4 ms·
I've been in crypto since 2014. I just had the California Franchise Tax Board literally steal money out of a bank account of mine without any warning or notice
by latchkey 4y ago
I've been in crypto since 2014.
I just had the California Franchise Tax Board literally steal money out of a bank account of mine without any warning or notice. They left $0.01 in there and charged a $125 fee. I found out today they are claiming I owe taxes from when I wasn't even living in the country (and I was paying taxes then too!). In 2021/2022, I paid more taxes than I ever have in my life. I even over paid just to make sure that I was fully covered, including additional property taxes now that I purchased a place. I'm not some crypto tax dodger at all, I pay more than my fair share because that is the right thing to do.
Today, I ended up going to my other bank and pulling all of my money out as cash (thankfully they picked the 'wrong' account!). I can't trust the system to not steal even more money from me. That's messed up. Because monday is a bank holiday, now I have to wait until tuesday until my accountant can deal with this bullshit. What kind of broken system is this?
Things like this really make me want to double down on crypto. Not your keys, not your coins is taking on a whole new meaning for me. It is easy to say "well, that's never happened to me. crypto is a waste. i have no use for this stuff", but if all it takes is some faceless government entity to wipe out your entire bank account without any notice... then obviously something is wrong with the system.
As for future employability... that's silly. Any place that wouldn't hire you because of where you worked in the past isn't a place you'd want to work at anyway. I hire people because they have the skills and attitude that I'm looking for.
- granddemolisher 4y ago> Today, I ended up going to my other bank and pulling all of my money out as cash. I can't trust the system to not steal even more money from me. That's messed up. Because monday is a bank holiday, now I have to wait until tuesday until my accountant can deal with this bullshit. What kind of broken system is this? Same. It's insane how little control and power you have as an average person. Your bank accounts can be frozen on a whimp, you can be put into a jail with no attorney because you cannot use your own money to pay for them and forced to confess to something you never did, then slave away for the state. There are too many laws everywhere which means you've broken some. The only difference between you and the person who got caught is selective enforcement and someone wanting to make an example or fulfil their own goals. And financial system will snitch on all of it. You have no privacy. Is that not insane? You could be jailed for having a financial transactions on grindr in some countries in the world. Countries impose financial and currency controls against the benefit of the people all the time. It's not "freedom" if you cannot choose to take your money outside. It's fucked up how normalised limiting freedom has become. You don't notice it. The state controls so much of your money forcefully with a threat of violence and isolation. Your money that you work hard for, sweat for, break your bones for.
- latchkey 4y agoYes. All of this is why "web3" is not bullshit and why I've dedicated years of my energy and my funds to it. Try living in another country too, I have. Banking is the number one pain point. Even more than language issues. Ever tried to get your own money out of a western union in a country that doesn't speak your language? If you're doubting "web3" then you've probably never experienced these sorts of pain yourself and I could understand your trepidation. But since I'm understanding you, how about understanding me too.
- granddemolisher 4y agoIMO, the term web3 is tainted by VCs using retail to dump their tokens faster than they can dump equity in traditional IPO which is less transparent to average schmuck because most of the money comes from the retirement funds passively investing in everything. It's their shortcut to liquidity which resulted in overpromises and dumps. It's not unreasonable for someone to be sceptical but to dismiss it all together is a mistake. We need to go back to the core. Decentralized financial instruments built to help people prosper economicly. To uplift poor people in unbanked countries. To stop dictators from rugging poor people and investors. To provide individual freedom and highest level of personal attainment. The yield bullshit needs to stop. Edit: I don't mean all yield strategies, just ones which are unsustainable (most of them). I want unsecured lending products in crypto based on on-chain reputation which happens automatically on taking small loans or doing a lot of transactions maybe endorsement system where institutions stake money in return of verification. Banks won't provide loans to people who need them the most. Even self employment people and founders with millions of dollars in exit struggle with a home loan because banks refuse to deal with anyone who doesn't fit their cookie cutter. I believe crypto has potential to disrupt it. I love flash loans for this exact reason. They are unique to crypto, allowing freedom to anyone to increase market efficiency by taking advantage of arbitrage without creditionals and needing absurd amount of capital to start.
