5 ms·
I know HN is just desperate for that i-told-you-so moment when fission rises from irrelevancy to save us all from climate change, but it's just not going to hap
by jeffbee 4y ago
I know HN is just desperate for that i-told-you-so moment when fission rises from irrelevancy to save us all from climate change, but it's just not going to happen. Look at this figure [1]. The amount of proposed solar and wind and battery projects in the United States at the end of 2021 was 1000s of time larger than the amount of proposed nuclear power projects. And one big difference is the renewables are actually built, while the fission projects never make progress. Fission's purported resurgence is a press release blitz being coordinated by defense contractor grifters who have no higher ambitions than raking a few tens of billions of dollars in consulting fees out of government budgets.
1: https://emp.lbl.gov/queues https://emp.lbl.gov/queues
- rectang 4y agoAre there any Y Combinator companies who are invested in the advance of nuclear power?
- MrMan 4y agothey are mostly sticking to web3 I think
- jeffbee 4y agoThere's Helion, a supposed fusion power company, but everything about it screams "fraud".
- pfdietz 4y agoI think Helion is the most credible of all the fusion companies.
- ncmncm 4y agoYour and Jeff's statements are wholly compatible.
- pfdietz 4y agoTrue. :) I mean that the other approaches appear to have obvious showstoppers (mostly engineering ones for DT approaches), while Helion has at least a plausible path to practicality. (plausible, adj.: superficially fair, reasonable, or valuable but often specious.)
- ncmncm 4y agoDid you see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31759753 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31759753 ? One of the projects has a plan to get p-11B closer to working. It didn't seem immediately stupid. It would be great to have a system that doesn't depend on unobtainium. Maybe in 50 years we will be able to take down the wind turbines, or explore the Kuiper Belt at length.
- amacbride 4y agoI know of Oklo, Helion, and UPower; there may be others. These three were relatively early (2014-2015 or so.)
- ncmncm 4y agoOf those, only Helion has any hope of a useful outcome. But it is a long shot, not least because of the 3He supply problem.
- TremendousJudge 4y agoThe United States is not the only place in the world. There are other countries with their own idiosyncrasies where different strategies may make more sense, and they all vent to the same atmosphere. So maybe if you're going to make a dismissing post such as this, about _global_ emissions, you should include arguments that cover places that are not the United States.
- Shadonototra 4y agospot on! no wonder you get downvoted! nobody likes to hear the truth over here
- nabla9 4y agoYou make huge order of magnitude errors in your thinking Nuclear provides the so called base load (the minimum level of electricity demand required). To replace base load with renewables + energy storage requires so much CAPEX and battery manufacturing that you don't have money to fill gaps between caseload needs and renewable energy production.
- jeffbee 4y agoThe state of California has built more battery capacity in the last six months than the entire nation has built of fission power plants in the last 25 years. It is extremely easy to build batteries for fixed service, and bulk semiconductor manufacturing is the #1 thing that humans are good at. These problems are absolutely solved, the whole industry thinks so, that's why the whole industry is behind pv+wind+storage, as demonstrated at that link I posted.
- nabla9 4y agoAs I said, order of magnitude error. > has built But enough? Global battery manufacturers have invested so much that they can take total battery capacity to more than 5,500 GWh by by 2030. US would need something like 3000 Gwh of energy storage to replace the base load. (within days, then few weeks). It would would be insane misuse of resources.
- fallingknife 4y agoIn 2021 US power consumption was 3.93 PWh. 5500 GWh is a bit over 12 hours of consumption. Not gonna cut it. And that's assuming 100% of the batteries are used for grid storage, and there is no demand growth in the next 8 years.
- ZetaZero 4y agoWith Vogtle 3 & 4, the only nuclear plants coming online in the US, the construction costs are now projected to be $30 billion for 2.2 GW. We'd need ~1000 of these size plants to power the US. That's not going to cut it either.
- nonethewiser 4y agoWind and solar are fighting very hard to replace existing supply at a comparable cost. It's a luxury substitute. We need more supply for cheaper.
- ZetaZero 4y agoIs Nuclear cheaper?
- dosenbrot 4y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_electricity_by_source https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_electricity_by_sourc... Depends. With just the cost per kWh is photovoltaic cheaper, but you would need additional storage for the nighttime, so it would become more expensive than nuclear. Also this didn’t account for winter time (in Germany photovoltaic make 5-10% compared to summer) and storing a half year worth of energy is going to be funny.(this will cost way way more than nuclear) A nuclear power plant could run 24/7 the whole year.
- Brometheus 4y agoIts only mid-november til mid-february that really sees a strong dip in production.
- dosenbrot 4y agoAnd the other months it's a not-so-strong dip in production (Jan 16%, Feb 31%, Mar 57%, Apr 94%, Jun 100%, Jul 100%, Aug 87%, Sep 60%, Okt 41%, Nov 22%, Dec 13%). This means (for germany) we have to install more than 170% PV and store 3 months worth of energy for half a year (or install 800% and don't store anything). It's just a very rough estimation, but it's clear that one can't compare the cost of 1kWh PV to 1kWh nuclear (at least if one doesn't live in the desert).
