8 ms·
IBM ordered to hand over ex-CEO emails plotting cuts in older workers
- downrightmike 4y agoThey should extend protections to younger workers too. IBM has a lot of dirty tactics that wouldn't be legal if the workers were slightly older.
- geodel 4y agoAlso for middle aged workers. They are quite vulnerable lately.
- paxys 4y agoAge discrimination laws in the US only apply for older people. A company can legally discriminate against someone for being young and they can do nothing about it.
- hoppyhoppy2 4y agoI think that's exactly why the parent commenter would like those protections extended to other age groups.
- swagtricker 4y agoDefine "slightly older". The US Equal Opportunity Employment considers you part of the protected class against age discrimination if you're over 40 (see https://www.eeoc.gov/age-discrimination https://www.eeoc.gov/age-discrimination). Let's be honest, 40 is pretty much considered the entry point into "middle age".
- kube-system 4y agoThat’s more difficult, practically speaking, because youth often correlates with inexperience.
- bee_rider 4y agoThere are real business reasons not to invest in younger and older employees, why should we just protect one group? (we should protect both! Or better yet, everyone, no need to have some ever-narrowing gap around like 35 of unprotected people).
- kube-system 4y agoI'm not saying you shouldn't. I'm saying that you might not be able to practically do so. Anyone who doesn't want young employees will just `s/young/inexperienced/g` and thwart your law.
- dangus 4y agoIBM should be on everyone's "never work here" list along with companies like Amazon and Oracle. In my opinion, IBM only cares about patents, not actually solving any problems or accomplishing anything.
- throwaway98797 4y agothey make a lot of money they pay pretty well there are worse companies to work for
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThey have been earning less and less profit for the past 10 years, a time during which almost everyone else experienced explosive growth. That is going to make for poor quality of life at work. https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/IBM/ibm/net-income https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/IBM/ibm/net-income
- RickJWagner 4y agoIBM has done very well during the downturn. Probably has to do with the nice dividend. https://www.marketwatch.com/story/why-ibm-is-one-of-few-tech-giants-that-are-actually-gaining-through-the-selloff-11655146869 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/why-ibm-is-one-of-few-tech...
- jobu 4y agoAccording to a coworker that had worked at IBM for a couple decades it was a great place to work until sometime in the mid 2000s. It was like they suddenly noticed how shitty Oracle was and decided that was the business model they needed to follow. Labeling older employees as "dinobabies" is a perfect example.
- floren 4y agoI visited IBM Austin a few times circa 2009-2011 to collaborate with an IBM employee on a project. Huge campus, absolutely completely dead at all times. I would come in through the main entrance, go past the security guard, and see nobody at all until I arrived in the lab space. The lab itself was a large workspace with all sorts of desks and project space, but the only employee in there was the guy I had come to see. Absolutely bizarre and an incredibly depressing place to be.
- tyingq 4y agoInteresting, as they went through this before, in 2006, with a memo calling experienced workers "oldheads". https://features.propublica.org/ibm/ibm-age-discrimination-american-workers/ https://features.propublica.org/ibm/ibm-age-discrimination-a...
- dehrmann 4y ago> contains emails that discuss the effort taken by IBM to increase the number of 'millennial' employees. This could be OK if your workforce is fewer millennials than you'd expect. I know the federal government has issues with this for tech workers because pay is lower than industry and its policy on cannabis.
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoHow many times has IBM been caught discriminating against older workers? Can they be declared a habitual offender and put under court supervision until whatever culture inside the company keeps spawning these incidents gets extinguished? This goes back at least to the late 80s and maybe even further back than that.
- dakial1 4y agoBeing an ex-IBMer let me say that the old timers are part of why IBM has stalled. But I don't mean that happens because of their age, but because of how long they are in the company and also how comfortable they are with all the non-sensical processes and red tape that company has (internally we called it IBM - International Bureaucracy Monster). Being a "business operator" really has a value there and most of the leadership is made of old timers simply because of how they know how to navigate (and circumvent) all the millions of gates and layer-over-layer of non-value added processes. Maybe if IBM worked to remove the "Old timers" from the leadership while, at the same time, bringing in older, experienced professionals, but without the vices that 15/20 years at IBM brings, it could be justified.
