5 ms·
America has socialized healthcare with a hundred extra steps and implemented in the most inefficient way possible so that everyone comes out worse. Hospitals a
by paxys 4y ago
America has socialized healthcare with a hundred extra steps and implemented in the most inefficient way possible so that everyone comes out worse.
Hospitals aren't allowed to deny care (obviously). They will bill people outrageous amounts and know that they will only ever see a fraction of it. So prices for people who do pay are raised considerably to make up for it.
People don't get early preventive care due to costs or because they are uninsured.
Supply of doctors is artificially limited by the ABMS so that demand stays high.
The government doesn't negotiate or mandate prices, so drug manufacturers, equipment manufacturers, researchers, hospitals and everyone else in the ecosystem squeezes out as much profit as they can to make up for all the countries where they are not allowed to.
The end result is that the average American knowingly or unknowingly pays a lot more for healthcare than any other country in the world while receiving sub-par care.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoI never understood why if they have a cap to at least increase it as population increases. Also we need to give more medical decisions over to advance level (but not doctors) levels of people like Physicians Assistants and Nurse Practitioners.
- maxerickson 4y agoEmergency rooms at hospitals that accept Medicare are not allowed to deny care under EMTALA. Hospitals that do not accept Medicare can run a 24 hour, high level of service department and deny care all they want. There's no requirement to provide non-stabilizing care.
- noelsusman 4y agoWhich hospitals don't accept Medicare?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hedora 4y agoAlso, something like 20-33% of health care dollars go to claim submission/processing at the doctor/hospital and the insurance company. Those people do nothing but argue with each other There's a highly rated HMO around here. Their costs are significantly lower than regular insurance, and they seem to pass some of that on to customers in the form of health care.
- corrral 4y ago> Hospitals aren't allowed to deny care (obviously). They will bill people outrageous amounts and know that they will only ever see a fraction of it. So prices for people who do pay are raised considerably to make up for it. They absolutely can. They just can't refuse care if you're actively dying or your condition's quickly deteriorating (they have to "stabilize" you). This makes the ER loophole, such as it is, useless as a backdoor for obtaining most hospital care. Plus if you go in for something that's not actually an emergency, they'll just make you wait until you leave. They'll never treat you.
- heavyset_go 4y agoThis is an important distinction. Nobody is getting free chemo or radiation therapy, treatment for chronic illness or anything like. For example, diabetics are not going to get a supply of insulin from the ER, especially if they can't pay, and someone with cancer isn't going to get treatment, either. Plenty of people die in the US from the inability to afford the medical care they need to live. If you're brought into the ER because of a heart attack or are bleeding profusely, your care won't be denied, but you will pay for it in some way later.
- missedthecue 4y ago"Nobody is getting free chemo or radiation therapy, treatment for chronic illness or anything like" Sure you can. In the US, you cannot be denied chemo or other treatments. You will be billed after the fact, and it's going to be a ton of money, but it's not as if they have security escort you out just because you don't have an insurance card. That simply doesn't happen. You'll get care, and if you don't qualify for aid programs or indigent care schemes (of which there are many), you'll probably file for bankruptcy and have the slate wiped clean. By law, nonprofit hospitals must provide charity care to needy patients. 57% of US hospitals are non-profit. Only 24% are for-profit. (The rest are government run)
- fellowniusmonk 4y agoI've known many people denied care, myself included, I've been asked to pay up up front or we don't admit you. This includes treatment for brain tumors and infection. ERs can't deny life saving care, but that's the exception. Is this the conception people have of the US healthcare system? That everyone's taken care of so why are they complaining? Let me disabuse you of that notion.
- Sohcahtoa82 4y ago> Hospitals aren't allowed to deny care (obviously). They will bill people outrageous amounts and know that they will only ever see a fraction of it. So prices for people who do pay are raised considerably to make up for it. This supposed truth is widely misunderstood to the point of simply being not true. Hospital ERs will stabilize you. That's all. If you have something that requires long-term care like diabetes or cancer, you're fucked. If you have Type 1 Diabetes and can't afford insulin, the hospital won't just give you a supply. They'll wait until you're about to die from diabetic ketoacidosis. A friend of mine had testicular cancer but had no money for treatment and no insurance. Hospitals straight-up told him that they won't treat him unless he's terminal. That's right, they wouldn't take care of him until he's on death's door, at which point all they'll be able to do is pump him full of painkillers to make him comfortable for his last couple hours. Luckily, the ACA passed, banning pre-existing condition clauses, and he was able to get some affordable insurance and treatment. Of course, anyone that has had cancer can tell you it likely never goes away [0]. He's always worried that a new tumor will appear somewhere. [0] https://xkcd.com/931/ https://xkcd.com/931/
- MomoXenosaga 4y agoI think Americans are smarter than that. In my country doctors don't give a shit about who you are or how much money you have. They do triage. You can be a millionaire yet have to wait 3 months for a new hip because there is someone with more urgent medical needs. It is pure unadultared fact based medicine to allocate scarce resources instead of market forces that turns you into a drone. Universal healthcare is beatiful but also utterly terrifying. It is pure communism without the "some animals are more equal". It will lift up many Americans no doubt but for the prosperous it is not an automatic win.
- buffington 4y agoI'm trying to understand what point you're trying to make here. Are you saying America's system is better or worse than that of your country? I'm in America, and I have fantastic health insurance (by American standards) and waited over a year for a hip replacement surgery. Even with insurance, I paid almost $10,000 for the surgery. Without insurance it would have cost well over $100k. I suspect that in any other country that provides universal health care it would have been less expensive (for everyone) and I would have waited less then 15 months to have it done.
- rayiner 4y agoWhy do you assume you would have gotten authorized for a hip replacement at all? Many elective qualify of life surgeries aren’t covered in European health care systems. Look, there is no free lunch. The UK NHS has strict standards of “cost effectiveness” that would shock Americans: https://www.nice.org.uk/media/default/guidance/lgb10-briefing-20150126.pdf https://www.nice.org.uk/media/default/guidance/lgb10-briefin.... 20-30,000 pounds per quality adjusted life year. American end of life care can cost hundreds of thousands of dollars for a year or two of extra life and American insurance companies will pay it without blinking. A friend of the family was diagnosed with terminal cancer and given six months to live. She received treatment costing hundreds of thousands of dollars, and lived almost two years. In European systems she would have been sent into hospice.
- 4y ago
- nradov 4y agoThe primary limit on the supply of doctors right now is lack of federal (Medicare) funding for residency training slots. Every year, students graduate from accredited medical schools but are never able to practice medicine because they can't get matched to residency program. This also impacts foreign doctors who want to immigrate and practice here. Ask Congress to increase funding. https://savegme.org/ https://savegme.org/
- maxerickson 4y agoA trillion dollar industry doesn't necessarily have to depend on the federal government to fund training.