8 ms·
Binance has paused Bitcoin withdrawals “due to a stuck on-chain transaction”
- raverbashing 4y agoHopefully what's not stuck is not the BTC equivalent of a bag of money on a trash chute ready to be offloaded somewhere else (metaphorically speaking)
- cyphertruck 4y agoBitcoin is not stuck. Transaction Fees are a little high, almost $0.60. No telling what’s going on with Binance. They may have been fractionally reserved.
- bragr 4y agoBinance has their own smart contract system for transacting Bitcoin. It's not Bitcoin itself stuck but the smart contract.
- marban 4y agoSo we're shutting down all ATMs because one guy had a ten-dollar bill stuck in the slot?
- llamajams 4y ago
- 323 4y agoYes. UK 2018 TSB bank IT meltdown shutdowns all accounts for weeks: > With clients locked out of their bank accounts, mortgage accounts vanishing, small businesses reporting that they could not pay their staff and reports of debit cards ceasing to work, the TSB Bank computer crisis of April 2018 has been one of the worst in recent memory. The bank’s CEO, Paul Pester, admitted in public that the bank was “on its knees” and that it faces a compensation bill likely to run to tens of millions of pounds. https://www.henricodolfing.com/2019/03/case-study-epic-meltdown-of-tsb-bank.html https://www.henricodolfing.com/2019/03/case-study-epic-meltd...
- ceejayoz 4y ago> faces a compensation bill likely to run to tens of millions of pounds I'm guessing Binance doesn't.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoYep, thats the all important distinction in the fine print
- criddell 4y agoYou see, like ̶A̶l̶ ̶G̶o̶r̶e̶ Ted Stevens said, it's really all a series of tubes. You put ten dollars in and it gets whisked away to a centralized location. Unfortunately, the location of the stuck tenner is right at the junction where all ATM transactions pass through. It's an unanticipated feature of our new centralized system. To complain, please fill out form 27-B-stroke-six.
- swills 4y agoI appreciate the Brazil reference, and I imagine few do these days.
- jackcosgrove 4y agoIf the tubes had been made of flex-duct this never would have happened.
- retcon 4y agoI blamed a bureaucratic SNAFU that other day on Central Services and was taken literally. This just now frightened me...
- Agamus 4y agoMy team was once described as the "Harry Tuttle" of the company by a VP - it was one of the happiest moments of my life.
- frob 4y agoThe "series of tubes" comment was Alaska Senator Ted Stevens, not Al Gore. "Ten movies streaming across that, that Internet, and what happens to your own personal Internet? I just the other day got... an Internet [email] was sent by my staff at 10 o'clock in the morning on Friday. I got it yesterday [Tuesday]. Why? Because it got tangled up with all these things going on the Internet commercially. [...] They want to deliver vast amounts of information over the Internet. And again, the Internet is not something that you just dump something on. It's not a big truck. It's a series of tubes. And if you don't understand, those tubes can be filled and if they are filled, when you put your message in, it gets in line and it's going to be delayed by anyone that puts into that tube enormous amounts of material, enormous amounts of material."
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- malikNF 4y agoYou do realize this is not something that's unique to the crypto space. [1][2] Seriously dislike this attitude some folks on HN has about crypto, yes there's massive fraudsters and there's lots of technical issues in this space. But so is most other spaces, fraudsters and criminals didn't happen to suddenly pop up after 2009 you know, they have been here always, everywhere. There's valid uses for crypto and the blockchain, I personally know several folks who were able to move away from war zones with some of their wealth intact thanks to crypto. I know people who send money to their parents back home thanks to crypto, minus the ridiculous fees predatory companies were charging them to send fiat before. Its not all roses sunshine and butterflies, but there's real people who are benefiting from this tech. [1]https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/canadas-major-banks-go-offline-in-mysterious-hours-long-outage/ https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/canadas-major... [2]https://www.google.com/search?q=Bank+system+outage&source=lnms&tbm=nws&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwibtbHWzqr4AhX9IzQIHSsHAf0Q_AUoAXoECAEQAw&biw=1920&bih=968&dpr=2 https://www.google.com/search?q=Bank+system+outage&source=ln...
