13 ms·
As professors struggle to recruit postdocs, calls for change in academia
- musicale 4y agoThis really seems like a variant of "there is a huge labor shortage of highly qualified candidates willing to work for low pay in an awful environment with poor advancement opportunities."
- gtsnexp 4y ago"I think the Ph.D. system is an abomination." - Freeman Dyson https://www.webofstories.com/play/freeman.dyson/95;jsessionid=A0370D88B976E13E6EB03A985BD4FB52 https://www.webofstories.com/play/freeman.dyson/95;jsessioni...
- baka367 4y agoI spent 4 + 1 (extra year) going for the PhD. Getting funding for anything was nothing short of nightmare and the workload was (obviously) very high. Eventually I decided to scrap those 5 years for a triple salary as a junior developer and had a successful career since. Is casual coding more interesting than research/teaching - no, but staying in academia requires way more altruism than I could find in me. I also still find how to get some of the joys of academia in industry, namely, mentoring/holding workshops/writing design specs/turning the cluttered documentation into a nicely flowing coherent one~
- arethuza 4y agoI stopped doing a PhD after about 5 years - I was a Research Associate in a UK university so I actually got a salary which wasn't too bad but quite a bit below the going rate (I had a few job offers during that time). I left to co-found a start-up - never regretted it as I was "hyper cynical" (a direct quote from a colleague) about the whole academic world and how easy it was to play the "publish or perish" game. I like building stuff that people use, not writing papers that mostly went unread.
- mizzao 4y ago> I like building stuff that people use, not writing papers that mostly went unread. I had the same feeling! And as it turns out, many of the skills are transferable: https://twitter.com/mizzao/status/1505529213612609536 https://twitter.com/mizzao/status/1505529213612609536
- coldpie 4y ago> I like building stuff that people use, not writing papers that mostly went unread. Circa 2010, as I was finishing up my BS in CS, one of my professors asked me to have a meeting in his office. He was trying to recruit me into a graduate program under him, since he liked my performance in his class. I said I wasn't very interested, since I wanted to make things people will actually use. His response was there was a team in Utah that helped make part of the USB spec the decade previous. I was attending the University of Minnesota. Yeah, no thanks.
- feet 4y agoI think this is a short sighted perspective. Basic research is important and has farther reaching impacts than a CRUD web app. Just because you don't see immediate impact doesn't mean it isn't there
- coldpie 4y agoSure, I'm glad people do that work. But it's not for me.
- criddell 4y ago> Basic research is important and has farther reaching impacts than a CRUD web app. Those aren't the only two options and even they were, it isn't always true.
- arethuza 4y agoI'm not saying that people shouldn't do basic research, far from it, more that I learned that given the way basic research actually works then I had relatively little interest in actually doing it myself.
- chrisseaton 4y agoIf you did a full PhD in what sense did you 'scrap' it? You just didn't do the defence?
- cs137 4y agoIt sounds like he went ABD. In the US, PhDs can take 6-8+ years. There are some shitty advisors who delay their students' graduations to get additional low-wage labor. Also, the academic job market is terrible and has been for 30+ years, so it takes a full year just to do the search.
- MereInterest 4y agoExpanding the acronym for non-academia, ABD is "all but dissertation". After the first 2-3 years of a PhD program, the coursework is finished, you're into mostly independent research, and so you've completed "all but dissertation". This is a nebulous time that could be as short as 1-2 years, and could be as long as 5-10 years. The shorter durations tend to be in the sciences, and the longer durations in the humanities. Because the duration is so dependent on the program, and the only end is when the advisor agrees that sufficient work has been done to merit a PhD, it can stretch on without much hope in sight.
- RhysU 4y agoIsn't ABD status the time from successfully proposing a dissertation to a specific committee until successfully defending that dissertation in front of that committee? The former step is intended to clearly define what is sufficient work. In effect, it is the contract that eliminates some of the risk of the advisor's whim.
- chrisseaton 4y agoSome people say ABD is 'all but defended' as in you wrote your thesis you just didn't do a defence, some people say ABD is 'all but dissertation' in that you didn't get the point of writing the thesis. That's a pretty big difference. The former is you basically did your entire PhD, the latter is you didn't really start it.
- doliveira 4y agoYeah, I quit after my Masters. I do miss the challenge, the feeling of achievement when you crack something, just the whole feeling of being close to the edge of human knowledge, it's all so much more exciting than development where you know your answer is basically already out there. But yeah, you gotta do what pays the bills. I'm not making triple figures in dollars, but in my country it's six times what I would get during a PhD program.
- kmmlng 4y agoA PhD can mean a lot of different things. Personally, I'm employed as a research associate while doing a PhD, which in theory means I should do the PhD as part of my job. In practice, I do not get to do any actual research during the job and the PhD is relegated to weekends. What I find curious: I get paid to do lots of things which are clearly complete nonsense, but the funding comes with the requirement that these specific nonsensical things must be done. I could do lots of useful things, but I do not get paid for those. I'm far enough into the process that I've decided to just collect the stupid credential before I move on. Which is funny because I did not get into this for the credentials, but dropping out at this point would just look weird on my CV.
- EEBio 4y agoWhat are the nonsensical activities you get paid to do?
- kmmlng 4y agoFor example solving specific problems in a data-driven way when there is no data and there never will be any data. Developing all sorts of platforms that will theoretically benefit the public / researchers / whoever, but in actuality will never be used by anyone and in fact will be shut down as soon as the corresponding project ends. Those are the two generic examples I can think of, for everything else I'd have to give too much context.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- april_22 4y agoDoing a PhD and getting a job as a software developer afterwards seems to be a pretty common route nowadays
- dinvlad 4y agoAlmost the same experience, 4 years. I've even stayed after it for another ~3 years because it was ~3x pay as a tech for doing less restricted stuff (no need to convince my committee what I do is important) and learning to run essentially a mini-startup within a lab, while being restricted in my portability due to visa policies.
