8 ms·
Mitochondria and the origin of eukaryotes
- alangibson 4y ago> For billions of years after the origin of life, the only living things on Earth were tiny, primitive cells resembling today’s bacteria I've often used this "fact" as an argument against complex extraterrestrial life. Glad to see it might be wrong after all.
- tomrod 4y agoSingle-celled life is complex. It has the same length of evolutionary time as multicellular life. We know very little about modes of sentience with N=1. Perhaps life is generally mutualistic.
- majkinetor 4y agoThis is Nick Lane's argument - that complex cell happend only once on Earth (no convergent evolution) via this symbiotic accident and hence it's highly improbable if not almost impossible. As usual, people always seem to foreget that in this universe, what happened once, happens all the time and we are not special.
- alangibson 4y agoWe're all just speculating given that were stuck at sample size = 1 until we develop near light speed travel. I get the convergent evolution point, but so far the story is that 1) life arose very quickly 2) then proceeded to do very little for billions of years. If that's true, then it's bad news for the possibility of complex life being common.
- majkinetor 4y agoIt only means that complex life is less frequent then single cell life, not that it is uncommon.
- Qem 4y ago> 1) life arose very quickly 2) then proceeded to do very little for billions of years. This is understating the feats of unicelular life. Those tiny organisms essentially terraformed the whole planet in those billions of years, oxidizing nearly all the iron close to earth surface, burying most carbon and then pumping so much oxygen in the atmosphere that at a point it comprised 30% of Earth gaseous envelope by weight. I wouldn't call that very little. To come close we'll need at least to terraform Mars or Venus, to match the feats of our microbial forebears.
- chestervonwinch 4y agoI think the parent comment meant doing very little from an evolutionary perspective.
- ssl232 4y agoNick Lane's book The Vital Question is a masterpiece. I reckon he's figured out the origin of life there. I hope he gets on some podcast like Lex Fridman to talk about it all, because his ideas are just waiting to explode into the public imagination.
- marcosdumay 4y ago> that complex cell happend only once on Earth Well, it's quite possible that once it happens, it voids any chance of it happening again just because life filling that niche already exists. If so, it only happens once, and this says absolutely nothing about the odds of that first occurrence. > what happened once, happens all the time That's a fallacy people do all the time here when talking about exobiology. It's basically states that all small numbers and all big numbers are alike, and that all small numbers are like the inverse of all big numbers.
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoMost other features evolved independently several (or even many) times so this is not a good argument. It’s not as if once there was a eukaryote it instantly spread across the whole planet, taking up every ecological niche. Even today eukaryotes don’t exist in certain environments.
- maneesh 4y agoWhile no single eukaryote did what you said, eukaryotes as a whole did, to some extent, during the Cambrian Explosion
- prox 4y agoAnd that is if there is only one universe, which might not be so special as well.
- simonh 4y agoIt’s not wrong, at least I don’t think this article is arguing that multi cellular life evolved any earlier than we thought. Just that the mechanisms were different than we expected.
- griffzhowl 4y agoNothing in the article contradicts that 'fact'. The question is only whether the development of eukaryotes involved other significant steps in addition to the mitochondrial endosymbiotic event, or whether the latter event was all that really mattered. In both cases, subsequent development of eukaryotes and hence multicellularity depended on the seemingly very rare endosymbiotic event.
- photochemsyn 4y agoThe rise of free atmospheric oxygen and oceanic dissolved oxygen levels were almost certainly a requirement for the development of complex multicellular life. Using oxygen as the electron acceptor in respiration means far more energy can be extracted from reduced fuel molecules (sugars, fats, amino acids, methane, hydrocarbons, ammonia, etc.) than by using species like oxidized sulfur and iron, CO2, or nitrate (NO3) for that role. This is really where the mitochondria come into play, as they allowed their host to utilize oxygen for this purpose. This can be seen by looking at modern eukaryotes that have reverted back to an anaerobic lifestyle: > "In lineages of eukaryotes adapted to low oxygen conditions, mitochondria have been drastically reduced, functionally altered and, in one case, completely lost." "The Origin and Diversification of Mitochondria (2017)" https://www.cell.com/current-biology/pdf/S0960-9822(17)31179-X.pdf https://www.cell.com/current-biology/pdf/S0960-9822(17)31179... Hence, looking for the signature of free oxygen in the atmosphere of exoplanets orbiting distant stars is considered to be a fairly good indicator of the possibility of complex multicellular life of some sort, and at least of an active photosynthetic microbial ecosystem. (Incidentally, the historical divisions withing academic university departments led to evolutionary biology generally ignoring the importance of early Earth's geochemistry in the evolution of life, as they saw evolution as a kind of cellular/organismal process divorced from the physical surroundings - the latter being the province of the geology department. The renewed interest in exobiology and origin-of-life research has tended to bridge this gap.)
