5 ms·
Their product is open source and MIT licensed, so their intentions shouldn't be relevant.
by krapp 4y ago
Their product is open source and MIT licensed, so their intentions shouldn't be relevant.
- lumost 4y agoUltimately their intention does matter, even open source projects tend to die once the financial interest in their success is gone. Most open source libraries you interact with are created in the course of building apps internally at a company, created by consultants and free lancers to support their consulting work, or are created as monetizable products in their own right. Software is a hard and complex thing to build, people don't tend to work full-time on projects which they can't earn a living from.
- hunterb123 4y ago> Ultimately their intention does matter, even open source projects tend to die once the financial interest in their success is gone. > Software is a hard and complex thing to build, people don't tend to work full-time on projects which they can't earn a living from. Wouldn't these be positive points towards how Wasmer is running the company? They are trying to keep their open source product alive by marketing and finding a way to build revenue, to continue to fund development. In the end, if they fail, it's all open source, someone can fork and continue it if the demand is there. Until then, they are the ones doing it, and doing it well imo.
- croes 4y agoIf they fail the IP is bought by a parent troll and everybody is sued using the term WebAssembly.
- croes 4y agoWho cares about the license of their products if you get sued for using the word WebAssembly
- krapp 4y agoI mean, they lost the case, they're not going to be able to successfully sue anyone for using the word WebAssembly, which they could have done regardless of whether or not they trademarked it, so that's a moot point. Nevertheless, people seem to have no problems forking Firefox and not literally calling it Firefox. Other open source companies own trademarks, and no one is implicitly suspicious of their motives. In the darkest of timelines when Wasmer owns a trademark over the word WebAssembly just use another word in your brand. It seems like people are specifically interested in spreading FUD about Wasmer and I can't see the justification for it.
- afiori 4y agofiling to trademark the name of technology invented by someone else is still a dick move. It is as if Nodejs tried to trademark V8
- krapp 4y agoSure, but as dick moves by software projects go, it's far from the dickest.
- reitzensteinm 4y agoThey're creating a platform, and that's a risky thing to build on if you can't trust the company. Sure it's open source, but unless you're at a scale where you actually can take it over and maintain it, that's not some magical escape hatch. This isn't a theoretical thing for me. I've got a project in mind that wasmer would be a candidate for, and I ruled it out for this reason.