- microtonal 4y agoIf you pay much lower than the industry and only give people temporary positions, it's not surprising people go elsewhere when they can. The solution is also quite obvious...
- sseagull 4y agoI hate the trivialization of this. The solution is not obvious. Paying more/longer requires more money. Where does that money come from? At least in my areas of science (chemistry), most of this money comes from grants, which comes from the NIH, DOE, or NSF depending on the project. Ultimately it comes from taxpayers, and portioned out by Congress. So the solution is either to get Congress to really care about this (ha!) or re-architecture funding of all of higher education. Neither of these is simple.
- maxerickson 4y agoThe fact that stakeholders don't like the solution doesn't make it complicated.
- InefficientRed 4y agoI hate the helplessness of this. You have agency. You also have responsibility. You have a chemistry phd. You don't have to build your career on other people's crushed financial futures. Either find a job where you can pay people well or find a job where you don't need to manage other people's labor to stay employed. I have A LOT of dubious pet projects I could convince NSF to fund and would love to work on if I had the moral stomach requires to convince highly educated broke 30 year olds to give me hundreds of thousands of dollars in free labor. But I don't. So instead I turned down TT offers and went to industry where I spend a lot of time convincing people with the money to actually pay living wages with good benefits to people who can work on slightly different things. I don't have a lab with my name on it. I don't have an office. I will never have tenure. No on calls me Professor or even Doctor. But I'm also not exploiting the shit out of 20-35 year olds. My post-docs are paid $100k-$200k. Stop relying on broke kids to fund your dreams. Leave academia and find a company who will fund your work. Or stay in academia and don't hire people to help you unless you can pay them even close to what they're worth.
- radicalbyte 4y agoNow would be a good time to donate all of the money spent on the administration instead on to paying postdocs well?
- trashtester 4y agoAgree. I would also prefer if universities focused their funds into subjects that leads to long term benefits, whether that is economic growth, better social cohesion (less polarization), etc. In other words: - More funding to STEM, at least the profitable parts. - More funding to the parts of humanities, socal science and law schools, who's work help bring the nation together, find common ground and reduce conflict. - Partly cut funding to institutions that do not provide such benefits, and to institutions with too much administrative overhead. - Completely cut funding to institutions that actively promote social conflicts. To make it easier to reach these goals, without interpreting each goal in a politcal light, change the funding process as follows: - Add an x% corporate tax, earmarked for science & education. - Set up a board, where representatives chosen by those companies that pay the above tax (proportionally to the tax paid) make up 60%, former highly trusted academics 20% and representatives chosen by the sitting government 20%. - Have this board govern the expenditure in the ways that maximize the benefits defined in the charter above, while having some checks and balances to prevent corruption. - Encourage grants to be given in larger chunks than today. Direct grants to students should be the exception, and not something a student would apply for. Rather such grants should be awarded in a similar way to how the military grants medals for exceptional performance. When a research leader identifies a particularly deserving candidate, he/she can recommend that this candidate is granted a special individual scholarship, due to exceptional performance and ability. Leaders who repeatedly send spurious recommendations should be discouraged from doing so. - Instead, institutions or high profile reasearch leaders should be given grants based on historical performance, and be trusted to be able to find the right students themselves. (Within some framework to prevent corruption.) - Once granted, funds should only be revoked in the case of breech of confidence. Renewal should happen early enough to allow continuity. The goal of the above proposals, would be: - Prevent public money from being wasted on wasteful or destructive activities - Reduce time spent on research grant applications, so that students and employees can focus on the actual science. - Encourage academic freedom and promote integrity. - Make sure institutions educate the kinds of students that are in demand in the job market, and the scientific results needed to promote economic growth as well as a more robust state.
- __jambo 4y agoI never know what to think about reports on labour demand anymore, I have heard "there are no jobs", "there are lots of jobs", "noone is working", simultaneously all year. I guess it all comes down to who is saying it. I guess most of the time it's the fact that the jobs are crap, but employers don't want to shift the social contract that creates the apparent contradiction, but who knows.
- adam_arthur 4y agoJob openings vs labor supply tells you most of what you need to know. Job openings exceed job seekers by a record amount. Unemployment is close to a record low.
- cs137 4y agoIn other words, the dysfunction (unemployment) on which capitalists rely, because it scares people into taking shitty deals, is a bit less of a problem... but it's also causing other dysfunctions, because it turns out that this is a shitty system.
- adam_arthur 4y agoWell, if you want uncontrolled inflation, keep advocating for policies that push unemployment below the rate of sustainable full employment. It seems to be making people happy, after all. Not like there are hundreds of years of economic history to learn from...
- xphilter 4y agoAh yes, people getting jobs is what caused inflation. Not the trillions printed and given to scammy upper classes through fraudulent PPP loans and artificially low interest rates.
- adam_arthur 4y agoIt's both. Do you think nominal wage gains coupled with real wage declines makes people happy? Check consumer sentiment polling which just hit an all time low, why don't you? It's funny to see society broadly reject the impact of covid era policy, yet some advocate to do more and more of it. Fed kept rates low in pursuit of unsustainably low unemployment, by the way, motivated by pressure from progressives
- chrisseaton 4y ago> Postdocs in general aren’t paid well Sounds like everyone understands the issue... so why don't they respond by meeting the market price? If you want to buy something like a tissue sample for an experiment in a lab then you pay the market price. You wouldn't think to offer 20% of the market price and then be puzzled when nobody will sell it to you - you just pay the going price, and it's part of the cost of doing research. Why don't people apply that logic when it comes to costs for hiring people? Why is it such a barrier to see that that's just how much a person costs?
