4 ms·
Thiel was an early believer that democracy is incompatible with freedom. And popular social media proved it even more right by making people believe that what's
by seydor 4y ago
Thiel was an early believer that democracy is incompatible with freedom. And popular social media proved it even more right by making people believe that what's popular is truth, and then manipulating what s popular. It was a mistake from the start to believe in it. I hope he gets back on his libertarian roots and quits changing the world through democracy.
- fny 4y agoThiel actively manipulates these same channels for his benefit. If you think he wasn't selling into the bitcoin pump all of last year that he helped provoke, you're incredibly naive. Much in the same way Musk pumped his own stock and sold (along with his brother) at the top. Thiel has no principles. He is an empire builder. His goal is to protect his wealth and build it through whatever means possible. The writing is on the wall for big tech, and he has changed his tune accordingly.
- aaaaaaaaata 4y ago> Thiel actively manipulates these same channels for his benefit. That's what GP is saying...
- bko 4y agoHow was Thiel pumping bitcoin and manipulating social media channels? He has no social media presence at all. I saw one speech at a Bitcoin conference that no one else really watched and I figured he liked the tech due to his politics. But he wasn't pumping it. > Much in the same way Musk pumped his own stock and sold (along with his brother) at the top. If he had a crystal ball about the future of the market and Tesla stock, why didn't he sell more? Seems like he left a lot of money on the table. > Thiel has no principles. He is an empire builder. His goal is to protect his wealth and build it through whatever means possible There are a lot of things you can say about Thiel but he's not all about protecting his wealth. He personally spent $10 million to fight Gawker for refusing a court order to take down an illegal sex tape of someone. He also suffered a huge reputational hit by supporting and funding Trump early on. He has principles, just ones that you may not agree with.
- anovikov 4y agoI agree with this thesis. Democracy is indeed, incompatible with freedom. Most of the human rights and freedoms we perceive to be essential today, only appeared because in the times when they were invented (late 18th century), technology and social structure ensured that only elites could use them (so "universal"-ness of these rights was a lie), or no one at all could use them for harm. When technology changed, we could see these liberties as harmful. Freedom to own and bear arms was OK in the times of muskets, they were too slow to reload to try a school shooting. Freedom of speech was OK when it was about freedom to print and distribute a pamphlet (which meant having cash, connection, and rare level of education = belonging to the elite). Now we have to either scrap democracy (resort to the kind of Putinism where police state ensures that there are no school shootings, and opinions of people do not matter thus making freedom of speech harmless), or scrap freedom, like in the Western Europe where the acceptable corridor of opinions and behaviour for expressing themselves without becoming outcasts is so narrow that no sort of public activity not sanctioned by the government appears possible. Or more likely, what's going on already will just get stronger: switch to a two-tiered world where will be large nations comprised mainly of brainwashed serfs, and smaller rich nations where elites will still enjoy all rights and freedoms - harmless because they are elites, and sustainable because they are fed by money plundered from the aforementioned large nations.
- cyber_kinetist 4y agoI also agree that the two are incompatible, but in a different way: why don't we ditch the liberal concept of freedom and save democracy instead? From the Online Etymology Dictionary, "freedom": > Old English freodom "power of self-determination, state of free will; emancipation from slavery, deliverance;" see free (adj.) + -dom. > Meaning "exemption from arbitrary or despotic control, civil liberty" is from late 14c. > Meaning "possession of particular privileges" is from 1570s. Isn't it interesting that the definition of freedom has changed from escape from control, to control itself? This happened roughly around the time when the Enlightenment started and liberal thoughts were beginning to spread in Europe, which is also the time when ideas of private property and capitalism were starting to take shape. Take note that one of the most fundamental "freedoms" of liberalism which is private property, can only be enforced by the state with violence or threats of violence, usually done by the police or the army. So at this point freedom has become an oxymoron, since to be free one has to submit to total authority of the law. I think neoliberalism is just an extension of this contradiction - you are encouraged to participate "freely" in the free market, which is held by the global financial system which is backed by the dollar and consequently the military powers of the United States. No matter where you escape to, any economic activity has to be done through the hegemonic powers of the world, and losing access to it means doom for your country and your people (ex. Cuba). So I view Thiel's search for his ultimate ideal of freedom by ditching democracy is futile, since the liberal conception of freedom itself was already contradictory and impossible to achieve. He can only think of more totalitarian ways to enforce a "free" system upon the people (so probably they can do whatever they want, like you have already said). The problem is that believing in contradictions don't automatically make societies fall, as Deleuze has said: "No one has ever died from contradictions. And the more it breaks down, the more it schizophrenizes, the better it works, the American way.” So as you have described nicely in your last sentence, most people will continue to get fucked regardless, until we fucking do something about it. By the way, Graeber has written a lot about the subject of freedom in many of his books and papers (the most evident one being his last book "The Dawn of Everything" co-written by Wengrow.) I think you'll enjoy his works if you have some shared sympathies with Thiel's views of libertarianism, regardless of if you're labelled left/right in the current political climate. Graeber has once written about a topic Thiel was also interested in ("Of Flying Cars and the Declining Rate of Profit": https://thebaffler.com/salvos/of-flying-cars-and-the-declining-rate-of-profit https://thebaffler.com/salvos/of-flying-cars-and-the-declini...), and they've also met together and had a debate about this topic (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eF0cz9OmCGw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eF0cz9OmCGw).
- walkhour 4y agoWhat's popular is truth for most people, since humans are herd animals, and being a contrarian can mean being marginalized. In the antebellum South slavery was morally right, and it required to be a true outlier to speak out against it. People didn't independently discover this morality, they just copied what's popular.
- spiderice 4y agoYou’re conflating truth and opinion. “Slavery is morally right” is an opinion (a shitty one), not a “truth”. Lying about objective truth is a much more egregious offense than pushing your shitty opinion, imo
- walkhour 4y ago> You’re conflating truth and opinion This thread is discussing conflating popular opinions and truth.
- yucky 4y ago>In the antebellum South slavery was morally right I don't think this is correct, abolitionism was a thing particularly within the most religious (read:moral) groups of people. Only a tiny fraction of southerners owned slaves, most estimates put that number at under 2% of the population, and there isn't much evidence that the owners of slaves even claimed to have the moral high ground, let alone the 98% of the population that didn't own slaves. That's not to say abolitionists saw all races as equal, and it also doesn't ignore those who tried to roll out the story of Ham to justify slavery, but there was no consensus on the morality of the institution even at its height. If there were and if it were considered the morally "right" thing to do then we would have seen far more people becoming slave owners, especially among the most religious. Slavery was essentially a business decision, not a moral one. And not a very good business decision either, even if you can look past the evil of it all.
- Flozzin 4y agoJust want to call out your 2% of the population claim. While maybe it is, 'technically correct', it gives a false impression. Slaves were counted among the population, thus skewing the number. Also, wives/women would not be counted as owning slaves, even if their husbands did. Same could be said about their children. "The 1860 census shows that in the states that would soon secede from the Union, an average of more than 32 percent of white families owned enslaved people. Some states had far more slave owners (46 percent of families in South Carolina, 49 percent in Mississippi) while some had far fewer (20 percent of families in Arkansas)." (https://www.history.com/news/5-myths-about-slavery https://www.history.com/news/5-myths-about-slavery)