7 ms·
I also stand up for Stallman. Yes, people think he is a weird guy. But we are all weird, and he's weird and has changed the world for the better. I don't see
by jrockway 15y ago
I also stand up for Stallman. Yes, people think he is a weird guy. But we are all weird, and he's weird and has changed the world for the better. I don't see what there is to hate.
People worry that he might not be the best interface between Free Software and the rest of the world (because it's hard to relate to him), but who cares? If you can do a better job, do it. The only thing that's bad for the Free Software movement is worrying about who the leader is. It's you. Now get back to work and make us some awesome software.
- armandososa 15y agoWhy do people from the U.S. use the word "hate" so lightly?
- jrockway 15y agoWhat makes you think I'm from the US?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- buro9 15y agoYour github? https://github.com/jrockway/ https://github.com/jrockway/ says you're in Chicago, IL Analysis of your comments suggests non-European use of English. "Strong male" whereas European English is usually classified as "Weak male". And on your Google Places page you list only Chicago as places that you've lived. https://plus.google.com/u/1/105337359554006968707/about https://plus.google.com/u/1/105337359554006968707/about Unless you're trying really hard to consistently give a false impression, I'd bet you were just playing devil's advocate there as you do indeed appear to be from the US. Oh, and your domain is .us... but we all know that's a weak indicator.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- chollida1 15y agoWell to begin with, different words have different connotations and meanings in different languages. In Canada we might say arse when we don't want to swear. My english friends tell me that arse is actually a pretty bad swear word over in there. From my experiences, hate doesn't have a very strong meaning. My wife might say she hates brussel sprouts and I wouldn't think anything of it. That's just a normal expression.
- hugh3 15y agoCompared to which variety of English? I'm pretty familiar with British, American and Australian English, and I don't think that "hate" is a particularly strong word in any of 'em. Depending on context, of course. A far stronger degree of dislike is conveyed by "I hate you" than "I hate lima beans".
- nailer 15y agoIn the US people have recently began using the the term 'hate' as a synonym for 'dislike', confusing not enjoying something (which may involve little regard at all) with caring about it greatly albeit in a negative way.
- hugh3 15y agoThat's neither particularly recent nor particularly US-specific.
- function_seven 15y ago"dislike" has never been a synonym for "apathetic toward." Rather, it is generally used as a polite way of conveying "hate".
- FreakLegion 15y agoThere's no confusion. The two senses of the word don't overlap; they can be used unambiguously in their own contexts. Unless you think people are also "confusing" things when they say "I like my coffee sweet" and "What a sweet little girl"--? Or, I don't know, the ringing of a bell and the ring on your finger? Or a flat object, a flat note, and a flat for rent? This is how language works. Not just English, not just a language. All language. Remember Wittgenstein: "Let the use of words teach you their meaning" (PI 220).
- gbog 15y agoI'd say it's just the common amplification style. Some other prefer understatements.
- autarch 15y agoI don't think Stallman's a very effective activist in some ways. Stallman and the FSF could benefit from looking at the history of social justice movements to see what made them effective. Of course that's no reason to treat him with disrespect.
- lambda 15y agoHmm. There are a few aspects of the FSF's strategies that I have never quite been a fan of, but I must say that Stallman has, in general, been much more effective at promoting free software than almost anyone else I can think of. Look at the GNU project, at Emacs, at GCC, look at how widespread the GPL is. Look at how many people know and care about what free software is, and what qualifies as free software (and despite the different name and different reasons given, the term "open source" is seen as meaning pretty much the same thing). That seems pretty effective to me. What do you think he could do that would make him more effective? Compromise his position, say that maybe, sometimes, it might be OK to recommend non-free software? What value would he be providing then? While using a fully free software stack may not be for everyone today, the fact that he has pushed hard enough that it is possible is inspiring, and created benefits for people beyond just those who use entirely free software.
- omouse 15y agoHe's not an activist; that's what makes him effective. The history of "social justice" movements is full of examples where some people were in favour of revolution as opposed to mere reform. There are a lot of people that want to live in a world where free software can be used and sold alongside proprietary software; Stallman and other revolutionaries envision a world where proprietary software is seen as a horrible social evil that the only common sense choice is to write free software. However, he doesn't want to force you to that; he's simply talking about and discussing his alternative and hoping that you realize that it's better than the current situation. Stallman doesn't need to waste his breath if there are many others who want to talk about reformist approaches.
- doki_pen 15y agoAnyone can step in and do what they want with the "movement". I don't think RMS has a monopoly on speaking about free software and would probably welcome anyone who wanted to be an activist. But even if he didn't, it matters little. If you can do a better job then step in and do it.