3 ms·
What happened when you closed the lid?
by renewiltord 4y ago
What happened when you closed the lid?
- abdusco 4y agoPresumably, it doesn't sleep or wakes up inside a backpack. I had a 2016 XPS13 with that issue and I keep reading it still exists after all those years.
- The_Colonel 4y agoThat's not a bug, it's a feature called "Modern Standby" pushed by Microsoft where laptops essentially run 100% of the time, unless you turn them off. It's incredibly stupid and contra-productive. It's supposed to provide "instant on" experience while it makes the exact opposite. Because I can't safely put it into a backpack without fear of it exploding or catching fire, I'm forced to go through lengthy turn off/on/hibernate procedure everytime I carry the laptop anywhere.
- vladvasiliu 4y ago> It's supposed to provide "instant on" experience Is that actually the case? I can't think of any of my laptops, PC or Mac, that would have me wait around for them to wake up, including those running Linux. It basically takes me more time to open the lid and get my hands on the keyboard than it takes the laptop to wake up. I always thought they were trying to copy Apple's "power nap", for checking email and whatnot while asleep. I always found this stupid on macOS, even though by default it only does it if it's plugged-in, so likely to have network access. Whereas my current PC laptop doesn't even have S3 sleep anymore, regardless of plug-in state. I know about hibernation, but it has quite a bunch of RAM, and despite the fast SSD, it takes longer to go to sleep and wake up than my older, slower ones with S3 did.
- The_Colonel 4y ago> Is that actually the case? > I always thought they were trying to copy Apple's "power nap", for checking email and whatnot while asleep. I think it's both, or that the latter is part of the former - "instant on" includes things like e-mail being already received etc., essentially a smartphone experience. But it's not a smartphone, obviously, I've never got burned and had battery swelled on my smartphone simply because I dared to put it into my pocket. Laptops, on the other hand, are not supposed to be mobile devices anymore and should stay stationary, at least according to Microsoft.
- harry8 4y agoI'm not entirely sure. Apparently it doesn't sleep properly and gets hot to the point where it fries the motherboard when you put it in a bag. I've found out that's a common fault, known to Dell since when a story hit the front page here. The bile in me comes from the fact that I don't usually actually do that so it didn't happen still in warranty. On the occasion I did it was because I wasn't home, I was sitting beside an intensive care bed. Dell sure as hell don't warn you that "This is not actually a laptop and you can't treat it like one" But they do know it, apparently. But screw the customers is their mantra, it would seem. What I do know for sure is that since closing the lid and placing it in a bag it doesn't boot. Doesn't get to bios. Many hours trying to work out led patterns, which inconsistently identify different faults are fruitless and if you replace the motherboard you are gambling that it will work after you incur the expense and it's more expensive than buying a new laptop with ram and disk and a power supply, and if it's not Dell you can close the lid because it will actually be a laptop. There is no way that Dell actually stand behind what they sell you and charge premium prices for. Utter garbage. Whoever heard of a laptop that you cannot close the lid and put in your bag? Well I have because I found it out after paying for Dell's overpriced, yet cheap and nasty e-waste. There's plenty of people who share that experience with me so you can say that Dell have thoroughly earned this reputation for garbage product and worse service. So yeah, I'm not encouraging anyone to buy Dell. Why would I unless I hated people? edit: Added the following links https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28639952 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28639952 https://www.dell.com/community/XPS/FAQ-Modern-Standby/td-p/7514448 https://www.dell.com/community/XPS/FAQ-Modern-Standby/td-p/7...
- renewiltord 4y agoCrazy. So it doesn't reliably sleep. That's super lame.
- harry8 4y agoDunno. Could be. I'd be a lot more sure of saying simply that Dell laptops are not fit for purpose and Dell dodge their responsibilities over selling you something that can't operate as generally expected also failing to tell you clearly and obviously in ways you can't miss before you buy it. Of course if they did tell you before you bought it nobody would. Could be "doesn't reliably sleep" But that sort isn't the real problem even if it is closely related to some technical cause of the original issue that cascades to this total failure that is 100% Dell's responsibility whatever it's initial trigger.