6 ms·
Looks like the account got restored. Seemingly, nothing got erased, the account was just temporarily unavailable. > Needless to say, the OOB lecturers were ful
by jeroenhd 4y ago
Looks like the account got restored. Seemingly, nothing got erased, the account was just temporarily unavailable.
> Needless to say, the OOB lecturers were fully clothed and rather obsessed with our historical narrative. Anyone not interested in feminist politics would have probably fallen asleep.
The lecturers perhaps, but the streamed lecture contains full-screen examples from pornographic magazines that obviously should be flagged for verification by any porn detecting algorithm.
Youtube does state that explicit materials are allowed for educational content, but if their copyright machines can't even distinguish white noise from copyrighted music then I have very little hope that context like "educational discussion" will ever be recognised automatically.
As a society, we may need a platform where educational/government institutions can upload content (with content warnings, if necessary) because Youtube is a terrible fit for content like this. Youtube's scope is too large to be managed by humans who can understand context and their advertiser seeking behaviour provides an incentive to "punish" videos containing even allowed nudity in their self-learning algorithms. Requiring every institution to set up their own video hosting infrastructure is unnecessary and even wasteful of public funds.
- tedivm 4y agoThey could just flag the accounts of educational institutions as educational. I sincerely doubt the Cornell University Library is going to pivot to pornography.
- puffoflogic 4y agoOn the other hand, wrongthink is quite likely to come out of such an institution (historically speaking, maybe not so much in the current place and time). So it would be a bad idea from the censors' point of view to allowlist the account.
- robertlagrant 4y agoAre you using "wrongthink" to ironically mean a wrong thought?
- sophacles 4y agoSo what you are saying that it makes sense to ban people for ideas you consider wrong, because you worry that those ideas might lead to people being banned for ideas that are wrong?
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y agoStill seems like a bad political[0] move for them to so shamelessly censor an institution of learning. [0] As in it will leave a bad impression on a lot of people, not that they'll lose the next election.
- jeroenhd 4y agoI'm not sure if they'd even want to. Youtube exists to make money of ads and giving account exemptions so that they can upload long-form content explicitly not fit for advertisers seems like a poor business model. Google is definitely not in it for the good of humanity (and neither are the decision makers at a lot of educational facilities, as hard as some staff may try to improve that). In a perfect world your solution would fix the problem, but in practice it doesn't work out. Vimeo seems like a much better fit for eduction to be honest. They're probably more expensive, though.
- KerrAvon 4y agoVimeo is moving to a B2B model, so definitely too expensive. What they really want is to upload the Internet Archive, but the UI really sucks.
- bambax 4y agoBut why would all advertisers refrain from putting ads next to lectures, even if some imagery is a little risqué? That some advertisers would not like it, sure, but all of them?
- SpicyLemonZest 4y agoIn the US, mainstream culture considers pornography to be totally beyond the pale and no company that isn't itself selling sex would allow its brand to be associated with porn.
- bambax 4y agoDiscussing nude imagery in an academic setting doesn't have much to do with "pornography". To the credit of YT, they host plenty of nude videos that aren't, somehow, "porn" (search for "Brazilian wax" for instance...) So much so that one begins to wonder if the problem with Cornell and such may stem more from the political message than the imagery itself.
- SpicyLemonZest 4y ago
- bambax 4y agoCame here to say this. An "AI" system may have a hard time distinguishing a porn image published for arousal, from the same image studied in a lecture. But how hard can it be to mark Cornell University as an account important enough that every action needs a human review, or two?
- civilized 4y agoDisclaimer - just my theory, but... The love for tech companies on Wall Street stems from their ability to scale up revenues much more rapidly than their costs. Human review is costly, and at YouTube's scale, every reasonable request for more human attention opens the floodgates for tons of other, equally reasonable requests. Thus, any broad policy change that increases demand for human review can eat into profit margins and stock prices big time, and will therefore be resisted with great ferocity and vigilance.
- SpicyLemonZest 4y agoI'm not sure they'd agree with the premise that it's OK to show pornography as long as your purpose is to educate people about it. Their current policy on the topic (https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2802002 https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2802002) is that even in an educational context "gratuitous" nudity isn't allowed.
- fatherzine 4y agoIt's gratuitous shock technique. Sir Timothy has blessed us with the revolutionary concept of the "hyperlink" and these days everyone has a "web browser" in their pocket where accessing a "hyperlink" is one tap away. Absolutely trivial to upload the pornography one "hyperlink" away and let people decide for themselves whether they want to look at it or not.
- rcoder 4y agoThese were literally _lectures_ containing images from pornography because it was _part of the lecture_. IIUC you're suggesting people -- academic lecturers, no less, not professional streamers -- splice out sections of their lecture, replace them with a content warning, provide a contextual link to the "risky" content, and then hope that people will follow it, jump right back to the original lecture, and then come back? (And that somehow that link won't trigger the same YouTube content flag, b/c obviously they're going to at least broadly categorize outbound links to combat spam.) This (meaning HN) community regularly nerds out over SEO, landing page optimization, and zero-friction payment flows. Why should we expect educators to be successful delivering complex content in an approachable way if we're also going to require them to carefully slice their content into "acceptable" and "NSFW" segments and deliver them separately, even when the original lecture was linear?
