19 ms·
Robert Jordan, the Man Who Connecticut Police Said Was ‘Too Smart to Be a Cop’
- HWR_14 4y agoBut not too smart. He got as upset when he sued for his constitutional rights being violated that the court focused only on that issue, and not whether the policy made sense.
- anigbrowl 4y agoIt's hard to sue on behalf of the public rather than oneself; courts often punt by creating or invoking balancing tests that are fundamentally arbitrary. I'm not at all sure the policy does make sense; it's not well-supported by data, and it seems to me that the only people who benefit from constraining the average intelligence level of cops are corrupt administrators. After all, it's much easier to govern if you have assistants with a lot of leverage but little initiative.
- HWR_14 4y agoYou can only sue if you have been harmed. His suit wasn't that stupid cops hurt him - it was that he was treated unfairly. But he was treated the same as anyone else and the people reason he was excluded was considered reasonable enough to be a question of public policy (not the courts job)
- anigbrowl 4y agoYes, that's my point. It's a problem because it creates an accountability gap, same reason we have such insanely long copyright terms.
- aaron695 4y ago
- SoftTalker 4y agoProspective jurors who are "too smart" (highly educated/credentialed) are often dismissed as well.
- dontbenebby 4y agoThey should do that with being charged for crimes too then, since we're entitled to a jury of our peers. (I'm not at all joking.)
- tjohns 4y agoEach side in a trial gets to dismiss a certain number of potential jurors, for nearly any reason they like. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voir_dire#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voir_dire#United_States
- dontbenebby 4y agoI know, but thanks for sharing this for those who do not.
- woodruffw 4y agoYour peers are your fellow citizens, usually from the same municipality as you. The US doesn't recognize a right to be tried by peers of a particular status, since consideration for that is likely to always be a positive or negative bias (e.g. juries of landholders against a tenant, juries of the educated against someone illiterate.)
- dontbenebby 4y agoYeah, that's why my metro area has negative population growth. You can EXPLAIN things like you just said, but if you just explain over and over "that's the way it is" to people who are trapped in interactions with you, they tend to act out, it's why Pennsylvania has been having so many issues lately.
- 4y ago
- cgriswald 4y ago> But there was a silver lining for Jordan: After his testing debacle, he was still able to land a new job at the Department of Corrections, proving that at least he wasn’t too smart to be a prison guard. I'd suggest that this is because prison guard turnover is high so it won't cost them any more than usual when he gets 'bored' and leaves.
- bombcar 4y agoYep. DoC hires the people who can’t successfully get a job with the TSA.
- silisili 4y agoDoC might be regional, but in my home city in the US of about a million, it was a real shithole. Buncha young white guys on steroids, who constantly drank and bragged about how they abused inmates in different ways. They constantly seemed to be waiting for someone to mess up even a little, so they could abuse them. Black people got it worse. Even as far as how much they hurt anuses looking for drugs(seriously). My best friend from highschool went down that path after getting rejected from police, and I had to cut him out completely. I feel sorry for anyone who goes to jail now.
- woodruffw 4y agoThis is a particularly absurd example, but more subtle versions of this policy show up in many large police departments. For example, the NYPD requires half of a college degree at a rock-bottom GPA[1], and has been agitating for the current mayor (himself an ex-cop) to drop even that requirement[2]. Edit: I forgot to mention that two years of military service also exempts prospective cops from needing half of a college degree. [1]: https://www1.nyc.gov/site/nypd/careers/police-officers/po-hiring.page https://www1.nyc.gov/site/nypd/careers/police-officers/po-hi... [2]: https://www.nydailynews.com/news/politics/new-york-elections-government/ny-nyc-mayor-eric-adams-nypd-college-credit-requirement-20220318-pyikz445izewllhcddhp5hg6cq-story.html https://www.nydailynews.com/news/politics/new-york-elections...
