6 ms·
Murder-Suicides by Pilots Are Vexing Airlines as Deaths Mount
- ekianjo 4y agoWait, in their chart, 9.11 is not counted as intentional crash? What was it then?
- bombcar 4y agoIt wasn't intentional by the airline pilots - it is usually classified as terrorism.
- thr0wawayf00 4y agoThey're defining intentional crashes as those caused by the pilot. The 9/11 planes were hijacked and crashed by passengers.
- ekianjo 4y agoThe chart does not say so explicitely
- werdnapk 4y agoThe hijackers had done some training as pilots, but were not the pilots of the planes themselves.
- rootusrootus 4y agoNot just a simple murder/suicide, either, which frequently involves people who know each other. This is flat-out mass murder, terrorism, call it what you will. Killing hundreds of strangers would rank you at the top of any serial killer list.
- travisgriggs 4y agoWe don’t have a lot of “what we’re you thinking?!” data on these pilots. I think if you do this servile type of job for years, the passengers become the cattle the rest of of the industry treats them as. My guess (but I’m am not a suicide contemplating jumbo liner pilot), is that any signal from those doing this is against the job/industry itself as the stressor in the pilot’s life. Perhaps we should avoid practices that dehumanize the pilot’s relationship with the cargo, er, uh, passengers. Maybe the stats say otherwise, but you don’t hear about a lot of tourist ride pilots (bush, etc) doing the in flight nose dive. I’m curious how many pilots take their lives in more traditional means (e.g. just themselves).
- rootusrootus 4y agoThe weird thing about that is, at least in my experience, passengers tend to idolize the pilot. I half expect the pilot sees passengers not as cattle, but as subjects ;-).
- cm2187 4y agoThat’s what I don’t understand. Do they just ignore the passengers when they want to just commit suicide? Seems hard to believe a professional pilot would not have the passengers in mind. Otherwise you need someone who is both suicidal and with psychopathic murderous pulsions, which should be extremely rare. But clearly it’s not. Like for school shootings, I wonder how much one event inspires the next one.
- MBCook 4y agoYes. Look up the German Wings case, flight 9525. In short one pilot waited for the other to leave the cockpit, locked the door, and deliberately crashed the plane. He was so suicidal and distraught (thought he was going blind and thus would lose his job) he was willing to do it. If you read the full story it’s even sadder.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rkk3 4y agoAnd just like school shootings, that German pilot studied MH370. The MH370 pilot likely did the same thing. He was separated from his wife & at his house they found he practiced the crash route on Microsoft Flight simulator.
- MBCook 4y agoReally? I didn’t know that part. I knew that psychiatrists had told him to stop flying while things were so bad, which he obviously ignored. I didn’t know he had prepared like that though.
- dotancohen 4y agoThe article is terribly written and accusingly ambiguous with scope. This quote from the fine article is not better in the context of the article that it is here on its own: > While intentional acts traditionally aren’t included in air-crash > statistics, they would be the second-largest category of deaths > worldwide if they were, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.
- robonerd 4y ago> Fatal crashes of private, business, and corporate-executive airplanes have increased after publicized murder-suicides. The more publicity given to a murder-suicide, the more crashes occurred. The increase in plane crashes occurred primarily in states where the murder-suicides were publicized. These findings suggest that murder-suicide stories trigger subsequent murder-suicides, some of which are disguised as airplane accidents. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17750236/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17750236/ The media has known about their role in inducing murder-suicides by reporting on them for decades, but they keep doing it.
- core-utility 4y agoAs every evil act gets blasted worldwide instantaneously, one has to think that we as a culture need to put an end to publicizing the name/photo of the attacker. It's been proven enough times that it empowers others to do the same, for the fame and recognition of the "nobody".
- norvvryo 4y agoThere's already a voluntary ban on reporting suicides because of the copycat effect. That it hasn't been extended to murder-for-attention is reprehensible.
- toyg 4y agoSome media organizations already do that, typically for school shootings or "homegrown terrorists".
- r721 4y agoI still remember this alleged quote from Germanwings co-pilot: >According to the German newspaper Bild, a former girlfriend of Lubitz, identified only as Mary W, said he had told her last year: “One day I will do something that will change the whole system, and then all will know my name and remember it.” https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/mar/27/germanwings-co-pilot-andreas-lubitzs-background-under-scrutiny https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/mar/27/germanwings-co...
- 4y ago
- mensetmanusman 4y agoA nose dive maneuver (and any that are clearly anomalous and dangerous) should require simultaneous action by the co-pilot as the likelihood of a double murder-suicide would be incredibly small.
- milesdyson_phd 4y agoFor the majority of charter/private/business flights this wouldn't be feasible as the vast majority of flights tend to be single pilot ops.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoSuch a requirement could be for large passenger jets only.
