8 ms·
End-of-life smartphone? Penguins at PostmarketOS aim to revive it
- ur-whale 4y agommh. given then number of phone that reach "end of life" only because the battery dies and is not (easily) replaceable, not sure what good this will do.
- afandian 4y agoI have two BlackBerry phones in a drawer with perfectly good hardware that I reluctantly stopped using because of software issues (Passport and KeyOne). PostmarketOS isn't relevant for these specificaly, but to your point, the hardware would have been fine for probably double their actual lifetime.
- DoingIsLearning 4y agoTo add to this, Google itself just dropped the security updates for Pixel 3a (their own phone not OEM) after just 3 years of launch. 3 years of use from a piece of complex hardware that could keep going easily for 7/8 years. This kind of narrow planned obsolescence should be an environmental crime.
- ansible 4y ago(Owner of Pixel 3a) Yeah, that's a bummer. There's not something else I'd rather own right now, so I'll likely keep running it for a while. But most other Android phones don't have a long support lifetime either. Heck, there are a lot of new phones you can buy today that have outdated OS versions, and you're not likely to get much in the way of updates either.
- DoingIsLearning 4y agoIndeed my example was just to point out the insanity of 3 years support on your _own_ products not some external third party. Truly a waste.
- pessimizer 4y agoGoogle's horrible support might turn out to be an opening for Linux. There are a lot of Pixel owners who hate iPhones with a passion that are currently, against all of their instincts and values, considering buying iPhones because they get double or triple the functional life of an Android. They would even switch to something more difficult to use if they both could avoid buying Apple, and either extend the life of their current phone (unlikely at this point, but maybe in the future) or have confidence that the next phone that they buy would last as long as an iPhone. If they could run Android apps on it with reasonable performance, it would be an easy switch.
- ancientsofmumu 4y ago> (Owner of Pixel 3a) Yeah, that's a bummer. There's not something else I'd rather own right now, so I'll likely keep running it for a while. I have the 3a and 4a (non-5G), if you can find a 4a someone is trying to give away on the cheap it's basically a nicer version of the 3a IMHO. It's going to EOL in a year so I wouldn't spend much on it, but if one crosses your path for $100, well...
- eric__cartman 4y agoI have a OnePlus 5 (a device from 2017) that's suffering the same fate. The hardware itself is fine. It has 6 gigabytes of RAM and a SoC that's fast enough that I don't notice any slowdowns in day to day usage. Yet the officially supported software by the manufacturer has been abandoned two years ago. I'm currently running LineageOS, and the phone is working as good as ever. Running a modern version of Android with monthly security patches. It's a shame that expensive devices nowadays are made to be disposable. After getting a battery replacement, this phone is ready to go for a few more years at least. SoCs have gotten so good that even a half a decade old chip will perform well for the vast majority of users that don't play big games on their phones. It's not like you need a supercomputer to browse social media, websites and use maps for navigation.
- cge 4y agoI have a Pixel 2XL. It's in perfect condition, works well, and still has decent battery life on the original battery. It has no problems running everything I use, and there would be little benefit I would gain from getting a new phone. Yet Google dropped security updates at the end of 2020, as with the 3a, three years after launch, and around a year after they stopped selling them. My phone now nags me to buy a new one in the settings. Now, it might be argued that Google has no obligation to produce updates for their products, but... if I try to improve security on the phone by using third-party distributions that are updated, rather than buying a new phone, then thanks to Google's SafetyNet, the phone will be crippled and have difficulty running many banking, payment, and other apps that are at this point a requirement in many situations. Thus, the reason the phone is problematic at this point is because of Google's working to make the phone unusable, not just the lack of updates. It is bizarre that SafetyNet will vouch for the security of an OS Google itself argues to me is unsafe because of lack of updates, while not allowing a third-party distribution. Yet I suppose I wouldn't be surprised if Google eventually decides to have SafetyNet stop functioning entirely on older devices, in the name of security, to make them even less usable.
