10 ms·
Why can’t we remember being born or our first words?
- dontbenebby 4y agoWould you want to?
- jannikarndt 4y agoI find the distinction between “semantic memories” (of facts), “procedural memories” (how to do something) and “autobiographical memories” (stories from the past) very helpful when thinking about memories.
- verisimi 4y agoYes - that's very good. I would re-state what you said as: "semantic memories" (of facts in objective reality), "procedural memories" (how to do something) and "autobiographical memories" (of subjective experience).
- ksaj 4y agoI think in order to recall something, you need to have some internalized understanding of it. In those very early formative years, you're still trying to understand 3D vision, and haven't yet learned to apply the shapes and colours you see to the crayons your using to scribble on the wall. In the same way that if you fail a high school math test based on material you covered in class already, it is because you were unable to recall the bits you don't yet understand. You've seen it before the test, but since you didn't understand it, you can't recall and apply it.
- SilasX 4y agoRight, like the machinery for recall is still being built. Similar to how a tape recorder can’t record the sound of itself being constructed.
- Tor3 4y agoI have only two clear memories from when I was around 2.5 years old. I think they stuck because of an unusual connection. There was a guy who used to come to our door and sell eggs, in huge 24-egg cartons (I didn't count them, I just remember the big square size). And then one day we took a long drive in my father's old car, along wet dirt roads, and ended up at a country house where my mother bought a sewing machine. And it was the same guy selling that one. So he was clearly some kind of peddler of various diverse items (and his farm house explained where he got the eggs from, but that's my much later reasoning). (the sewing machine is still around, btw, a lifetime later). For other memories I don't have any clear ones until I'm a bit more than three years old. But I have lots of them. Edit: Oh, and of course the memory from when I was exactly three.. I fell on my head from quite high, landed on ice.. I probably fainted, but I remember a guy came and carried me home. I got a concussion from that.
- al_borland 4y agoMost strong memories are either linked to a strong emotional event or can be linked to a lot of other memories/ideas. If I get a new piece of information, I'm much more likely to remember it if I can relate it to things I already know. The things that don't relate to anything else are difficult to remember, or at least difficult to recall. My theory is that when you're first born you have no basis to relate anything to. Eventually you experience enough things that your brain starts making connections to make it easier to start remembering things. Those early memories, if they exist, are orphaned and lost to time without a clear path to recall them.
- kqr 4y agoExcept when you're born you've been around for a few months already, likely felt one thing or another shared with your mother. You're right in another way, though: when you are born your body is still not physically wired up completely yet, a process which starts in the womb but we're not in there long enough to allow it to complete. This is part of the reasons newborns flail around so much -- they're learning what's connected to what, and that takes lots of repetition. I would be surprised if this didn't affect the physical wiring of the brain, too. Also keep in mind that in the body, connectedness is not a binary idea. It's really the strength of connections in relation to each other that make up how we respond to things.
- pessimizer 4y ago> Except when you're born you've been around for a few months already With the same level of stimulation that you get from a sensory deprivation tank (by design.) Without memories and associations to get lost in, lying in a sensory deprivation tank would probably be a completely timeless thing, no different than being dead. There's very little you're going to learn in the womb that will help you to interpret what's happening outside, other than you may get some experience with the sounds of your mother's language. [edit: Feelings of acceleration? A sense of one's own mass?]
- darkerside 4y agoNot quite sensory deprivation. You certainly feel circadian rhythms and movement, and can likely hear talking and music.
- analog31 4y agoBeing born is a clearly demarcated event, but first words are probably not.
- trompetenaccoun 4y agoMore like being conceived is, but at the moment we likely weren't conscious. From then on it is a long and slow process of becoming aware. Birth is only one of many steps on the way, it's more special for the mother and others than the person itself.
- cvccvroomvroom 4y agoCompared to many other species except marsupials, human babies aren't close to fully developed. It has to do with evolutionarily with infant brain size and the size of a woman's pelvis. Few other animals have such as a high mortality rate. Sheep, which are domesticated animals, are close in infant mortality rate to humans.