- belltaco 4y agoDid that coincide with a huge drop in the value of the Canadian dollar and happen to stop people selling CAD for other currencies like USD? Didn't think so. Your point would be more valid if that were true. >yes there's massive fraudsters and there's lots of technical issues in this space. But so is most other spaces, fraudsters and criminals didn't happen to suddenly pop up after 2009 you know, they have been here always, everywhere The disdain of regulation that cryptobros have and the lack of regulation results in a free for all for fraudsters and criminals, compared to regular banking/finances.
- lern_too_spel 4y agoAll of your benefits are due to the fact that cryptocurrencies aren't regulated yet. That isn't a technological benefit.
- Havoc 4y agoThis week is gonna be a bloodbath.
- HideousKojima 4y agoGot my popcorn ready and the satisfaction of knowing I invested $0 into crypto. Also makes me super grateful I ignored and turned down a bunch of offers from crypto startups when I was looking for a new job ~6 months ago.
- jefftk 4y ago> Only a single network, the Bitcoin network, is impacted due to the stuck batch of transactions. Users can withdraw $BTC on Ethereum or BNB Chain while our team works to resolve this temporary pause.
- gus_massa 4y agoWhat does "withdraw $BTC on Ethereum" mean? Are they tokens that they claim to have a 1-to-1 peg with $BTC?
- efficax 4y agoThey can exchange Ethereum for the equivalent amount of BTC, but good luck turning that BTC into cash
- gbasin 4y agoYep. Some of these are held by custodians and others in smart contracts, depending on the type of "wrapper"
- yellow_postit 4y agoThere’s wrapped BTC which is an eth network token “backed” by BTC. [1] https://wbtc.network/ https://wbtc.network/
- bidirectional 4y ago
- bravogamma 4y agoWhat does a “stuck on-chain transaction” actually mean, can someone explain? The least generous read is that they’re testing their withdrawals halting system in preparation.
- 323 4y agoOne possible example: their usual transactions to fill up the hot wallet are not going through because too low fees, or timelocks/multi sig issues, and now unexpectedly they need to go to the cold wallet and this takes time. I bet they are doing waay more withdrawals today, many times over their usual volume so they are hitting some capacity issues, and you can't rush these things.
- efficax 4y agowell you see, they tried to exchange it for cash and there was no cash left, so it got "stuck"
- oleganza 4y agoLOL, but no. What they probably mean is that they have a transaction that consumes $1000000 on their address and creates two outputs: $100 withdrawal for client A, and $999900 on a "change" output. Later withdrawals have to link to that change output (bitcoin is a directed acyclic graph of inputs-outputs). If that transaction is not confirmed, then later txs also cannot be confirmed and backlog grows.
- 01100011 4y ago(paraphrasing from Twitter) It means they have to let the mafia pull out their money first so that no one ends up murdered. Then they'll let the normal folks withdraw.
- steve_taylor 4y agoIt means they've run out of money.
- FollowingTheDao 4y agoIt means they are trying to stop the price of Bitcoin from collapsing. The whales have exited so it's ok.
- nvr219 4y ago
- well_actulily 4y agoIf you don't have the private keys, they're not your coins.
- amanj41 4y agoAnd if you keep your gold in a bank safety deposit box, it's not your gold
- maweki 4y agoBut what if I have the private keys to said deposit box?
- chii 4y agono it's not your gold technically - but the law gives you the ownership, because the bank is only a custodial owner. For cryptos, the law doesn't make this promise for you, and even if they do, crypto being mathematically secure, the courts can't just declare an outcome that cannot be achieved in reality.
- motoxpro 4y agoThis is the difference. If the bank doesn't give me my gold, they go to jail. If service X doesn't go give me my crypto, they just cruise on.
- whb07 4y agoYou should really look up the policies and expectations on a safe deposit box with banks. This is definitely not the case. Finally, look up executive order 6102[0]. Where by decree due to those "evil" people who where hoarding their savings (as they should) got their gold seized. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Order_6102 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Order_6102
- jakelazaroff 4y agoCelsius is also pausing all withdrawals, swaps and transfers between accounts [1]. Very convenient time to have a “stuck transaction”. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31723286 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31723286
- kobalsky 4y agoThis isn't on the same ballpark though. Only the main BTC network is affected on Binance, other BTC networks and other coins are fine at the moment. You can convert and withdraw. Celsius froze withdrawals for non-technical reasons. It reeks of rug pull.