- dagw 4y agoIf you want to buy something like a tissue sample for an experiment in a lab then you pay the market price Academic researchers often pay either zero or get a massive discount on all kinds of stuff (hardware, software, data, samples etc.) for their research that people in private sector pay a huge premium for.
- pacbard 4y ago> Academic researchers often pay either zero... Not completely accurate. Every time you get a grant, your institution get a percentage of it to pay for indirect costs. These costs include office space, office personnel, and other expenses that the grant doesn't pay for directly. So, if you are getting "free" stuff from the department closest, it is very likely that your (or some else's) indirect expenses are paying for it. Overhead percentages are set by each institution. My current one is set at 54%, meaning that for each $1 of award, I get to keep 64 cents and the university takes 36 cents (more or less).
- dagw 4y agoI was more referring to how Academic licensing is often cheap or free. For example a certain data set I'm working with right now is made available to us for free as researchers, but costs on the order of $200k to access if you're a commercial entity.
- Spooky23 4y ago
- refurb 4y agoSupply and demand. We produce more PhDs than needed by either academia or industry. Hence, the burden of post-docs just grow (I was talking to a biology PhD who said 5-6 years of post-doc was typical, for chemistry I've seen people do 2).
- chrisseaton 4y ago> We produce more PhDs than needed by either academia or industry. I don't think so - industry can't hire enough PhDs. In my field (programming languages) shortage of qualified people is a bit of a problem at the moment! We wish there were more being produced.
- jonsen 4y agoShortage of qualified people does not imply shortage of PhDs.
- chrisseaton 4y agoA PhD is the most common way to gain the experience and context needed to work professionally on compilers. If there aren't many PhDs, then the supply of people with the experience needed in practice is going to be low, even if there are also people without PhDs who can do it.
- jonsen 4y agoI think we were better off trying to raise the percentage of PhDs who are qualified, rather than just increasing the number of PhDs.
- quantumwannabe 4y agoNo university class teaches modern compilers and the state of the art is in open source projects. If someone is interested in compilers, they don’t need to get a PhD in order to learn. Many major companies that maintain programming languages do not require PhDs in order to work on their compiler teams; they are willing to train you on the job. The supply of people interested is just low in general, and if you are biased towards people with PhDs and preexisting experience for junior hires, of course you will find a shortage of workers.
- blackbear_ 4y agoPhD student looking forward to graduate and move on. I think one can make a decent living with a German salary, which is still 50% lower than an industry position, the reason why I want to leave is the insane competitiveness and inherent up-or-out structure of academia. If I could have a permanent position with the same salary I currently get I would seriously consider staying.
- kmmlng 4y agoThe lack of almost any permanent positions aside from full professorships in the German research landscape is truly ridiculous. What does that get you? A whole bunch of inexperienced PhD students with one professor at the top who cannot possibly find the time to adequately supervise them all / steer the research in useful directions.
- martopix 4y agoSame in Switzerland. In the UK (where I did my PhD) it was quite a bit better imho.
- jarenmf 4y agoI'm currently a postdoc in Germany, to be honest, it seems that only people who can't find a job in the industry are staying in academia. I've never met a postdoc who was happy about what they are doing, everyone one is thinking of an escape plan.
- bachmeier 4y agoMy impression (from the inside of the university) is that academia is simply not a great employment option these days. There's an attitude on the inside that those who have academic jobs have won the lottery. No doubt, in a few fields that's still the case, but academic jobs are mostly bad working conditions and low pay combined with limited job security. It was trending in that direction for many years, but the pandemic was a major structural change. You should consider any kind of academic job as a backup rather than a destination.
- Moggie100 4y agoCurrent UK CompSci PostDoc here - and yeah, pretty much what everyone says here is correct. My contract is 'contingent on funding' (so casual/short-term by any other name, but 'perminant' so HR can fudge their short-term employment numbers down) and my pay is well below what I could get in the wider industry. I stay because I'd like to think I can improve things (I'm very active in management talks, where I can be) but as we're now at 6 (? Maybe 7) years of below-inflation pay adjustments, and with no progression possible at my grade unless I make the leap to lecturer or equivalent I'm just stuck here and its getting tiresome, and every year I look at my bank and go 'why am I doing this?'. One day I'll stop asking why and leave, but I like what I do - its just not economical. ... and for the curious, I've made the case for promotion and applied for it a number of times, but as no-one ever retires in the industry (profs forever?) the next grade up is stupidly over-subscribed, so my chances are extremely low.
- titanomachy 4y ago
- jzer0cool 4y agoI think there are certain "fundings" that could be higher or lower depending on the project commensurate with hiring with high pay. Post-docs should be paid well in my opinion. They are our future leaders, educators, innovators, and to me, the ones who teach "how" to fish. The same goes for salary in certain fields in teaching. Something seems backwards.
- biophysboy 4y agoThe quote from a prof upset that they only received 28 applicants in about 6 months is pretty rich to read, as someone who is in currently a PhD student. They should be delighted so many people want a job with indefinite length, uncertain prospects, and very little pay. I just recently got a post doc offer from someone, which I will almost certainly turn down because I know the reality: academia sucks, science is great. For years, people have put up with the former to enjoy the latter, but I think we are hitting a threshold.
