11 ms·
Potato diet community trial
- dane-pgp 4y agoThat reminds of the old Simpsons episode, "Lisa the Tree Hugger", where she meets a boy who is a "level 5 vegan" and thus "won't eat anything that casts a shadow."
- modulated 4y agoI’d be very cautious about following any mono diet for a prolonged period of time. For every anecdote you find with a positive story you can find an opposing narrative. I work as a physician and had a patient come in through emergency very sick after eating nothing but potatoes for 2 years.
- hansword 4y agoI thought this was super silly, but when I read the article I thought it quite interesting. Shame he study is all google based.. :(
- Animats 4y agoOh, the "Irish Potato Diet".[1] [1] https://www.irishcentral.com/culture/food-drink/irish-potato-weight-loss-diet https://www.irishcentral.com/culture/food-drink/irish-potato...
- leobg 4y agoThe Irish? I thought that was a joke throwback to 1845.
- cheese_goddess 4y agoThe way HN crops your link I thought it would lead to an article about the Irish potato famine.
- DeWilde 4y ago> It sounds like a dumb gimmick that could never work, but there are a surprising number of people out there saying that they tried it, it worked for them, and they kept the weight off for months or even years after. Losing weight isn't causal to being healthy. In most cases it correlates because gaining weight is usually done through eating unhealthy (excess calories, refined sugars, etc.) so going on a healthy diet means losing weight gained from unhealthy diet. Also, there are unhealthy diets on which you can lose weight but the effects on your hormones might be even worse than an unhealthy diet that causes you to gain weight.
- adrianN 4y agoYou can gain weight on a diet of "healthy" foods. It's the amount of calories. Being overweight is bad for your health even if you only eat healthy foods.
- sinsterizme 4y agoSure, but healthy foods contain more nutrients, that’s why they can be called healthy. So fueling your body to excess with a lot of nutrients will lead to a much better functioning body than doing the same with garbage
- automatic6131 4y ago>fueling your body to excess with a lot of nutrients A commonly held myth about eating is that fueling the body with an excess of (micro)nutrients is healthier than fueling the body with an adequate amount of micro nutrients. It is not healthier, it is exactly the same (and then becomes toxic again in excess!) And as you know, fueling the body with excess macronutrients is unhealthy. Indeed, eating a diet poor or absent in micronutrients is bad for you, but also quite rare.
- sinsterizme 4y agoI don’t think it’s quite as rare as you think. I don’t have sources to back this up at the moment but some common deficiencies include vitamin D, b12, magnesium, zinc, sulphur. Our modern practices have denuded the soil, plants and animals of a lot of their nutrients so nowadays it’s indeed hard to be at good levels of nutrients from diet
- potiuper 4y ago"No dairy": would result in a Vitamin D deficit unless the some other food fortified with vitamin D is used, person is living in a tropical region with little clothing, or the multivitamin option is chosen over the emphasized B12 supplement. It also lacks fiber: https://spoonuniversity.com/lifestyle/potatoes-and-milk-is-the-martians-diet-sustainable https://spoonuniversity.com/lifestyle/potatoes-and-milk-is-t...
- sschueller 4y agoIsn't most Vitamin D "absorbed" (generated via sun light) via skin and only very little via diet?
- TylerE 4y agoIn theory. In practice most people, especially at non-Tropical latitudes or who don’t spend multiple hours outside everyday don’t get nearly enough.
- 2000UltraDeluxe 4y agoAll day at Arctic latitudes, and that assumes your skin is somewhat lightly pigmented, and that you don't live too far north. If you do, there is no sunlight during winter. If you've got a daytime job, live above the Arctic circle or immigrated, then your only option is to eat vitamin D-rich foods or eat supplements.
- alar44 4y agoYeah which is why so many people have problems with vitamin D, not enough sunlight. That's hard to control, but you can take vitamins daily.