- rexreed 4y agoIBM has stalled because it stopped innovating, and instead pushing highly cumbersome, expensive, consulting-centric "products" that are nothing more than expensive services tied to proprietary technologies. Where IBM isn't proprietary, it rests heavily on open source offerings that it has acquired (RedHat). Ironically, it's IBM itself that is every much the sclerotic "dinobaby" that it seems to dislike. Simply hiring in a younger pool won't change that dynamic. If anything, that approach is deeply cynical, and only makes sense when you realize that IBM sees its growth in services and "solutions" offerings that depend on large numbers of lesser-paid, non-family bound "early professional hires" that they seem to desire. IBM placed bets on highly speculative "moonshot" programs like IBM Watson (especially Watson Health) that failed, while simultaneously failing to effectively compete in the growing cloud-centric market. IBM could have been a realistic contender in the Enterprise against AWS, Google, and Microsoft cloud environments, but it instead opted for large-scale vendor lock-in style approaches.
- rusticpenn 4y agoCurrent employee here. They have identified and are focused on changing this. IBM is moving towards technology provider role (from consulting focus). This is also reflected by the new CEO who comes from research background and was the main person pushing towards buying of Redhat.
- mattlondon 4y agoThey did this by proxy in the UK by ruining the dinobabies' (decent) pensions unless they quit - if they quit they get to keep the pension, if they stay they'd be throwing away significant sums in pension. Only the older IBMers had these decent pensions, so there was a huge loss of older IBMers who understandly just quit rather than miss out on their gold-plated pension. Ironically many were rehired as freelance contractors (by their individual projects, not "centrally" if that makes sense) on significantly higher rates, so they got to keep their pension, keep their job (as a contractor) and get a pay rise too. The millennials meanwhile were kept on low salaries (it was the main reason I quit )
- matrix12 4y agoAs an ex-ibmer it always felt the stalls were due to short sighted management decisions. That and the rampant nepotism. Age was never an issue, far less so than working in SV afterwards.
- BeefWellington 4y agoYeah, in my time there it was clear that everything was about quarterly targets set by some unseen person with a spreadsheet.
- theplumber 4y agoI have a hunch though that IBM employs more old people than any other big tech company (i.e apple, facebook, google etc). At some point the old generation should step aside to make space for the new or the company itself will die just like its employees. It's no secret that after a certain age you stop chasing big dreams and just want to do more of the old things/job which is not a competitive strategy for a company.
- speed_spread 4y ago> after a certain age you stop chasing big dreams I have "certain age" and must strongly disagree here. Those who stop never were big dreamers in the first place, or had their morale crushed by eternal bad management. "Age" itself is not a factor. If anything, age gives confidence, wisdom, focus and autonomy to pursue one's goals. Age also means you also realize that you're gonna die one day (soon) and that you'd better get your shit together if you're gonna have any kind of meaningful impact within the short timeframe you're alloted on this ball of mud.
- LinuxBender 4y agoI'm an old fart and I embrace new ideas assuming they have been well thought through, allowed for documented feedback from old stodgy curmudgeons like me and are not putting the company, customers or investors at risk. That said I can understand why you are saying that. Some organizations do permit people with high tenure to paralyze a companies innovation and I do not know how to fix that short of creating competition and importing the good employees at the new competition.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cardosof 4y agoCompanies after achieving huge success and growth become finance companies, in the sense that it isn't about technology or products and services anymore, it's just about balance sheets and stock prices and cash flows. Everything becomes money problems and money solutions, like buying smaller players, selling non-core business units, hiring cheaper workers, firing expensive workers, paying more dividends, buying back stocks, etc.
- Terry_Roll 4y agoIf IBM have done what every other major business seems to have done when GDPR came into effect, they will have burned anything and everything. This will be interesting.
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoHas IBM changed? My cohort of graduates in the 90's found them stuffy, extremely cautious and change-resistant. One fellow in my graduating class was chastised for wearing a shirt that wasn't IBM blue - "I understand you're trying to make a statement," (he wasn't) "but you won't fit in around here unless you make an effort." He was told when he quit to join a startup "You know you will never work at IBM again?" What a dinosaur.
- jiveturkey 4y agoHas it changed? You're talking about the 90's. That's 30 years ago. Of course it's changed.