5 ms·
Making the collective knowledge of chemistry open and machine actionable
- ur-whale 4y agoThis kind of endeavor should be a common theme to all science, not just chemistry.
- shpongled 4y agoIt's certainly a goal to work towards. However, it's pretty difficult to build One ELN to Rule Them All given how flexible many kinds of biological experimental designs are - especially when you're working on the bleeding edge. A good first step is to require supplemental materials are published in a machine readable format (e.g. not manually thrown together Excel files that lack any kind of normalization or rational schema)
- ur-whale 4y agoBut then there are things like GPT-3 , which means stashing everything in a rigid schema isn't as hard-core of a requirement as it used to be. OTOH, facilitating: 1. access to the raw data 2. access to the metadata 3. access to the source code of whatever software was used / created to run the experiment 4. making sure everything is computer readable (i.e. not a 256x128 graph as a PNG embedded in a bloody PDF) should be a requirement for any scientific publication worth its salt.
- abraxaz 4y ago> it's pretty difficult to build One ELN to Rule Them All given how flexible many kinds of biological experimental designs are - especially when you're working on the bleeding edge. RDF is quite flexible and using a combination of domain specific ontologies like cheminf[1] and other top level ontologies like BFO[2] should allow you to capture most of the semantics. [1]: https://www.ebi.ac.uk/ols/ontologies/cheminf https://www.ebi.ac.uk/ols/ontologies/cheminf [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_Formal_Ontology?wprov=sfti1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_Formal_Ontology?wprov=sf...
- RationPhantoms 4y agoIt would be wonderful to see something like the Materials Project (https://materialsproject.org/ https://materialsproject.org/) but for Chemical research/knowledge.
- gtmitchell 4y agoChemist here. Every few years, someone has the novel idea that we should have open data for all chemistry laboratories, so then we can do Better Science. And like every other proposal I've seen, this one will get approximately zero traction because it doesn't address any of the core issues behind why laboratory data is currently closed. I try not to be too pessimistic about it, because it really would be great if there were more open chemical data. I just really doubt anything could accomplish that without remaking the US university research system from top to bottom.
- bjelkeman-again 4y agoWhat are the core issues?
- mint2 4y agoProbably dealing with enough meta data to capture the stuff like the reaction only works because the supplier of one of the reagents used by that lab had ppm copper impurities
- gtmitchell 4y agoOff the top of my head: -Academic researchers are already overworked, underpaid, and undertrained. Asking them to spend even more of their time to meticulously upload all their notes and data to an electronic notebook is going to be an uphill battle. -Academic scientists live or die by their ability to publish. Open data, especially if you're sharing in real time, makes you vulnerable to being scooped by competing researchers. Even disclosures of data after the fact make it easier for others to benefit from work you did with no benefit to the ones who collected the data. Given how cut-throat academics is, you're also not going to get many researchers on board with this idea. -Interoperability of most laboratory software is poor. People have been trying to get laboratory instrument manufacturers to support open data standards for years with little success. They don't have any financial incentive to allow competitors to have easy access to their data.
- JPLeRouzic 4y ago
- pfisherman 4y agoGood luck with that...lol. The ontological / informatics space for chemicals is a mess. To make the collective knowledge of chemistry open and available, you need to represent, organize, and index it. This problem is not as sexy, but it is orders of magnitude more important.
- convolvatron 4y agothis is a huge problem. arguably one of the primary technical reasons that 'web 2.0' was such a dud.
- cellis 4y agoCan someone with more knowledge of Chemistry enlighten me why chemistry experimentation isn't the killer app for the Metaverse, at least for low-order reactions? I know the e.g. protein folding class of problems are prohibitively computationally expensive, but surely there's some low hanging fruit?
