7 ms·
"Web3" isn't even able to solve problems it's supposed to solve. The big pitch was that you could have non-copyable items which you could move between virtual
by Animats 4y ago
"Web3" isn't even able to solve problems it's supposed to solve.
The big pitch was that you could have non-copyable items which you could move between virtual worlds. The Second Life / Open Simulator ecosystem already has that problem. People looked into NFTs as a way to solve it, and concluded it would not help.
You can download content and upload it as new content, perhaps with a minor mod, creating a new object. This is called "copybotting" in Second Life and Open Simulator. As with any copyright violation, you can file DMCA takedown requests if you find a copy of your stuff.
Would NFTs stop copybotting? No. They just protect the object's ID, not its content. You can still copy the content. If you want to copy a Bored Ape Yacht Club NFT image and make a poster of it, the NFT system does nothing to stop you. It's not even clear that's a copyright violation in the US, since BAYC images are computer-generated.
Many NFTs don't even have an on-chain cryptographic hash of the content, only a URL for some server. Nor do most NFTs have their NFT ID watermarked into the actual content. So the NFT doesn't even give you a verifiable proof of ownership independent of the creator's server. There isn't info that would allow a server to tell if a new image upload is a copy of an existing item. An image search might help, but that doesn't need NFTs. Decentraland's solution to this problem is to charge a $500 "curation fee" to get an object onto their platform, which cuts down content to the point that they can check for duplicates.
NFTs are thus useless for their claimed purpose.
- dvt 4y ago> They just protect the object's ID, not its content. This is very similar to how DRM works (protects the ID, not the content, hence we need DMCAs if someone tries to illegally stream a movie on YouTube or whatever) and it seems to be doing a pretty good job. In spite of everyone hating it, we have the luxury of Spotify, Netflix, Apple+, etc. because of DRM. NFTs definitely have a use case in gaming and digital collectibles; they also happen to be consumer-friendly (unlike the current status quo of digital collectibles). I wish I could sell my thousands of items in WoW for real money, or my Fornite skins for real money, or my unneeded Magic Arena cards for real money, but I'm locked in their ecosystem. The tokenomnics aspect of Web3 is mainly speculation, which imo also has a use case, but it most likely will be impacted by some much-needed regulation.
- yashasolutions 4y agogenuine question: what is the value of a virtual artifact outside of the sofware where it is played? What would one do with a token of a lotus123 addon?
- bragr 4y agoThere's probably a niche market. Some people collect boxed games or software so maybe there's some VR/AR collectable shelf in the future to put them on, but then the price needs to reflect that its some bobble collecting virtual dust on a virtual shelf.
- threeseed 4y agoDRM protects a particular version of the content from being copied. NFT does not perform an equivalent function. Be infinitely more useful if it did.
- tsimionescu 4y ago> I wish I could sell my thousands of items in WoW for real money, or my Fornite skins for real money, or my unneeded Magic Arena cards for real money, but I'm locked in their ecosystem. That's exactly it: you may wish it, but the reason it won't happen isn't that NFTs weren't invented yet, it's that companies making these products really don't want you to. One simple reason is that it might make someone else play less if they could all those items by just paying a little money. The other reason why selling in-game items for real money will never be permitted (again) is all the gigantic legal crap that it brings along. If the items are worth real money, you can sue Blizzard or other players for events which unfairly make you lose an item, or affect the value of the items you hold.
- dvt 4y ago> If the items are worth real money, you can sue Blizzard or other players for events which unfairly make you lose an item, or affect the value of the items you hold. This isn't true at all, because Magic (the card game) already has a vibrant secondary market with no legal problems. They nerf/buff cards all the time. People like you are just pushing back so vehemently because it's popular to hate on crypto and NFTs right now. Rightfully so, even, as there's tons of scams out there, but that doesn't mean the idea and technology is interesting or useful.
- douglaswlance 4y agoIn web3, the "curation fee" is gas fees.
- InefficientRed 4y agoThe point of BAYC was the community. So others could copy your image but that wouldn't provide them with access to the community. It's a single-factor login token to a private web forum, which is non-revokable by the client (but AFAICT is revokable by the hosting platform). So sort of the worst all worlds in terms of authentication technology.
- Animats 4y agoAnd to private parties. ApeFest just started in NYC a few minutes ago. If you own a BAYC or MAYC NFT, you get to go to a rave in Manhattan today. Food and drink included.
- ALittleLight 4y agoI'm imagining this as the opening scene of Blade but instead of one guy getting attacked by vampires it's a club full of gullible people getting scammed by con artists. "You must be THIS rich and gullible to attend."
