3 ms·
> People have forgotten what unregulated markets are like. They assume a century of pretty good securities regulation, and the orderly markets and general prosp
by oblio 4y ago
> People have forgotten what unregulated markets are like. They assume a century of pretty good securities regulation, and the orderly markets and general prosperity that flowed from that, are normal — because it’s all they’ve ever known.
> But it’s not normal. It’s a lot of work to regulate a marketplace so that it’s free enough to work and innovate but not collapse, and the crooks are kept at least manageable.
> Crypto is almost entirely unregulated.
Daily reminder that the population at large has enough idiots (hard to quantify, maybe 20%?) and crooks (also maybe 20%?) that the rest of us folks in the middle need to accept regulation because otherwise all the idiots would starve and probably kill us all in desperation while the crooks would destroy everything in their path (look at Putin).
- api 4y agoOne takeaway I've gotten from cryptocurrency is the sense that money "wants" to misbehave. It "wants" to scam, pump and dump, make bubbles, and especially to gamble. It's incredibly difficult to get money to do things that are constructive. Of course money doesn't "want" anything. That's a metaphor. The real driver is human cognitive biases and the dopamine loop. Gambling and scams provide a Skinner box type environment that plugs right into our closed dopamine loop systems. Productive investments often do not. They take too long to mature, are too risky (individually but not necessarily in aggregate), and are too hard. The path of least resistance for economic activity is something like those casino-like loot box games but with markets and pseudo-investments. Without heavy regulation money will just gamble and scam and gamble and scam. The only way to get it to do anything productive is to systematically block off the other avenues, which is an endless game of whack a mole against both the natural organic tendencies of human beings and the large number of hustlers and sociopaths who love to take advantage of them. As the USA has demonstrated, this does not require a fully planned economy with a total loss of freedom. It just requires that there be barriers in place to prevent people from advertising casino chips and pyramid schemes as investments, and requiring that such things be gated at the very least by disclaimers that explain what they actually are. The term investment should be reserved for actual investments. This is actually protecting people from fraud, which is a legitimate function of government in a free society. Our execution of it has of course been flawed and sloppy, but that's real political systems for you. It's better than nothing. Absolute anarchy is not freedom. It's the rule of the nearest thug with the biggest stick... or the best grift in the case of markets. The "big stick" is a deceptive pitch that hooks your dopamine system and drains you.
- oblio 4y agoMonica from Friends was right. Games are fun because of rules. If I can headbutt you during a game of table tennis, table tennis will never be fun for you. Same principle for markets.
- alangibson 4y agoThere's a growing body of work that sees markets as state projects. The same way a game is defined by it's rules, markets are defined by the rules governing them. Without that, you basically have no market. Just crooks separating people from their resources.