- jaywalk 4y agoNot possible. In an emergency situation that requires rapid descent, the last thing you'd want is to require both pilots to be on the controls.
- teeray 4y agoAnomalous maneuvers are exactly those used to recover from stalls and the like.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoWould it be possible to detect stalls and other situations that could override the copilot requirement? I’m wondering what happens when the M/S death rate is 100x the stall death rate; would engineering controls would be added?
- dghlsakjg 4y agoYeah. You could even automate a response that commands the plane to pitch down so that it never stalls! (Changing flight controls around stall behavior is how Boeing 737 Max planes behaved. In all seriousness, check out AF447. The plane crashed because the pilots were inputting different commands on the control stick and the plane picked the wrong one
- seandoe 4y agoIs this an effort to reduce airline ticket demand?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ramesh31 4y agoIt all comes down to the mental health stigma. Even hinting at the slightest bit of mental distress can be enough to lose your medical certificate and end your career. It's no wonder that the pilot population would be more susceptible to the consequences of untreated mental illness.
- Qem 4y agoIt's a catch-22 situation. You'd like to avoid unstable people to pilot the plane, but any atempt to filter out unstable people would lead to people hiding the condition and enduring untreated mental disease, what makes the situation worse. I don't see much to be done, beyond screening people that are entering the profession, and then ensuring the work conditions don't make people sick afterwards. When the Germanwings flight went down, I remember it was noticed the pilot was bullied at work. They should have cracked down on the bullies.
- dghlsakjg 4y agoThe easy solution is to allow doctors to make fit-for-flight decisions instead of the FAA. If a doctor, or panel of flight doctors ok’s you to fly, then why does the FAA have final say? I don’t care if my pilot has treated depression and a doctor says they are fine(currently an administrative disqualification). I very much care if my pilot is hiding/denying their depression and not getting care because they could lose their flight status. The standard advice about getting a flight medical is to only answer what is asked and to volunteer nothing.
- throwaway130124 4y agoAbsolutely. I ran into this as a new student pilot recently. Went in to get my medical thinking it would be a breeze, but my mention of going through a period of depression more than a decade ago (not diagnosed, just my layman's assessment at the time) and some more recent work-related anxiety was enough to get my medical deferred. This process will likely take me months to wade through, and this is only for a third-class medical (for a private pilot, not commercial)! I filled out the form assuming the doctor would be free to exercise discretion and that it wouldn't be an issue, but it turns out the FAA wants all these kinds of responses referred to a small team in Oklahoma City who will eventually get through the backlog and review them. It's not a very big deal for me; I just wanted to fly for fun, and can wait a few months. But for someone for whom this is a career, I can't help but imagine that there are lots of pilots out there that avoid seeking help so as not to jeopardize their career.
- phkahler 4y ago>> Preliminary evidence suggests the crash of a China Eastern Airlines Corp. jet in March may be the latest such tragedy, a person familiar with the investigation said. What is the preliminary evidence? For this type of conclusion I would think the first and last bit of evidence would be the control inputs as recorded by the black box. Supporting evidence should be on the voice recording. What is this "preliminary evidence"?
- jaywalk 4y agoThe video of the plane going down is enough to strongly suggest it. It was almost completely nose-down before it hit the ground, which is basically not going to happen without the pilot commanding it.
- mattkrause 4y agoThis is also (IIRC) how one recovers from a stall, so it could be a “malign” command, a best-effort at fixing a bigger problem, or anything in between.
- jaywalk 4y agoThere's nothing in the publicly-available flight data to suggest a stall. The flight was at cruising altitude when the descent started.
- kayodelycaon 4y agoStall recovery and intentional dives look very different. 1. In a stall recovery, you don't move the trim to the limit or move the throttles to idle and keep it there for tens of thousands of feet. 2. Planes don't want to keep going in a stable, near vertical dive. You have to force them into that position the entire way down. The flight path for stalls, breaking apart, and control problems are all shallower or slower.
- _moof 4y agoYou recover from a stall by relaxing back pressure, not by pushing nose down. If you're pushing when you stall, you're scaring your instructor. :)
- 48cfu 4y ago[dead]
- someweirdperson 4y agoThat chart of deaths looks fishy. It shows a lot more deaths from 2011-2020 than from 2021-2022. Which seems completely obvious. Of course there is more deaths in 10 years than there is in 1.5 years. Unless they intend to say "deaths per year", but that's not on the lable at least. Numbers for 2020 and 2021 are useless anyway due to reduced number of flights. It looks like someone wants to push their political agenda.
