8 ms·
Terra Luna crash: CTO of Tether welcomes fair regulation of stablecoin market
- dragontamer 4y agoCapitalize the gains, socialize the losses. We ain't gonna bail out the cryptocoin community, not after the antigovernment crap they spewed for the last decade.
- Jgrubb 4y agoWho is “we”?
- chasd00 4y agoTaxpayers
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoNot that i think we should, but then why do we regularly bail out other industries that continuously undermine regulation? At least these guys wear their heart of the sleeve
- dragontamer 4y ago> Not that i think we should, but then why do we regularly bail out other industries that continuously undermine regulation? 1. First and foremost: because George Bush was forced. The Republicans are famously against interfering with the free market, so George Bush let the first couple of banks fail, and fail, and fail... by the time Bear Stearns failed, there were already many bank failures and George Bush still didn't bail them out. 2. The big failures, specifically: Bear Stearns and Lehman Brothers, had a big effect on the economy. Remember, George Bush _LET_ these banks fail, he wanted to be hands-off. The collapse of these two banks set of a large set of cascading bank failures that had an outsized effect on the "normal people's economy" of main street. George Bush started getting random phone calls from factories who "suddenly couldn't meet payroll", because their banks failed. It became obvious that bank-failures would lead to factory closures. 3. It was at this point, that George Bush took the unprecedented step to start saving banks. It was clear that the country couldn't take another $200+ Billion bank failure. Congress passed TARP and that was it. The banks were saved. ------------- Everyone agreed that saving the banks was allowing "moral hazard" to take place. But as what was discussed at the time, banks of that size are "too big too fail". If we, as a country, "let them fail", then random parts of the country / random parts of the economy blow up, in ways we don't understand. It was easier to understand / fix the issues through a bailout, rather than randomly seeing thousands of people get fired at effectively random, as factories close. Over the next few years, the plan was to reduce the "too big to fail" effect. As the US Economy was setting up new regulations to prevent "too big to fail", cryptocoins started up, and decided to recreate the too-big-to-fail problem all on their own. ------ In 2008, we were too dumb and ignorant to see "too big too fail". But in 2022, we remember the issue. With any luck, our banking system is properly containerized and safe. No bailouts should be necessary to save our economy.
- arbitrage 4y agoIt seems you're pushing an agenda, here. > then random parts of the country / random parts of the economy blow up, in ways we don't understand. This is disingenous. The fallout from the banking disaster in 2008 was not random in effect, and we understood it at the time perfectly well. > It was easier to understand / fix the issues through a bailout, rather than randomly seeing thousands of people get fired at effectively random, as factories close. You're saying 'random' a lot. Again, the fallout from the economic and banking mismanagement in the US at that time was in no way random, nor inexplicable. You're trying to smear around blame to dilute the responsibility pool. > Over the next few years, the plan was to reduce the "too big to fail" effect. [...] In 2008, we were too dumb and ignorant to see "too big too fail". But in 2022, we remember the issue. This is absurd and wrong. The US in no way planned to reduce the "too big to fail" effect. You are simultaneously implying that the US glibly ignored "too big to fail" in 2008, and somehow was too ignorant to know about it?? > With any luck, our banking system is properly containerized and safe. No bailouts should be necessary to save our economy. Bailouts in 2008 and later years were not intended to save the economy. A simple understanding of calculus would show a competent onlooker that the amount of money dispensed in government bailout schemes came nowhere close to the amount of money needed to stop the economic collapses in the US. The bailouts were, and are, only capable of -- and only intended to -- prevent rioting in the streets. You're pushing a really weird agenda in a very half arsed way.
- dragontamer 4y ago> You're saying 'random' a lot. You're saying "agenda" a lot. > The US in no way planned to reduce the "too big to fail" effect. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dodd%E2%80%93Frank_Wall_Street_Reform_and_Consumer_Protection_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dodd%E2%80%93Frank_Wall_Street... > An Act to promote the financial stability of the United States by improving accountability and transparency in the financial system, to end "too big to fail", to protect the American taxpayer by ending bailouts, to protect consumers from abusive financial services practices, and for other purposes. Now maybe you don't like Dodd Frank, or maybe you don't think it goes far enough. But anyone who was paying attention to politics can easily list off the laws and changes we did to our economy to try to fix the identified problem. We _tried_ to fix it. No way to know if we really fixed it until our next crisis. But I can always point to what our President did (both George Bush _AND_ Obama handled this mess, with the same plan btw), as well as Congress's laws. The very phrase "Too big too fail" exists because of the outstanding effort this country put into identifying the problem, and discussing possible solutions. You're literally using the language of Congress whenever you use those words. -------- USA isn't perfect. And Republicans / Democrats have different ideas of what "would fix" the problem. But what I can say with 100% certainty, is that George Bush + Obama acted in similar manners through the crisis, suggesting that the two grossly different ideologies came to similar conclusions about what would solve the issue. EDIT: There are also multiple days / weeks worth of Congressional hearings on this subject, proving that Congress was discussing solutions for a long time.
- throwoutway 4y agoZuckerberg also welcomes “fair regulation” where he gets to define “fair” as good for him and not others
- verelo 4y agoI think that’s fair criticism of the situation but i would also point out that if i was in business X and some others were acting in a way that risked the public not wanting to participate in my product due to the behaviour of others, i too would welcome some oversight to manage these bad actors from damaging my reputation.
- ravel-bar-foo 4y agoIn this case it is like you are in business X and having personally ruined the reputation of the group you call for welcome oversight to manage bad actors...
- throwoutway 4y agoTether has destroyed their own reputation multiple times, so they have lost the benefit of the doubt and we should view their actions more critically
- lupire 4y agoOf course but the problem is the relativism -- every business thinks that exactly what they do is the ethical way that should be sanctified.