- crummy 4y agoThere's an alternative explanation: https://www.gocomics.com/calvinandhobbes/1989/08/01 https://www.gocomics.com/calvinandhobbes/1989/08/01
- strogonoff 4y agoAmong the different takes on consciousness one goes that we become conscious when our minds begin to model humans close to us. As you model others in your mind continuously over time, you end up modeling their minds, which leads to creating a model of yourself embedded in them; consciousness as a sort of feedback loop. Yes, it implies that we are essentially conscious through others and no man is truly an island. As the article mentions, it might explain the lack of autobiographical memories in early years. It also explains how treating a person as if they were X results in them eventually behaving as if they are X, especially if you are of consequence to them (a parent, a teacher) or if this treatment is persistent in their life. Since their model of themselves is partly your model of them, it adjusts correspondingly to whatever label they are assigned.
- agumonkey 4y agoI forgot where and what but I discussed the idea of us being waves of perception diffusing along peers. An evanescent phenomenon.
- pessimizer 4y agoThere's very little in a baby's head to hang those memories on. Not only can we not remember birth, but I'd bet that the baby doesn't remember it after five minutes or so (after the fear that it might happen again dies down.) The only reason I can recall anything is because the words that I use to try to recall it ("what did I do yesterday morning?") take me down a chain of associations that hopefully will spit me out yesterday morning sometime, and that thing I remembered (maybe that I dropped one of my shoes when I was putting them on, or that one of my teeth hurt when I brushed it) can be a conduit to remember the rest of my morning. The memory experiment just seems like spaced repetition to me [edit:which you can use to teach a cockroach, or a worm.] They show a baby a unique object with a particular use. The next time they show the baby that unique object, they either recall the particular use, or the experimenter demonstrates it again. As these periods grow longer and longer, the memories grow longer. The intuitive reason it would be less effective earlier in life than later is because babies can't see properly, or understand the positions of things in space, so they don't care when a mobile or a train moves; they don't recognize it as interesting. Note: I can never remember what I did yesterday morning, because with the way I process the world, there's usually nothing in the sentence "What did you do yesterday morning?" that would associate with a particular day; every morning is yesterday morning. If I'm celebrating having done something significant "yesterday," however, I can start with that thing and work backwards to how I prepared for that thing. Some people are journalers/diarists, or heavily scheduled, and knowing what they have to do today, or maybe the last thing they wrote in their journal, would bring up almost immediately the memories that I have a huge difficulty recalling.
- codefreeordie 4y agoWe have done some interesting studies on infant memories. At first, you are correct that they basically can't remember anything. Even then, though. At a very early age, they will recognize their mother. This comes well before "object permanence," which happens at about 8 months. (Object Permanence is the ability to remember a thing even after you can't see it anymore, and to recognize it as the same, rather than a new one, when it returns. It is the ability to mentally follow an object when it "goes away" and to understand that it still exists)
- dsego 4y agoI've lost the visual memories, but I remember having memories from an early time, short glimpses. Things like trying to repeat words and the grownups not being patient enough and moving onto the next word before I could attempt to speak. Faint memories of my first steps, walking from my father to my mother, being proud, stuff like that. I remember a particular new year's eve, the grownups were dancing and I was in a crib alone, feeling left out. I remember not liking to wake up in the dark, being scared and crying for mom to get in, or the sensation of having a soiled diaper. People don't believe that I remember. My brother is the same, we still hold onto some distinct memories from really early on, although the specifics are getting muddled and eroded.
- mwint 4y agoWow, I always thought I had abnormally early memories, but nothing like this. Do you have these memories only from being very young? Or are the glimpses there from infant up to now?
