17 ms·
Parents’ trauma leaves biological traces in children
- pleb_nz 4y agoSo maybe there could be some small fact to the theory that some studies report in which older parents are on average are more likely to have smarter children? Many more life experiences to pass on at 40 compared to that of 20.
- swayvil 4y agoCall it a DNA-level intellect. Just like my personal intellect but smeared across a generational tree. Or a species.
- neonate 4y agohttps://archive.ph/3i31R https://archive.ph/3i31R http://web.archive.org/web/20220618204642/https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-parents-rsquo-trauma-leaves-biological-traces-in-children/ http://web.archive.org/web/20220618204642/https://www.scient...
- lisper 4y agoThis shouldn't be too surprising. It is well known that what a mother ingests during pregnancy can affect development, so it makes sense that stress-related hormones could do the same.
- bobviolier 4y agoThis article is specifically not just about "during pregnancy" though. Quote: "It suggested that trauma might have affected the mothers' eggs decades before her children were conceived, while she was herself a child." "They gave a male mouse a mild electric shock as it smelled a cherry blossom scent, stimulating a fear response to the odor. The response was accompanied by epigenetic changes in its brain and sperm. Intriguingly, the male offspring of the shocked mice demonstrated a similar fear of cherry blossoms—as well as epigenetic changes in their brain and sperm—without being exposed to the shock. These effects were passed down for two generations. In other words, the lesson the grandfather mouse learned, that the cherry blossom scent means danger, was transmitted to its son and grandson."
- lisper 4y agoYeah, I have to confess that I didn't get that far. I pretty much stopped here: "The effect was most prominent in babies whose mothers had been in their third trimester on that fateful day." At which point I thought, "OK, that's not surprising", wrote my comment, and went on to other things. Frankly, I am extremely skeptical of the mouse results. I would be really surprised if this turned out to be reproducible. It's Lamarckian evolution, which has been long-discredited, which makes this an extraordinary claim which requires extraordinary evidence. By what possible mechanism could memory of a smell be recorded in a gamete's DNA?
- catlifeonmars 4y agoThat’s totally different. What’s unique here is the epigenetic mechanism of the effect. The effects are fixed at conception when recombination occurs and have nothing to do with development in the womb. Edit: it’s also worth noting that epigenetic effects can span generations[1], something that a purely environmental effect could not. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transgenerational_epigenetic_inheritance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transgenerational_epigenetic_i...
- lisper 4y agoWell, that's not quite true. The first half of the article is about effects of stress during gestation. "The effect was most prominent in babies whose mothers had been in their third trimester on that fateful day." > epigenetic effects can span generations[1], something that a purely environmental effect could not Why not? It seems to me the only way you could rule out environmental effects is if there are no aspects of the environment that are constant across generations, otherwise those constant aspects of the environment would necessarily effect multiple generations.
- catlifeonmars 4y ago> Well, that's not quite true. The first half of the article is about effects of stress during gestation. Quoting from the article, the researcher starts looking due to the presumed effects of stress during gestation: > Finding low cortisol in the 9/11 babies back in 2002 had told us that we'd been thinking about some things all wrong. We'd assumed all along that trauma was behaviorally transmitted: Joseph's problems seemed to result from the stressful, bereaved atmosphere in his childhood home. But now it looked like the uterine environment also played a role. So did the sex of the traumatized parent. However, ultimately, the key discovery of the article is actually about epigenetic causes and not due to the (current) mother’s uterine environment: > In 2020 we reported lower levels of FKBP5 methylation in the adult children whose mothers—and not fathers—were exposed to the Holocaust during childhood. This effect was independent of whether the mother had PTSD or not. It suggested that trauma might have affected the mothers' eggs decades before her children were conceived, while she was herself a child. I agree with you that you can’t rule out environmental effects without a trial that controls for the effects of the current environment. However, the featured article is really about the hereditary effects, ostensibly epigenetic in nature, rather than nonhereditary.
- monkeybutton 4y agoDNA methylation! I first read about it from this study in 2014: https://reporter.mcgill.ca/dna-signature-found-in-ice-storm-babies/ https://reporter.mcgill.ca/dna-signature-found-in-ice-storm-...