- 0des 4y agoWhere I am all you need is a GED or high school diploma and no felonies. They do drug test, but I'm told you're informed in advance.
- woodruffw 4y agoYou and Chicago (unless you also live in Chicago!)[1]. [1]: https://news.wttw.com/2022/03/10/police-drop-college-credit-requirement-some-recruits-amid-attrition-spike-top-cop https://news.wttw.com/2022/03/10/police-drop-college-credit-...
- 0des 4y agoSimilar in some ways, but no, just the south.
- SoftTalker 4y agoYeah I can't see why being a street cop needs a college education. Note I'm not saying there should not be some aptitude and psychological screening. But I think plenty of people who didn't go to college could be good cops.
- pharrington 4y ago
- javajosh 4y agoIt's very easy to start generalizing and speculating. But does anyone know how prevalent the low IQ standard is across the country? Presumably its set by each department, so that's like 10k or 20k different policies.
- woodruffw 4y agoThere's no uniform policy, but the person in the article above eventually filed a case that reached the 2nd Circuit. The court determined that the police did not violate any discrimination laws by forbidding smarter applicants, because the test was applied uniformly[1]. Edit: it's left to us to understand why "uniform application" prevents discrimination. The court apparently didn't consider that a discriminatory test, uniformly applied, is still fundamentally discriminatory. [1]: https://abcnews.go.com/US/court-oks-barring-high-iqs-cops/story?id=95836 https://abcnews.go.com/US/court-oks-barring-high-iqs-cops/st...
- bombcar 4y agoProbably because “smart person” isn’t a protected class
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> it's left to us to understand why "uniform application" prevents discrimination. The court apparently didn't consider that a discriminatory test, uniformly applied, is still fundamentally discriminatory. The US legal system considers that all the time. Minimum IQ requirements run into legal problems because they have a disproportionately negative impact on blacks. But a low maximum requirement would have a disproportionately positive impact on blacks, so no problems there.
- silisili 4y agoProbably pretty common. When I was in my early 20s I applied for a relatively high paying job delivering beer locally. They had us all take a test...I don't remember a ton about it but it seemed a combination of general knowledge and 'IQ' testish questions. The guy told me nobody had ever got a perfect score before, but they wouldn't hire me. For the same reason listed in the article - I wouldn't stick around long before finding something better. The guy was nice about it, and said I could find something better than this position. At the time I felt a bit cheated, but thinking back I guess that's correct. I was off programming computers about 3 years later. That said, this was beer delivery, not tax funded policing. I think we'd all be better served by having smarter police.
- devilbunny 4y agoManagers appreciate skills, but want a warm body that won't bail in a couple of months, forcing the manager to cover the shifts themselves. A good beer example of how to get past that filter was the father of a childhood friend. He worked for a beer distributor all through college (back when drinking age was 18), and was wildly popular among friends for always knowing where the biggest parties were going to be every weekend. They knew he was going to be around for 3-4 years at least, so they could plan ahead (and probably count on him recommending someone for the job when he graduated).
- wombat-man 4y agoDoing beer delivery for a bit while you work out some other parts of your life sounds like an alright time to me.
- izzygonzalez 4y agoLong stretches of automaticity definitely give my brain a chance to simmer whatever ingredients are in it at the moment. One of the luckiest times in my first few years of work was being able to listen to audiobooks and podcasts for almost 40 hours a week, for several years. I think that gave me a little bit of a wide range of the world to begin building a complex systems model of it in my mind.
- 4y ago
- laretluval 4y agoI also thought that, based on his books
- idanman 4y agoA few jobs back when I was working for a fairly large telecom company there was a similar kind of thing for the software department. I was in hardware but sometimes I would interview software people if they were hired to participate on my project. The software department asked me to rank the interviewee on various categories and give a score. If the total score from all interviewers were larger than some value, they wouldn't hire them because they didn't want them to get bored and leave. Needless to say, this process frustrated many people. It was not consistent across the company though. For the hardware department there was no such system.