- aksss 4y agoNot necessarily. The best way to get it is arguably via the sun, but with caveats. Because of the thickness of the atmosphere when the sun is at lower altitudes you will only start to get enough UV-B penetrating when the sun is at an angle of >=35 degrees. If you are within 35 degrees of equator you can get UV-B every day, but outside of these latitudes there are many months where there's just not enough solar hang time high enough in the sky to deliver any meaningful amount of UV-B. The shitty part is, the whole time and more you're still getting UV-A, which is a known cancer risk. Depending on your clothing, skin pigment, weight, and age, UV-B uptake may be significantly reduced (up to 6x for dark skin pigment, 2x for age over 50). So while you can get UV-B from the sun in mid-day at the right latitudes, most people benefit from supplementing. Good info at the D-Minder app site: https://dminder.ontometrics.com/ https://dminder.ontometrics.com/ I think what I've learned from this is supplement, supplement, supplement.
- 2Gkashmiri 4y agoi consider myself a potato connoisseur. i have been eating and loving potatoes ever since i can remember and even before as far as my family can tell me. "don't you get bored from eating potatoes"? i am asked on a regular basis. my answer is a standard "potatoes are life, potatoes are my comfort food. now get off my lawn" edit: i am willing to do an all potato diet but its not like i hate anything else, i just cant hate potatoes.
- ethbr0 4y agoWhat are your top 2 favorite potatoes?
- kuhewa 4y ago1. Pink-eyes
- tomcam 4y agoWhen you say you are asked on a regular basis… What basis is that? Once a week? Once a month? I have never had anyone so interested in my diet and I am a little jealous. Also who are these people and what impels them to be so interested in what you are eating?
- 2Gkashmiri 4y ago"When you say you are asked on a regular basis" anytime there is a discussion on food, i bring in potatoes into the conversation automatically. i can't help it. its not like people come up to me and ask about my eating habits. i am willing and have at many times given up a plate of a variety of meats and stuff for a plate of fried/baked potatoes so i bring that up and people start saying stuff...
- tomcam 4y agoThanks for clarifying this all important situation!
- throwaway742 4y ago
- fredsted 4y agoI don't doubt this works, but I'd rather do e.g. keto where I can eat delicious meals and still feel fully satiated.
- Smaug123 4y agoGood for you! Keto doesn't work like that for me. We need many different diets that work for some people, because no diet works for everyone.
- anonytrary 4y agoI assume it depends on your gut microbiome and physical habits.
- kuhewa 4y agoOr just preference. I just would be bored and unsatisfied on a real keto diet, I'd rather fast or die an extremely low cal diet on raw veggies.
- fredsted 4y agoI agree, keto is probably uniquely suited for my lifestyle and tastes. YMMV as they say.
- MrBuddyCasino 4y agoI did this for a year. Its not sustainable, you'll loose muscle mass. I eat potatoes daily now, but not exclusively - complex carbs are harder to burn, so they are fattening, so I have gained some weight. Maybe I'll eliminate the rice and see how that goes. I'd recommend against olive oil and for coconut oil, frying potatoes needs a lot of heat. Add parsley, bacon, caraway, onions and serve with pickled white cabbage. Good & simple!
- gjs278 4y ago
- 4y ago
- buf 4y agoDid nobody read The Martian?
- bigiain 4y agoIf you enjoyed it, go get yourself a copy of Hail Mary. He's got even better at writing that style of story.
- browningstreet 4y agoAlmost any diet with a predominant control can work. It’s the attention to what is being eaten that’s enabled. Vegan? No meat. Carnivore? Just meat. IIFYM? Caloric control. “Dieting” usually has too broad a set of parameters. You need a control. And if you have a goal and you’re paying attention, you’ll probably see an improvement over not having a control and eating freely. Health, over the long term, may be more complicated but having a lean body mass makes health easier to achieve than not having a lean body mass.
- Borkdude 4y agoTake a look at The Starch Solution by John McDougall.
- mattnewport 4y agoI tried it for a couple of months last year. It worked in that I lost weight, quickly the first month, less so the second. The weight did not stay off for me. It wasn't particularly difficult but not particularly easy either compared to other diets I've tried.
- keyle 4y agoOne word of caution on these "only this diet". Your gut bacteria is a jungle with many species of microbes, trillions of them. They basically fight for territory and some subspecies will die if you stop injecting <x food>. So if you are not lactose intolerant and get off lactose for 6-9 months, don't expect that your belly will react well to a glass of milk in a year. I'm all for _reducing_ X and Y. But completely going polar is trendy and extremely dangerous long term.