- april_22 4y agoI think what really changed is that people who have a PhD nowadays certainly also have great coding skills and the latter is so much more attractive job wise
- Master_Odin 4y agoFair number of the CS PhD students I knew while I was there were not good coders, with professors being even worse at it. There's no incentive to write good code, just that it "functions".
- ev1 4y agoI would always dread new teammates that were 100% academia with no industry experience or real project experience. More often than not if you leave them alone for a bit you come back to functions with several dozen one character parameters or something equally odd. Really uncertain why this is, but this has consistently happened multiple times and it's always this type of situation.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- derbOac 4y agoYes, the whole article is sort of tone deaf: it's like they see a problem but not the actual problem. It's very typical of the whole thing: complaints without actually doing the painful work of restructuring things, because that would cause too much inconvenience for the people who have benefited. So we have these discussions about pay and supply and demand, which is part of it, but not the nature of the positions themselves, the ponzi funding scheme underlying it, the status hierarchies, none of it. No one wants to cut or line-item justify indirect funds, or turn those postdocs into faculty positions. The last place I was at this issue came up about being able to have grad students without funding: the argument was if you can't fund them off of grants you shouldn't have them. On the surface, this sounds great, pretty reasonable, until you realize that now you're incentivizing taking grad students to support grants, rather than as an end in itself. Basically you're incentivizing a permanent student culture, because the expected lifecycle of the researcher is maybe 30 years, whereas the student is expected to only be there maybe 5 in theory. It's so hard for me to wrap my head around it it: the best analogy maybe really is a ponzi scheme. The desired product is the input. It's so broken in so many ways. It's like no one is actually paying for research, they're paying for attracting students, attracting the money to pay for the research, the trappings of research, etc. That actual useful research gets done is a convenient side effect.
- slurpmaker 4y agoMake it make sense. Offer Postdocs an actual career path not based on broken tenure and disposable adjunct professor roles, with hundreds if not thousands of applicants. Why would someone, with any field of study, be a "scum of the earth" post doc for 1/5th the salary and double the hours required as a junior python developer role? Moreso, post doc'ing for the wrong professor can ruin your career, why risk that either? If the pay isn't good, the culture and work should be. In academia, that's almost never true. I couldn't support my family, nor ironically pay my families student loan payments as a post-doc, the decision was an easy one to make... But if I were really doing it for the love, the love isn't there. You might think "oh here's an industry person who doesn't like academia", wrong. I loved research, writing papers, teaching people stuff, forming collaborations, etc. Just can't make it survivable financially or psychologically.
- jjoonathan 4y ago"There's a shortage of Lamborghinis!" "Oh? At which price point?" "At the $4000 price point! It's a travesty!"
- plaguepilled 4y agoThat is a perverse misreading of the original comment. Calling a livable wage and fair working conditions a Lamborghini is not applicable.
- TheTacoMerchant 4y agoI think the comment was comparing good post-doc researchers to Lamborghinis. Makes sense as the academic are not offering enough ($4000) for it to make sense.
- CobrastanJorji 4y agoIn this metaphor, the postdoc is the Lamborghini, the speaker is the employer bemoaning the difficulty of acquiring a postdoc/Lamborghini for an unreasonable price point, and the $4000 is the unreasonable price point.
- JOnAgain 4y ago“Money is just sitting there that isn’t being used … and there’s these projects that aren’t moving anywhere as a result,” What money?!? Lol. Headline should read, “People with 10 years post-secondary education not applying to jobs paying less than corporate entry level jobs.”
- bjourne 4y agoI think Western academia is mostly reliant on immigration. Few natives would accept the low pay/high workload combination that is a postdoc, but for an immigrant from a third world country it might be an amazing opportunity. Same reason most fruit and berry pickers also are immigrants.
- persedes 4y agoDon't even know where to begin...but according to this [1] less than 5% of students in the US are international students. 1 - https://www.fwd.us/news/international-students/ https://www.fwd.us/news/international-students/
- vpb 4y ago"And even though they make up only 5% of the total student population, international students earned nearly half of all Master’s and Doctor’s STEM degrees awarded in 2019, a total of 117,000 degrees." That's an interesting stat which might be the source of the parent post assertion.
- bmitc 4y agoThat is either for undergraduates or total enrollment. The percentages for international students in graduate schools basically range from 50% upwards, depending on the field. https://www.forbes.com/sites/stuartanderson/2021/08/19/international-students-remain-a-primary-source-of-us-tech-talent/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/stuartanderson/2021/08/19/inter...
- snakeboy 4y agoWe're talking about postdocs though, which is a completely different population than college students. I found this [1] which estimates that 51% of US postdocs are foreign-born as of 2018. [1] https://elifesciences.org/articles/40189 https://elifesciences.org/articles/40189
- bjourne 4y ago"The dearth of Americans is even more pronounced in hot STEM fields like computer science, which serve as talent pipelines for the likes of Google, Amazon, Facebook and Microsoft: About 64 percent of doctoral candidates and almost 68 percent in master’s programs last year were international students, according to an annual survey of American and Canadian universities by the Computing Research Association. In comparison, only about 9 percent of undergraduates in computer science were international students (perhaps, deans posit, because families are nervous about sending offspring who are barely adults across the ocean to study)." https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/03/education/edlife/american-graduate-student-stem.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/03/education/edlife/american... Note that the definition of "international student" excludes those with permanent visas. The number of foreign born PhD students is therefore significantly higher than 64%. Don't know if there are any stats for citizen/non-citizen share of PhDs though.
