7 ms·
> the world will have to get better at balancing energy supply and demand so we don’t go dark when the sun isn’t shining or the wind isn’t blowing. Thanks Bill
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
> the world will have to get better at balancing energy supply and demand so we don’t go dark when the sun isn’t shining or the wind isn’t blowing.
Thanks Bill, that's really helpful, was there really no other way you could have phrased that?
> Another option is to produce hydrogen using the current methods that burn fossil fuels and then capture the CO2 produced in the process before it’s released in the atmosphere. It may never be economical to capture 100 percent of the carbon released using incumbent technologies, but while we’re waiting for thousands of industrial facilities to retrofit their infrastructure, carbon capture can help drive emissions way down.
Oh dear.
Was expecting him to shill for expensive nuclear generated (aka pink) hydrogen but he went one better and started pushing the dead end that is blue hydrogen.
Make green hydrogen, make lots of it. The more we make the cheaper it'll get. This is not complicated.
- phkahler 4y ago
- arbol 4y agoI was confused by this comment until I read this: https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/08/hydrogen-carbon-intensive-energy-solution/ https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/08/hydrogen-carbon-inten...
- ncmncm 4y agoPoint is that it is hard and anyway probably unwise to divert renewable power to hydrogen synthesis from things that are using the electricity without conversion losses. It is just about as good or bad to burn NG making hydrogen as to burn NG to make electricity. But once we have got renewable overbuilt, all the math changes. Until then, unquestionably the right place to spend capital is building out renewables. Building up hydrogen infrastructure, in the meantime, and even fueling it with gray hydrogen, is OK provided it doesn't cost money that could have gone to renewable generating capacity instead. Often capital has strings attached, and can't go for renewables. Then, spending on readiness to use the coming, cheap hydrogen or ammonia (and burning gray fuel for now), or generally on energy storage, is better than most choices. Thing is, money is fungible. Each dollar goes to one place and therefore not another. Energy is too, albeit with conversion losses. So, green hydrogen and NG electric is no better or worse than gray NG hydrogen and renewables. Anywhere we can displace NG entirely is good. Moving use of it around, much less so.
- wh33zle 4y agoCan you expand why separation from water is a net energy loss?
- arbol 4y agoConversion from water to hydrogen via hydrolysis is only 60-80% efficient so it takes more energy to generate the hydrogen than the hydrogen will produce in future. Source: https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/08/hydrogen-carbon-intensive-energy-solution/ https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/08/hydrogen-carbon-inten...
- bbojan 4y agoWater electrolysis is around 60-80 percent efficient. Hydrogen fuel cells are around 40-60 percent efficient. Plus you spend additional energy to either compress or cool the hydrogen in order to be able to store it. Electricity storage in a lithium-ion battery is on the order of 98% efficient, and electric motors are around 90% efficient (if you take into account the whole drivetrain).
- wh33zle 4y agoThanks! Although it seems like these numbers can be improved [0] and are not fundamentally linked to the technology. [0]: https://newatlas.com/energy/hysata-efficient-hydrogen-electrolysis/ https://newatlas.com/energy/hysata-efficient-hydrogen-electr...
- ncmncm 4y agoYes, hydrogen and ammonia handling efficiency will mostly go up, unless extra-cheap (to buy) electrolysers come out with unfortunately lower efficiency. What always matters most is cost. Inefficiency will get cheaper and cheaper as generation cost falls. Switching from gold & platinum catalyzing electrolysers to something not dependent on those and less efficient is still a win if you get a lot more electrolysers for your money.
- ncmncm 4y agoIt is absolutely trivial that separating hydrogen from water uses energy. Then, when you burn it, you get water and energy back. That is the whole point.
- wolfram74 4y agoYour first point doesn't make sense to me, there are transmission and discharge losses associated with batteries, but they're still practical for many use cases. The amount of tolerable losses depends on how cheap the power is, if the power supply is intermittent, some time they'd be greatly in excess of standard loads, in which case you could run hydrogen cracking at 10% efficiency and it might still be useful just as grid ballast.
- ravenstine 4y ago> separate it from water, which is a net energy LOSS This is true of every form of energy transfer. There is never, ever 100% energy maintained, and maybe you'll be stunned at how inefficient existing energy sources are.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kkfx 4y agoIt's not a matter of efficiency but a matter of scalability: hydrogen generated by hydrolysis demand so much energy that we can't produce it on the needed scale, no matter how much it can cost. Methane extraction is absurdly costly, transport and storage are no less absurd BUT we can do it on a needed scale. That's the sole thing that matter. Similar if for hydro: mountain hydro is fantastic, we MUST develop it as much as possible, but it demand mountains and water. For some part of the world it's ok, they are there both in needed quantity essentially all the year, for some other they are not. You can power Norway on hydro with little nuclear backup, you can't power Mongolia even if Mongolia have very little needs compared. Similarly we can imaging electric commercial trains that only run on p.v. surplus, for all non-perishable goods that might be ok if well designed on scale. We probably can design that on scale in many, many areas of the world. We can't to the same for ships, for plane, for cars. We can't do that for perishable goods of passengers transits.