- latchkey 4y agoCertainly, the marketing around web3 went to shit. But I've been in it for 4 years now so I don't really care about the VC's because I see the larger picture already. I agree with everything you said, but the end. The ponzi tokenomics definitely needs to stop, but the lego yield stuff has potential. It is more than just unbanked, it is people without lines of credit. It is teaching people how to be fiscally responsible. Based on my Vietnam example below. Woman with gold teeth instead deposits her stable money into her phone. That money earns yield automatically. She can also use a portion of it as collateral for a Kiva-style loan to help with her farm crops (or whatever small business she has). People who buy her products effectively pay back her loan directly by submitting to her phone app. She's in control of it herself.
- olalonde 4y agoThere are a lot of stories like this. There are also a lot of unbanked people (1.7 billion worldwide). People who fail to see the value in Bitcoin/crypto often are not aware of those very real problems people are facing. Traditional banking is great so long as you are on the happy path.
- latchkey 4y agoIn northern Vietnam, where I've done extensive travel, to this day, women store their meager wealth in gold fillings because that is the only place where they can put it and not have it stolen from them. There is no bank where they can deposit funds and even if there was, the Vietnam govt's version of FDIC is like $2k. Amazingly, they also have smart phones and the government has put 4G towers through the whole country and in the most remote places. That's our usecase right there.
- granddemolisher 4y agoSame is true for Bangladesh, India, Philippines, etc. They all have good Internet connectivity but too many unbanked people.
- hestefisk 4y agoMobile wallets are quite popular for the unbanked in those countries. You don’t need a decentralised ledger for that.
- latchkey 4y agoThe banks are awful and have been known to go out of business and take peoples money with them. The concept of FDIC insurance doesn’t exist. Also, good luck getting an account when you don’t have an address.
- mmcnl 4y agoYour reasoning is something like: problem unbanked people, solution crypto. I don't understand that reasoning at all. Why not look at solutions that have actually proven to work first? Why not investigate the problem and figure out what their needs actually are?
- herbst 4y agoI too had something like this happen. After a burnout and extensive travel I somehow got my whole account frozen and emptied just after I got back home. I spend weeks begging friends to pay my bills (i.e. server bills, domains, ...) Because otherwise my business would have died because I couldn't pay for anything. It took several weeks until I had a cash flow established again. In no world am I going to trust a bank with my active money anymore. I rather loose 50% within a week than everything within a day. Edit:// or the one time I couldn't buy any food before Monday because I forgot (or rather didn't care) Thursday and Friday is a holiday and transferred money on Wednesday afternoon only to arrive on Monday at noon. And this is within the same bank! Also: Imagine doing international business like a SaaS in a Industrie Visa/MasterCard doesn't allow. Without crypto I would be having 50 PayPal (Payeer, PM, ...) like accounts from several countries and fees multiplying all over. Edit2:// Or when I was living abroad but couldn't open a bank account because I also live in Switzerland and EU banks are afraid of money laundering so much that they simply refuse to open an account for someone that could 'launder so easy'. Even thought I do have an EU passport, and a legit business.
- Simon_O_Rourke 4y agoHad similar experience when I was out working in Berlin. I had a gym membership in one part of the city (paid up 12 months in advance in cash). Moved to a different part of the city and didn't go back. Fast forward about six months, two bald headed goons came knocking at my old address looking for me, with a 1850 euro bill. Gym membership for the next year plus a 900 euro service charge because I hadn't written a letter starting my intention not to renew by 90 days of the time of an automatic roll over. Luckily for me, the Aussie guy staying in my old place told them I'd moved into a squat and they'd have to serve notice on two dozen angry punks if they wanted their money. Never heard from them again. But I was lucky, if I'd given them a bank account the full amount would have been charged straight away, with no comeback or way to get my money back for a service I didn't use, and the bank would be absolutely fine with that. Shortly after I moved much of my funds into crypto, and would do it again for the security from arbitrary seizure.