- dsego 4y agoUnfortunately, I'd forgotten a lot from my school years. There are of course moments, some more vivid than others, but I can't really remember my classmates, teachers, school activities and such anymore. I don't really reminisce a lot, maybe I could dig up the memories if I had someone else from that period to talk to.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- abyssin 4y agoDuring a psychedelic trip, I had similar memories of how difficult speaking was in early childhood. It made me quite proud afterwards that I had finally managed to master speaking. During the same trip, I also heard my mother as if my mental dictionary of sounds was made of her voice.
- mongol 4y agoI remember being carried around, having diapers changed on some table in a bathroom. "Oh back here again", I started to think. I am not kidding, of course I did not think that in words, but just the familiarity of it happening over and over. I believe those are true memories.
- justinlloyd 4y agoMemory is weird. Interestingly language shapes memory. There was a study I read years ago (digging up that citation would be next to impossible) that revolved around psychologists asking adults to recall memories from their childhood. And what was curious about the study is that all of the participants reverted to using simpler, more child like vocabulary to describe the memories, because the memories formed at the time were formed along with the level of language they had. I have observed this in myself when discussing certain computing concepts, talking about projects I undertook 20 and 30+ years ago, and describing in language those concepts that today we would simply say "oh, that's this data structure" or a particular technique or algorithm or concept. You observe the same thing in certain cultures that do not have the words to describe certain concepts, e.g. complex familial relationships in English. And you observe certain things in gendered and non-gendered Romance languages. I grew up before there were camcorders and video recording in every phone or even instamatic polaroid cameras in every hand at every point in life, and I have "core memories", very distinct events in my life, where I describe them as "riding a bicycle" moment. One day you cannot ride a bicycle, and then something clicks inside you, and then you can. Learning to swim, learning to read, learning to ride a bicycle, learning to wire up a circuit, learning to stand up in my crib, learning to take my first steps, learning to get out of the pushchair. I have a recurring nightmare, that has lessened over the years, as I've gotten older, but still holds the same terror, that forms part of my earliest memories, I would say I have had that nightmare before I could even speak coherently. It's like a movie that plays in my head, the exact same way, the exact same sounds, the exact same feelings of dread. I also log a lot of my life, so I don't recall "yesterday" but I can tell you a lot of what was going on in my life on any particular day, from deaths of pets and family members, to changes to my workshop, to code I wrote, to algorithms I was pondering, to new stuff I learnt.
- agumonkey 4y agoI'm surprised my brain remembers a lot of weird dreams I had along the years. Most often completely imaginary, psychedelic ones with no relation with reality.
- amesdemarbre 4y ago
- wudangmonk 4y agoI remember waking up and walking around the house until I ran into one of my parents. My father was complaining about something that apparantly I had done, he wanted me to say a phrase that obviously pointed to me and I remember thinking that it was dumb since that was the same as a confession. Notheless I repeated it to him since more than anything it seemed he just wanted me to say it for his own amusement. Shortly after while I was under this fog of confussion I was given photographs of me with some cousins at some nearby park, the event had happened a week earlier and I was very intrigued by these photos and spent a long time looking at them trying to recall the event in some way but no matter how much I tried I never did, to me it was the same as looking at a stranger's photos. That's my first memory, since then its been an uninterrupted stream. By my calculations I must have been older than 3 and younger than 5 since I remember when my sister was born who is the youngest but not my younger brothers. If someone ever mentions a past event all I ever need is a few pieces and then I will eventually recall without problems and with many more details than they themselves remember, same thing with any photograph that includes others. I've never experience anything similar to that initial event.
- noasaservice 4y agoWeirdly enough, I have a distinct memory when I was "young". Young was in my case, 1.5 years old. I met my great grandmother, whom was nearing her death. She knew that we were making one last visit and that I was coming. I remember meeting her, being in the old 80's hospital room with the upper white and lower green tiles. I remember how frail her hands were, like delicate paper. I remember getting out of my stroller and laying my head on her hand, carefully. I could feel this was my last and only moment with her, and that somehow a continuation or some completion was right then and there. I have other memories that become more 'solid' later. My memories really start around when I was 3 onwards, along when I was able to read. I never was taught... I just knew how to. My mom even still has my first alphabet I wrote down when I was 2.5y old.
