary criticism is as you say; most critics of GMO and proponents of organic that I know are all about "only putting natural stuff in my body"
- rglullis 4y ago> "only putting natural stuff in my body" That's not a belief, this is a stated preference, and you would be fully entitled to ignore it as "invalid criticism" due to the confusion between facts and opinions. The belief that you are actually asking me to "back up with links" is that GMO reduces genetic diversity. Do you really need a link for that?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- chadash 4y agoThe title of this post says "conclusively invalidated by data" and I'm not sure anything is conclusive when it comes to organic food. The evidence that the Moderna vaccine lowers the risk of death due to COVID is conclusive in the sense that a controlled, double blind study was performed and we have determined with some degree of certainty (>99.9%) that the vaccine is effective. But it's relatively easy to design an experiment. How would you even go about designing an experiment for organic food. Giving a vaccine is binary... it was given on two occasions or it wasn't. With organic food, if there are benefits to it, they are most likely over a much longer term. So you'd need to police a participant's eating habits for years or maybe even decades to test your hypothesis. It's not a practical experiment to perform. At best we can say "there's no scientific evidence that organic food is better for you than non-organic", but that's not the same as saying "we have concluded with 99.9% certainty that organic food is no better for you than non-organic food". Certain things just can't be tested effectively, especially things as complicated as diet. This is why dietary recommendations change so frequently. Still, not everything requires conclusive science. There's never been a controlled experiment showing that parachutes save skydivers' lives. But sometimes common sense trumps the need for scientific inquiry. EDIT: Please don't read this as anti-science. On the contrary, science is great for answering certain questions, but has limitations for other questions.
- andyjohnson0 4y ago> GMO is harmful On the basis of the article that you linked to, I think it would be more accurate to say that "currently available GMO food is not thought to be harmful to humans." There is nothing inherent in genetic modification that prevents if from being used to create food that is harmful when consumed by people (or animals) - whether due to toxicity or negative dietary effects. There probably isn't much incentive to do the former (except maybe as a weapon of war or terrorism), but engineering unhealthy but addictive foods isn't hard to imagine. Similarly, theres nothing in the technology that prevents it from being used to develop plants or animals that cause harm to their environment - for example by runaway reproduction, excessive use of resources like water, affecting species equilibria, etc. I personally wouldn't be worried about eating a GMO foodstuff, but I'm extremely unhappy about the environmental impact of ideas like terminator seeds or engineered pesticide resistance that leads to over-use of pesticides, and I wouldn't call them "safe".
- fsflover 4y ago> On the basis of the article that you linked to, I think it would be more accurate to say that "currently available GMO food is not thought to be harmful to humans." I would actually say instead that "there is no reason to think that genetic modification itself introduces any additional danger to the food". Of course you can create dangerous food using GMO. You can also just poison it, too.
- phkahler 4y agoAlso on the flip side - the notion the GMO are all the same risk. This should be obviously untrue.