- ncmncm 4y agoIt is not, in fact, the case that production of hydrogen is impractical. It will take time to build out electrolysis equipment. But you can buy it from China today. And, given cheap storage, of course we can run passenger trains on renewables.
- moralestapia 4y agoI may be wrong about this but I recall reading it on a book about the history of energy. Anyway, supposedly around 99% (!) of the net energy of fuels gets lost from the source to your home. This due to energy conversion, loss in transmission lines, transformers, you own electrical installation, battery charging/discharging and other inefficiencies on the grid or the devices you use.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoDon't use it as an energy source, see the hydrogen ladder for the sensible markets that we should switch from gray hydrogen to green and the ones we should just electrify directly: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/clean-hydrogen-ladder-v40-michael-liebreich https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/clean-hydrogen-ladder-v40-mic...
- giantrobot 4y agoThe colors of hydrogen have specific meanings. Green hydrogen - hydrogen derived from water electrolysis, ostensibly from renewable electrical sources so no greenhouse gases are produced Blue hydrogen - hydrogen derived from hydrocarbons, produces greenhouse gases as waste Pink hydrogen - hydrogen from water electrolysis from nuclear electrical sources, no greenhouse gases produced The description of "green" hydrogen is only tangentially related to the colloquial use of "green". So long as no greenhouse gases are produced the hydrogen is labeled green. The use for hydrogen isn't an energy source but as an energy transport and storage. So "green" hydrogen is still "green" in the colloquial sense despite its inefficiency if it doesn't produce any greenhouse gases in the pipeline. All that being said, I personally think hydrogen is stupid as a transport and storage medium for electricity. Electrical transmission lines will always be more efficient than a theoretical hydrogen pipeline. A chemical battery has a lot less that can go wrong than compressed hydrogen storage. About the only place it even starts to make any sense is grid-scale storage and even then I don't think it can practically beat other storage systems.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoGrey hydrogen is hydrogen derived from hydrocarbons which throws the carbons into the atmosphere. Blue hydrogen is grey hydrogen but the carbons are captured and stored. So nominally it's carbon-neutral but in practice the capture is never perfect.
- ncmncm 4y agoBlue hydrogen is also unicorns. Probably even mentioning it can only distract.
- giantrobot 4y agoI'd agree, the concept of cracking hydrocarbons and then capturing the GHG byproduct effectively is just fantasy. At best a blue hydrogen fuel cell would be on par with a super clean natural gas combustion engine. You'd get CO~2~, water vapor, and electricity. Better than rolling coal but not better than "green" hydrogen or just a chemical battery. The math for blue hydrogen might work out in commercial and residential installations in regions with existing natural gas and siting that makes solar impractical. A fuel cell with a catalytic cracker could feed a building with hot water and electricity vs a combusting water heater that only provided hot water. For similar GHG output it might be an efficiency win. But I see that as a weak maybe all things considered.
- chicob 4y agoOf course there is green hydrogen. First of all, the green aspect of it is that the source is renewable. That's what makes it green. It's not correct to call it a net loss, because no one wants to produce power from hydrogen in order to harvest more hydrogen. There would always be a renewable input somewhere. About losses. There are always losses on each energy transformation step. The same thing applies to electricity generated with fossil fuels, or heat generated with electricity generated from heat, or light generated with electricity produced with light. The fact that the source is renewable means we can probably afford that loss in the long term. Using green hydrogen as fuel for far-from-grid cases still makes sense. Electric tractors are not feasible yet, given the required power×autonomy. Also, consider Iceland, were electricity is cheap and produced via geothermal sources, but exporting it is impossible: producing green hydrogen would make that energy exportable. And consider also the Haber-Bosch process, where ammonia production requires hydrogen that currently comes from fossil sources (natural gas) which implies carbon emissions. Shifting to green hydrogen would be a game changer in the production of fertilizers. Remember farming is one of the major sources of CO₂ emissions.
- kkfx 4y agoIt's not a matter of efficiency but of scale: we can't produce enough hydrogen by hydrolysis even with all the electricity we can produce. On contrary probably we can made electric tools to substitute tractors. Something that demand a bit of investment but last FAR longer and can run only on p.v. the hard part there would probably be convincing farmers that they do not need tractors anywhere but only for very specific activities... If you use all Island electricity you can't even produce enough hydrogen to power a hypothetical nations-wide fleet of cars...
- lukeschlather 4y agoThis EU study suggests that we could produce enough hydrogen to fuel air travel with about 32 Pwh annually, which is maybe 20% of current global energy production. I am pretty sure your assertion is simply wrong. Converting to hydrogen would be expensive, possibly dramatically more expensive than other solutions, but it seems totally achievable. https://www.fch.europa.eu/sites/default/files/FCH%20Docs/20200507_Hydrogen%20Powered%20Aviation%20report_FINAL%20web%20%28ID%208706035%29.pdf https://www.fch.europa.eu/sites/default/files/FCH%20Docs/202...
- Melatonic 4y agoBurning fossil fuels has some pretty big negatives.......