4 ms·
Can anyone give a summary? This is ridiculously verbose.
by IshKebab 4y ago
Can anyone give a summary? This is ridiculously verbose.
- 542458 4y agoThe UK has eliminated cookie pop up requirements. However, they have introduced other legislation that requires websites to establish the ages of all visitors via checking legal ID so that adult content can be restricted. This is expected to be done by integrating with (paid) third-party APIs that will keep track of users’ legal identity across websites. This will be both privacy-invasive for users and expensive for website operators. The UK has also axed many of the EU-based data protections that users have.
- buttscicles 4y agoWanted to add that according to the article, these checks will be required for all content, not just adult content.
- ectopod 4y agoAll user-generated content specifically. If you host non-adult content and there's no way for randos to upload it you don't need to verify.
- matt321 4y agoThat is not true. Either A) You know for a fact all content is safe for underaged, or B) You verify. What is safe for underaged is not defined and can change on a whim. Therefor, any sane person running a website that is not "explicitly for underageds" will verify and eject said underageds. Especially since the one in charge (hired by the company) can be personally liable for any "harm" comming to the underaged.
- jcranberry 4y agoIs this website reliable?
- __alexs 4y agoThis article is discussing draft legislation that hasn't been voted on yet. These changes haven't come into effect and IMO probably won't.
- zuminator 4y agoAnd if you don't have legal ID, the website will need to access your Webcam and measure the size of your head(!) to determine your age.
- jeroenhd 4y agoPopups were never required in the first place, what was required was to get consent before tracking users. Websites that seem they need to track users immediately and across their entire web space implemented popups because it's the only way to get consent before showing content, but that's the website's choice, not a consequence of the law.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- fanf2 4y agoThe postscript has a reasonable summary: « in their professional experience, age verification is only ever invoked in discussions around what we might call explicit adult content: pornography, alcohol, tobacco, and firearms. So that’s what they assume this discussion is about, here, in the UK. They don’t realise, until I explain it to them, that the UK legislative discussion is not just about preventing children from accessing those four kinds of content. It’s about mandating age verification for anything and everything, for every user, of every age, in front of access to all topics, all subjects, all sites, all service providers, all opinions, and all content. The whole public open web. Everything. »
- nbevans 4y agoIndeed this is overly editorialised and the author very much assumes the reader is of the same opinion of them from the outset. The author seems to believe that web browsers will just ignore UK legislation and not bother to implement the necessary changes.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tjbiddle 4y ago
- Arkanum 4y ago*she Although i can't find any clear statement of pronouns [1] https://webdevlaw.uk/about/ https://webdevlaw.uk/about/ [2] https://twitter.com/WebDevLaw https://twitter.com/WebDevLaw
- nbevans 4y agoThank you!
- iostream24 4y agoIt has not been editorialized at all, let alone overly editorialized. The author outlines the consequences of a very Ill-thought-out law that will harm the worldwide web, not protect users, and damage what is left of the UKs standing in the world. Telling the truth is never “overly” doing anything. Sometimes, you must call a spade “a spade” Do you have some information to contribute to the discussion or are you suggesting that the author should lie instead?
- nbevans 4y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- mmarq 4y agoThe UK legislators want to replace GDPR with a watered down version that only applies to the UK. Their claim is that this will allow businesses to save money on compliance. (Me: Companies in Brazil, Australia and the US comply with GDPR, so realistically British companies will have to abide to both regulations and so costs can only increase) Furthermore the British government is planning to force all websites to verify their visitors’ age (allegedly using government approved providers), which is orders of magnitudes more onerous than GDPR (me: which is actually almost free unless you abuse your users’ data).