- SpicyLemonZest 4y agoWe shouldn't expect them to be! I just don't think it's tremendously important whether educators can effectively deliver complex pornographic lectures on Youtube.
- duxup 4y ago>I sincerely doubt the Cornell University Library is going to pivot to pornography. Probably not but what rando has the password to that account could be crazy wide ranging, that's the real key. Professional sports teams still have run ins with "oh some rando intern was posting sorry". Still worth a try. Maybe have it so the filter "flags" questionable video, the account is special so it doesn't remove the video and it gets checked "quickly" with some identifier that this is an educational account. Granted exceptions are always complicated. What happens when someone else gets their content shut down and a concerned educational account starts reposing it ;) (and that's just the first complication I can think of)
- neilk 4y agoThat’s a solution that works for 150-year-old universities, not for little indie publishers. If we don’t have solutions that work for obscure and unpopular ideas - like Susie Bright in the 1980s - what good is the right to free speech? I wish that regulation was the answer, but back in the day, government censorship was the problem. Which also fell disproportionately on small and weak organizations. In the 80s and 90s, in Canada, there were Supreme Court cases about small LGBT-identified bookstores routinely having their orders seized by Customs on obscenity grounds. EDIT: I don’t know what I believe any more. We know that censorship falls heavily on on unpopular speech from marginalized people, no matter whether it’s government or private industry. On the other hand, without censorship or regulation, it seems to be true that content providers and adtech will turn about 10-15% of the population insane with far-right conspiracy theories.
- shadowgovt 4y agoThere's no single uniform right answer, and the tech community got away with naively believing their might be one for decades because they actually didn't have the social clout for the median person to care what was going on in online fora. But the tension between free speech, censorship, information, and misinformation is as old as communication itself, and there's more to be learned on the subjects from history than from the YouTube Terms of Service.
- stickfigure 4y ago> content providers and adtech will turn about 10-15% of the population insane with far-right conspiracy theories. I have some of these people in my family tree. Adtech, content providers, censorship, etc are all irrelevant. Those 10-15% are going to find their nutjob content no matter where it lives. The content doesn't make them crazy, they make themselves crazy by filtering their memetic exposure to stuff that confirms their biases. Kicking it off of youtube does not prevent them from finding it, it just confirms their suspicion that there's a conspiracy trying to stop them from hearing "the truth".
- CivBase 4y ago> As a society, we may need a platform where educational/government institutions can upload content (with content warnings, if necessary) because Youtube is a terrible fit for content like this. I understand Cornell using YouTube as a mirror for the content - especially considering the content is probably more "discoverable" there. However, I find it ridiculous that a large, well-funded institution with such a large catalog of public video content can't stand up their own host. Relying on YouTube to host their content is just negligent.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- geekbird 4y agoLOL! I have worked for a large, well funded, private non-profit university with many millions in its endowment funds. They are probably one of the biggest cheapskates I've even worked for when it comes to IT spend. If it doesn't bring in grant money or student money, it is not supported. They'll spend millions on research computing, but balk at buying anything but the cheapest "ergonomic" chairs for the open plan offices that they cram IT staff into. (Professors and academic staff get offices, IT staff don't even get cubes.) They might pay for uncensored video hosting and exposure an "edu only" site, but they wouldn't want the expense of hosting their own. The value add would be a content nexus for academic and "open university" lectures that could possibly be monetized by a per view/per topic fee from the users.
- jimmaswell 4y ago> we may need a platform where educational/government institutions can upload content All these institutions already host their own websites.
- duxup 4y agoBut they also want to be visible and a part of other conversations ... for now platforms kinda dictate that...
- Closi 4y ago> As a society, we may need a platform where educational/government institutions can upload content (with content warnings, if necessary) because Youtube is a terrible fit for content like this. These institutions are big enough to host their own videos - we don't need a new platform, they just need to spin up a server and to pay for their own bandwidth. If you trust Google to provide your video hosting at a pricetag of £0 this is what you get... You are on their platform, with their rules, where their algorithm is judge, jury and executioner.
- Terry_Roll 4y ago> You are on their platform, with their rules, where their algorithm is judge, jury and executioner. Sounds like a Govt's.
- frereubu 4y agoWhen I see a comment on HN that says someone "just" needs to do something I always wince. There are so many things to consider here, even if universities weren't the bureaucratic labyrinth that they are. Quite apart from the discovery aspect of being on YouTube, where people already on YouTube are much more likely to stumble across Cornell videos when using certain search terms, it wouldn't "just" be spinning up a single server - it would involve all sorts of stuff like encoding videos, bandwidth detection, load balancing etc. etc. I'm not saying this might not be a good thing to do, particularly as a backup if their YouTube channel gets taken down for some reason, but it's almost never as simple as "just" doing something. I'd encourage anyone who catches themselves writing "just" in a sentence to have a deeper think about why a person or organisation isn't doing that.