- giardini 4y agoThis. My doctor put me on a "no milk products" diet years ago for a digestive ailment. I [too rigorously, perhaps] held to it for a year and a half. The diet solved my problems but at end left me lactose intolerant. It didn't at first seem like much to live without milk products. But the ramifications of eating say, a banana pudding, which then turns one's intestines into a freestyle trumpet, cannot be ignored.
- infofarmer 4y ago> Your gut bacteria is a jungle with many species of microbes, trillions of them. To clarify: modern science estimates 300–1000 species in gut microbiota, 99% by number of cells coming from 30-40 species. The total number of microbial and viral cells throughout a healthy adult body is estimated at over 100 trillion, or roughly 10x the number of one's own body cells. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gut_microbiota https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gut_microbiota
- rtpg 4y agoI really want a huge tech tree and flowchart of all the things these microbes love to eat and everything like that. Not really to provide an argument for only potatoes, but to perhaps have stronger ideas about the value of certain kinds of food I want to get beyond the boring "too much of anything is bad". Of course it is! That's what "too much" means!
- exar0815 4y agohttp://biochemical-pathways.com http://biochemical-pathways.com Well, have fun!
- prmoustache 4y agoAny X-only diet doesn't seem healthy to me. There is no magical ingredient and we are omnivorous. Sure you can reduce weight with many types of different diets but it doesn't mean it is good for your health. It is better to develop good healthy habits than you can maintain for years and also while socializing and living in family.
- jmnicolas 4y agoTelling an obese person to develop good healthy habits is like telling an alcoholic to drink with moderation. The theory is sound but it get crushed once it gets IRL.
- ravenstine 4y agoWe are not omnivores. Humans are obligate hypercarnivores that are capable of scavenging other energy sources for survival. Plenty of animals, both herbivores and carnivores, are capable of eating foods that they were not developed to eat, but that does not mean it's optimal or good for them. Humans only became "omnivores" in the last 30,000 years as a result of agriculture. For several million years prior to that, hominins ate diets almost entirely of meat from ruminants and occasionally some roots and tubers. If we were designed to eat everything in a "balanced" proportion, as is often suggested, we would have a cecum to properly ferment plant material, and our digestive systems would be more basic than acidic.
- cheese_goddess 4y agoWe have a cecum. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cecum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cecum And we can digest plants just fine without having to ferment them. All those fantastical ideas about how the human body works, they keep cropping up in this kind of thread again and again. Where do they come from, I wonder? I am really curious. Who comes up with those things? The other day some guy was saying we can't digest plants. Like, at all. A vegetarian once told me that our teeth and stomach can't deal with meat. Have those people never eaten the things they say we can't eat? There's clearly a kind of madness in all those diets that starts to become dangerous when it becomes a fad. But I'm still curious: how do they start?
- chicob 4y agoOf course eating only potatoes will make you lose weight. It's malnutrition.
- fractallyte 4y agoThe article overlooked one essential macro-nutrient: fiber. Definitely lacking in a regular potato, even if one eats the skins. Also, sweet potatoes are not potatoes - different families, and different nutritional profiles. The former is considered a root, the latter a tuber. A well researched diet should be aware of these points.
- zerohp 4y agoFiber is not a nutrient.
- fractallyte 4y agoFiber is increasingly being recognized as essential to gut health, so arguably it should be considered a nutrient. Classifying it differently risks omitting it from discussions (as we see in the article) and - vitally - food labeling. Here's a discussion: https://www.jandonline.org/article/S2212-2672(15)01743-8/fulltext https://www.jandonline.org/article/S2212-2672(15)01743-8/ful...
- ravenstine 4y agoFiber is only "essential" in the context of eating food that isn't appropriate for our digestive system. Eating an appropriate diet primarily of meat requires no fiber whatsoever. The idea that fiber is necessary for anything but mitigating some effects from an inappropriate diet comes from the American dietetics association's desire to push a plant-based diet despite all the evidence contrary to plant-based diets.
- kuhewa 4y ago2200 kcal of potato gets you over 60 grams of fibre, I don't reckon that is the issue with an all potato diet.
- vmladenov 4y agoThis title is fairly disingenuous considering the test subjects are using vitamin supplements to make up for the obvious deficiency. The weight loss bits are just silly. Any sustained caloric deficit will cause one to lose fat, regardless of the source. This just seems to be rediscovering the already well-known fact that complex carbohydrates (which potatoes provide) keep you better satiated than simple carbohydrates, so the subjects were consuming less calories overall.