- yarg 4y agoYeah, it's been known for quite some that epigenetic changes are heritable, and that they can be stress induced.
- monkeybutton 4y agoI find it really interesting that one of the consequences is increased obesity in offspring. It's basically evolution passing on the message from one generation to the next: "Pack on those extra calories when you can kid, you're gonna need them!" Then when those environmental stressors are gone the signal is turned off for next generation. Sort of a short-term but cross-generational mechanism for optimizing metabolism. Wild.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoIt might also be a gene’s way of reducing the likelihood of future propagation due to the harm? https://endocrinenews.endocrine.org/obesity-fertility-and-contraception-disparities-among-women-3-perspectives/ https://endocrinenews.endocrine.org/obesity-fertility-and-co...
- em-bee 4y agothere was another study about obesity in sweden that could be traced to a famine in a certain village several generations earlier.
- benreesman 4y agoThe more difficult life experience I amass, the more I become persuaded that the key to all of life's highest callings is to make peace with and ultimately transcend the various early-childhood traumas that we're often not even aware are shaping our decisions and behaviors. It is no surprise to me that there is some biological basis for all these inherited ticks most of us seem to have.
- boredemployee 4y agoYep. Now, for example, I'm trying to avoid at all costs a trip by airplane because of my fear of flying - which I took from my dad as a child.
- hnuser847 4y agoThe best way to overcome that fear is to take a really long flight. I also I had an irrational fear of flying that held me back from traveling internationally for years. Taking a 14 hour flight to Seoul fixed that. I have zero anxiety around flying anymore.
- boredemployee 4y agoI traveled across oceans a few times (12h+ long), when I'm in the plane I feel "ok". The problem is when taking off and landing, I get super anxious/panicked.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- fartcannon 4y agoI had to travel weekly for work. It completely took away my fear of flying.. Now it's just a slog. Obviously not everyone can just fly a bunch to do half assed exposure therapy, but maybe something like VR?
- 4y ago
- 1970-01-01 4y agoI can imagine the next Prop 65 warnings for Hollywood: WARNING: This movie contains scary trigger scenes known to the State of California to cause birth defects or other reproductive harm.
- jimmygrapes 4y agoWe are more than halfway there already: https://news.yahoo.com/obi-wan-kenobi-disney-plus-warning-texas-shooting-095945750.html https://news.yahoo.com/obi-wan-kenobi-disney-plus-warning-te... (and this is far from the only example)
- unwoundmouse 4y agothat would actually be pretty interesting lol
- 1970-01-01 4y agoWhy was my comment flagged?
- m348e912 4y agoI read about epigenetics a few years ago and it's fascinating. I hope more research gets done on it. Trauma passed through genes makes me wonder a few things: * Where/How is it encoded in the gene sequence? * Is having kids earlier in life better for the kid since these is less parental trauma to pass down (assuming the parent experiences some adult trauma) * What good things are being passed down? Such as ability to play music or understand math more effectively?
- abledon 4y agoheres a quote from the article > And Dias and Ressler reconditioned their mice to lose their fear of cherry blossoms; __the offspring conceived after this “treatment” did not have the cherry blossom epigenetic alteration, nor did they fear the scent.__
- colechristensen 4y agoDNA methylation is one mechanism. https://www.nature.com/articles/npp2012112 https://www.nature.com/articles/npp2012112 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DNA_methylation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DNA_methylation
- m348e912 4y agoCool thanks for the links
- FollowingTheDao 4y agoAs is histone modification: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fgene.2019.00192/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fgene.2019.0019... And both can be modified by changes in the environment and diet.
- imwillofficial 4y ago“And the sins of the father”
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- throwaway0a5e 4y agoWe've all heard the proverb about apples and trees but there is a fine line between studying these things and denying people their agency. I fear that in today's ideological climate the information gleaned from this type of study will almost exclusively be used as justification for denying people the freedom to run their own lives.