- ZetaZero 4y agoNo one is suggesting PV alone. My understanding is that Germany already gets more power from wind. Wind still works at night and in the winter, right?
- mgfist 4y ago> The amount of proposed solar and wind and battery projects in the United States at the end of 2021 was 1000s of time larger than the amount of proposed nuclear power projects Because the public has been anti nuclear energy for the past 4 decades. > And one big difference is the renewables are actually built, while the fission projects never make progress. Nuclear energy regulations are an absolute nightmare and make building anything virtually impossible. You're not necessarily wrong with your point, but man the world would've been so much cleaner if we didn't abandon nuclear energy 40 years ago. Now that we've lost all expertise and have neglected research, yes it's very hard for nuclear energy to make a huge resurgence.
- pydry 4y agoIt was always too expensive. It wasnt hippy peaceniks that killed it. It was money. The odd catastrophe didnt help though. Why there is a resurgence of interest now when dirt cheap solar and wind have effectively rendered it a costly relic of the past is somewhat puzzling. I guess PR campaigns like the OP's link are one reason.
- mgfist 4y agoIt's expensive when you rely on cheap Russian/ME fossil fuels > Why there is a resurgence of interest now when dirt cheap solar and wind have effectively rendered it a costly relic of the past is somewhat puzzling. If cheap solar/wind was enough right now Europe wouldn't be going through an energy crisis.
- nicoburns 4y agoThere isn't enough solar/wind or nuclear to power Europe right now. The question is which power mix will be best in a decade's time.
- otherme123 4y agoSolar is cheap since 2012 or so. 10 years is not enough to make a full shift. But we europeans are going there: 15 GW installed in 2019, 20 GW in 2020 and 23 GW in 2021.
- Phlogistique 4y agoDid you mean fusion? Fission is certainly not irrelevant today!
- ncmncm 4y agoFission is decreasingly relevant. The faster, the better for us all.
- IMTDb 4y ago> The amount of proposed solar and wind and battery projects in the United States at the end of 2021 was 1000s of time larger than the amount of proposed nuclear power projects. Your article links to capacity not effective production when customer needs it. The issue with electricity production resides in being able to reliably produce electricity when customer needs it, not when planet aligns for [insert preferred electricity production method]. It's great to say "I can produce 100Gw of green electricity", but if I ask you "Give me 30GW now" and you tell me "Best I can do now is 5GW, there are clouds in the sky", I'll kindly ask you to shut up about your "100GW capacity". As the recent price hikes in Europe have shown, the prices paid by customers is dictated by the cost of the most expensive megawatts. Solar and wind have not suddenly become pricier, but gas has. And as a consequence, prices paid by customers have increased proportionally. Batteries might seem like a good answer, but basic physics shows us that it is not remotely doable on a large scale, if we want to guarantee reliable supply. The energy density simply isn't there.
- jeffbee 4y agoPlease explain said "basic physics". I'll wait. California is building battery storage at a rate of ~2500MW/year. There are ZERO physics problems standing in the way of this. And there is considerable innovation in fixed batteries like iron-air flow batteries, ones that exist and aren't just VC scams like most of the nuclear stuff. https://www.energy-storage.news/california-utility-pge-proposes-1-6gw-6-4gwh-of-new-battery-storage-across-nine-projects/ https://www.energy-storage.news/california-utility-pge-propo...
- IMTDb 4y agoBasic physics 101. The US produced 4 10^9 MWh in 2017 [1] That's roughly 11 10^6 MWh / day or 11 10^12 Wh /day So to power 50% of the US for half a day, we need : 11 10^12 Wh /day * 0.5 day * 0.5 = 2.75 10^12 Wh = 275 10^10 Wh The energy storage of a Lithium Ion battery is roughly 270 Wh / kg [2], let's round this up to 275, I am feeling nice here. This means we need : 275 10^10 Wh / 275 Wh / kg = 1 * 10^10 kg of Lithium Ion batteries. That's 10 million tons of batteries The total reserve of lithium for the whole world are roughly 20 million tons [3] The US cannot claim half the total worldwide lithium reserve to give batteries for half a day for half their population. It does not work like this. [1] https://www.eesi.org/papers/view/energy-storage-2019 https://www.eesi.org/papers/view/energy-storage-2019 [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium-ion_battery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium-ion_battery [3] https://www.statista.com/statistics/1253739/lithium-reserves-worldwide/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1253739/lithium-reserves...
- fallingknife 4y agoWell that probably won't happen. The I told you so moment will be more like in 20 years when we didn't build nuclear, still don't have economically viable tech for a renewal only grid, and are still burning fossil fuels.