- Smaug123 4y agoThe purpose of this random Internet trial is to verify or disprove the assertion that this diet is easy to stick to for most people, which would be absolutely massive if true because no weight-loss diet ever has had this property. And it seems to have done very well at that purpose: four weeks later, only about 10% of the cohort were still doing it.
- edanm 4y agoLots of diets are "easy to stick to", for the short term, which 4 weeks definitely is. E.g. Keto, Intermittent Fasting, etc. Most people fall off diets in the longer term, and there are various causes, including hunger, but also including things like wanting to be able to partake in social events that feature other foods.
- Taikonerd 4y ago4 weeks is a very, very long time to only eat potatoes. When Penn Jillette tried this, the all-potato phase lasted 2 weeks. I wonder what % of the cohort was still adhering to the diet at the 2-week mark?
- TrueSlacker0 4y agoSigned Up: 220 [CLOSED] Past the 4-Week Mark: 46
- notahacker 4y agoTbf, last time I was shown this blog it was to highlighy on their detailed arguments to the effect that eating less in general and less processed food in particular and exercising more wasn't an answer to obesity (a remarkable piece of analysis which concluded that the average American eating 20% fewer calories than a time when Americans were less obese was no big deal and couldnt possibly be causal) Quite why they have chosen to abandon their diet-scepticism in favour of anecdotes from a guy who literally promoted potatos as his day job and a guy who sells courses on how to eat potatos for $199+, but I guess contrarians gotta be contrary...
- implements 4y ago“Potatoes, milk, butter and the occasional piece of meat” is apparently a nutritionally complete diet, but you need to be able to eat something like 10-lb of cooked potatoes a day, which is hard work and also not that inexpensive either.
- mr_mitm 4y agoMore like 7lbs for an average man, but that's probably the point. You realistically can only eat something like 4lbs a day (I guess - I haven't tried), and thus you lose weight. If that amount is enough to make you feel full, that would plausibly explain why these people have success with this weight loss strategy. Note that the article recommends refraining from consuming dairy products, albeit without any reasoning.
- paulluuk 4y agoDairy products are usually high in fat and cholesterol, and are generally considered to be unhealthy. They are high in calcium, but the absorption rate (how much calcium you actually get from consuming it) is very low, and according to some research it's even negative (as in, it costs your body more calcium to consume dairy than what you get from it). Dairy is also a relatively new addition to our diet, and was exclusively for babies for most of our history. A lot of people hate on vegans for being "unnatural", but at least when it comes to eating dairy that's just silly.
- cheese_goddess 4y ago
- throwaway742 4y agoPotatoes are cheap af what do you mean?
- cassianoleal 4y agoQuick back of the envelope numbers. At Tesco's you can get potatoes for £0.36/kg. 1kg = ~2.2lb, so ~£0.165/lb. Even at the higher daily consumption in this thread, 10lb/day, that's £1.65 daily cost of food. I imagine the only way to go cheaper is by dumpster diving.
- lostboyscratch 4y agoAussielent did a nutritional comparison. Potato, potato and more potato: surviving on spuds https://aussielent.com.au/blogs/news/potato-potato-and-more-potato-surviving-on-spuds https://aussielent.com.au/blogs/news/potato-potato-and-more-...
- janekm 4y agoThis made me wonder whether potatoes are really this expensive in Australia? In the UK buying 2000 calories worth of potatoes from a major supermarket would cost the equivalent of AUD2.12 not AUD9.90 ... Though by comparison rice gets you 2000 calories for AUD1.03, spaghetti AUD0.92, carrots AUD2.51, "pure vegetable oil" AUD0.059 so a more varied diet could be cheaper. Actually I'd like to propose the carrot-only diet... Trying to eat 5kg of carrots a day is bound to make you lose weight, though your skin may turn orange ;)
- DoreenMichele 4y agoBad title. They are actually trying to do a study. They have arguments for taking kind of "a fad diet" seriously enough to do a study based on existing anecdotal evidence that this might not be a crazy fad diet.
- doubleunplussed 4y agoAnd they have a whole other post [1] about why science needs to actually check stuff like this, because reality is full of complexity that prevents us from drawing conclusions as rapidly as we'd like. [1] https://slimemoldtimemold.com/2022/01/11/reality-is-very-weird-and-you-need-to-be-prepared-for-that/ https://slimemoldtimemold.com/2022/01/11/reality-is-very-wei...