- sirspacey 4y agoI can understand that fear. I find for myself (& others that share these issues) that recognizing ways you may have been affected is liberating. An analogy is having a broken hand your whole life without knowing it. You wonder why you can’t do what the other kids can do. But by noticing it, you have the option to give yourself the additional care, adaptation, and kindness that can help you create a happy & successful life.
- barrysteve 4y agoPsychotherapists do admit they are primarily a role of social control. The field was an offshoot from philosophy and has developed into a bottom-up inquisition against perceived problems that are very vaguely defined. I'm not sure they do any more good than enforce parenting and individual behaviour norms. Much like the inquisitors of olden days enforced christianity and loyalty to the crown. The science is never quite grounded, which could be a feature instead of a bug. People are sometimes mysteriously cured without explanation and it's not really ever possible to determine if someone is mentally healthy or not. Someone internally pretending to be mentally ill is indistinguishable from the real deal. Some people are 'treatment resistant' for completely unknown reasons. The whole field is philosophically and scientifically uncertain.
- mrsmee89 4y agoI’ve intuited this for quite some time. There seems to me to be a place within our psyche were decisions are made and I would bet that it’s not through our “thinking through a problem” paradigm where so many of us think our decisions come from. I’m curious how this plays into the free will conversation. I think if people could get accustomed to seeing themselves and others as not having quite as much free will as one might think, that would do wonders for humanity.
- BeefWellington 4y agoInter-generational Trauma, as a term, has been kicking around for a while but has had a bit more attention paid to it recently.[1] [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transgenerational_trauma#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transgenerational_trauma#Histo...
- kosyblysk666 4y ago
- abledon 4y agoIgnorance is bliss, this is just more stressful knowing than not lol, whoops already caused some methylation for my future kid :( haha
- serpix 4y agoIgnorance is precisely what keeps the trauma train rolling.
- abledon 4y agoso are the kids of tiktok addicted media scrollers going to have increased likelihood of gambling and attention deficits?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- _ywdj 4y agoI've been living "as if" this is true for over 10 years. After years of struggling with confidence issues, anxiety, and physiological issues like muscle tension/pain and inflammation, and trying all the conventional modalities with minimal lasting benefit, I came onto a form of healing that seeks to address subconsciously-held traumas picked up and earlier life and inherited from parents. Without making this a long, detailed post, the results are profound and lasting, though slow, given how deep this stuff goes and how much there can be to work through once you start digging. There are books and talks about it by a former Stanford biologist called Bruce Lipton, who gets panned for various reasons that seem mostly to do with him being out of step with conventional thought, and (I think) for having a manner that doesn't seem science-y enough, but in my experience his research and teachings on the links between inherited/held emotions and biology and on the physiological benefits of subconscious healing are very solid. I'm really hoping to see more research and widespread interest in this topic, as after experiencing it and contemplating it for so many years, I'm convinced it offers many answers, or at least clues, to issues that medical science and broader society have been stuck on for a long time.
- kadenwolff 4y agoThis seems like a bit of a misrepresentative title. It's been well known for a long time that stress during pregnancy (high cortisol levels particularly) has a negative effect on the child's mental health throughout their whole life. Labeling this as epigenetic trauma feels like stretching the definition in a motte and bailey kind of way.
- wyre 4y agoDid you read the article? The author's research shows that trauma creates epigenetic changes.
- bobviolier 4y agoIf giving your opinion, make sure you read the whole article. For example: "It suggested that trauma might have affected the mothers' eggs decades before her children were conceived, while she was herself a child." "They gave a male mouse a mild electric shock as it smelled a cherry blossom scent, stimulating a fear response to the odor. The response was accompanied by epigenetic changes in its brain and sperm. Intriguingly, the male offspring of the shocked mice demonstrated a similar fear of cherry blossoms—as well as epigenetic changes in their brain and sperm—without being exposed to the shock. These effects were passed down for two generations. In other words, the lesson the grandfather mouse learned, that the cherry blossom scent means danger, was transmitted to its son and grandson."
