5 ms·
There's a real alternative to higher interest rates: bring government spending under control. Notably, this was done during the 1990s Clinton administrations a
by zozbot234 4y ago
There's a real alternative to higher interest rates: bring government spending under control. Notably, this was done during the 1990s Clinton administrations and it worked quite well.
- zthrowaway 4y agoThis is the real answer. Everything else is just arguing about what type of band-aid we use. Root of the problem with inflation in this nation is out of control government spending and printing of money. Unfortunately no politician will seriously campaign to do this, as combating inflation results in a drop in economic boost, potential unemployment, etc. It stings at first but the other end of it is worth doing. Our hand will be forced one way or another to hit the brakes.
- tablespoon 4y ago> Root of the problem with inflation in this nation is out of control government spending and printing of money. Eh, not entirely. There's also a war going on, which has had serious impacts on the food an energy markets. Plus the supply chain is still all out of whack due to COVID. Neither of those is due to "out of control government spending and printing of money." The people who reflexively complain about "out of control government spending and printing of money" have predicted 12 of the last 1 bouts of inflation.
- abduhl 4y agoYou don’t think that the supply chain issues are related to our Covid strategy of “Stay the Fuck Home” via massive printing of money to support ridiculous unemployment benefits and bridge loans to businesses? You can argue that it was necessary to prevent an economic recession, but that argument is a bit hard to take seriously as our economy currently enters recession territory.
- tablespoon 4y ago> You don’t think that the supply chain issues are related to our Covid strategy of “Stay the Fuck Home” via massive printing of money to support ridiculous unemployment benefits and bridge loans to businesses? 1) The US could have pursued a COVID policy of “Kill Grandma, Save the Dollar,” and still had supply chain issues. We live in globalized economy, and China's COVID policy is just as significant to the supply chain as the US's (or even more so). 2) Even if the US's COVID policy did cause inflation, a policy along those lines may have still been the right one, given the circumstances. People monomanically focused on one or a few metrics (like inflation) usually advocate shit policy that's bad for everything else.
- hourago 4y ago> You don’t think that the supply chain issues are related to our Covid strategy of “Stay the Fuck Home” via massive printing of money to support ridiculous unemployment benefits and bridge loans to businesses? The supply chain is affected way more by what China does than by any other country. I do not think that supply chain and inflation problems are just happening in the USA but world wide.
- Hammershaft 4y agoI wouldn't be so confident on pinning US COVID policy as the root of supply shortage issues consider supply shortages and soaring costs are currently worldwide problems; Other causes have been cited more commonly by economists & institutions. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=b1JlYZQG3lI https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=b1JlYZQG3lI
- throwaway0a5e 4y agoIt certainly didn't help the supply chain. I think the shock to the economy did more to affect people's perception of things in a self-fulfilling way than it did directly.
- zthrowaway 4y agoYes entirely, at the very least 90% entirely. What I'm saying here isn't novel whatsoever. This is a phenomenon well documented and understood in economics for the past 5 decades. This isn't some reflexive talking point. This phenomena is so concrete that it was seen in the gold rush era, and even when tobacco leaves were used as currency in the south. There's plenty of historical data to back this up.
- rightbyte 4y agoInflation was wack in January too.
- Supermancho 4y ago> Notably, this was done during the 1990s Clinton administrations and it worked quite well. - in the summer of 1995, the Clinton administration admitted that “balancing the budget is not one of our top priorities.” "It worked quite well" meaning: "We have a balanced budget today that is mostly a result of 1) an exceptionally strong economy that is creating gobs of new tax revenues and 2) a shrinking military budget." - Stephen Moore https://archive.ph/OD4nl#selection-1643.78-1643.91 https://archive.ph/OD4nl#selection-1643.78-1643.91 Whoever was to blame, the issue is that politicians have been disconnected from spending constraints for too long. There are no controls that impact them when they fail to perform one of their basic duties. Deciding how to spend tax revenue has morphed into deciding how to spend future revenue across all strata of politics (local to federal). The 91fwy express lanes from 1994 are STILL tolls, which was supposed to be converted to additional freeway lanes decades ago, based on the initial project. Nope, money in the hand and promises of money in the future, is what the cities want. From this, we get wasteful slush-fund industries (eg lotteries, etc).
- frgtpsswrdlame 4y agoIf inflation is occurring in Oil & Gas because of the crisis in Ukraine and inflation is occurring in eggs and beef because of monopolistic price gouging, then what is the point of lowering government spending? End the crisis in Ukraine, bring Russian oil back on to the market for its correct price and discipline the companies currently making record profits off record prices for goods.
- michaelmrose 4y agoYou are advocating for increasing consumption of Russian oil despite it being used to fund genocide because you value temporary economic prosperity over cutting WW3 short before we ruin the world?
- bequanna 4y agoRight, the mechanism the Fed has available isn’t perfect, but it is a good tool. In general, lowering demand for goods will decrease upward price pressure. Unfortunately, rapid rate increases are needed. The downside will be painful. The crying, screaming, bargaining and delusion we are seeing is normal as money gets expensive, asset values drop and times get harder.
- somewhereoutth 4y agoOr equivalently, tax rich people more. Interest rates should be returned to their norm, around 5%, for sound resource allocation (i.e. the time value of money is priced correctly). Fiscal policy, specifically wealth taxes, should be used to cushion low and middle incomes from this painful readjustment.
- zozbot234 4y ago> Or equivalently, tax rich people more. "Soak the rich" is a nonstarter if you're after tax revenue (as opposed to intentionally stoking widespread social envy for political gain), and everyone knows it. The middle class is where the real money is.
- somewhereoutth 4y agoOf course, the rich would certainly like 'everyone to know it'. Wealth disparities have become so pronounced that I'm not sure this holds anymore. Let's have small armies of people washing hospitals, instead of yachts.
- diordiderot 4y agoThat's not true. The top 1% of the population own 40% of assets. Solving tax evasion is simple. All capital boils down to something you can put your hands on.
- throwaway0a5e 4y agoSoak the rich is what you say when you're trying to get the middle class to vote to soak itself.
- Hammershaft 4y agoVery difficult to directly attribute low inflation of the 90s to Gov spending. 90s also had a record surge in economic productivity partially brought on by the integration of computers.
- dimitar 4y agoIt can help a bit, but fiscal policy is not sufficiently effective with a floating exchange rate, unless the economy is in a liquidity trap (which the USA just exited). The reason is when the rates are low, the removed government spending it will be replaced with private. A budget takes time to make, vote on and spend (or not spend). To be effective it must also align with monetary policy. Changing rates has a much quicker effect. By the time Congress agrees on what to cut the inflation might even be low - due to Fed action, a recession, or repairing of the post-Covid logistic issues.
- rayiner 4y agoBringing government spending under control is politically impossible. A lot of Reagan Republicans are now stuck in the Democratic Party, at least at the national level. And a significant slice of the old FDR coalition, working class people in rural states, are now in the GOP. Immigration has thrown a wrench in everything, because both parties now have an incentive to push government spending (as both Trump and Biden did). Democrats, to keep immigrants, who lean socially conservative but like immigrants in the past value social services, in a coalition with white social liberals. For Republicans, abandoning fiscal austerity is a way to peel off the more conservative segments of those same voters. It’s the same play Tories have run in the UK, for much the same reasons—winning minorities and working class rural people away from Labour. And it’s resulted in exploding government spending there too.