- noduerme 4y agoFunny. Exactly the opposite of what I always heard growing up: don't eat anything white. White bread, potatoes, rice, etc.
- chihuahua 4y agoHalf of the internet is people shouting that "carbs will kill you", and then there's people who argue that eating only carbs is the best idea ever. The only thing that makes sense to me is that any extreme position is wrong. E.g. only carbs, no carbs at all, only meat, only plants.
- kilroy123 4y agoIt's not that carbs will kill you. It's more like, people growing up on western diets, have such destroyed metabolisms, that you have to resort to going very low carb to try to fix or mitigate the damage. I think the real tick is not eating highly processed food. Eat highly nutritious whole foods.
- ravenstine 4y agoActually, they can all be "right" but only in exclusion. Eating mostly carbs absent fat or fat absent carbs means engaging the Randle Cycle to a much lesser degree, given that fatty acid and glucose aren't competing fuel substrates. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Randle_cycle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Randle_cycle
- IndySun 4y agoFor those mentioning Gut Bacteria. https://joinzoe.com/learn/category/gut-health https://joinzoe.com/learn/category/gut-health (And I'm not affiliated or suggesting join, just read)
- pubby 4y agoMy long-running pet theory is that eating a large variety of foods is bad for our gut biome. Between breakfast, lunch, and dinner, our intestinal flora cycles through blooms and die-offs of different bacteria. The blooms interfere with bacteria diversity, while the die-offs create waves of toxins that trigger our immune systems. To give an analogy, it's a bit like an ecology having its climate messed with. Imagine a forest that was hot one day, cold the next, dry as a bone on some days, and wet as a swamp the next. I reckon most animals eat a steady diet of only one or two things, and people did too for a very long time (on a seasonal scale). It was only recently that we ate so many different foods so frequently, and this coincides with a rise in gut-related illnesses and obesity in first world countries. Many people see success treating these diseases with some diet, but what's interesting is how different and disjoint these diets are. For example, both carnivore diets and vegetarian diets have seen success treating inflammatory bowel disease. Perhaps this success isn't due to eating one food over another, but rather to the reduction in variety a diet brings.
- brylie 4y agoThere are research studies exploring the link between dietary diversity and gut biome, such as the following: A healthy gastrointestinal microbiome is dependent on dietary diversity https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4837298/#:~:text=The%20more%20diverse%20the%20diet,narrow%20the%20GI%20microbiome%20further https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4837298/#:~:tex...
- lionkor 4y agoPeople lived normal happy lives for thousands of years on varied diets, not sure what else you could possibly want.
- anentropic 4y agoI guess maybe they were serially varied, as food is gathered or harvested in season, rather than simultaneously varied though? So you might eat a wide variety of things during the year, but for weeks at a time you might be eating lots of just the few things that are currently available Not saying that is the case, I don't know, but I would not totally dismiss OP idea out of hand
- timwaagh 4y agoAlmost every diet like this that is extremely restrictive will work. But it's not going to be fun at the very least.
- scarmig 4y agoMy guess here is that the potential benefits come from potatoes satiating better than most other cheap calories and that you quickly get tired of eating potatoes and just quit eating. Another approach that I've been experimenting with that makes pretty much any diet satiating: semaglutide. FDA approved as of last year, and for people whose main issue with dieting is constantly feeling like you're starving (most dieters, I would bet), it effectively destroys appetite. It's one of two drugs I've tried for weight loss that have been effective for me, and its side effect profile is far, far better.
- qwerty456127 4y agoI ate only potatoes (+oil/butter and spices) for years and was happy (I really love potatoes) but then got too tired of washing potatoes many times a day (you have to wash them because even a clean-looking potato has a serious chance to have a particle of sand stick to it and that's very unpleasant to bite). My mass (rather humble) never changed during those years, mo matter how much I ate, slept or moved.