- kbelder 4y ago>"Intriguingly, the male offspring of the shocked mice demonstrated a similar fear of cherry blossoms—as well as epigenetic changes in their brain and sperm—without being exposed to the shock. These effects were passed down for two generations. In other words, the lesson the grandfather mouse learned, that the cherry blossom scent means danger, was transmitted to its son and grandson." It's going to take multiple teams replicating that before I even start to believe that claim.
- eric4smith 4y agoGreat. Even more stuff we can blame on our parents. At some point, more people should take responsibility for the hand that they are given and run with those cards. At the best, we now have more ammo as parents to deal with trauma so we don't pass it off to the offspring.
- ge96 4y agoMakes me so annoyed people say "you're lucky" like nah, I worked my ass off
- rjbwork 4y agoHard work alone does not yield success. Any of us who have succeeded have had a huge amount of luck. Simply being born in what is presumably a first world country during a time of relative prosperity is already a tremendous amount of luck.
- smt88 4y agoLots of people work their ass off. My housekeeper does, and so do the guys who collect my garbage. They're never going to be financially stable in the way I am, though. I work hard too, but I also have luck. You can be rich, lazy, and lucky. You can be rich, hardworking, and lucky. But you can't be rich, hardworking, and unlucky. Luck is necessary ingredient.
- TaylorAlexander 4y agoYeah to be honest that was always something upsetting about my life. I did really well in math, science, and engineering, but I never really had to try. I was lucky to have a roof over my head growing up, a stable home with science toys and free time to watch educational science shows. I was lucky I had an aptitude for those subjects. But success wasn’t hard for me. I didn’t work very hard. I didn’t do my homework. I dropped out of college after four years and a bunch of dropped classes. And yet I’m so good at engineering I’ve never had any trouble finding a job, and I’ve always had a roof over my head. I watch people work so hard and still struggle. And it’s upsetting. I think everyone should have it as easy as I have, or easier. There is so much wealth in this world. But it doesn’t go to the hard workers. It goes to the lucky. Amongst the lucky there will be some perception of fairness and equity, but that is only because they can’t see the people far above and below them.
- cato_the_elder 4y agoIs Lamarckism making a comeback?
- guerrilla 4y agoand Freud.
- specialist 4y agoIndeed. I had long dismissed epigenetics because I had been taught that Lamarckism was disproven. So now I'm playing catchup, reading about methylation and whatnot. The problem with facts is that they keep changing. PS- My noob metaphor for methyl groups: Like feature flags for DNA transcription.
- dudeinjapan 4y agoI'd like to know if anyone's parents, or grandparents, or great-grandparents (think WWII) are actually free of trauma? How do they find a control here for trauma-free people?
- manmal 4y agoTrauma is not automatic even for people put in very bad situations, afaik. Perception and expectations are very important here. For example: A person is fired from their job. For someone who wanted to quit anyway, that could be a rather small annoyance, perhaps a blow to the ego. But for someone who struggled very hard to hold down even that one job, this could be catastrophic, and be perceived as life threatening. In the case of really really bad situations (like being kidnapped), just not being (or not feeling as) the only victim can make a big difference already. People also made very different experiences during the war. Some lived in remote areas and didn’t ever hear air raid sirens or anything. Others lived in constant fear because their parents were taken away in the middle of the night (try ever sleeping well again).
- dudeinjapan 4y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jVhlJNJopOQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jVhlJNJopOQ
- cm2187 4y agoAnd also it is impossible to separate the genetic part from the nurture part for humans. People who were traumatised might be genetically pre-disposed to be traumatised and will pass it on to their children. Alternatively, you can bet that the kids will be reminded all their childhood of their parents trauma, or at the very least may grow up in an abnormal environment because of their parents trauma. Plus trauma is probably not a linear scale. If you live a quiet life, it maybe that a short scary event might traumatise you, but that if you go through the horrors of war for years you may develop a tolerance. So I am skeptical of any study that claims that it works one way or another. Experiences on mice are more interesting I think.