- the_third_wave 4y agoHere you go: https://download.lineageos.org/taimen https://download.lineageos.org/taimen That device is officially supported by Lineage and as such gets weekly OTA updates. You'll get a clean Android experience not unlike that of the original Pixel, you can - but don't have to - install Google apps and can even if so required get one of the 'PixelExperience' distributions: https://download.pixelexperience.org/taimen https://download.pixelexperience.org/taimen Personally I'd stay away from those since they are (by design) heavily tied into the Google world while I do my best to stay free but if you're a heavy Google user this might be the way to go.
- HidyBush 4y agoWe will finally able to re-use old smartphones if open source drivers will be written for their hardware. There is literally no fundamental smartphone functionality that has been lacking from 2012 onwards, and as such there is absolutely no reason why a Galaxy S2 shouldn't at least have an up to date kernel that isn't limited by driver incompatibility
- ansible 4y agoUnfortunately, the S2 has very limited 4G (LTE) support, and the 3G networks are being shut down. I believe, based on the supported bands, that it would only work with AT&T. The 1G of RAM is going to make things difficult moving forwards too. ------------------- Ultimately, we need something even beyond Google's Fuchsia OS. First, we need hardware that is relatively standardized, and able to be identified at boot time. Just like how you aren't bothered by having an extra USB controller on your PC motherboard, or which PCIe slot you plug in your network card. We need a standardized means of identifying on-chip and off-chip peripherals available to the system, so that we can have a standard set of drivers loaded automatically. This is hampered by all the changes (over the last couple decades) in things like power management and security (secure boot). It is not all bad news. For example, there is relatively low diversity in USB host controllers, everyone tends to use the same standardized hardware interface. But there hasn't been much cooperation across the industry to standardize peripherals in the embedded world like there has been in the PC world.
- BurningPenguin 4y agoI still have a BQ E5 Ubuntu Edition laying around at home. Still waiting for any other distro to support it, despite Ubuntu Touch.
- agentultra 4y agoThis is a really cool project! I decided a few years ago to never buy a new laptop/computer again and reuse as much as possible, repair, and buy refurbished if necessary. Maintaining a lean Linux distro for older generations of hardware is a great idea.
- Mildlypolite 4y agoGreat, I am trying to do the same thing because the rhythm of Change is unsustainable in every possible way (ecologically, but also, I want to master my skills on the instruments I use everyday and this is not possible when something change every year).
- squarefoot 4y ago> They're not all equally supported, though. Most of them can can boot, many have Wi-Fi support, but currently just two actual phones work as phones: the open-source hardware PinePhone and the Purism Librem 5. And very little will change until something is done at legislation level: companies declaring a device obsolete, withdrawing it from market, or ending its support, should be forced to publish at least the bare minimum information necessary to allow the creation of drivers and functioning software; nobody is asking them to surrender all their IP. PostMarketOS and other projects are a wonderful effort, but they can't keep the pace of the absurd number of perfectly good devices that are thrown away each year because their manufacturers didn't want them to be reused. This practice encourages bad habits from users contributing to pollution, and it's more a political issue than a technical one.
- dogleash 4y ago>nobody is asking them to surrender all their IP I agree with you, but that is how they'll see it. Some of the datasheets I've gotten for an NRND or EOL device are under NDA and still too spartan to write a driver without a lot of trail and error. Because this year's latest-and-greatest product is is 95% the same as the old perfectly-functional products they'll call trash.
- aidenn0 4y agoFor a lot of the more complicated communication chips I've used the data sheets are more aspirational than a reflection of reality anyways. I've often used registers in ways that are documented; it didn't work, and the response from the support was "oh just do it the way our example driver does it."
- rez9x 4y agoMy understanding is that the support is less about the device OEM and more about the SoC supplier (ie Qualcomm). Once Qualcomm decides they're not supporting the SoC anymore, there's not much the OEM can do in terms of security patching. This is the understanding I've picked up from similar discussions over the years, but I very well may be wrong.
- NoGravitas 4y agoI have a few old Moto G1s that I'd love to put this on, but they have carrier-locked bootloaders, so that's out. I have a 2012 Nexus 7 that's pretty well supported, but it won't charge (or recognize the USB connection in any way), so that's out, too.
