4 ms·
I've read that this is the EU's approach, altho I don't know how it works out in practice.
by euroderf 4y ago
I've read that this is the EU's approach, altho I don't know how it works out in practice.
- gruez 4y agoThe downside is that novel technologies (eg. GMOs) take forever to get approved.
- pwdisswordfish9 4y agoHow is that a bad thing?
- pragmatic 4y agoPeople starving to death in the mean time, perhaps?
- suture 4y agoAs a result of GMOs the carrying capacity of the world increased. Isn’t it the case that the population tends toward the carrying capacity? If so then the delay of GMOs would only mean that the world’s population today would be lower and not that the amount of overall starvation would be higher. We still have episodes of starvation in the world even with GMOs.
- gruez 4y ago>As a result of GMOs the carrying capacity of the world increased. Isn’t it the case that the population tends toward the carrying capacity? This model assumes that human population will grow forever. Carrying capacity is one constraint on total population, but it's not the only constraint. Nowadays population growth is slowing down because demographic factors (ie. falling fertility), not because we've reached the earth's carrying capacity and famines are killing people off.
- suture 4y agoSure, those factors come into play and are dominant. It seems to me that one can’t assume there would have been more starvation had GMOs not been invented. And the factors you mentioned haven’t yet had an effect in India and Africa. The population of there has greatly increased alongside the rise of GMO. I’m not saying GMOs are the cause of sad increase but I am suggesting that the population in India and Africa might have been lower today without GMOs without being the result of starvation.
- jpgvm 4y agoPeople in the EU aren't starving to death though. Appropriate laws for appropriate circumstances. Given high standard of living in EU they can afford to take the long road with many improvements to food security favoring safety over reduced cost or expediency.
- euroderf 4y agoThe problem is not a shortage of food. The problem is its distribution. Like many things.
- manuelabeledo 4y agoWhich makes sense. New technologies should be approached using a precautionary principle.
- gruez 4y ago>New technologies should be approached using a precautionary principle. But what happens in reality is: When we apply the precautionary principle, it's because technology is dangerous and The Responsible Thing to Do is to be careful. When our opponents apply the precautionary principle, they're luddites who hate change and just want an excuse to drag their feet. Here are some examples to illustrate that effect * nuclear power * vaccines * self-driving cars/AI * gmo
- GekkePrutser 4y agoNuclear power was plenty dangerous in its first iterations and there was in fact too little precaution. Chernobyl and three mile Island really shouldn't have happened. Fukushima was much later in the game but was also bad design. I think the tech is safer now but the nuclear industry really has itself to blame. It's no wonder anti-nuclear sentiments increased after each disaster. With the other ones I agree more.
- adhesive_wombat 4y ago> Chernobyl and three mile Island really shouldn't have happened. Fukushima was much later in the game but was also bad design. Fukushima was an older reactor then Chernobyl, by 6 years (commissioned 1971 vs 1977). Very old nuclear reactors are common partly because it's been politically untenable to build new ones, even if the new ones are safer.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoOk I did not know that, but I thought Chernobyl was already an old design when it was commissioned?