- adharmad 4y agoBinance and Celsius new strategy: Forced HODL
- 300bps 4y agoI liquidated my Bittrex account today and did an ACH transfer back to my bank account. The risk of these smaller exchanges is too high for me now.
- rib3ye 4y agoIf Binance goes down, I am seriously scared for every exchange.
- realce 4y agoUnregulated casinos are not good places to conduct your banking from.
- whoisninja 4y agothere's no such thing as stuck Bitcoin on-chain tx unless you don't pay enough . fees and fees rn is around $0.50 to move any amount of value. these altcoin casino companies are ridiculous
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- FollowingTheDao 4y agoBank runs leads to bank holiday. its the 1920's all over again. "Every thing old is new again." - They Might Be Giants
- duxup 4y agoWhat is the value of a thing if in theory there is a bunch of pent up demand to sell that can’t be processed?
- crate_barre 4y ago
- tiku 4y agoThis is a Exchange only problem. Bitcoin on your own wallet can never be stopped.
- duxup 4y agoBut the value is still subject to exchange disasters…
- TuringNYC 4y agoReminds me of Mike Burry on The Big Short when all the investment banks were "having systems issues" when he tried to close his highly profitable trades.
- pc86 4y agoSomewhere between $(currentPrice-0.01) and 0.
- glofish 4y agoMaybe the front fell off. It is not very typical, I want to make that point. The front is not supposed to fall off. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3m5qxZm_JqM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3m5qxZm_JqM
- senectus1 4y agoso they towed it "out of the (financial) environment" ?
- doomroot 4y agoI would like to provide some context to people unfamiliar with how the bitcoin mempool works and what you can do to avoid getting your transaction stuck. The mempool is all of the transactions that have ben gossiped about but have not yet been mined (finalized) into a block. Each node has their own mempool. You can see [1] that there are roughly 6 hrs worth of transactions in this node's mempool (everyone should have a similar mempool, though not identical). So Binance's claims of network congestion are "true" on the surface, however there are a few interesting points that lead me to believe that they are acting fishy. 1. Why does Binance not have RBF enabled on their withdrawal transactions? RBF mean "replace by fee" and it's a way you can mark an unconfirmed transaction as replaceable by a similar transaction that pays higher fees. This is extremely useful when you need to ram a transaction into a block by increasing the fee you're willing to pay miners to mine your transaction. I highly recommend you only use a wallet that allows you to use RBF & to have RBF enabled by default. Of course Binance knows about RBF so why aren't they using it? 2. Why does Binance not use 'Child Pays for Parent'? CPFP is a little hard to understand if you don't understand that bitcoin transactions are linked together in a graph structure. In short, a bitcoin transaction is a data structure that points to previous transactions to spend. CPFP is when you make a new transaction that spends from your previous unconfirmed transaction (un-mined transaction in the mempool) and over pay in fees to cover the cost of both transactions. This incentivizes miners to include BOTH transaction in the same block. Once again Binance should be doing this. An ideal way to do this would be to batch a bunch of customer withdrawals in a single transaction. This would save a lot on network fees. They would make this big transaction payout a *large* amount back to themselves so that they could CPFP this batched withdrawal transaction. 3. Binance has their own mining pool with 11% of the network hash[2]. Binance could easily prioritize their "stuck" withdrawal transaction in their pool's blocks. Of course if they didn't subsidize their miners for this they risk them switching to another pool. One would think that halting withdrawals is an existential risk to their business so temporarily paying their miners to ram transactions through should be worth it? So what is the take away from all of this? There are numerous tools at Binance's disposal. Why did they not work/why are they not using them? My hunch is that they don't have all of their ducks in a row & are running a fractional reserve. (this is pure speculation on my part) They likely had a lot of (your) bitcoin tied up in "risk-free" interest accounts (Celsius) and are scrambling to get ahold of bitcoin to give back to customers. [1] https://mempool.space/ https://mempool.space/ [2] https://mempool.space/mining/pool/binancepool https://mempool.space/mining/pool/binancepool
- DemocracyFTW2 4y agoExactly what you should expect from a high-tech, fully digitized and "decentralized" payment (slash gambling) solution /s