- ansible 4y agoIn some cases, you can ask the carrier to give you the unlock code, if the device is out of contract.
- sillycube 4y agoOne of the issues of old phones is that the battery can't be replaced and the battery cannot run for a long time
- chrismorgan 4y ago> They're not all equally supported, though. Most of them can can boot, many have Wi-Fi support, but currently just two actual phones work as phones: the open-source hardware PinePhone and the Purism Librem 5. This seems like a very significant error. In https://wiki.postmarketos.org/wiki/Devices https://wiki.postmarketos.org/wiki/Devices I see twelve more in the Community section with a Y in the “Calls” column (and they all have SMS and mobile data too), from various different brands—Lenovo, Motorola, Samsung, Wileyfox, Xiaomi. I get the impression from this that many in the Testing section will also support calls.
- csnover 4y agoIt’s possible that both are true depending on the definition of “calls”. It may be different with postmarketOS, but at least with LineageOS, there are phones where calls are supported over 3G but not VoLTE. So, while the phone and OS are technically capable of making calls, without VoLTE support they can’t actually do it because mobile providers have decommissioned their 3G networks.
- chrismorgan 4y agoAh, USA problems. I don’t think anywhere else has decommissioned 3G just yet, though some plan to next year or so; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/3G#Decline_and_decommissions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/3G#Decline_and_decommissions suggests the EU may even be planning to keep 2G alive as a fallback, which is an interesting decision. I have used at least three phones (two Android, one PinePhone on Arch) that allegedly support VoLTE, but I have never had a phone call do anything other than drop to 3G on the Optus network in Australia (through at least three different carriers). I’m not sure quite what’s up with that, but I vaguely recall some kind of insanity about VoLTE not having any baseline codecs and carriers being able to operate a device whitelist and idiotic user-hostile things like that. I’m fuzzy on details, and have never tried asking the telco why it doesn’t work. I really dislike how opaque everything is in mobile telephony.
- citrin_ru 4y agoKeeping 2G+4/5G alive looks like a good option to me - 2G is supported by any GSM phone and has long range, 4/5G - high bandwidth for modern phones. I would not miss 3G at all if 2G and 4G will be available, but 2G decommission will turn a lot of working dump/feature phones into e-waste (I myself use multiple SIM-cards and some of them are in 2G-only phones).
- Diris 4y agoMan it'd be so great to be able to run a home server on an old phone, kinda like a raspberry pi but with a lot of accessories included.
- amphetamine 4y agoIt would be very cool indeed. I can imagine myself gathering a bunch of old smartphones people inevitably throw away as it rots in a drawer somewhere for years and years. Then proceed to create a little network of these things and... I dunno, use as CCTVs or something. If we can get up to 50 sub-par smartphones we'll be able to make some sort of resemblance of a botnet!
- doublepg23 4y agoYou can do that easily on Android with Termux. Not sure it would be very powerful though.
- 3np 4y agoAs an aside, Alpine is a really great distro and an excellent choice to base pmOS on. If I'd have been in the anti-systemd camp I'd consider it where I currently use other distros.
- lproven 4y ago[Article author here] It really is, and it's got a lot easier to set up as a desktop OS in recent years. I wrote about it too recently: https://www.theregister.com/2022/05/26/alpine_linux_316_released/ https://www.theregister.com/2022/05/26/alpine_linux_316_rele...
- theandrewbailey 4y ago> The project's own wiki currently lists over 200 supported devices... Most of them can can boot, many have Wi-Fi support, but currently just two actual phones work as phones Dealbreaker. I guess that using a phone for its intended use (for making phone calls) makes me a boomer.
- pessimizer 4y agoI've never met someone who needs at least three types of phones at a time.
- happymellon 4y agoThis is a project trying to provide all of these things. The limitation is device manufacturers not providing drivers or specifications for people to write drivers against. If there is a driver that supports calls then it will support calls.