- nonrandomstring 4y agoIn the UK we had a very successful chain called Spud-U-Like. Oddly it was super trendy mid to late 80s as I was a teenager, and I can recall it being an acceptably cool thing to go with some mates there. One of the options "plain potato", for about 2 quid IIRC, was literally just the spud with a sachet of butter and pepper to add if you wanted. I found that quite addictive TBH. Don't recall there ever being much or any TV, radio or billboard marketing. They just sprung up in the high street in premium spots and out-competed McDonald's, KFC, Subway, PizzaHut and whatnot, which are all total junk-food in my reckoning. Sadly they couldn't weather the property hike and probably over-reached on prime location real estate [2] (but that does how location is everything). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spudulike https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spudulike [2] https://www.theguardian.com/business/2019/aug/04/spudulike-closes-all-37-outlets-as-high-street-downturn-continues https://www.theguardian.com/business/2019/aug/04/spudulike-c...
- GordonS 4y agoNote that potatoes have a very high GI - for example, eating mashed potato will badly spike your blood sugar, about the same as if you'd literally eaten pure sugar. This is a bad idea.
- lionkor 4y agoHot take: Just eat a balanced meal, traditional meals are usually good, anything homemade in moderation, as long as it has veggies, protein, and some fresh veggies rich in vitamins every now and then. Drink water, eat in moderation, and see a doctor if you have issues with it (there are plenty of issues which can cause a misbehaved appetite). And please, for the love of god, don't do any "only X" diets. Just eat balanced and go outside every now and then, and you'll be okay.
- toyg 4y ago> Just eat balanced and go outside every now and then Hot take: If it were that easy, obesity wouldn't exist. People are different, their metabolism works at different rates, they might have sensitivity to different foods, and not everyone has the chance or resources to solve the likely psychological issues related to the condition (either cause of, or caused by) - which are often the hardest ones. Diets can provide some direction, and are useful in a number of situations. You can't tell a prediabetic person to "just eat balanced", because that will not work - they need a precise diet to survive and possibly revert the condition.
- pas 4y agothe main claim of the authors is Lithium contamination causing obesity, their hypothesis is that sticking to potatoes can avoid that somehow
- anentropic 4y agoDo they discuss that elsewhere? I didn't see Lithium mentioned once in the linked article
- s-lambert 4y agoThe series of articles called A Chemical Hunger is where they discuss this and go over a variety of ideas around obesity, the series starts here and it's very long: https://slimemoldtimemold.com/2021/07/07/a-chemical-hunger-part-i-mysteries/ https://slimemoldtimemold.com/2021/07/07/a-chemical-hunger-p...
- fasteo 4y agoI haven't seen it mentioned in the post, but it is worth mentioning that (boiled) potatoes have the highest satiety index [1] among common foods. The highest SI score was produced by boiled potatoes (323 +/- 51%) which was seven-fold higher than the lowest SI score of the croissant (47 +/- 17%) [1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7498104/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7498104/ edit: added (boiled)
- SnowHill9902 4y agoAlso one of the highest glycemic indexes which is undesirable.
- mizzack 4y agoYep. That's why this works. If you limit the palatability (by restricting added salt/fat/seasoning), you get to a point where you simply do not want to eat any more potatoes. And that happens a lot sooner with potatoes vs. other foods due to the high satiety, so you're full and satisfied at a significant caloric deficit.
- DonHopkins 4y ago* Sponsored by SpudULike. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spudulike https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spudulike https://spudulikebyjamesmartin.com/ https://spudulikebyjamesmartin.com/
- CamogliX 4y agoActually this has already been done, it was how we discovered that potatoes are not toxic. For centuries everyone believed that were super toxic and throw them in the woods in hoping of killing wolfs and boars. During one the many war between french and germans, french has captured a POW and as torture they fed him only with potatoes for more than a year, thinking of slowly killing him. He went out of prison in better shape than when he entered
- toyg 4y agoPotatoes give me heartburn, so that's right out for me. Besides: > Magician Penn Jillette lost over 100 lbs using a strategy that started with two weeks of a potato-only diet, and seems to be keeping it off I know this because Kevin Smith started in a similar way after talking to him, and discussed it on his podcasts; it follows the teaching of some other guy who wrote a book and works as personal dietician. The thing is: that initial stint was meant to effectively wean them off carbs. By bombarding the body with the same complex carbs for an extended period, they got so tired of them that they actually switched to craving less starchy foodstuff. It also "reset" their psychological attitude to food: because after a while you are kinda disgusted by potatoes, you stop eating for pleasure, and figure out how to eat only when strictly necessary. Obviously they both moved on to more balanced diets after a month or two. So yeah, it can work in the short term, as a gateway to something better. But it's not a sustainable diet.
