5 ms·
If war was the predictable outcome, Ukraine should probably have been more dovish towards Russian-speaking Ukrainians in the East, ie. not banning Russian langu
by whimsicalism 4y ago
If war was the predictable outcome, Ukraine should probably have been more dovish towards Russian-speaking Ukrainians in the East, ie. not banning Russian language, not shelling cities.
Obviously what Russia has done is reprehensible, but if Ukraine saw war as incoming I don't see why they took these aggravating steps.
- the_af 4y agoLet's just say I find your comment very on point. I would like to discuss this, but I don't think this is the best venue, and also this is a very sensitive topic and people are likely to be upset. And I wouldn't blame them. I did want to say your observation is astute.
- int_19h 4y agoRussian language isn't banned anywhere in Ukraine. Indeed, 5 minutes of combat footage from the Ukrainian side will quickly show that the majority of their armed forces speak Russian. Even Russians themselves reflected on this, noting that most volunteer forces they have faced so far come not from the Western (majority-Ukrainian-speaking) regions of Ukraine, but rather from Kharkiv, Dnipro etc. Their explanation is that all those people are "brainwashed by Ukrainian Nazis". There is some real contention with the status of Russian as 1) the official government language, and 2) the official education language in schools. But I don't think it's fair to phrase that as "banning Russian".
- notahacker 4y agoAnd anyway, the Ukrainian population did take those steps when most of them voted for a political outsider from a Russian speaking background seen as sympathetic to Russian speaking culture and somewhat willing to negotiate better relations with the "independent Republics". Putin interpreted that as a sign of weakness...
- whimsicalism 4y agoIt is illegal to have government communication in Russian or to have a Russian language radio station in Ukraine. I would call that banning Russian language from some aspects of public life.
- thraway11 4y agoDo you have a link for this? I hadn't heard about the Russian language being banned. I did know about this from 2019: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-ukraine-parliament-language/ukraine-passes-language-law-irritating-president-elect-and-russia-idUSKCN1S111N https://www.reuters.com/article/us-ukraine-parliament-langua... "The new legislation requires TV and film distribution firms to ensure 90 percent of their content is in Ukrainian and for the proportion of Ukrainian-language printed media and books to be at least 50 percent." It also says civil servants must speak Ukrainian. It does not say they can't also speak Russian. In any case, that's not a ban.
- whimsicalism 4y agoIt is illegal for any business to offer services or communicate in Russian unless the customer explicitly asks. It is illegal to have Russian language newspapers or schools, all of which existed before the crackdown. Turkey has done the same thing to Kurdish speakers and most of the West has rightfully condemned their attempts to crack down on the language.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- int_19h 4y agoIt's legal to use Russian as the primary instruction language in schools for the first 5 years. After that, they have to switch to Ukrainian, but they can still continue to teach Russian as a foreign language class (same as English etc). On the whole, I'd say that Ukrainian language policies are more akin to Quebec. OTOH Turkey has been packing its prisons with Kurds until recently for crimes such as "insulting Turkishness", so no, it's not really a valid comparison. I don't like the laws on this subject in either Ukraine or in Quebec (or really any place that tries to force cultural cohesion), but specifics do matter.
- cestith 4y agoRussian is as banned in Ukraine as French, Hindi, or German are banned in the United States. That is, they are not the primary language taught in schools nor the language in which government business is conducted but nobody's being jailed for speaking it.
- whimsicalism 4y agoThe comparison with the US is disingenuous - it is not illegal to open a French language school in the United States, it is in Ukraine. Previously, Russian was allowed to be taught in schools in Ukraine. It was then banned from being taught in schools even in regions where the majority of people speak Russian. Furthermore, it is illegal in Ukraine to have a Russian language radio station. I encourage you to read up on the actual policy differences.
- scrose 4y agoMany of your statements are outright false.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoEvidence beats a bare denial. (Of course, the original claim didn't have any evidence, either...) "Yes it is" "No it isn't" is a really uninteresting conversation. Somebody supply some evidence, not just claims.