- photochemsyn 4y agoIf you're talking about computational modeling of chemical reactions, for example getting a computer to figure out a novel low-cost synthesis route for an important molecule, well... This becomes incredibly complicated very quickly. It's generally more likely to get a result using the traditional experimental methods, with some exceptions for very small molecules perhaps. The field of physical inorganic/organic chemistry is one of the more difficult ones to build accurate models for. A first step is to calculate the electronic structure of products, reactants, possible intermediaries, and this blows up fast for even moderately complex molecules. A lot of work has been done with simpler systems like 2 H2O -> 2 H2 + O2 but even that's ridiculously complicated, as you have to model the catalyst and the surrounding environment as well, and then get the kinetic model right. The computational power required is on the supercomputer scale, and the level of background knowledge required is pretty high to even start to implement something like that, for a taste see: https://h2awsm.org/capabilities/dft-and-ab-initio-calculations-water-splitting-including-real-time-time-dependent https://h2awsm.org/capabilities/dft-and-ab-initio-calculatio... This is an area where quantum computers may have applications (2021): https://www.energy.gov/science/ascr/articles/quantum-computing-enables-unprecedented-materials-science-simulations https://www.energy.gov/science/ascr/articles/quantum-computi...
- JPLeRouzic 4y agoCan someone in the field explain how this "machine actionnable" would be different from Galaxy Pipeline [0], or a Chemputer [1]? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galaxy_(computational_biology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galaxy_(computational_biology) [1] https://www.chem.gla.ac.uk/cronin/news/cronin-group-builds-chemputer-to-chemify-chemical-space/ https://www.chem.gla.ac.uk/cronin/news/cronin-group-builds-c...
- apienx 4y ago"Alchemists turned into chemists when they stopped keeping secrets." -- Eric S. Raymond Open Science (in the publishing sense) used to be fringe just a decade ago. It's very much mainstream now. Open Data will be a much tougher (and long-term) battle, but it's inevitable.
- statuslover9000 4y agoFor chemical reaction prediction, see the Open Reaction Database, a collaboration including the Coley lab at MIT (surprisingly not cited by OP): Paper: https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/jacs.1c09820 https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/jacs.1c09820 Docs: https://docs.open-reaction-database.org/en/latest/overview.html https://docs.open-reaction-database.org/en/latest/overview.h... It’s an incredible effort to collate and clean this data, and even then a substantial portion of it will not be reproducible due to experimental variability or outright errors. For computational methods development it’s extremely useful, maybe even necessary, to have a substantial amount of money and one’s own lab space to collect new data and experimentally test prospective predictions under tightly controlled conditions. The historical data is certainly useful but is not a panacea.
- mlinksva 4y agoRelatedly (and also not citing) from a couple weeks ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31566200 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31566200 Call for a Public Open Database of All Chemical Reactions
- photochemsyn 4y agoThe notion of open-source scientific discovery is a good one, but some of the suggestions here seem very unlikely to catch much traction, and even if they do, problems will remain. For example, say an academic chemical research group synthesizes a series of novel compounds in the lab - they're not going to just release the raw data on everything they did immediately. The thinking might be, 'we can give this MS student this compound to work out a better synthesis route for, or this pHD student can try to extend the synthesis and make other compounds'. A more realistic scenario mentioned in the article would be to require publication of the raw data to a database as a condition of publication. This is already done to some extent in journals, but materials and methods sections are notorious for leaving out some key factor or other, meaning repeatability is an issue and other labs will generally only try to replicate the more interesting results (possible new antibiotic, etc.). This worked out fairly well with GenBank, the database of published gene sequences, and also with the protein crystallography databases, but everyone in the molecular biology world knows that all sequence data is not of the same quality, and so cross-referencing by the more reputable researchers and reading their papers to see if their methods are transparent and robust or not is still an important step. A database clogged with low-quality data isn't as valuable as a more carefully curated one, certainly. It would be nice though, to have a database where you could look up everything there is to know about something like the antibiotic ciproflaxin, including all the spectral identification data, optimal reaction conditions, etc. - but this is also a molecule that researchers are busy making derivatives of, likely with the hopes of patenting some novel new knockoff and getting an exclusive license distribution deal with a major pharma corp, and so they won't be releasing any data, or even publishing in a timely manner (at least not until the patent application goes through, and maybe not even then). That leads to a controversial question: should research universities and academics financed by taxpayers behave like for-profit startups pitching to a VC outfit?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rwhomer 4y agoI'm surprised that no one mentioned RDKIT. It's an open source cheminformatics platform. It provides software to read and write multiple molecule file formats. It even has a chemical search feature implemented as a PostgreSQL extension. https://www.rdkit.org/ https://www.rdkit.org/