3 ms·
OK sounds great to me so what are the downsides? For example a navigation app itself could still collect and use the data itself, but couldn’t sell that to a t
by gumby 4y ago
OK sounds great to me so what are the downsides?
For example a navigation app itself could still collect and use the data itself, but couldn’t sell that to a third-party. A geofenced application could be woken up by the system when I entered the region (say OmniFocus reminding me that I could stop in and pick up a prescription that is ready — I would be explicitly asking for this to happen).
So what great functionality could I miss out on if this became law?
- nickff 4y ago>"So what great functionality could I miss out on if this became law?" We are just at the beginning of analyzing and using health and location data; if there are groundbreaking use cases for them, it's very likely that we haven't seen (or even thought) of them yet.
- jen20 4y agoGreat - in that case now is the best time to get ahead of the curve in making sure that such use cases are ethical and not used by scumbags to target advertising.
- MBCook 4y agoThe one big downside I see is Google (and the cell phone carriers, and a few others). They already HAVE this data. It’s part of running Maps or a cell network. So this further entrenches them in some ways because they can make decisions and products off data no one else has. You know that thing when you search a place and it tells you how busy it is at certain hours? Bing could never replicate that. They have no way of knowing.
- GauntletWizard 4y agoThe way to deal with that is to enshrine into law that Google are not the owners of this data, but merely stewards. My maps location data should not be available to other divisions within Google, and should only be available to the maps team to serve my interests. There are effective rules that your bank is not allowed to sell your account information. Your location information should be subject to much the same.
- Dracophoenix 4y agoThat's where you bump up against copyright problems. For example anyone who composes a book or an opinion piece in the New York Times is obtaining data/information and publicizing it for profit. If you're going to argue that publishers of information don't/can't own the substance of their publication, how does one make a claim to the rights of what one has published? I would think GPS software operates on the same principle. The bank cannot directly sell your location information but they can disclose it to financial partners, likely for some financial quid pro quo. If you read the contracts on the You have to manually opt out by way of mail. I'm assuming Google does the same thing.
- TheCoelacanth 4y agoFacts can't be copyrighted.
- Dracophoenix 4y agoBut compilations of facts can be copyrighted. Textbooks, encyclopedias, and research papers are all copyrightable. In that regard, map data seems no different.
- MBCook 4y agoI’m not saying I’m against this law, but it gets messy very fast. When a business is busy is a part of Google Maps, but no one else but Apple could realistically try to duplicate it. That’s a hell of a wall against innovation. But can Google include that graph in search results? It’s part of Maps. But it’s derived from location data. But Google Search has location data, so maybe. But what if that would show different busy time? Do you have to show a different graph? What does Google Assistant do? I don’t know how we put the genie back in the box on this stuff. I like the idea. But I don’t know if it’s executable.
- strongpigeon 4y agoA downside is that it strengthens huge companies (e.g. Google, Apple) that have that information from one of their products (e.g. Google Maps) and are able to use it in another one (e.g. Google Ads). That being said, data brokers seem to be rather poorly behaved players in the market with little respects for users privacy. So it's a tradeoff I guess.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y ago> Nothing in this Act shall be construed to prohibit a disclosure of the data of an individual for which the individual provides valid authorization. Nothing will change. You'll just be bombarded with requests for permission or it will be buried in the fine print you agreed to in the non-negotiated "contract".