- edge17 4y agoIs this situation also reflected in gradschool and phd applications, or is it as competitive as ever?
- titaniumrain 4y ago4,5 years as a PhD student, then 2,3 years as a postdoc then 5 more years to get tenured... modern slavery isn't it?
- CoastalCoder 4y agoOne can freely leave at any time, so I don't think this counts as slavery.
- fullshark 4y agoJust a reflection of how desperate people are to get a shot at the final prize: tenured professor. You see this type of competition and desperation in a lot of fields with highly prized superstar occupations (successful musician, pro athlete, etc)
- MontyCarloHall 4y ago>Postdoc salaries are frequently based on what the U.S. National Institutes of Health sets as its standard, “and that’s pretty low,” says Daniel Wolf Savin, a physicist and senior research scientist at Columbia University who is currently struggling to fill five postdoc positions. When hiring, he competes with national labs that offer up to $20,000 more per year in salary. “If we put in a research grant with a postdoc salary that they pay at a national lab, the program office is going to look at it and say, ‘Look, I can’t give you this much money. It’s so out of line with what everyone else is asking for,’” he says. I never understood why there are salary guidelines in the first place. Why should a lab with $200k/year to spend on postdoc salaries be unable to hire a single postdoc at $200k/year? Current guidelines stipulate the lab must instead hire 4 postdocs at $50k/year. At the end of the day, research quality is what matters. The research output of a single excellent postdoc worth $200k/year could easily exceed the total output of four mediocre postdocs each worth $50k/year.
- valarauko 4y ago> Why should a lab with $200k/year to spend on postdoc salaries be unable to hire a single postdoc at $200k/year? Current guidelines stipulate the lab must instead hire 4 postdocs at $50k/year. The article pretty much answers this. It's impossible to convince the program office that a postdoc is worth $200K/year - that's substantially more than the PI himself probably makes. In reality, the program office will majorly push back if you ask for 10k more than the going rate. You can swing $5k more for a postdoc with some years of postdoc experience, but not more than that. Given the way the contractual relationship of postdocs are setup, it's actually hard to find mediocre postdocs that survive in the system. Mediocre postdocs would be fired soon enough and a bright fresh PhD from China or India would take their place who's willing to work at $50k/year. That bright Chinese or Indian postdoc cannot easily accept a better paying industry job due to the nature of work visas for those countries so will work as a postdoc for several years till they can finagle a green card.
- 11101010001100 4y agoWhere do they find these professors to give these statements? At the very least, ask when the professors were postdocs, were they happy with their salary and benefits?
- rr888 4y agoThis is always a problem when the economy is strong. Just wait for a recession next year and there will be long lines of people wanting to get into grad school.
- bmitc 4y agoHonestly, there are just too many PhDs and too much glorification of PhDs. Academia is just far too inefficient as well. I have no idea where all the money that’s being moved around is going. My other thought is that maybe companies that pay little taxes but hire a lot of PhDs should maybe be looked at. Corporations have been extremely successful in outsourcing training to higher education, online learning, and other learning avenues, all off of their books and timesheets.
- feet 4y agoThere's a bunch of glorification of physicians too, who are essentially repair techs for people
- throwawayarnty 4y agoSorry to sound elitist, but no reasonable phd graduate that wants to pursue academia would ever want to do their PhD at Clemson university. Only possible exception would be that PI has done Nobel prize level work or the candidate has personal reasons to be in South Carolina. For perspective postdocs, it’s not about money, job security, or job environment . It’s first and foremost potential to be a leader in their field. Plenty of phd graduates are willing to postdoc at MIT or work with a Nobel laureate for starvation wages and intense work environments. Clemson university just can’t compete.
- jkqwzsoo 4y agoThis is "saying the quiet part out loud" in academia. For engineering undergrad, your in-state university (ABET accredited) will usually be your best cost/benefit option (unless you're going to MIT, Stanford, or, for CS only, CMU). For grad school, I believe you'd want to think very carefully about the opportunity cost (and what you want your PhD for) before going anywhere outside of the top 20 (or even top 15) schools in your program. For a postdoc, where your opportunity cost is even higher, I think you need to be in the top 10 (or top 5) for it to be worth it. There's no reason to do a postdoc at any school outside of the top 10 in your field unless, as you point out, you're working for an exceptionally well-regarded PI who is particularly going to be able to move your career in your desired path. The people who do postdocs at these institutions are usually foreign, for whom a US postdoc is gold. Come to think of it, I can't recall ever interacting with a university postdoc who was a US citizen -- I've only worked for one "PI-generating PI", who happens to not like hiring postdocs.
- bertday 4y agoPostdocs are sometimes used as a mechanism to play games with tenure rather than getting the an academic job. You get a publication “head start” without invoking the countdown, and you already often have a future job in hand early.
- throwawayarnty 4y agoAcademia beyond postdoc is so competitive that even being in top 5 school is not enough information to decide whether it is a good idea. Even within Harvard, the percentage of postdocs getting faculty positions is low. One needs to calculate essentially how likely you will get a top publication in that lab. The arithmetic is something like for a research group, what is the average number of top publications per year per postdoc. Many top labs at Harvard don’t do well with this metric because they have like 20 postdocs and 1 top paper a year. Another metric is what fraction of postdocs end up in good faculty jobs.
- gww 4y agoIn addition to terrible compensation, I think another common issue for a post-doc is that they are not afforded the same protections as a graduate student. In the places I have worked the grad students are usually protected by the university, their committees, etc. Post-docs on the other hand are usually contract workers and they can be fired without any recourse. Usually with two to four weeks compensation. It gives their bosses tremendous power. I know post-docs who have been fired for questioning a PI or a paper they are part of. This can be devastating for a post-doc and their future career. They may have toiled years on a project and can have it taken away on a dime.
