5 ms·
Not lead pipe safe, don't think touch ID cares if your hand is attached to your body. might still do it.
by ggm 4y ago
Not lead pipe safe, don't think touch ID cares if your hand is attached to your body.
might still do it.
- polycaster 4y agoOn the other hand: Neither does password authentication check if it were your fingers typing.
- ggm 4y agoWell played. You have your finger on the pulse.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- synu 4y agoHow is your password safe from someone threatening you with a lead pipe?
- throwaway287391 4y agoI suppose if you value your privacy over your well-being/existence you can perhaps resist giving up your password (not so with a fingerprint). Or maybe you could set up a "suicide pill" alternate password that wipes/bricks the machine when entered if you wanted to deprive your future self of the opportunity to relent as the torture escalates... (Edit: I guess the latter is also doable via fingerprint if a different finger is used as the suicide pill, seems a bit risky for normal use though!)
- gattilorenz 4y ago> you could set up a "suicide pill" alternate password By... rewriting or modding sudo AND the login screen of macOS? Doesn't seem like a realistic option.
- throwaway287391 4y agoYeah it was more theoretical speculation, probably not doable on Mac (and I don't see Apple adding this feature tbh). I wouldn't be surprised if someone's implemented something like that in Linux though.
- Sebb767 4y agoIt's actually quite simple and readily available with PAM duress [0] (at least on Linux, I'm not sure about PAM on Mac). It was also discussed here already [1]. Still, you should consider that doing so might not work in your favor, especially if the fact that you used a duress code becomes obvious. [0] https://github.com/nuvious/pam-duress https://github.com/nuvious/pam-duress [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28267975 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28267975
- sebzim4500 4y agoIf you're in the US than the cops can't force you to give up your password but they can force you to unlock your phone with your finger. I think that's far more important.
- synu 4y agoWhat’s the connection with the lead pipe threat?
- ggm 4y agoLike a password, fingerprints offer no high barrier to entry if you are under physical threat or control. The connection is that if you think your password is at risk to lead pipe attack, a touch entry won't fix it.
- prvit 4y agoOkay, but if the cops get to the sudo prompt they already have access to all of your data...
- dividedbyzero 4y agoOne option is to protect the master password with a security LARP scheme that's so complex and unwieldy that no sane attacker will believe you when you tell the truth. Like, Shamir's secret sharing, but the fourth part can only be passed via a Ballet choreography. Also, the sixth Yubikey is biometric and will only work with a latex fake of the right pinky prepared by this exact recipe. The final part of the password is the statistical expected value of this slightly unfair die, obtained after 10 000 throws, to the third digit.
- rvieira 4y ago(I'm joking, but curious) How difficult would it be to implement and oximiter-like sensor along with touch id, to at least make sure blood is pumping through the finger?
- wyager 4y agoIt's unclear to me if Touch ID already ignores dead tissue. I can find some reputable sources claiming it does, but there seems to be a lack of consensus. > Mashable repeatedly asked Apple, Google, and Samsung for comment on the matter, but received not a single response to our numerous inquiries. We also reached out to a host of biometric security experts, hackers, digital law experts, and forensic pathologists in an attempt to get to the bottom of what has passed from the realm of dark thought experiment to serious inquiry, but the responses (or lack thereof) only further muddied the waters. The articles I find claiming touch ID rejects dead fingers seem to be written by people who have no idea what they're talking about, so I would not take claims about its liveness guarantees (hah) seriously. People mostly seem to be confusing credible claims about rejecting e.g. pictures of fingerprints with incredible claims about detecting if a piece of tissue is alive or not.
- 2Gkashmiri 4y agoheh, i watched a video about putting a carrot in an oximeter and it showed a reading. i swept that as covid costcutting making shoddy equipment but i had a 2016 bought oximeter and i saw 50-60% saturation on a carrot and mind=blown. the problem is, you cant really say "ignore less than 70% saturation as that is most probably a carrot" because covid patients got as low as 50% so i don't know what to make of it
- zwog 4y agoI don't know about smartphones and Macbooks, but biometric access control systems in buildings and such usually measure at least the body temperature.
- Gigachad 4y agoWhy does it matter? They could already unlock the laptop with Touch ID. Now they can also install drivers?