- Mo3 4y agoAnd this comes from the CTO of Tether? Who themselves borrowed money the day before an audit, put it into the reserve and then returned it the next day after the audit? Who print Tether like there’s no tomorrow with almost zero redemptions? CFO and CEO nowhere to be found? I can hear them laughing from over here in Europe.
- troon-lover 4y ago
- epolanski 4y agoAn audit which wasn't even independent.
- jpmoral 4y agoWasn't even an audit.
- raesene9 4y agoNot directly related to this article, but it seems odd that (AFAIK) almost all the public statements by Tether come from their CTO or general counsel and not their CEO. You'd think for things like this the CEO would be the person involved...
- NoblePublius 4y agoStable coin? More like stable con!
- gonzo41 4y ago
- lancesells 4y agoThe funny thing is two years ago BTC was under 10k. The sky is not falling it's probably just going back to a more sane price.
- sfe22 4y ago12 years ago it was a penny. 12 years is not long when we are talking money, so…
- lancesells 4y agoAgreed. I don't see any value in it.
- legulere 4y agoThe question is: What is a sane price for bitcoin? I would say $0.00.
- Grimburger 4y agoYou can bet on that happening over long periods. Shorting the 2024 bitcoin price isn't hard at all for a consumer.
- ABeeSea 4y agoYou can only short bitcoin on exchanges that are internally betting on increasing crypto prices. Not exactly a fair market maker.
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoAlso an unlikely party to pay out should you win.
- antihero 4y agoThis seems like it’s virtue signalling honesty but actually it’s slightly deeper - regulation is a path to perceived legitimacy and credibility. P2P lending companies did the exact same thing here in the U.K. and it worked.
- lupire 4y ago"Regulated crypto" is Gemini's entire business model.
- nathias 4y agoif there was such a thing as fair regulation, of course ...
- tehlike 4y agoWhere is tether CEO?
- trakl 4y agoBBBBBBBAAAAAAHAHAHAHAH
- olalonde 4y agoWhy call for regulations when existing laws are not even enforced? If you run a stablecoin that claims to be backed in a certain way and it turns out to be a lie, that is fraud. If you promise guaranteed returns on an investment without disclosing risks, that is fraud. If you embezzle funds, that is fraud. The real problem in the crypto community is that existing laws aren't enforced. Why not start by applying them before calling for new regulations? I am reminded of this video by Milton Friedman: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vhgaPVO8aw8&t=63s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vhgaPVO8aw8&t=63s
- Cwizard 4y agoSerious question: is it really? I always thought that crypto was specifically not rated as a financial asset and thus didn’t have nearly as strict regulation as other financial products. For example what is the difference between 1% daily returns vs some cleaning product claiming it can remove all stains? I always assume both to be marketing lies. And I assume in both cases there is some fine print T&C that denies legal liability/contextualises claims. I might be totally incorrect here but this is always how I saw crypto, unregulated, buy at your own risk, marketed products.
- PragmaticPulp 4y ago> Serious question: is it really? I always thought that crypto was specifically not rated as a financial asset and thus didn’t have nearly as strict regulation as other financial products. If someone makes a product that acts like a financial security, they are required to comply with securities laws. The laws don’t have to explicitly say “this also applies to crypto”. This is what many crypto projects are being held accountable for as the enforcement agencies catch up. If you offer a security but don’t adhere to securities laws, you are breaking the law. Of course, many projects sidestep this altogether by operating out of countries that don’t have such regulations. > For example what is the difference between 1% daily returns vs some cleaning product claiming it can remove all stains? I always assume both to be marketing lies. And I assume in both cases there is some fine print T&C that denies legal liability/contextualises claims. The difference is that financial products have a lot of regulations and laws beyond just marketing claims. The difference between an interest-bearing security and a carpet cleaning product is so huge that I’m surprised you think they can even be compared in terms of regulation. Securities and financial law goes far, far beyond marketing claims. It’s entirely unreasonable to think that financial instruments can simply promise something and then not deliver it because they say “just kidding” somewhere in the fine print.
- BaseballPhysics 4y agoCool. How about regulations that require an open and transparent audit by an accredited third party accounting firm? Maybe we can finally find out what's actually going on behind the curtain say Tether. As an aside, one can't help but wonder if this piece is stealth marketing given how friendly it is to Tether and recent concerns of a de-peg in the face of incredibly high market volatility. There's an enormous amount of very valid criticism about the company and barely a hint of it in this article.
- rntn 4y agohttps://archive.ph/6SZ7q https://archive.ph/6SZ7q
- mixxit 4y agopaywall :(
- jcranmer 4y agoIf I'm reading the interview correctly, the regulation that is desired here is something that provides a stamp of approval on Tether's current "transparency". This isn't the same regulation that most observers want for stablecoins. The rational thing to do is to require that stablecoins provide the same transparency that money market funds do. That means publishing a detailed list of the exact securities you've invested in, i.e., 50 shares of Acme Inc's commercial paper with maturity at the end of August (and CSIP #whatever). Money market funds are able to do this, so it shouldn't be challenging for stablecoins to do this either. Furthermore, there is absolutely nothing that prevents Tether from providing this transparency right now (assuming, of course, that Tether isn't lying about its asset composition). If you're really serious about welcoming regulation, then you should start by doing that. By not doing so, you're only making me think that you want to poison-pill any potential regulation.
- senectus1 4y agoThe only reason they're saying this is because they have their assets in hand and now want the value of it to rise and stabilize. They have no intention of being held accountable, they just want the market illusion to make it LOOK like someone will be accountable.