- LeonM 4y agoIf it makes you feel better: most gyms are a scam. The whole business model is about selling as much memberships as possible, and making it hard to cancel. Most gyms sell much more memberships than they could even remotely facilitate, because they know ~80% of the members never return after the first month or so. I used to work at a small gym that could handle maybe 100 visitors a day, I think they had over 8000 paying members. You could only cancel by letter 1 month in advance of the renewal date. The only exception was a doctor's letter for some medical reason you could no longer go to the gym. The owner drove a Ferrari (albeit second hand). Every year on January, after people had been over-consuming food and had ambitious new year resolutions, they'd do all sorts of promotions, and they would sell for about a years worth of new subscriptions in a day. I'd estimate 90% of those 'januaries' (as they'd call them) no longer returned after the first month. About 75% forgot to cancel in December, so they would be charged again for a full year, though they hadn't visited in 11 months. This is a common 'exploit' of human behaviour. People feel good about taking the first step in weight loss by buying the membership. But when you think about it, it makes no sense at all why you'd need a 'membership' the gain access to a gym. This is also why home training devices are a big business, and why they usually come with terrible return policies.
- 4y ago
- wasmitnetzen 4y agoI feel like it's a bit naive to expect that the crypto world can evade the authorities forever. You need a registered office and executives and lawyers to run any big company, and thus the authorities and laws have a way in. The laws governing the existing banking system are not an intrinsic property, the crypto world will have the same laws eventually, just on a slightly different technical platform.
- latchkey 4y agoNot evade. Just give me control of my own funds such that nobody can just empty my account without at least giving me notice first. As you can imagine, that is a quite disturbing and disruptive event.
- wasmitnetzen 4y agoI do understand you feelings, but I don't see how that's a technical problem. That's an entirely legal problem. The law could easily mandate that feature to any cryptocurrency which doesn't want to go to the underground, or remove that feature from regular banking.
- latchkey 4y agoHow is law not technical?
- wasmitnetzen 4y agoLaw does not follow physics, it's a purely human invention. But I'm not sure how that's relevant to the discussion?
- mmcnl 4y agoCrypto is one of many solutions for this problem. I'm willing to argue that out of 10 possible solutions, the crypto solution is the worst of all. Simply because the law is the law, and crypto might make it harder to enforce the law, it doesn't _change_ the law. So even with your crypto solution, you still would owe money to the California Franchise Tax Board, whether you like or not.
- nootropicat 4y agoPossession is 9/10 of the law. What some tax board thinks only matters insofar as they are able to enforce their will. People think governments are omnipotent. They are not.
- latchkey 4y agoRead what I wrote. I paid my taxes. I paid what I owed. I am almost 50 and never had an issue with taxes in my lifetime. They still emptied my account with no notification. I never thought that would happen to me.
- ufmace 4y agoTo be fair, it's a lot easier to deal with tax board says you owe $X but can't physically take anything, so you get a chance to make your case before actually handing it over, than tax board says you owe $X and just grabbed it out of your account without even warning you, you can try to contest it after but you'll be broke while you do.
- roflyear 4y agoYah bc when you get scammed in crypto no one can get your money back! Lmao.
- latchkey 4y agoAgreed. Wallet security needs to improve. That said, my company was recently scammed with a phishing attack where we were sent an invoice from one of our vendors. Someone had hacked the vendors accounting firm and we paid it to an different account number, get this… in the same bank. So, scammers were able to create an account, with kyc in the same bank. Crazy. We are struggling to get the money back now.
- granddemolisher 4y agoUse an escrow? It's pretty simple to build reversible transactions for an erc 20 token on EVM. Obviously you would introduce a centralized arbitrator. It's a solved problem in crypto except nobody uses it.
- deanmoriarty 4y agoWhy do you think the FTB took money from your account? Do you think you had unpaid taxes/etc.? You must have some intuition about it (e.g. previous notices?), and I'd love to hear more. Thanks.