- ddingus 4y agoI have a couple! 2 years old and some change: Direction was important to me somehow. I can remember the orientation of every house we've lived in. And it's coarse, like north, west, etc... The very earliest one is of being in my crib, bouncing the little spring that is wound around one of the shafts that hold the crib together. I would lay there and lift it up, and it would bounce. Boing, boing, boing... Lift higher, more bounces. Slamming it down worked too. A related one, a bit later was flicking the little springy door stop and realizing they were the same kind of thing! And that realization is probably why I remember. I can remember my crib, parts of the house, and the porch with little walk leading to the fence and the little gate that could open to the sidewalk, out of our yard, into the world. One day, my parents set me down, opened that gate and walked next door, across the street! And there was this other little kid. A little older than me, his name was "cash" and I had associated "cash" with money, and why would someone name a person like money? I thought about that a lot while we met, and I have a set of photos from that day in my head. The walkway, being set down to walk. The gate opening, or open. Walking up to Cash, my parents on my left, us talking while they talked, and then the best: Cash said, "you want to play downstairs?" I said, "yeah" because I had been downstairs in our house a time or two and people had all manner of interesting stuff in the downstairs! Parts, equipment, things, and all sorts of smells, and the walls are usually not finished, can see stuff we don't always see. We walked in the door, Cash opened the door leading downstairs and flicked a light switch, and the light came on. He said, "Two way switch" and that it just worked when you needed it to. I remember being super impressed! Like that was some high tech our house did not have. Their house was much bigger than ours... I need to cut this short. Bottom line is those people were thieves. They had way more stuff downstairs than I had seen and it solidified in my mind. Tires, radios, stuff.. Years later, age 17'ish, I mentioned all this to my mother, who said they moved after finding out! The people in this discussion saying that memory is about connections are on the right path. The earliest ones I have also have a basis, a connection of sort, a place to be.
- mosquitobiten 4y agoAm I the only one who remembers the "black void"? Before my first visual memory I was feeling something and nothing at the same time, it was like a black void that lasted a moment.
- peterburkimsher 4y agoMy ex-girlfriend told a similar story. Her mum had chosen a "natural" home birth without anaesthetic. Years later, soon after learning to speak, the baby girl (my ex) kept talking about going back into the warm, dark, safe room. By the time she and I were in a relationship, it was unclear whether it was her own memory, or just what her mother had repeated back to her over the years. But the story has stuck, and it does make me think deeply about life.
- mongol 4y agoI don't know what you refer to. But I have some kind of memory that I think may be from the womb. It is very hard to put into words, but something similar to waking up from sleep. Just a memory of consciousness. Even if this memory may not be real, just "remembering" it makes me dizzy, because it feels like it is a memory from when the light was turned on inside me, so to say. A very strange feeling.
- mosquitobiten 4y agoYour description is similar to what I referred as a "black void".
- wmwmwm 4y agoI remember several times putting my eldest son to bed when he was a few months old and having this intrusive thought that maybe the reason why he was yelling was because he knew he wouldn’t remember today when he woke up the next day and that every day was like being reborn! Darker than a Black Mirror episode for sure! It only went away when he started developing more of his own personality (This stuff + sleep deprivation is a heady cocktail!)
- jessermeyer 4y agoThis is some approximation of what half the globe already believes to occur with reincarnation, but it is not felt exclusively as a dark terror. More like the setting and rising of the sun. The nights are dark and full of terror, but it is cast away with the coming rays.