- whimsicalism 4y agoInteresting. I know graduate students at my alma mater are now unionized, I wonder if that can cover post docs as well.
- gww 4y agoI think some places do have post doc unions and it is sometimes combined with graduate student unions. However, in the places I have been it sadly does not exist.
- PlasmonOwl 4y agoI'm in the UK and am a PDRA in polymer chemistry. Desperate to get out. Would like to transfer to some type of coding. Pay and job security is far better. Just trying to work if I can manage with pay cut to a more junior role. It's not that I'm unsuccessful, I published plenty and work at a top institute. It's just that the jump from PDRA to permanent is impossible and I'm not interested in industrial chemistry
- notjustanymike 4y agoI've worked with a few chemists turned engineers, for some reason you lot always take to coding fantastically well. I suspect any pay cut you take would be quite temporary.
- alangibson 4y agoInteresting observation. I wonder if it's because chemical reactions read a lot like function calls. Complex reactions look a lot like programs written in some arcane language
- vt85 4y agoWelcome to the results of Leftists taking over the Academia. Coming soon to the whole country. And then - civil war, of course. As EVERY time.
- qayxc 4y agoWait, so back in 1861 - the first and last time a civil war erupted in the US - it was due to Leftist taking over academia and then the whole country? Interesting. Or maybe you are from Europe, where civil war has a long tradition. But maybe you insist that it was "Leftists" back in 130 BCE in the Roman Empire. The 8th century Chinese general An Lushan was a Leftist as well? Good to know. The "Roundheads" in the English parliament back in 1642 were basically commies as well, whereas the royalists "Cavaliers" were the level-headed ones - I mean what's not to love about absolutism, "All hail the King!" and all that. The Portuguese back in 1832 must have been Leftists as well; I just need to find out which of the royal brothers was the commie. But yeah, sure. EVERY time with the god damned leftists!
- lqr 4y agoIn CS right now, people with a very strong PhD can go straight to the tenure track. I took a postdoc because my PhD is solid but I jumped around topics a lot, so it's not quite coherent enough. My postdoc is also at a more prestigious institute. I'm rolling the dice that it might be enough to get that tenure track job. But I also have no dependents and don't care about material possessions very much. If my situation were a little bit different, it would be foolish to do what I'm doing.
- jarenmf 4y agoEvery post-doc I know is plotting an escape plan, some are learning web development, some are learning data science or system administration, heck, there is even special bootcamps now for postdocs evading academia
- clircle 4y agoPhD students are just reacting to market conditions. This all sounds really good to me.
- balanoceous 4y agoI am a post-doc in one of the ivory towers. I've been in the system a long time (technician, MD, PhD, residency, fellowship, now post doc). Jeez! I am a computational immunologist who studies cancer immunotherapy, if it matters. I am not independently wealthy or blah blah. I am a normal everyday person. I agree academia is nonsensical for the many reasons that are frequently discussed in HN. Mine is not a perspective I see represented here often: I absolutely love my job as a post doc. Everyone is different - I get a lot of joy from my work. Most of my friends in science at different stages feel more or less the same (albeit everyone complains). I could get paid 10x more or work half as much, maybe both at the same time. So to answer the question here, why do people do this? Cuz I like it. Don't make everything so complicated (as an academic, that is my job).
- 2b3a51 4y agoGood for you. Would the pay scales below for post-doc positions be about rightish or make you laugh hysterically? https://www.crick.ac.uk/careers-study/postdocs https://www.crick.ac.uk/careers-study/postdocs https://www.imperial.ac.uk/human-resources/pay-and-pensions/salaries/research/ https://www.imperial.ac.uk/human-resources/pay-and-pensions/... Just to put a rough scale on things
- balanoceous 4y agoRelative to my salary as a board certified physician in private practice, I take about a 10x pay cut. I guess since I sling code/data I take a pretty nice pay cut relative to that also. Whoops!
- throwawayarnty 4y agoI think the main issues with postdoc even if it’s enjoyable is that there is an expiry date to how long one can postdoc. Even if you enjoy postdoc, some places won’t let you stay for more than 4 or 5 years. If permanent postdoc positions existed, I am sure many people would view it favourably, especially if the lab is a good environment.
- option 4y agoPostdocs don’t make sense. Once you get PhD, you should be able to find faculty or industry job.
- rschachte 4y agoMy partner is a post doc with an Ivy League background. If I wasn’t in tech she would essentially be eating Ramen and living in a box to survive. The structure is such bullshit. Incentive to get a postdoc is super low IMO. You make 50k after 10+ years of training and publications and are treated like a second class citizen. They need to offer more money and better benefits with an actual path for growth.
- jsiaajdsdaa 4y agoProfessors struggling to recruit slaves in high cost of living areas who will willingly give away x years of lucrative salary elsewhere?
- pkaye 4y ago> For instance, academic administrators and policymakers may want to ask, “How can we make postdoc positions more attractive? They could start by firing a few administrators and spread the savings on better pay for the postdocs.
- alfor 4y agoAcademia is mostly a bureaucratic scam at this point. So many research lab have zero impact on the real world. I think most of the useful research happen in corporation now.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- epvgwwqe 4y agoI did a postdoc at a top 5 institution and found it to be an ideal transition point into the startup world. I was pretty sure a few months into it that I would leave academia, and spent as much time as possible beefing up my coding skills and doing a startup on the side/finding a cofounder. I even hedged my bets and applied for tenure track jobs in the meantime. This may not work for everyone but it was definitely better than doing a full time industry job during those years which would have made any substantial entrepreneurial activities much harder to do on the side, and not nearly as good for networking.