- alangibson 4y agoThe way I read that is that developing complex life is even more contingent than 'just wait long enough'. Given what we know for sure, you need rather narrow concentrations of specific gasses at least.
- Ericson2314 4y agoTo your last parenthetical, organicism a la Hegel mends the blind spots once again!
- csr86 4y agoHow the children inherited the swallowed organism?
- majkinetor 4y agoBacterial division would get some mitos on either side of the dividing cell. Mitos then proliferate on its own.
- frostburg 4y agoPresumably like we do - (I'm heavily simplifying the complex regulation involved) the mitochondria have their own DNA which gets duplicated when the cell prepares to undergo mitosis, then the two new cells split the results.
- anton96 4y agoDoes that implies that mitochondria also had to evolve at some point to detect duplication of their host cell so they duplicate at the same time?
- reubenswartz 4y agoThere are lots of mitochondria in a cell (almost always, ignore red blood cells, for example), and the mitochondria have their own mechanisms for detecting when they need to divide (exercise and the resulting stress being one of them, which is why working out makes you more fit). Also note that the DNA for most of the mitochondrial proteins is in the host cell's nucleus-- the mitochondrial DNA is stripped down to coding for just a few essential proteins.
- bergenty 4y agoI know the cytoplasm between cells is split on division and corresponding the mitochondria are roughly as well. They could technically have different times of reproduction than the overall cell and it would still work. I’m not certain what actually happens to the mitochondria during cell division though.
- wheelerof4te 4y agoA neat fairy-tale but, with all due respect, scientist don't know anything that happened a billion+ years ago. This is a little more than a tabloid article.
- ncmncm 4y agoIf they find cells lacking some organelle, it will be hard to say whether it was never acquired, or was later abandoned. One clue would be leftover genes from when it was there. Eukaryotes often find it hard to prune out excess DNA, vs. just turning it off.
- edgyquant 4y agoDNA doesn’t help as much as you think with single celled organisms thanks to HGT. Bacteria, at least, share DNA and thus we can’t use it to determine a linear evolutionary sequence.
- ncmncm 4y agoEukaryotes don't do so much of that.
- jjtheblunt 4y agoHGT?
- reubenswartz 4y agoHorizontal gene transfer. Because biology isn’t complicated enough. :)
- jjtheblunt 4y ago:) [ i should have thought of that. thank you. ]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 323 4y ago> If they find cells lacking some organelle A most famous example is red blood cells, which are emptied of most organelles to make space for hemoglobin.
- 4y ago
- CRUDite 4y agoIf we assume single celled life is common, and exists in either all star systems, or in all systems without a hot Jupiter close to the star; then given the length of time involved here before eukaryotes, can we estimate how many planets in the galaxy have eukaryotes? Or how long it will be before some do? Presumably increasing the length of time increases the probability of occurrence as would increasing the number of stars involved. Though how can we know if the event was statistically likely after that amount of time or whether we are deviations from the centre of the distribution (other than observing the quiet galaxy). Surely we can have a rough idea now of where we stand
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> can we estimate how many planets in the galaxy have eukaryotes? Not yet. In the history of life on Earth, this has happened once. Knowing what we know about cellular biology, it’s stupidly unlikely. Beyond our present theories’ ability to quantify. By the way, I think this is one of—if not the—great filters. It’s unlikely to happen, to not promptly get smote by its primordial planet’s tantrums and to get it so right it perpetuates for billions of years.
- echelon 4y ago> Not yet. In the history of life on Earth, this has happened once. 1) That we know about. 2) Not unlike startups vs. established business, any newly emerging "eukaryotes" have to out-compete the already-evolved incumbents, which are already quite good at harnessing energy. You're much more likely to find success in business than in an entirely new evolutionary branch, though I doubt biological "gray goo" is outright impossible [1]. [1] Reverse chirality autotrophs sound like a scary sci-fi novel plot https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28038505 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28038505
- ajuc 4y agoAdditionally the environment changed significantly since then (for one example oxygen which was highly toxic to most forms of life that existed back then is now over 20% of atmosphere). > Reverse chirality autotrophs sound like a scary sci-fi novel plot Very ice-9-like.
- pmags 4y agoFor those interested but new to role of endosymbiosis in evolution, it's useful to keep in mind that there's strong evidence of an endosymbiotic origin of chloroplasts, another major event in the history of life. Here's a recent review article that highlights some of the key evidence and outstanding questions: Sibbald SJ, Archibald JM. Genomic Insights into Plastid Evolution. Genome Biol Evol. 2020 Jul 1;12(7):978-990. doi: 10.1093/gbe/evaa096. PMID: 32402068; PMCID: PMC7348690.
- Ericson2314 4y agoIsn't that long established, as the article says? The article, and yours too I would assume, mentions https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paulinella https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paulinella which is really cool for being a second known primary symbiosis. Greatest rerun of all time!
