4 ms·
This is interesting research and I encourage everyone to go read the article. But, on the assumption that a lot of people will just read the headline and commen
by roenxi 4y ago
This is interesting research and I encourage everyone to go read the article. But, on the assumption that a lot of people will just read the headline and comments I'm going to preemptively talk about the question there ...
People misunderstand decentralisation in practice. Computer types, when they talk about decentralisation, usually mean a relatively large number of homogeneous nodes acting as peers. Which is cool but not how decentralised systems work in practice out in the meaty reality we all live in.
In reality, we have an economy that quickly works out who is the best (say, Samuel is the best) at something (say, mining bitcoin) and routes most of the resources available for hashing to Samuel. The situation is still decentralised, because if Samuel stops being the best at calculating hashes then resources will be reallocated to someone else. But in the short term all the resources will go to Samuel and he could do a lot of damage to the network.
People keep thinking that because the economy picks out a few winners that means that the system is now locked in stone - that isn't the case. The economy is perfectly happy to change things up radically when the situation changes. At least until a government steps in and regulates the ability to change flexibly out of the system.
- sandworm101 4y agoExcept that Samuel wants to keep his place. So he will do whatever he can to leverage his current centrality to continue. His hope is to be in control when the hammer falls and flexibility stops. One way of doing that is to force the issue. Those in central positions within a dynamic market eventually seek to kill that market, leaving them in the monopoly position (amazon, google, facebook etc). To maintain decentralization in the long term such leaders need to be periodically culled, hopefully though market forces prior to them killing the market. In bitcoin, that might mean periodic removal of the largest commercial actors, perhaps by periodic price crashes that favor niche setups.
- roenxi 4y ago> (amazon, google, facebook etc) I'm not sure where I sit on your major point, but these 3 just are not monopolists and this is a mistake that keeps getting made. All 3 of these are in cut throat markets where they compete by selling really great products (AWS, Google Search and Facebook respectively). A lot of individuals don't like them (I refuse to use Google, for example) but that doesn't change the fact that they get market share by being great at what they do.
- deebosong 4y agoAren't Goog/ Ama/ Fbook known for swallowing up smaller companies who might be potential threats/ competitors, and "kill them off" via this method? Seems like it's common practice for such entities.
- theplumber 4y agoWow... and you really believe that? It's just like with Microsoft. Once they've got enough money and market share they destroyed their competition through various monopolistic tactics: i.e acquisitions, dumping, lockin etc
- kwertyoowiyop 4y agoMaking great products isn’t incompatible with being a monopolist, is it? For example, Google isn’t the default search provider for Firefox just because it’s a great product. They pay Mozilla more than any new competitor could afford. By the way: I’m not an economist, so I read this article to see if my claim makes sense: https://stats.oecd.org/glossary/detail.asp?ID=3262 https://stats.oecd.org/glossary/detail.asp?ID=3262
- tsimionescu 4y agoI know less about AWS and Good ads, but Facebook has bought each and every social network it could afford to prevent any chance of havjng competition - most notably Instagram and WhatsApp. That is the very definition of monopolistic practices.
- NineStarPoint 4y agoGoogle is very much a monopolist in search. They have more than a 80% usage share of the space (most places I look at say 90% today), and have had that much share for more than a decade. (On a separate note they are in a duopoly with Apple in the Phone OS market and a borderline monopoly in the web browser market, giving them a lot of power to throw around in general.) Facebook I go back and forth on. They are undoubtably the biggest player in the social media space, but if you count all social media (reddit, twitter, Pinterest) they are large but definitely not monopoly level. On the other hand, when it comes to real name interaction and local community organization they are completely dominant over the other players. Ultimately I consider the acquisition of instagram to have been over the line enough to consider them deserving of the treatment of a monopoly, but it’s not as obvious a case a google. Their space also isn’t as cut-throat as you would expect due to network effects, and there are other countries where they are in fact locally a completely dominant monopoly. Amazon is definitely not a monopoly by any reasonable definition. All of the fields they are in have multiple other major players as well that they are in fierce competition with.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- masswerk 4y agoHowever, in praxis, not every participant in an economic system is a perfect player in the sense of game theory. Take for instance the history of the London Underground and its rivaling companies and directors. There are several instances, where a player maintained a position detrimental both to their own economy (as in profits and strategic position) and to the entire system (as in gains that may be secured in the future), as other motives take over. (E.g., hurting another player gains top priority, even if the damages inflicted to the respective own position exceeds the damages inflicted to the competing player. Even to the extent of losing that position altogether, as in being fired as the director.) Notably, this was a system with multiple controlling parties, as directors and boards, acts of parliament, financiers, etc, still, this couldn't stop this kind of behavior. (E.g., blocking closing the circle line is a prime example.)