- titanomachy 4y agoI'm pretty sure that most of what's said in this article doesn't apply to "top 5" universities. There will always be people willing to put up with a couple years of shitty pay in exchange for being able to work with a Nobel laureate and put "MIT" on their resume.
- misterkrabs 4y ago> Graduate students are also listening to postdocs, who in recent years have become increasingly vocal about the precarious nature of their positions and the challenges of getting by on a postdoc salary This is exactly what saved me. I was an undergraduate research assistant and our postdoc warned me.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- alpineidyll3 4y agoThe end of Chinese immigration will force change on this issue, it will be great for science and humanity.
- screye 4y agoI have always seen Postdocs as a 'desperation' position. The struggle to recruit post-docs might indicate healthier alternatives for phds instead of living life as white-collar slaves. I am surprised that universities haven't created formal part-academia-part-industry partnerships with nearby companies just yet. Instead we are stuck with post-docs and adjunct roles, which get you the worst of both worlds. Good Riddance.
- quantum_magpie 4y ago>I am surprised that universities haven't created formal part-academia-part-industry partnerships with nearby companies just yet. These do exist. I was offered to do a so-called 'Industrial PhD' at University of Copenhagen, where you get funded by a company, you do research split between university labs and the company labs, and work at the company at the same time. Should be noted that the time crunch is brutal, as you have the standard 3 years to complete it, but also have to work part time.
- titanomachy 4y agoDoes the "industry work" part of it produce publishable research that could be used towards a thesis?
- quantum_magpie 4y agoUsually yes, but there are always exceptions.
- pvaldes 4y agoPublish your hardly earned knowledge is directly against the interests of most private companies. The smart people in industry don't do it, unless they need a government pass, or at least keep the best parts for themselves.
- cycomanic 4y agoIronically when I was a postdoc in Australia, where you get paid on the same (good) payscale as other academics (you could even be promoted to professor level on a non permanent "postdoc" position), industry managers (from collaborators) always complained about the high salaries, which made it less attractive for people to move to industry. Since I moved to Sweden I see much more issues trying to recruit postdocs. We still get reasonable number of applicants, but they are very low quality. We have been hiring PhD instead, who are much better generally (most of the postdoc applicants for positions where we looked for both, wouldn't have made the cut amongst the PhDs). I blame that on several factors, 1. We are in a research area where our PhDs can go to industry earning 6 figures (at least in the US) so many opportunities for them if they look around 2. An increasing percentage of funding comes from competitive grants, so there are lots of postdoc positions. So even if applicants want to stay in academia if they are good they can be very picky. 3. A more general frustration with funding processes and universities continuously increasing academic workload, which academics are more open about. So PhDs see the downsides of sticking around more clearly. I should say that I agree with the article that all this is good because it might be the only way things will change
- photoelectric 4y agoHere's another perspective from a physicist in one of the less popular sub-fields (IE not quantum computing, high energy, etc.). I am currently coming to the end of my PhD and want to end up in industry later. However, I am going to do a postdoc for at least a year for a few reasons. Firstly, it is with a scientist that I work well with and is doing work that I believe in. They are a great boss and I take time off when I need it and without guilt. Second, the location is right and in an area I want to live in and eventually find jobs in. Lastly, the postdoc pays like $80k with benefits; less than I could make in ad-tech, etc. However, it is a decent amount to live well in the location. I'm also doing work on problems I choose and without a need to justify them. It's amazing to me that I can earn money doing this type of work at all. Plus the postdoc is meant to be a job-hunting exercise. I basically am getting paid a salary to do interesting work and shop around for a job and live in the area I want a job in. It's a win-win. Even my most anti-academia friends in my PhD program are considering doing this for similar reasons. I guess I am posting this because going through PhD I only ever heard complaints come through about the system (a lot of them valid IMHO). However, now that I'm making the decision it seems like I have a lot of great opportunities. Not that my field doesn't have its problems, but I wonder if the severe ones are concentrated elsewhere. I suppose there's hope out there if you're in the right field.
- zmachinaz 4y agoArticle misses the point. By now, the good students and post-docs know what is going on: The system is already so broken that there is a high chance that you end up with a PI who got his job because he/she/* is good in making friends with some VIPs. For the actual research, that is what you are hired for. Have fun turning the "great vision" of these PIs into something that makes at least a bit of sense. And only if you are as well the type to make friends with VIPs, you will have a chance to tenure-track.
- seydor 4y agoAcademia is a despotic, anachronistic system. There needs to be a movement to break education and research out of academic institutions. There are enough online resources to provide free education to anyone who wishes it, and nobody should have to pay for a degree (instead; students should be paid; it's in the interest of society). Funding and licensing of science needs to open up to anyone who desires it, in order to become productive again. The current system is optimized to create busybodies who oversell their work for a few years before dumping it and moving on to their next scam. Postdocs are victims of their own delusion that working in academia is somehow superior to working in any other way.
- toddm 4y agoMy experience through 2 postdoctoral appointments was quite pleasant. The pay was low and I lived in high COL places, but I knew that going into it. In return, I met and worked with and for some brilliant people and was exposed to interesting research.
- mbaytas 4y ago> “Ph.D.s are looking at the labor market, seeing opportunities out there, and taking them,” she says. “Those skills that we teach our Ph.D. students are in demand.” LoL. Among all the stereotypes in academia perhaps the truest one is profs taking credit for what their students achieve. Not even bothering to hide it anymore.
