12 ms·
Google's history with messaging services has been a mess. I don't see how they will ever get anywhere if they are always starting over. I have very little inter
by al_borland 4y ago
Google's history with messaging services has been a mess. I don't see how they will ever get anywhere if they are always starting over. I have very little interest in anything Google makes in this space as a result.
Google Talk, Chat, Meet, Duo, Messages, Hangouts.... I'm sure Im missing some. It's like they don't have any idea where they want to go and need to make a whole new service every time they have an idea, instead of just adding a feature to their existing service.
- thefourthchime 4y agoIt's like 12 or 13. I've never seen a company fail this much at something.. They need to create a Razzie just to give it to google for their total incompetence at chat. https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/08/a-decade-and-a-half-of-instability-the-history-of-google-messaging-apps/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/08/a-decade-and-a-half-...
- dane-pgp 4y agoThat's a very comprehensive article, thank you, but I'm reminded of an earlier one from 2018 with the amusing title: "Google to simplify messaging strategy, will support only five messaging apps" https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2018/12/google-promises-to-shut-down-two-of-its-seven-messaging-apps/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2018/12/google-promises-to-s...
- orthoxerox 4y agoI remember reading this article and thinking, "okay, this is already absurd, things can't get any worse" and then there's another chat engine Google once used to have. And another. And it keeps going on.
- imglorp 4y agoIt's only failing if you define that as "not dominating the planet's chat", which has a bunch of externalities. Several of their chat products were decent and companies were able to run all their internal meeting rooms off them. What IS a failure is the thrash within that whole set of products. Adoption of new users via network effect is the activation energy and every flipflop halves their potential new market. If they had simply stayed on, say, hangouts and kept improving it, they would keep all those users they lost.
- delecti 4y agoAlso Allo and Buzz, plus chatting with other editors in Docs. SMS through Voice also integrated into Talk/Chat/Hangouts at various points. If they had put an even remotely competent person (who cares about more than just getting promoted) in charge and they could have been a leading player the space by just keeping things clear enough to follow.
- colechristensen 4y agoIt is clearly the result of the internal structure of Google where no one in charge is seemingly that interested in producing cohesive products, there is apparently a kind of internal competitive economy which results in this and other nonsense.
- IceWreck 4y agoYoutube Chat and Google Maps chat too
- TedDoesntTalk 4y agoWhy the heck would Google Maps have chat??
- pooper 4y agoWaze has (or has had) beep beep as long as I can remember but nobody questions why Waze has chat...
- petre 4y agoSo you can text while in a traffic jam and probably hit the car in front if you?
- vagrantJin 4y agoAsk for directions? ba dum tssss.
- cuteboy19 4y ago
- aaronbrethorst 4y agoI don't see how they will ever get anywhere if they are always starting over I'm sure literally thousands of Google employees have gotten promoted on the strength of their work on building out yet another new chat platform. That's why they keep doing this; it has nothing to do with any sort of broad corporate strategy. It's individuals optimizing for their own success instead of for some vague notion of corporate success.
- akkartik 4y agoThat explanation helps but doesn't explain why new chat apps get greenlit more often than new local shopping sites, social networks or balloonshots.
- andrewstuart2 4y agoPromotion Driven Development combined with https://xkcd.com/927/ https://xkcd.com/927/ and a heaping helping of decentralized decision making and probably charisma in order to convince someone that This Time It's Different™.
- travisgriggs 4y agoA never ending boatload of enabling cash from the golden goose of adtech monopoly certainly contributes to this as well?
- YZF 4y agoDefinitely. Basically the business results (ad revenue) is more or less decoupled, in the short and medium terms, from what I would guess 90% of engineers in Google do. So calculate digits of Pi, write books and blog posts, write chat apps, reinvent any wheel possible, rewrite code all the time. A lot of Google's software is actually becoming worse, search, chat, navigation/maps as the 10% that are doing valuable work are fighting entropy and the other 90%. Pure speculation (other than the part about their software becoming worse) so would be interested in the insider's take here. That said it's a pattern I've seen in other places. It's crazy that with so many people of this caliber they're basically spinning their wheels in many areas. Some progress in a few areas, like cloud.
- gedy 4y agoYeah I'm just one person, but their confusing and chaotic approach to messaging apps and the Inbox vs GMail thing a few years ago were the two things what turned me from respecting Google and interested in their new apps into believing the don't have any idea or care what they are doing and better off not trying out or depending on their offerings. (Thank goodness they haven't done same to maps and docs).