- imgabe 4y agoThere must be a better way to screen people who are likely to leave. While maybe being a beat cop walking patrols isn’t too intellectually stimulating (though I wouldn’t take that for granted) surely there’s other positions like detective and management that would benefit from intelligent people, and where are they going to get them if they filter out all the smart people up front?
- JasonFruit 4y agoOne of the smartest men I know was a police officer. He was frustrated with the poorly thought-through rules of the job and with his coworkers and commanders, and was never happy in that job as far as I could tell. He was indeed too smart to be a cop, or at least too smart to have wanted to be. It would have been better for him if he had been rejected. Was he a good cop? Depends on what you mean by that. He was non-violent, and conscientious, and principled, and enforced the law with unusual accuracy and precision — but whether his superiors were satisfied with his performance, I can't say. I'm inclined to imagine that they found his resistance to what he saw as bad, stupid, or unethical policies inconvenient, and his enforcement of what they saw as trivial violations tiresome. I'm inclined to doubt that his superiors appreciated his intellect. Are we really sure that it's unreasonable to reject an applicant because he is too smart, if it creates a dissatisfied officer and dissatisfied superiors?
- m4x 4y agoYou said he was frustrated with his coworkers and superiors, but that's probably due to not hiring many other intelligent officers. Hire more intelligent officers and you'll have fewer frustrated intelligent officers.
- saurik 4y agoIt is striking how there is literally not a single mention of what the community members think about this officer in your comment, only the satisfaction of other officers, even when talking about something--enforcement of "trivial violations"--that might have a direct negative effect on the community members.
- markdown 4y ago> negative effect on the community members. You misspelled positive.
- thaumasiotes 4y agoThe primary reason we call them "trivial violations" is that enforcing them causes more harm than it prevents.
- Miserlou57 4y agoThought I recognized that line https://youtu.be/ROmdZxS7lqE https://youtu.be/ROmdZxS7lqE (first minute or so)
- jamesdhutton 4y agoThe theory that officers who are “too smart” will get bored and leave could be tested empirically. One could look at past hires, and make a graph of test scores vs length of service. This data would help inform the discussion.
- reggedtorespond 4y agoThis is addressed in the article. The plaintiff provided evidence that intelligence does not impact job satisfaction, however the courts ruled that the factual reality did not matter. What mattered is that the hiring department thought that his intelligence would be a problem.
- philipswood 4y agoNow they just need to enforce an equivalent rule limiting the intelligence of the criminals they need to catch.
- bryanrasmussen 4y agoGiven that policing is supposed to offer a path into the middle class https://www.policemag.com/374280/law-enforcement-a-path-into-the-middle-class https://www.policemag.com/374280/law-enforcement-a-path-into... - as the middle class gets squeezed is the idea that smarter people will leave policing to go on to other jobs less likely to be correct?
- bdixat 4y agoI hate the fact that cops with their sub 2.0 GPA don't understand what is necessary.
- shrubble 4y agoI came to the cynical conclusion that they didn't want as a general rule, a cop smart enough to investigate the dark areas of political corruption. Smart enough to write tickets and oppress the populace, but not so smart that they will investigate their political masters.
- aidenn0 4y agoI applied to Navy OCS after college, and got a soft rejection - the recruiter wouldn't return my calls. When I finally got a hold of them, they strongly implied that my abnormally high score on the aptitude test, combined with poor GPA suggested I had cheated on the test.
- mariuolo 4y agoCouldn't it be he was too old and they used the IQ as an excuse?
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoTakes all kinds to do all kinds of jobs. For instance software engineer and software QA are done best by entirely different kinds of people. One wants to get to a solution, skating around issues as they go by to get to a first successful implementation. The other wants to notice every issue that is encountered and carefully investigate it and record it. Maybe it's good to have a few outliers in every job to keep the others honest.