8 ms·
SpaceX firings likely violate US labor law, experts say
- jmfayard 4y agoThose experts don't understand the absolute free speech principles that Elon Musk cherishes
- kieselguhr_kid 4y agoFree speech unless you criticize SpaceX?
- aj7 4y agoFor himself. Not absolute, obviously.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ugiox 4y agoAnd I thought this was about static test firings of their rocket engines…
- fendy3002 4y agoSometimes I think English language is not that great EDIT: though I don't know if there's better alternative
- seibelj 4y agoYou can find some expert to say anything. I have literally no idea whether it was legal or not. But finding an expert to quote for your narrative is not exactly breaking news.
- therouwboat 4y agoIf you know nothing about the subject, why would you think this law professor is lying?
- kieselguhr_kid 4y agoIANAL but I know enough about the labor process to know the expert is probably correct.
- walkhour 4y ago[flagged]
- immmmmm 4y agoFighting climate change with luxury cars or rockets?
- Elinvynia 4y agoA person can do both good and bad things, and if you believe in the idea of free speech, both should be allowed to be pointed out.
- engineer_22 4y agoOP is pointing out that news media is only pointing out the bad things.
- threeseed 4y agoThe news media points out things that are happening now. Musk combating climate change is not new.
- johannes1234321 4y ago> When was the last time we saw a post in HN talking about how Elon Musk is helping combat climate change? Is he? - Sure, Tesla pushed the EV market forward but EVs aren't really a solution. We need efficient transport with less infrastructure than roads, but in Musks view public transport is bad as there "might be a killer" next to you. SolarCity also lost relevance in the space since integration with Tesla. With SpaceX his goal also doesn't seem to be to enable scientific advance in researching climate from space or building technologies which can help here but to abandon the planet and building a colony on Mars, where he and his friends can build a new world, just for them.
- kieselguhr_kid 4y agoThe impact Tesla has on climate change is so small as to be complete negligible. Electric cars are entirely insufficient, and we need to move past this rhetoric to actually get anything done.
- sn0w_crash 4y agoThe Verge has lost a lot of credibility. Since musk announced he was buying Twitter it has basically become a musk hit-piece firehose. A few People got fired. This is not news.
- mojzu 4y agoWhat specifically have the verge reported on to make them lose credibility in your eyes? Personally I've got a bit tired of how often he comes up, but it's perfectly understandable considering he's a very public personality with a large following who leads some large tech companies and says/does some very divisive and controversial things And one of Musks companies firing people for criticising him, when he's trying to buy Twitter claiming to want to change its policies because it isn't sufficiently pro-free-speech seems newsworthy to me
- celdon25 4y ago> What specifically have the verge reported on to make them lose credibility in your eyes? This article, for one. It looks like they shopped around to find people with law degrees and opinions, even though those opinions may not be much on their own. But when put together in a montage of quotes, you can get a real spin effect. You don't notice it? Motive (left-wing media) Means (spin doctor on call) Opportunity (Elon is public enemy number one with Trump all but out of the picture) But let's ignore the fact that at least some of the employees that got fired were sending emails to most or all of the employees, more than once, during company time with company equipment, to solicit assistance with the letter. I'm sure there's more to the story that will be revealed, and it's certainly too early to be declaring that someone has a case, so putting these misleading headlines out (even if ambiguously worded) is a big red flag.
- arolihas 4y agoWhich of these lawyers is a spin doctor?
- staticautomatic 4y agoShopping around for informed opinions is normal and should be expected. That said, I’ve been a legal commentator and the pressure to be aggressively sound-bitey is real. However, it’s often self-imposed by the expert and not always the reporter’s doing. I remember chatting with a Reuters reporter about the Uber/Lewandowski case and it was pretty clear that if I didn’t say something sexier, the article wouldn’t run. Yes, she was presumably under some pressure to find some sizzle, but I was also asking myself how badly I wanted to be quoted.
- kieselguhr_kid 4y agoThis sounds like firing people for concerted action, which is one of two illegal reasons for termination in the US (the other being discrimination). I suspect the NLRB will reward them with an offer to get their jobs back or back wages.
- Throwawayaerlei 4y agoSince absolutely nothing could go wrong with disgruntled employees making and launching rockets it has better be back wages, or something that limits the actual, physical damage they could cause. "Rocket science" has a reputation because it is not a forgiving domain.
- kieselguhr_kid 4y agoIt's usually back wages, but that's up to the fired party.
- johncearls 4y agoDepends on the roles of the people who were fired. > the NLRA is restricted to nonsupervisory employees, said Kate Bischoff, And whether the statements themselves qualify. According to WSJ , https://www.wsj.com/articles/spacex-fires-employees-involved-in-letter-critical-of-musk-company-11655471021 https://www.wsj.com/articles/spacex-fires-employees-involved....
- kieselguhr_kid 4y agoAnti-harrassment campaigns have historically been qualified statements. You're correct that they have to be nonsupervisory workers.
- lelandfe 4y ago> an action has to be concerted (certainly the case here) From the article, quoting a law professor. I'd never heard the term "concerted action," so I looked up the relevant text of the National Labor Relations Act. It says that employees have the right to engage in concerted actions "for the purpose of collective bargaining or other mutual aid or protection..."[0] I am not familiar with this law; could someone explain why employees complaining in a circulated letter falls into this category? I'm (pleasantly!) surprised this was a legally protected action. [0] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/29/157 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/29/157
- meatsauce 4y agoYou can always find a lawyer who will lie for you.
- kieselguhr_kid 4y agoYeah, but this lawyer is almost certainly right. Firing people for taking concerted action is illegal in the US. Why chime in at all if you don't understand the subject?
- upsidesinclude 4y ago'The Verge' says it all. I've never heard of a company that let's you trash talk the CEO with no repercussions and as it goes, their firing was predicated on other employees discomfort with their activism. Make your money somewhere else if you have a problem with the boss. NASA will give you a fair shake I'm sure.
- tonfreed 4y agoThey might finally get SLS working
- stmfreak 4y agoThe woke mind virus seeks to protect itself. I don’t see how bitching about your boss’s tweets constitutes discussing working conditions.