- scrose 4y agoI don’t have the time to google citable sources to refute false claims without any evidence in the first place. My sources are my own multiple very recent visits to Ukraine(last visit earlier this year), and my extended Ukrainian family and friends who were all taught either only Russian(older and grew up in Russian occupied territories or Eastern Ukraine) and at times spoke Ukrainian under threat of death. Or were taught both Russian and Ukrainian(younger, recent grads from the Kyiv region)
- 4y ago
- The_Colonel 4y agoIt's said to see such misinformation here. > [not] banning Russian language Russian isn't banned in Ukraine. Millions of Ukrainians use Russian in their day to day life just fine. You can hear Russian spoken by Ukrainians on the battlefield. > not shelling cities Check photos from Donetsk in e.g. 2020, city ~10 kilometers from the frontline. Does it look destroyed? No, it looks like any peacetime city. There were artillery exchanges between both sides targeting military fortifications. Civilian casualties in the last few years have been minimal. But this doesn't really matter either way. Putin doesn't care about civilian casualties, otherwise why would he start this war?
- whimsicalism 4y ago> Russian isn't banned in Ukraine. Millions of Ukrainians use Russian in their day to day life just fine. You can here Russian spoken by Ukrainians on the battlefield. It is illegal to have Russian language radio stations, Russian language schools, and for government to communicate officially in Russian (in addition to Ukrainian & English). Of course people still speak Russian in Ukraine. > There were artillery exchanges between both sides targeting military fortifications. Civilian casualties in the last few years have been minimal. Yes from both sides. 3.4k civilian casualties prior to the actual war.
- The_Colonel 4y ago> Of course people still speak Russian in Ukraine. Then it's not banned as you claimed. > Yes from both sides. 3.4k civilian casualties prior to the actual war. With 3000 out of that in 2014 and 2015. In 2021 - 18 civilian deaths, half of that caused by unexploded shells/mines - https://ukraine.un.org/sites/default/files/2021-10/Conflict-related%20civilian%20casualties%20as%20of%2030%20September%202021%20%28rev%208%20Oct%202021%29%20EN.pdf https://ukraine.un.org/sites/default/files/2021-10/Conflict-... War in Donbas was actually dying out in the past few years, until Putin decided to escalate it and cause deaths of 10 000s.
- zoomablemind 4y ago>...Ukraine should probably have been more dovish towards Russian-speaking Ukrainians in the East, ie. not banning Russian language, not shelling cities. This is an understandably myopic view. Especially now, as the whole charade of justification and "objectives" of russia's invasion in Ukraine is in full swing. Perhaps, remembering that in putin's view, Ukraine is not an independent state, its existence is a mistake, the land is a sphere of russia's influence... well, the madman outright wants it "back" into the "empire". Thus it has long been clear that no amount of pacifying or "non-irritating" is to alter such policy. Language, aspirations and affinities are simply pre-texts for the forceful grab. Fundamentally, we're dealing with a clash of mentalities. One adopting to modern day and the one still stuck in the "age of empires". To putin's russians, tank is a symbol of forceful conquest. So it's not going away. Perhaps, more images of the charred russian army tanks could break this perception... temporarily.
- thriftwy 4y ago> it has long been clear that no amount of pacifying or "non-irritating" is to alter such policy. This represents the total failure of diplomacy present in today's discourse. We no longer think diplomacy affects the outcome and we think that any compromises from our side is just "free stuff" for the other one. What happens if Putin is not insane? What happens if there were better diplomatic outcome to this situation that the war? The ones that were missed by the lack of effort?
- zoomablemind 4y ago>...What happens if Putin is not insane? What happens if there were better diplomatic outcome to this situation that the war? There're no more what ifs. The madman was amassing the troops on the border for months, dismissing any possibilities of preparing an invasion. Then invaded, and openly blackmailed the rest of the world with a nuclear strike, all spreaded by his chief "diplomat". Present day russia as state proved to be pathologically incapable of maintaining signed treaties. If anything, the diplomacy needed to rely on the effective sanctions. However, that's were the failure was. Since the 2014 the sanction pressure proved to be insignificant to alter russia's course. Did we get a second chance at it now?