- seltzered_ 4y ago> The project is quite different. It uses the mainline Linux kernel, and a standard userland, to support a wide variety of devices. The theory is that not needing a manufacturer's outdated firmware or drivers means that pmOS can use more current components, direct from the various upstream Linux projects. This clarifies a lot for me. Regarding android app support on postmarketos - I haven't tried postmarketos yet but my understanding is some have been managing this via using 'waydroid'
- lproven 4y ago[Article author here] Oh, good. Glad to hear that. I was lucky enough to attend a talk about postmarketOS at the last in-person FOSDEM conference in Brussels, which explained some stuff. :-)
- seltzered_ 4y agoGood to hear. My personal use case that tempts me to learn how to build postmarketOS is to have a 7" tablet (arm, currently android) that can be a fast second screen for my main 13" tablet PC (Intel, Ubuntu gnome) The key part is fast, I've tried the vnc / rdp based options wired & wirelessly and they've been slow, there's recently been some nice explorations into another approach with a postmarketOS device: https://tuxphones.com/howto-linux-as-second-wireless-display-for-linux/ https://tuxphones.com/howto-linux-as-second-wireless-display...
- lproven 4y agoI have read about this tech, yes, but I lost interest as soon as I learned I'd need to use GNOME. I can't stand it. I like traditional menu bars, and desktop iconsm, and a vertical taskbar or panel -- and the top panel in GNOME is an egregious waste of desktop space. JOOI, what Intel tablet do you have that works well with Linux?
- seltzered_ 4y agoHuh, for me GNOMEs been a decent fit as a tablet user thats used to trackpad & screen gestures. Part of desiring this tablet and PC paradigm has meant questioning and letting go of traditional PC design aspects, including ones I've been fond of from macos. I use an HP Elite X2 G4: https://www.reddit.com/r/ErgoMobileComputers/comments/s6k1qr/raised_tablet_pc_setup/ https://www.reddit.com/r/ErgoMobileComputers/comments/s6k1qr... It's surprisingly supported Linux well out of the box, and has some more repairability options (and a business-tier warranty plan), just wish it had a bit more ram than 16gigs when occasionally juggling several projects/VMs. There's starting to be more Linux Intel Tablet options (Surface Pro 8 as ihci touch support becomes baked in, Asus ROG flow Z13, Dell XPS 2-in-1 for 2022, etc.) but this turned out okay as a sudden replacement need after my MacBook finally died a year ago. This is pretty much my one and only computer so reliability is crucial.
- jancsika 4y agoOk, I'll bite. Here's what I want: 1. make phone calls with bog standard reliability with a Verizon account 2. receive and send texts 3. take pictures with the phone's camera 4. have a bog standard virtual keyboard 5. read Wikipedia Can PostmarketOS achieve this on some piece of ubiquitous hardware? If so, which one?
- aidenn0 4y agoMy understanding is the current state is "yes on 3G, but no on LTE" which means (depending on where you live) the actual answer may be "no."
- jamesgeck0 4y agoUnfortunately Verizon is disabling their 3G network at the end of the year.
- CameronNemo 4y agoHave you considered jmp.chat? You'll never have to worry about VoLTE, WiFi calling, or 3G decomissioning again.
- jancsika 4y ago> In case it’s been a while since you checked out JMP, here’s a refresher: JMP lets you send and receive text and picture messages (and calls) Even for $2.99, I'm suspicious about those parentheses! :) How is the call quality? What's the latency like?
- CameronNemo 4y agoCall quality is meh and latency is not that bad.
- jancsika 4y agoIf it isn't "bog standard reliability" then it's simply not usable as a phone replacement.
- leke 4y agoThis is a really neat idea, but their coverage is not that great. I would totally by a phone that gave over details that made it easy for projects like this to adopt.
- smm11 4y agoEnd-of-life? How about just the Samsung Galaxy line beyond one made 12 years ago. It's sort of popular in Android-land.
- throwaway81523 4y agoIt seems like a lost cause because of the ever-escalating CPU demands of the present-day web. Keeping the phone running is one thing, making its browser able to keep up with the latest web bloat is another.