- Linda703 4y ago[dead]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Koshkin 4y agoIf you are curious about these things, do yourself a favor and dive into Alberts et al. Molecular Biology of the Cell. I can't recommend it enough.
- feet 4y agoVery solid text book +1
- wrycoder 4y agoAlberts et al. Essential Cell Biology is a bit less advanced, but I'm finding it very complete, just not quite so exhaustive (pun intended). It's still 700 pages, so you'll get your money's worth (if you buy a used copy).
- sn9 4y agoYeah Essential's more aimed for underclassman (e.g., sophomores) whereas the other text is for upperclassman (i.e., juniors and seniors) and graduate students. It's probably more useful for laymen. Those who find themselves wanting more can always go to the larger, more comprehensive text later.
- anuvrat1 4y agoHow simple are Prokaryotic Cells really? Like "simple" enough that we understand all the intricate workings of it, or "simple" enough to be made from scratch?
- david_l_lin 4y agoHonestly, neither. Biology is complex and messy, and often not at all intuitive.
- Daniel_sk 4y agoImagine giving a scientist in 1900 a modern CPU. He may be able to disassemble and study it, but it’s impossible to make it from scratch because it takes a chain of steps that lead to complicated modern factories that then produce the chip. It’s hard to skip those steps. We can swap DNA in living cells and produce modified cells, but we lack the tools to create such complicated and microscopic structures in a pure synthetic way.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lock-the-spock 4y agoAn accessible and incredibly insightful read 100% on this topic is "Power, Sex, Suicide: Mitochondria and the Meaning of Life"- despite the flashy title a thorough scientific read and analysis, working through various possible arguments and teaching fundamentals along the way. My favourite book I read in the past five years or so https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power,_Sex,_Suicide https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power,_Sex,_Suicide
- aesch 4y agoI haven't read that one but after reading The Vital Question I will recommend anything with Nick Lane's name on it. There are very few people who have thought about the origin of life as deeply as he has.
- code_biologist 4y agoRead it as soon as you have the time. It is every bit the equal of The Vital Question.
- BrainsPachanga 4y agoDoes this book address how potentially the first cell ever came to exist? If not, do you have any suggestions?
- aesch 4y agoThe Vital Question discusses Nick Lane's hypothesis on how the first cell came to exist in Part II: The origin of life. Energy at life's origin ; The emergence of cells
- soramimo 4y agoThanks for sharing, just ordered.
- flybrand 4y agoYes, and read all of his books! Start w anything that seems interesting. His probabilistic approach to life sciences is wonderful and invigorating.
- sonicggg 4y agoEvolution did a terrible job there. So many diseases linked to mitochondrial dysfunction nowadays. We have this amazingly complex machinery, and a single point of failure, no redundancy whatsoever.
- code_biologist 4y agoEvolution did a great job? I highly recommend reading Nick Lane's "Power, Sex, Suicide". Mitochondrial function is a complicated question. It's amazing nature makes it work at all. Two aspects he discusses: 1) Mitochondrial selection is multilayered and aggressive. Mitochondrial population selection goes on during formation of egg cells [1]. Mitonuclear compatibility is heavily selected for during ontogeny [2]. Many miscarriages are are related to mitochondrial dysfunction. Once someone is born they've already passed a high selective bar for mitochondrial health. 2) There is a tradeoff between mitochondrial selectivity and fertility. Birds have much greater energetic requirements than mammals (flying is hard) and therefore have much greater mitochondrial selectivity. This means fewer offspring though. Pigeons and rats have similar size and metabolic rates, but a pair of rats can have 80+ offspring in a year while a pair of pigeons can only manage under 20. [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-019-1213-4 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-019-1213-4 [2] https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1910141117 https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1910141117
- Ir0nMan 4y agoMitochondria: more than just the powerhouse of the cell.
- Sniffnoy 4y agoSo does anyone know how Lokiarchaeota fit into this? I remember reading that Lokiarchaeota were evidence against the mitochondrion-first hypothesis, but I have no idea how that claim has held up over time.
- mgraczyk 4y agoSurprised the article doesn't mention Viral Eukaryogenesis, the hypothesis that the nucleus of Eukaryotes evolved from a virus. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viral_eukaryogenesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viral_eukaryogenesis My understanding is that there is much less evidence for this, but it seems like the question of whether or not there were multiple gradual endosymbiotic events in eukaryotic evolution would definitely depend in some way on viruses.
- andrewflnr 4y agoFor some reason people fixate on the mitochondrion in the context of the origin of eukaryotes, to the near total exclusion of the nucleus that actually defines the eukaryotes. I don't understand why this is. I can only cynically guess that it's a form of streetlight fallacy: we have a pretty good idea where mitochondria came from, so let's focus on that (and conveniently forget about the nucleus, golgi body, endoplasmic reticulum, ...).