- School-Cotton 4y agoYou can go to raves in nyc without owning NFTs too.
- randomhodler84 4y agoGenerally better ones with better demographic distribution too. But the NFT as a ticket thing is valid, even if I would not attend such a rave myself.
- School-Cotton 4y ago> But the NFT as a ticket thing is valid No it isn’t. That’s exactly my point. There is no real problem being solved here, because clearly, events (even illegal ones!) that required tickets for admission have worked fine for ages without NFTs. This is the problem with most proposed blockchain applications: they have no mechanism to compel behavior in the physical world. Someone controls access to this rave; at the end of the day, the only reason that they accept blockchain tokens instead of entries in a centralized database is because they’ve decided to arbitrarily. You could totally feasibly create a private club whose members you track yourself in a spreadsheet (allowing them to sell their membership to other people, or not, as you prefer). Someone else, or more likely yourself, could then decide to give your members access to private parties, and everything would work the same way. The only thing NFTs give you is irrevocability of the initially stated membership rules: with my example of a private club tracked in a spreadsheet, you could choose to change the rules at any time (say, charging a fee for anyone who wants to transfer ownership). You couldn’t for NFTs. But this advantage of NFTs is somewhat illusory because, again, whoever controls access to benefits in the physical world can themselves change the rules at any time, and so you haven’t really changed the number of parties you have to trust. Whatever organization is running these raves might decide tomorrow that you need a Super Duper Bored Ape that costs extra or has different transferability characteristics, and you’re back where you started.
- k__ 4y agoWeb3 isn't equivalent to NFTs.
- JohnHaugeland 4y agoweb3 isn't anything it's just a brand name that's being used to trick crypto people into thinking that, in a couple decades, they'll invent the future of gaming and the bullet list is always stuff we've had for decades
- k__ 4y agoWeb3 is the decentralized web. Not more, not less.
- arnvald 4y agoThe web is the decentralized web. A server that you can keep at home that you can plug in to make it part of this huge network of machines located all around the world that communicate with each other - this is the decentralized web.
- k__ 4y ago"You" can do it, yes. Most people can't.
- tsimionescu 4y agoThat has nothing to do with centralization, and everything to do with the fact that it's hard to run a website with 0 computer skills, which crypto doesn't improve on in any way.
- k__ 4y agoIt has all to do with centralization and crypto certainly helps by providing a way of decentralization that doesn't require everyone to run infra in their home.
- _manifold 4y ago> The big pitch was that you could have non-copyable items which you could move between virtual worlds. The whole "moving objects between virtual worlds" thing is one of the most ridiculous concepts I see pushed by the crypto/NFT/web3 community. As you've outlined there is a potential for this functionality in non-game/metaverse environments - even if NFTs fail to do it properly. However, when this gets applied to video games at large, I really start to roll my eyes. Even if you could magically hand-wave away all the technical issues that go along with trying to implement something like this - why would developers even bother? Game economies have to be tightly controlled to combat things like RMT, botting, and unsanctioned item trading. Letting people transfer in any item they want basically makes that impossible.
- dvt 4y ago> Letting people transfer in any item they want basically makes that impossible. This is missing the forest for the trees. Of course it wouldn't be a carte blanche, but it would be trivial to let people transfer in cosmetic items (think stickers, color schemes, etc.) based on another ecosystem/game/achievement/etc. Cosmetic digital items (e.g. non-gameplay-impacting) are like a hundred-million-dollar+ industry.
- highwaylights 4y agoWhat's in it for the game developers? They don't profit from the scam so why would they support it?
- cinntaile 4y agoThey could be paid a fee when transferring your item to a different game universe. Please don't poison the well by calling it a scam. edit: -4... Time for some of you to read the HN guidelines I guess.
- giantrobot 4y agoSo an item you bought/found/won now costs you more money to move to a different game. Not only would you have it cost money but there's no guarantee the OrcFucker2000 in Game A has any meaningful ability in Game B. If that's not a scam is certainly is wearing a scam's uniform.
- Tenoke 4y agoThat was definitely not 'the big pitch' of web3. That's a pitch of nfts. Different web3 companies have different pitches. Uniswap for example has little to do with virtual world items and is definitely web3.
- bb88 4y agoWeb 3 seems to want to monetize every web transaction under the guise of providing increased freedom. So it may not have been the pitch, but NFT's are definitely Web 3. You're just moving the goal posts.
- yawnxyz 4y agohaha I put a bunch of NFTs on OpenSea that connects to an Airtable base, so all the metadata and image just reflects what I put on Airtable.
- cyanydeez 4y agoThing is. What they're asking for is Digital Rights Management. The promise of NFT is DRM. Seriously.