- Taikonerd 4y agoIn defense of the linked article, they're not saying volunteers should stay on the diet indefinitely -- they say "at least 4 weeks." And all the examples they cite are people doing it for X weeks and then transitioning to a diet that's more varied (but still restricted compared to what they were eating before).
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoThe arguments that people lost weight eating only potatoes is... not very strong, because you can lose weight eating only pizza or whatever as well. It's weak non-science. Any diet that says "only eat X" is a red flag in my not so humble opinion. It's trying to make it easy for you, while the hard part that most people don't want to confront is learning to cook, actually cooking, and eating steadily. Few people that start a diet start off with having a regular eating pattern in the first place. Diets don't last either; they're too big a change from your norm. The diet yoyo effect is from people starting a diet, and either slowly going back to their old habits or stopping and changing back completely after a few weeks / whenever their initial goal has been achieved.
- nopcode 4y ago> It's weak non-science. This type of restriction is often more about the mental, "lifestyle" part than biology. It's an alternative to calorie-counting, you automatically eat much less. I went meat-only for a few months and then slowly transitioned to low carb (relative to western diets) paleo-ish. I now enjoy eating vegetables I never touched before. Penn Jillette said the same thing about the potato method, it was more about palet-cleansing for him than actually losing weight on the potato itself. It also gave me the opportunity to learn about every ingredient as I added it back into rotation. > is learning to cook, actually cooking, and eating steadily I grew morbidly obese on >80% homecooking. It's actually about making the right choice, 10 to 20 times per day. If you go potato-only, meat-only or whatever - you're eliminating a lot of bad choices. In the end, reading a lot about food allowed me to make informed decisions and that seems to work for the long haul. > a regular eating pattern And what is that supposed to be? SAD? There is no one-size-fits-all solution.
- Terry_Roll 4y agoNo mention of the fact the immune system doesnt attack starch which is high in potatoes, but the immune system will attack other sugars ingested.
- aitchnyu 4y agoCould you elaborate on this? Would grains and fruits trigger an immune response?
- Terry_Roll 4y agoSerotonin in seed shells (think anaphylactic) would trigger an immune system response because its how they have evolved in order to be pooped out by animals, serotonin irritates the digestive system and aids fast passage, ergo the seed is spread further afield. Fruits could, but its really a good idea to quantify the chemicals in each and their subsequent response, because the phrase "trigger an immune response" is so vague its like trying to quantify legislation.
- nisegami 4y agoI'm on something like this due to an eating disorder called ARFID. I'm also of Indian descent and intensely pre-disposed to insulin resistance. Basically, not doing too well here.
- siskiyou 4y agoThis diet falls into the same trap that all temporary diets do: assuming a brief change followed by a return to SOP will result in meaningful change. Your diet is properly understood as what you eat regularly for long periods, or forever. Change that and you may get somewhere. After your 30s, eat less total calories each year.
- doubleunplussed 4y agoIt's not assuming it, that's what they're testing for.
- rob_c 4y agoarguments against... blight
- 11235813213455 4y agoWould this work with rice?
- silicon2401 4y agoPotatoes are very high in oxalates, which people at risk of kidney stones (1 in 10 men) are often told to avoid. That alone is enough reason for me to basically never eat potatoes.
- cheese_goddess 4y agoI'm a kidney patient and no nephrologist, or any other health worker, has ever advised me not to eat potatoes. I'll tell you what they all advised me to drastically reduce: salt. How do you feel about salt consumption? Excess salt consumption, typical in western and Asian diets, is a major risk for cardiovascular disease and for kidney disease (not kidney stones... kidney disease). Are you similarly cautious of a high-salt diet as you are of a high-oxalate diet? I'm really curious.
- silicon2401 4y agoI didn't mention anything about oxalates and general kidney health or kidney disease, only kidney stones. I haven't seen a reason for avoiding oxalates unless you're at risk for kidney stones, so I'm not sure what point you're making. > For stone prevention, a reasonable goal is below 100 mg of oxalate daily. An ideal would be about 50 mg daily if that can be accomplished. > POTATOES These are Trouble! I put them into their own separate group even though they are vegetables. > From french fries to baked potatoes they are very high oxalate items. https://kidneystones.uchicago.edu/how-to-eat-a-low-oxalate-diet/ https://kidneystones.uchicago.edu/how-to-eat-a-low-oxalate-d... To your question, yes. I drink tons of water and avoid salt as much as I can.