- alar44 4y agoNone of that is difficult, especially for a University, sorry.
- hnthrow1010 4y agoWhat exactly do you mean? Say the university hired you to do the job, I assume you have a budget & headcount ready?
- jhugo 4y ago> As a society, we may need a platform where educational/government institutions can upload content (with content warnings, if necessary) because Youtube is a terrible fit for content like this. It's problematic to only let government or entrenched institutions deliver uncensored content. Powerful groups have a habit of shaping what is "educational" to fit their goals.
- epgui 4y agoThe goal of a university is to promote learning. It’s not very nefarious.
- jhugo 4y agoUniversities in HK will soon eliminate any mention of the period when it was part of the British empire from their History programmes. That's one example among many. In general, the establishment teaches what is convenient for the establishment to teach.
- epgui 4y agoIf this is true (and I assume it is for the sake of argument), then it's pretty obvious that there's an element of coercion at play. This is not happening because the HK universities decided that they should do so. My comment obviously presupposes that a university is acting autonomously or independently, and this assumption largely holds true across space and time: even throughout History and in challenging political regimes, universities have tended to be at the forefront of academic freedom.
- lupire 4y agoNot everyone who promotes learning is a university.
- epgui 4y agoThat is true, but irrelevant to my comment.
- philipwhiuk 4y agoNow you have to define 'educational institution'.
- Xylakant 4y ago> As a society, we may need a platform where educational/government institutions can upload content Some of the museums in Vienna started posting to onlyfans to avoid running into the rules around nudity on other platforms https://www.artnews.com/art-news/news/onlyfans-vienna-museums-1234607398/ https://www.artnews.com/art-news/news/onlyfans-vienna-museum...
- dkural 4y agoThis is a bit off topic: The parent article mentions some higher math talks - out of curiosity, anyone can see one? I don't doubt everything got restored, but I can't seem to find any math.
- jeroenhd 4y agoI can't find it either. Looking at an archived copy of their channel[1] I mostly see videos about the humanities. The playlists are also there. I don't think they weren't restored. It's possible that the videos are unlisted or uploaded on some other account. [1]: http://web.archive.org/web/20211010100521/https://www.youtube.com/c/cornelllibrary http://web.archive.org/web/20211010100521/https://www.youtub...
- shalmanese 4y ago> Youtube does state that explicit materials are allowed for educational content, but if their copyright machines can't even distinguish white noise from copyrighted music then I have very little hope that context like "educational discussion" will ever be recognised automatically. But why the obsession with recognizing it automatically? I've long wondered why we never developed a digital system for asserting copyright rights. Like, you register a piece of IP with Google and Google should give you a key. You can then use that key to sign certificates that grant certain people legal use of your content on Google. When I go upload a video, I upload all of the relevant keys that indicate that I've included certain copyright material in my video but I've cleared it up with rights holders ahead of time. Video game companies, for example, could one click hand out keys for free to make sure game streamers could legally stream their games. Similarly, Google could outsource their enforcement of "for educational discussion" to individual organizations. Cornell could agree that staff uploading content that is in keeping with Google's TOS is an official part of Cornell disciplinary proceedings. In return, Cornell has to place a bond at Google that would be forfeited if they ever broke their agreement. Insurance companies could insure such bonds by evaluating whether Cornell has the right processes in place that would prevent TOS violating content from ever appearing on Cornell's YT channel. In return, Google agrees to turn off all ML content moderation on Cornell's account. This could easily scale down to smaller channels. If I'm a video essayist channel, I could agree to take a mandatory training course and put down a $X00 bond to have my channel be free from all ML copyright checking up to my first X0,000 followers/X00,000,000 views. If a human judges me to have violated the TOS, the $X00 is there to pay for that human's time. No spam channel would find it worthwhile to go through verification and they would still be subjected to the normal ML checking but people who depend on YT for professional reasons could be more certain of avoiding automated false positives & negatives.
- fatherzine 4y agoQ: But why the obsession with recognizing it automatically? A: "500 hours of video are uploaded to YouTube every minute worldwide." https://www.oberlo.com/blog/youtube-statistics https://www.oberlo.com/blog/youtube-statistics A bit of arithmetic gives 30000 days of video uploaded to YouTube per day. Manually reviewing all that content would require an army of people.
- chasing 4y ago> As a society, we may need a platform where educational/government institutions can upload content (with content warnings, if necessary) because Youtube is a terrible fit for content like this. We do: It's called Their Own Websites. Not that what YouTube did was right, but I sure wouldn't rely on them to be the sole holder and provider of my content.