- techdragon 4y agoThat’s a really good way to describe it. I no longer respect Google. Their core search engine is in decline, their cloud is innovative but useless and has the most confusing UI of the three major cloud vendors, they began weaponising open source as a recruitment pipeline, and they can deliver a product with any sort of expectation that it will last more than 12 months anymore… I have lost respect for them. I have gone from an enthusiastic Search and chrome and gmail user… I got into the invite only beta in the first six months! … to basically only caring when Google do things that affect the non-stuff I actually care about.
- brian_cunnie 4y ago> cloud is innovative but useless and has the most confusing UI of the three major cloud vendors I beg to disagree: I find AWS's UI the most confusing--I am showered with services I don't use & don't know what they do (Beanstalk? I have no idea what that is). I find that if I stick with VPC and EC2 I'm safe, but even then they throw some curve balls at you: for example, VPC is all about networking & IP addresses unless you're talking about Elastic IPs, in which case you need to go to EC2. Azure's interface is okay, but the sliding menus-thing throws me off. Google's is the cleanest UI IMHO. Not too many services, intelligently grouped. Although I've used AWS the longest & am used to its idiosyncrasies, I'm under no illusion that its UI well laid out.
- jedberg 4y ago>It's like they don't have any idea where they want to go and need to make a whole new service every time they have an idea, instead of just adding a feature to their existing service. It happens because of their internal promotion culture. You get a promotion much faster if you make something new than if you improve something old.
- ironmagma 4y agoDon’t they have a rule that you can’t create something that competes with another Google product? How do any of these get created in the first place?
- londons_explore 4y agoThere is no such rule. "Make a better thing thats so good that the users all choose to use the new thing over the old thing" is the aim...
- al_borland 4y agoThat was probably a fine idea when they were getting started and just throwing ideas against the wall when starting at 0, but they are a big establish company with big established products. They can't just throw the baby out with the bathwater every time and expect users to actually be on board. Google Wave was the perfect example of that. Wave would have been amazing if it was integrated into Gmail. Like Apple did with iMessage, if a Gmail user emailed another Gmail user (or group of users) it would turn into a Wave and get a bunch of extra features. This would have provided value, instantly given it millions of users, and encouraged current users to get their friends and co-workers on Gmail to use Waves. Instead, they made it it's own invite-only service (trying to recreate the Gmail magic) and it was a failure due to lack of users. This is a horrible strategy and they are going to continue shooting themselves in the foot if they don't pivot.
- houseofzeus 4y agoAlso, never consider how you will migrate users of the old thing if you are ever actually successful.
- duxup 4y ago> are always starting over I wouldn’t mind it if they kept features or something. Some coherent process, features, etc. But it is a half baked deal every time with old / obvious features missing. They operate like a mini no name start up and as far as I’m concerned I don’t think of it that way / if it has the name Google I expect some level of polish…maybe respect the users who get dragged from app to app…
- noneeeed 4y agoIt's like what happened with Google Pay (I think it was that) where they rewrote it from scratch with fewer features, it was so bizarre.
- denimnerd42 4y agogoogle play music to yt music. they rewrote from scratch with less features and more bugs
- refulgentis 4y agoHN tends to read deprecation notices (in this case, for a 17 year old frontend) and immediately bring up every marketing name for anything and everything involving text communication Google has ever made. For the record: - v1 - "Gchat" - simple chat added to Gmail - v2 - "Google Talk" - 2005 - general chat service created out of "Gchat" enabling people to use it outside Gmail - v3 - "Google Hangouts" - 2013 - integrate video chat from G+ into Talk - v4 - "Google Meet/Chat" - 2017 - split Hangouts into video (Meet) and messaging (Chat)
- mpol 4y agoIf it is all different frontends to the same backend, they very much failed at marketing. For an advertising company, creating this much chaos in their branding and communication is very confusing and somewhat laughable.
- q-big 4y ago> For an advertising company Google is not an advertising company, but a provider of space for advertising.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoDistinction without a difference Its not like they assemble billboards
- joshuamorton 4y agoIdk that really feels like what adsense and such are.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoDo people that make billboards create complex algorythms to evaluate their efficiency and charge you per each glance the billboard get?
- throwaway675309 4y agoWhen are we going to get the google version of WOOF to unify all of these disparate services?
- triggerman722 4y agoUnderrated post...assuming you mean wuphf lol
- dehrmann 4y agoThey also acquihired Meebo.
- torvald 4y agoDon't forget a out Google Wave!
- flowerbeater 4y agoOr Google Buzz!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- PontifexMinimus 4y agoWas it Google Messages the one that came up as a pop-up in gmail and let you very easily do videoconferencing? I can't remember.