- cheese_goddess 4y agoMy point is that people who avoid entire food groups, or foods that have one particular nutrient usually have very strange reasons to do so, that border on the metaphysical and are routinely misguided. Like the carnivore diet, or the various macrobiotic diets, for example. But strangely those weird diets never center around cutting salt out (and some of the meat-only diets are also deliberately heavy in fats). My intuition is that this is because salt is almost addictive, because it is so tastey, and it is very, very difficult to get people to reduce salt in their diet, despite the damage it can cause. Anyway it's still the case that none of my doctors or nurses have advised me to cut down on oxalate-heavy foods to avoid kidney stones, so I don't think you need to worry that much. If there is a risk, it's a risk only when considered at a population level and probably very low at an individual level. Not that it will harm you to eat fewer potatoes. They're mostly starch anyway and I think at this point everyone agrees that too much starch can be a problem (because gaining weight is all too easy even without excess starch).
- cheese_goddess 4y agoAnecdotally, that kind of thing sure works. Back in the day my aunt turned from plump and boring to thin and elegant in a couple of months by eating only chicken and rice. However, I think those diets only "work" because they make you starve while filling your belly. I guess what they do to your body is that they deprive it of the vast majority of the nutrients it needs. It makes sense that you'd lose weight then, in the same way that it would make sense that you'd lose weight during a bout of serious illness, or after invasive surgery, or an accident etc. It's a sudden shock to the system, you know? So I would be really careful with following one of those diets. You risk losing weight for reasons really deterimental to your health. I would only do this if I had a doctor I could trust that could monitor me regularly.
- bambax 4y ago> However, I think those diets only "work" because they make you starve while filling your belly Another way they could work is because eating the same thing all day every day is extremely boring and makes you not want to eat at all. It would be the case for the most delicious dish, but it's even truer with bland food.
- cheese_goddess 4y agoYeah, maybe. That could be the reason, or an additional reason. I think if I had to eat only one kind of food that I really like (not cheese because there's such a huge variety that it wouldn't really count as "one") I could just about manage to eat only that for two weeks. After that I think I'd be craving something else. Of course, that could also cause me to over-eat to try and make up for the craving. Anyway I don't think this is such an easy diet as the article here makes it sound like. Anecdotally again, the only time I went on an "eat-only-x" diet was during a heatwave when I spent a week or two eating only teaspoonfulls of peanut butter and drinking milk kefir. The reason being that it was so hellishly hot that I couldn't stand the thought of cooking or eating anything more. I think I lost a few pounds during that time.
- Taikonerd 4y agoI think any crazy-restrictive diet can "work," in the sense of short-term weight loss. But the article seems to think that the potato diet will somehow reset something that's gone wrong, leading to the weight staying off after the all-potato phase is finished? That will be the real test...
- 43543523435435 4y agohttps://www.nutritionix.com/food/potato https://www.nutritionix.com/food/potato > Calories 161 > Protein 4.3g grams Let's do some math here. 2500 calories of potatoes works out to 2500/161x4.3 = 66.77 grams of protein. If you don't understand immediately why that might be a bit of a problem, then you're probably the target audience for this Dunning-Kruger Diet. Sure, you'll lose fat, along with what little muscle you have, and probably even some bone mineral density.
- bell-cot 4y agoI quickly found a few credible sources stating that that was sufficient protein for most people - https://www.health.harvard.edu/nutrition/when-it-comes-to-protein-how-much-is-too-much https://www.health.harvard.edu/nutrition/when-it-comes-to-pr... https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26630101/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26630101/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reference_Daily_Intake#Dietary_Reference_Intake https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reference_Daily_Intake#Dietary...
- 43543523435435 4y ago> sufficient protein for most people Your own sources admit uncertainty around adequate intake, and even then, that's just for most people. Most people aren't actively trying to build muscle, or actively trying to lose weight. Ignore the studies demonstrating the benefits of high (upto 2g./kg., or a roughly 1g./lb.) protein diets on body composition at your own peril.