- eatbitseveryday 4y agoBetter yet: do not feel as bad because kids won't remember. If you are sleep-training them and they cry for hours, they won't remember the next day anyway. Edit: this is what a pediatrician said to help console a parent who was hesitant to try sleep training
- treeman79 4y agohttps://hyperioncantos.fandom.com/wiki/Merlin_Sickness https://hyperioncantos.fandom.com/wiki/Merlin_Sickness A variation on Merlin Sickness.
- Pigalowda 4y agoKind of like object permanence though. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Object_permanence https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Object_permanence
- comboy 4y ago> he knew he wouldn’t remember today when he woke up the next day How can he be afraid of the thing that happened yesterday if he doesn't remember yesterday?
- aaron695 4y ago
- lottin 4y agoI remember standing on two legs for the first time.
- StopTheWorld 4y agoAnother thing is how can we date when a memory is? I have a collection of memories from when I was 22 months old, but I can date those in retrospect. I also have various memories of being fairly young, but have no idea if they were before or after 22 months as there is nothing to date them by. It's not that different than more modern memories - I can remember something happened about a decade back, but often have no idea if it happened eight years ago or twelve years ago, unless I can date and contextualize it by some means.
- jmyeet 4y agoI see a lot of claims like this. I believe you believe it's true. The scientific evidence is to the contrary however. Memory at this age is extremely malleable. And I mean "malleable" even years later. I mean "malleable" as in you can create false memories. Consider this experiment [1]. Participants were told about meeting Bugs Bunny at Disney. A significant number of participants then added their own stories of the same thing happening. Bugs Bunny isn't at Disney. He's a Warner Brothers character. What I suspect happens is that you're told about these events at various points, enough that you start to fill in the details. Dating memories from childhood is even more difficult. It's easy to be years off the mark. Often it's only successfully dated by corroborating details eg you remember a dog that died when you were 4 or you remember your room in a house that you moved out of. [1]: https://www.washington.edu/news/2001/06/11/i-tawt-i-taw-a-bunny-wabbit-at-disneyland-new-evidence-shows-false-memories-can-be-created/ https://www.washington.edu/news/2001/06/11/i-tawt-i-taw-a-bu...
- StopTheWorld 4y ago> The scientific evidence is to the contrary however The scientific evidence? Scientists have no idea why a nematode with 302 neurons moves to the left or the right, how can a scientist determine that I don't remember what I remember?
- conductr 4y agoI can confirm this happens to me. Several occasions I have a “memory” of something. A house we lived in, a late relative, etc. Things that have an oral history since before most my normal memory begins. I have an image in my head of what that memory was to me. (My normal memory is rather image recall based, even for facts I remember/see the books/movie/website where I saw it as a reference for the memory.) Except on a handful of these early memories, I’ve later, sometimes much later, found an old photo in one of the family albums that IS my memory. Leaves me somewhat in a minor existential crisis each time I realize my memory is a sham.
- dadjoker 4y agoAs Steven Wright says, "I kept a diary when I was born. It said, "Day 1 - Still recovering from the move. Day 2 - Everyone talks to me like I'm an idiot."
- uberdru 4y agoLot of interesting comments here. It is odd that we Cartesians consider "memory" to be a kind of passive process, like geologic sedimentation, RAM, or something like a material impression. Memory is interactive. It's a skill, like walking. I've taught kids the art. It takes work and very specific techniques. I'd point anyone interested in the topic to folks like Henri Bergson, or Frances Yates's "Art of Memory".
- sampa 4y agoI remember reading a book by Soviet neuropsychologist Alexander Luria about a man with 100% memory. Afair, he was able to recall the events right from his birth when he was still in a a crib. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solomon_Shereshevsky https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solomon_Shereshevsky
- elkos 4y agoMy father died when I was 3½ years old. Now that I'm a toddler's father I remember a bit more of him and my mom carrying me around or my crib. Hope my kid will more memories of me, her mom and the people that love her than the few I have of my dad.
- mackman 4y agoI remember visiting my moms house in my 20s and seeing an old dresser I had as a baby. I immediately had a flash of the feeling of chewing on the drawer handle. My theory is that the memories are there but they just don’t make a lot of sense to us once we start to use language for storage and recall.
