4 ms·
How do you know an actor or actress is not performing in a shoot because they were forced to? How do you know the editor hasn't cut out the parts where the mode
by jeroenhd 4y ago
How do you know an actor or actress is not performing in a shoot because they were forced to? How do you know the editor hasn't cut out the parts where the model revoked consent between shots? You'll have to review the entire making-off process and confidential interviews with all participants to find out that the people on camera actually consented or were merely forced to do so.
Then there is porn which specifically focuses on vulnerability, humiliation, power balances, trust, you name it.
I don't think most porn is nonconsensual, especially not most professional grade stuff, but I know for sure there is a percentage of "consentual" porn that's actually based on faked or revoked consent because human traffickers can make big money on platforms like Pornhub and Onlyfans. It's the only logical conclusion, you don't need to be a criminal mastermind to think of this.
The legal definition of consent and exploitation is the easy part: there is no consent until it's freely given, and consent can be retracted at any point. Any non-consensual activity is abuse and exploitation. Easy peasy, covers pretty much everything. The verification process is where the actual problem lies. You obviously can't have people sign a document (because people can easily be coerced). Even in full production pornos where the people on screen seemed professionals doing their job, produced by dedicated companies and sold to the public on VHS tapes, turned out to be rape years after the fact, and people who bought those might never find out.
It's a practically unsolvable problem.
- dijit 4y ago> Then there is porn which specifically focuses on vulnerability, humiliation, power balances, trust, you name it. I don’t want to rape anyone but I have a rape kink, my girlfriend also has a rape kink- but anything that remotely resembles realistic depictions of rape (rape depicted in movies) is deeply unsettling still. I think a lot of people don’t understand this, kinks of a thing aren’t direct desires to do the thing, and I can understand why- it’s confusing for me too. > How do you know an actor or actress is not performing in a shoot because they were forced to? How do you know the editor hasn't cut out the parts where the model revoked consent between shots? By making it legal and ensuring there are custodians who’s purpose in life is to ensure workplace health and safety. we have this for office workers already
- jeroenhd 4y agoRape kinks are definitely an extremely difficult problem when it comes to evaluating consent. The whole point of them is to fake the absence of consent, but no normal person with a rape kink will ever enjoy someone actually being raped. Other kinks with questionable consent (bondage etc.) face similar problems, going so far as depicting people causing each other real pain in a completely consensual and (in my opinion) acceptable way. Your average sex scene is difficult enough to check for consent; scenes where both parties get off to pretending to force one another to perform sex acts are impossible to ever validate. Should such porn be banned? I don't know. Clearly there are couples out there who can live out their fantasies safely with people they trust. Looking at the statistics, it's almost shocking how common coercion, either physically or otherwise, comes up in kink prevalence lists. These topics aren't enjoyed by just the tiny minority I'd personally expect them to, and taking away their porn for theoretical possibilities of abuse seems quite extreme. > ensuring there are custodians who’s purpose in life is to ensure workplace health and safety I'd love that, but the fact remains that the people most vocal about these solutions are either extremely opposed to many concepts or perhaps too much into them to make clear judgement calls. The UK has a list of topics not allowed by porn. Activities like pretend sexual abuse and role-playing as people who can't consent can be defended relatively easily, but the ban also covers spanking, caning, water sports, restraints, female ejacularion, and face sitting. If this is the type of committee that will decide the future of all porn, people like you and your girlfriend may be left disappointed quite quickly. The government is very reactive on these topics and that usually means they're a bunch of prudes in any society. Furthermore, a personal vetting system for porn would put a few people who will see quite a lot of porn during their work day in a position of power. That sounds like a recipe for disaster to me.
- limaoscarjuliet 4y agoSafe Word was invented for the purpose of stopping the play when faked violence or lack of consent do not go as planned.
- elp 4y ago> I know for sure there is a percentage of "consentual" porn that's actually based on faked or revoked consent because human traffickers can make big money on platforms like Pornhub and Onlyfans. Human trafficking is almost entirely urban legend. https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2022/01/children-sex-trafficking-conspiracy-epidemic/620845/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2022/01/childre... https://www.buzzsprout.com/1112270/3883928-human-trafficking https://www.buzzsprout.com/1112270/3883928-human-trafficking
- jeroenhd 4y agoHuman trafficking may not be as big a problem as the media often claims it is, I don't think anyone can say for certain that all porn on a given website is uploaded solely consensually. In the same way barely any, if any at all, international clothing brand can claim to work completely without sweatshops, child labour or even slavery. It's not that these companies don't try, it's just a very difficult problem to work around. As far as I know, though I'm clearly no expert on this topic, actual human trafficking mostly seems to involve the physical part of sex work (not necessarily the performing part). It's also usually not even close to the typical depiction of someone getting kidnapped, shipped off, and forced to have sex. The real world involves modelling/fashion/contract deals that turn out wrong when the victim gets picked up from the airport, financial coercion of family, forms of wage slavery and other "soft" coercion methods. There have been plenty of stories in the news here about men and women signing contracts they couldn't read that claimed they agreed to all sorts of things (though legally that's complete nonsense, of course, but the victims don't know that!) The approach is not very different from the approaches abusers use to make Eastern European people work in richer European countries for far less than minimal wage with barely any worker's rights. It's a tragedy that needs more nuance and definitely more government action even at its relatively modest real world scale, at least here in Europe. Every abuse case is one too many.
- Ansil849 4y ago> How do you know an actor or actress is not performing in a shoot because they were forced to? How do you know $worker isn't performing $job because they were forced to? If you're going to make the pearl-clutching argument that /anyone/ can potentially be in a coercive situation, then apply to to genuinely anyone, not just sex workers.
- jeroenhd 4y agoI feel that sex work is a particularly sensitive type of work. Being forced to work anywhere can be a traumatising experience but sexual violence is particularly impactful. I don't think the risks of porn and other online content are comparable at all. If I'm watching your average YouTube video, I don't doubt for a second that the content on display was made intentionally by the video host. Your angry ex won't upload your comprehensive four hour Minecraft tutorial or the video detailing how you constructed your own army of garden gnomes. Coercion might be a risk present in any media but there are definitely areas where the risk and impact are much higher than in others.
- Ansil849 4y ago> If I'm watching your average YouTube video, I don't doubt for a second that the content on display was made intentionally by the video host. Why not? Parents pressuring children to gain celebrity status isn't exactly an undocumented phenomenon.
- dismantlethesun 4y ago> I don't think most porn is nonconsensual, especially not most professional grade stuff... If most is consensual and certainly most professional grade stuff is, then what's the need to abolish the commercial sex industry as a whole? I think it's better to drag these sort of things into the light where people can feel safe reporting abuse, and other criminal activity. Right now if you're forced into performing a shoot, it might be very hard for a person to report that to the police. Apart from the usual worries they'd have in your typical rape incident, they'd have to worry that people wouldn't take them seriously because it happened during their occupation. In fact, many people might start to opine that they are just owed money for 'forced labor' and this is a civil matter. > It's a practically unsolvable problem. Crime in general is an unsolvable problem. We can mitigate it. We can reduce it. Yet we can't solve the issue for good. However, mitigation and reduction start by having good laws that target the actual situation at hand. Look at the case of J. Epstein, where people were potentially forced to have sex with politicians who had no idea their partner was coerced. There ought to be a more specific law against this situation, because at the time everyone was unsure of who would be charged (the politicians who were honeypotted? Epstein? Other workers?).