- kubanczyk 4y agoAgenda or not, the whole point of the chart is to show that row with 132 deaths as a solid statistic. At the bottom of the same chart: "* Unconfirmed" in small print. Classic.
- signatoremo 4y agoWhy is it the whole point? The chat is about aviation fatality caused by pilot suicides, not to show “132 death as solid statistic”. Also, the small print is “March 2022 China Eastern Crash is likely intentional, but unconfirmed”. You took out the important first part. The article has four paragraphs that discusses this specific event, yet you choose to go with a small print.
- signatoremo 4y agoThe label could have been “2020s so far” instead of “2021-2022” but the intention is quite clear, isn’t it? to show the death in the last four decades. Poor choice maybe. What is fishy about it? > Numbers for 2020 and 2021 are useless anyway due to reduced number of flights. As opposed to standstill air traffic after 9/11?
- vessenes 4y agoIt may be that pilot murder-suicides are a terrible problem, but the data in this article does not back this up. The graph of the data they show is an almost textbook-grade ‘evil’ graph. What the graph shows is that * all cause flying mortality is way, way down over the last 30 years * in raw deaths 2011-2020 was way up over prior decade but only slightly up over the one prior to that * there has been one crash this year that might have been an m-s crash. The graph doesn’t use the same time scales for the different bar charts, and doesn’t show any useful data like * percentages against all air travelers or flights (way, way up since the 90s and down during covid) * unit number of crashes * that the stats might be ‘0’ this year after all depending on outcome of investigation of a single flight Given all this and the raw numbers of people (single digit hundreds per decade), it’s also possible that rather than this being an epidemic, there were like 4 crashes in the 1990s, 0 in the 2000s, 3 in the 2010s, and possibly 1 so far in the early 2020s. Again, terrible, but if this is the situation, then appropriate response might not be mass publicity, especially because stories like this can be memetically viral and help cause the behavior they describe.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Retric 4y agoIt’s not about the raw numbers but that “fatalities caused by murder-suicides are becoming an increasingly large share of the total.” The assumption is this a very low probability event that’s neither increasing or decreasing, but if you improve everything else then then people are just going to hear about murder cases like this.
- supertrope 4y agoKind of like how child mortality in car crashes has decreased below gunshot deaths. And all other pediatric causes of death are now dwarfed by those two.
- arminiusreturns 4y ago
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoI haven't looked at their source data, but their graph is extremely suspect. They list zero "intentional deaths" from 2001-2010. I seem to remember at least 1 large aviation murder-suicide event in that time period that resulted in a huge number of intentional deaths.
- steeleduncan 4y agoI think the point is that the Pilot in the title of that graph implies an on-shift airline pilot choosing to crash the plane intentionally, not a terrorist killing the pilot and grabbing the controls.
- thematrixturtle 4y ago9/11 is excluded from the stats because it was not the pilots that caused the crashes, but the hijackers.
- silvester23 4y agoI think they only take into account intentional crashes caused by the original pilot of the plane, not by hijackings.
- winsbe01 4y ago"Vexing" feels like the wrong adjective here. IMO, terrorism is not a "harumph" situation.
- Terry_Roll 4y agoConsidering more and more aircraft is fly by wire and most pilots get their "air time" in sims, is there not a advantage in building a mock cockpit at the back of the airline with a backup pilot to take over when other protocols are met? All this is doing is highlighting how one person beit the president or prime minister of a country, judge's, GP's, practically anyone including a pilot can steal some or all of other people's lives to one degree or another. Edit. Where I am going with this, is the Space Shuttle had 4 control systems and majority rule or agreement of the 4 control systems made things happen. I dont think more than 2 cockpits would necessary. Another left field idea, is the cock pit doors could be engineered so that if enough people all pulled on a rope firmly attached to the cock pit door like a tug of war, in order to gain access to the cockpit, then maybe the passengers have a chance. However this relies on the passengers not being deceived by the pilot which is also what is troubling the air line industry and so called psychologists. When you can work out when you are going to lose your temper in the future, let the psychologists know, they might be able to study it....
- toast0 4y agoIt's all about tradeoffs. You could increase the number of pilots to hopefully reduce the number of these incidents, but the added complexity might increase other incidents and would reduce the capacity for paid passengers and increase the labor costs when there's already a shortage of qualified pilots willing to work for the airlines. Same thing with the doors. They got strong locks and protocols to use them in response to rare events, but it makes other rare events harder to manage. We generally live in a pretty trusting world, which enables many things, including violations of trust with major consequences.
- Terry_Roll 4y ago> It's all about tradeoffs Trade offs that we have to trust other people to make the right decisions and we only have to look at how people game the system for money, just look at Jeff Bezo for a prime example!
- willcipriano 4y agoCongress when will we have common sense airplane regulation to resolve this issue?