- masswerk 4y agoApparently, this (or the intent of this) requires an explanation. This is a comment on the factuality of statements like, "Except that Samuel wants to keep his place," and a reminder that game theory is an interesting thought experiment, but not an accurate description of human social behavior. There's nothing in the rules or the setup of a "game" that would determine moves as actually observed and about anything may happen. Including even worse outcomes than pictured here. At best, it describes an inherent tendency.
- SideburnsOfDoom 4y ago> Which is cool but not how decentralised systems work in practice ... In reality, we have an economy that quickly works out who is the best .. and routes most of the resources available for hashing there I disagree, somewhat. It depends on the purpose of the decentralisation. If your aim is "best" which I think also means "cheapest" then yes, you have described what could happen. But decentralisation can also have "resilience" as the goal, even at the expense of the best performance. These goals might even be in conflict. What if Samuel, as noted "wants to keep his place". What if Samuel wants all the traffic to go him so that at some time, he can subvert it in some way. He may only need 51% of the traffic. He may be willing to take a loss for a while to get into this position. He may even have a government backer willing to spend a lot on outcomes and not be seeking a profit in itself. And as noted, when Samuel is suddenly no the "best" after a long time in that position, chaos could ensue. I hear "resilient" when "decentralised" is said. Many others will too. You're showing how this may be very misleading.
- hansworst 4y agoBy this definition, the current financial system is also decentralised. After all, if one bank fails, a new bank could very easily take its place. Even our system of central banks consists of a relatively large number of more or less equal peers. If the US central bank fails, I'm sure "the economy" will be more than happy to change things up radically and reassign some of the global influence on the financial system that the fed currently has to competing nations' central banks.
- Spooky23 4y agoIt is, from a different perspective. Pre-Fed, we routinely had depressions and bank failure cycles because the private markets weren’t resilient enough to withstand different types of shocks.
- Cthulhu_ 4y ago> People keep thinking that because the economy picks out a few winners that means that the system is now locked in stone - that isn't the case. The economy is perfectly happy to change things up radically when the situation changes. At least until a government steps in and regulates the ability to change flexibly out of the system. This flexibility and survival of the fittest mentality is costing people billions; of course a government would step in, because clearly the economic techno-libertarians aren't able to come up with a secure and stable system. At some point, cryptocurrencies and blockchain technologies sounded like We The People taking power back from the big bad government and banks. In practice, it turns out - to everyone's sarcastic surprise - that a handful of people got very rich off it and shat on those lofty goals. I'm not buying it. Never did. Yeah I missed the boat on getting rich and I am salty about it, so it exceeded my initial cynicism, but it's still inherently broken. Unregulated finance attracts conmen. So does regulated finance but at least they can be tracked down.
- gizzlon 4y ago> At least until a government steps in and regulates the ability to change flexibly out of the system. Just as often, the government is the only one who can keep the flexibility and ensure free competition. E.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sherman_Antitrust_Act_of_1890 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sherman_Antitrust_Act_of_1890
- roenxi 4y agoThe US economic policy in the 10s and 20s is a candidate for the cause of the crippling depression in the 30s. I note from the wiki article that once the 30s roll around they all but stopped having notable anti-trust cases. The US's industrial policy for the last 50 years has successfully pushed a lot of manufacturing out of the country to the point where the US is arguably being out-competed by communists. It isn't obvious that US government economic policy in living memory is succeeding in promoting a healthy market. The argument for why that is going to change and their intervention will help needs to be more clearly articulated.
- gizzlon 4y ago> The US economic policy in the 10s and 20s is a candidate for the cause of the crippling depression in the 30s Or too little regulation. Or too the wrong kind. Or something else. I'm not arguing for or against current US economic policy. This is the theory: Without any regulation, one or a few actors can grow large and stifle any competition and innovation. This theory seems to be proven by history. Some might say: "that wasn't a *real* free market". Just like some might say: "that wasn't *real* communism". These both need some strong arguments to back them, or they come off as No true Scotsman (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman)
- dghlsakjg 4y agoThe US is the 2nd largest manufacturing economy in the world, and is much higher than China (no. 1) on a per capita basis. Also, Let's not pretend for a second that China is actually communist when it comes to manufacturing
- 4y ago
- dpierce9 4y agoThe royal family of Britain has occasionally changed over time. Is it decentralized?
- t_mann 4y agoBy your definition of decentralization (a central entity could theoretically be replaced) everything from the Roman Empire to North Korea is decentralized - nothing is guaranteed to have its place forever. A definition that applies to every imaginable instance is pointless, but more importantly, it's far from how people commonly use the word.
- roenxi 4y agoIs there a central authority that decided it was time for the Roman Empire to go away but that North Korea is still good to keep going? No. From an external perspective, states are decentralised. They compete viciously too, there are a lot of deaths. If you want them to be centralised, note that a thing can't be the thing centralising itself - because then no system could be decentralised.