- TazeTSchnitzel 4y ago
- factorialsystem 4y agoI have autism and adhd and I am trans and queer and plural and in the last few years I have been able to trace nearly everything that I struggle with to themes that have been passed on throughout my family for generations. The cycle continues until someone breaks the cycle. I see how autism runs in my family. I see how my mother's early life trauma during and around childbirth directly contributed to my general sense of "life isn't safe". For a long time I just kinda floated through life feeling vaguely existentially anxious. Learning about the struggles of my parents and extended family has helped me to release resentment, since I can see exactly why everything happened, how everyone was doing their best, and yet things happened anyway. I have the best and worst traits of my parents, and increasingly it feels like the only thing to do is to thank my parents for the good they did for me and forgive the bad that they did to me without even realizing that they were doing bad to me. All beings are the heirs of their own karma, but heck parenting is HARD yo. Happy fathers day to all the fathers who do their best even if it doesn't always go exactly the way it was planned.
- brobinson 4y agoSorry, "plural"? I don't know what this means, and I feel like I am probably not the only one.
- jthrowsitaway 4y agoSame. Multiple personalities?
- hilyen 4y agowait till you hear about generational trauma. do we have trauma from the entire history of our ancestors? :|
- tomhoward 4y agoIn my experience, yes, in the sense that by acting as if it’s true and undertaking practices to address it, health and life gets much better.
- guerrilla 4y agoDoes nobody else here question this concept of trauma? This really seems like an obvious fad right now.
- secondcoming 4y agoTrauma, trauma, trauma. People collect them as though they were Pokémon. No doubt someone will claim this comment caused them trauma.
- Hoasi 4y agoMany people who sure as hell never experienced actual trauma are touting trauma everywhere. But then again, mental damage is intangible, right? Since you can't experience other people's distress, your worst experience is always at the top of the scale on an individual level. You can use empathy and reason to understand other people's struggles, but your personal experience is unique in scale.
- TazeTSchnitzel 4y ago“actual trauma” is needlessly dismissive. It doesn't have to be very dramatic to affect someone. Everyone has traumas.
- guerrilla 4y agoI don't think this is a useful way of thinking. If we applied the same thing to physical medicine then every impact of an air molecule with your skin would be a "trauma" which is clearly absurd. There needs to be very clear boundaries for these things or else they become completely meaningless. It's meaning comes from it's restricted use, which seems to me have become completely unrestricted as of late.
- TazeTSchnitzel 4y agoThis argument doesn't make sense to me. It's not like any bad thing that happens to someone is traumatic to them. Consider that seemingly insignificant things can be very traumatic, and likewise major things (e.g. death) might not be traumatic at all.
- Terry_Roll 4y agoEuropeans are still dealing with the fallout of WW1 and WW2.
- Terry_Roll 4y agoIn the UK, the population is still suffering the effects of the Victorian culture and the British Empire.
- tpoacher 4y ago"The Sins of the Fathers" as our ancestors would say.
- thejackgoode 4y agoThe headline is somewhat disappointing, based on it I expected some finding for children who were not already a fetus at the time of traumatic event.
- AltruisticGapHN 4y agoAlso relevant https://www.theguardian.com/science/2015/aug/21/study-of-holocaust-survivors-finds-trauma-passed-on-to-childrens-genes https://www.theguardian.com/science/2015/aug/21/study-of-hol... Sadly extremely obvious for me. Trauma is generational, it's within families; communities, countries, and eventually through all of humanity. And likewise it is addressed at those many levels.
- markdown 4y ago> How Parents’ Trauma Leaves Biological Traces in Children > Adverse experiences can change future generations through epigenetic pathways > By Rachel Yehuda > July 1, 2022 An article from the future.
- corrral 4y agoPieces that are published both online and on paper often bear the date the print version will go out, even if they are posted online somewhat earlier.
- SnowHill9902 4y agoThis is “surprising” only under the individualistic reductionist approach of modern science. Offspring are a biological extension of their ancestors and it’s only natural that they inherit some of their epigenetic expressions.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- MollyRealized 4y agoI find this fascinating and in some ways consoling. I know for a fact that at least one of my parents had truly severe trauma when growing up; the other may have had trauma as well.