- physicsguy 4y agoOh yeah, I wonder why people aren’t biting off the hand of academics for 6-12 month contracts with no control over what type of project you’d actually work on in many labs. And of course the salaries haven’t kept up with the rest of the job market.
- throwaway24124 4y agoI graduated college in 2018, and, even though I majored in Neuroscience and wanted to do computational neuroscience research, that there was just no way I could accept the working conditions + cost of grad school, PhD, and postdoc life. It seemed like a terrible deal then, even as a young student who ONLY wanted to do research. Learning software engineering and breaking into the industry was SO much easier than continuing my education, and while I don't regret it, I have to imagine the deal has only gotten worse. The only people I still know doing research are fully funded by their parents, and even then most of them have dropped out for easier jobs. Cannot imagine the brain-drain that is happening across the US right now.
- pvaldes 4y agoDesign your letter in the most aseptic and unfunny way possible. Extra points if is in a foreign language to show that you are cool people. The problem to solve is less important than all this marvelous crispy sounds when is spelled Use a lot of trendy terms and fancy words. Your project to improve the texture of the mayonaise must sound like Bruce Willis in Armageddon. The more confusing, holistic and superfood, the better. Stress that you want really motivated candidates. The job is boring as hell so they need to came yet motivated from home. They will not grow professionally here. Assure that the job is available only in a narrow interval of time. Much better if is in the time when everybody is posting job offers and competing for your attention. Biology shows us that fishes in a school are safer from being noticed individually. Reject people that stopped for three years working on science. They could need to spend an entire afternoon to read and understand everything that happened in their field in the last three years. Yup, the whole nine articles. You don't want to use their previous decades of experience and university classes. For a better measure go to the corridor and run screaming "a gap!, a curriculum gap!" in terror Use deadlines in your profit. Assure to email your job offer two or three days after the closing time has expired. Don't be concise, your candidates love to spend ten minutes reading about vanity issues, the history of your building and why the bricks are violet. Ask they to write an essay about how your project was their dream since school. Put the salary hidden in a link. Better if this leads to twenty pages of bureaucracy before. Use several categories for your job offer to reduce the probability of a match. Use fancy names like "Ramon y Cajal" position or "Juan de la Cierva" offer to made it seem more relevant. Then put your job only in one of them. Example: We look for a biochemist for a Sara Borrel thing, requisites: having less than 30 years, visited the Tibet in the last year and be a natural blonde more than 6 feet tall. Their field of research does not matter. "Oh, you studied exactly the same thing but you look more like a `Juan de la Cierva' to me. Maybe the next year". Your job application must be a turning point in their life. Assure to ask the lab rats to spend all the day filling a job application so complex that would made Kafka proud. A real example: Looking for somebody to work in city X. Requisites. Can't live currently in city X (that would be so easy, and yes, is a real example from a real job offer). Assure that your selection process to hire scientists has a 70% of questions related with laws, 10% about ideology, and the rest about the real work to do.
- qgin 4y agoWages get set by supply and demand. In the past, there were still people lined up around the block for limited academic positions. Now thats not working, so something has to give if they want to fill those positions.
- jleyank 4y agoWhy would anybody postdoc in cs or anything software related if they weren’t interested in being a professor? It’s a field where people can literally come from nowhere and make a big impact. It’s not like chemistry or physics where labs are involved or have steep learning curves to be able to function. Is this just being unwilling to engage? Why would people remain in a training role in todays environment?
- dontbenebby 4y agoWell part of it is fields not meant to have post docs use them as a way to avoid hiring tenure track folks. Post-docs are meant for the physical sciences, where you can need a few years to learn the physical mechanics of research in a field like biology, chemistry, physics, or other "hard" sciences. But as a side effect of decisions folks were coerced into making during the last recession, many fields like CS which require very little physical labor now also use post-docs. Often a post doc is just something given to a sub par PhD student who coasted on the work of others graduates from a "prestigous" program until they can author a few papers ACTUALLY on their own. On my end, I deeply regret not backpacking around SE Asia doing English lessons the past ten years -- I'd probably be happier, healthier, and have a bigger bank account than the path I took instead. (Aborted PhD -> terrible NGO -> terrible nonprofit -> piecemeal consulting paired with a Bellingcat certification) If I were going to attempt a PhD a second time, I'd probaby do it in the EU where they clearly define success criteria from the outset, and I'd probably do it after obtaining an EU passport. (I should not have to consider getting a second passport to find work with my skillset, but people sometimes are stupid enough to interview me, refuse to take my advice, then get butthurt when the Russians skullfuck their servers or their bank goes out of business because they decided to be cute and treat an interview as a free consulting session, but not actually listen to anything I said.)
- ikrenji 4y agolack of funding + way too many people doing phds = shitty job market. there is at least 10x more phds than the current system can comfortably sustain. i would love to see the budgets 10x and salaries 2x but since there is a fat chance of that happening i would recommend everyone to steer clear of academia...
- mbrodersen 4y agoWhy would anybody want to become an academic? Low pay, crazy politics and bureaucracy, long hours, constantly chasing grants, the threat of lawsuits from students who might “feel violated” by something you say, the demand to increase your external funding every year, the routine science malpractice, the very low chance that anybody will actually read the papers you produce etc. etc.
- PeterStuer 4y agoThe toxic divisive culture reported at most academic institution is suspiciously absent in this piece. Yet anecdotally it comes up a lot in talks about why people were not keen to stay in academia.