- tiffanyh 4y agoAre you sure it’s a memory you formed in first-person, or is it a memory of you seeing a photo of yourself chewing on that drawer?
- bicx 4y agoI’ve had similar memories, and remember a specific taste of the furniture.
- ksaj 4y agoLikewise, I think most people remember the taste of crayons. Yet, when was the last time you actually tasted one?
- mod 4y agoI have a memory of falling off a dock when I was 3 while fishing. I think half the memory might be imagined, which is while I was underwater. I remember it being green and seeing fish nearby, which seems a little unlikely to adult me (I would scare the fish away presumably). The rest of my memory is being rescued. I'm relatively certain it's a real memory, because I can describe to you what it feels like to have your entire body weight pulling against your scalp, as my dad lifted me out by a handful of hair onto the dock. It was not painful, as you might imagine. It was rather nice.
- magicalhippo 4y agoI recall reading about a paper where they ran a test on kids just as they had started to learn language, and again a year later after they had learned a lot more. They did a vocabulary test and played a game. A year later they did another vocabulary test and memory recall challenge. They found that for the kids that remembered the game they played, if they didn't know the word for something at that point, they wouldn't use that word when recalling, even if they had subsequently learned that word in the meantime between tests. Their conclusion was that memories were closely linked to the vocabulary the kids knew at the time the memory formed. Been trying to find it again to no avail, sadly.
- mackman 4y agoWe moved when my baby was one year old. Both our old and new houses had stairs he would scoot down backwards on his belly. Once right after we moved he would reach the bottom and keep scooting backwards on the floor. He pretty clearly was thrown off by the fewer steps in the new house.
- tails4e 4y agoI've a terrible memory (actually I think its more accurate to say recall, the memories are in there, it's just hard to access at times). However my earliest memory is of seeing an orange glow as I was falling asleep in bed. I found out many years later, well in my 20s, that I used to sleep in a cot in my parents room that had an electric bar heater on the wall. We moved from that house before I was 1. Crazy.
- dboreham 4y agoBecause the brain is running the wetware equivalent of CP/M at this point.
- 0des 4y agoIt's not true for everyone.
- fukpaywalls2 4y agoSure we can. My first words were "I'm out!"
- MrMan 4y agoI remember a lot after about 6 months which is when I started running around. I remember my first word - "hot" after I burned myself on an iron at about a year old. but I used to remember everything, now a lot of it is gone.
- fercircularbuf 4y agoDuring a shrooms trip one sapphire blue sky day in Fall at university, I lost all access to my language faculty. It felt like an invisible hand was erasing my entire lexicon in huge swaths at a time until there were no more words left in my head. One moment I had thoughts. The next moment, after the last word blinked out of existence, I had only feelings. The clouds covered the sun, and a gust of wind passed over me, and I was cold, and I could only experience the sensation of discomfort. Then the sun emerged, and I was basked with warmth, and I experienced happiness that brought a smile to my face and a feeling of safety. For about two hours I existed in this language-less state. Without words I wasn't able to think. There was no internal dialogue. I couldn't reason about things, or think about the past or future. There were no words there to attach to the objects around me let alone abstract concepts. Then, as quickly as my language had been erased, it returned again in patches. Once it was all back I was able to reflect on this experience using my words. I have always wondered if this is what it is like to be a baby.
- alfiedotwtf 4y agoFor someone who's experienced loss of language, I have to say that your writing style is very vivid and poetic. I could only wish to have even half your diction
- jvanderbot 4y agoAt this point, because of a long history of meditation and other factors you'd recognize, I'm absolutely certain that there is nothing to our consciousness other than a narrative machine that creates who we are using words. This is why I believe were so close to AGI, just looking in the 'wrong' direction. We think AGI should have more than just a self-centered narrative, because we think we do.
- crotho 4y agoAs the person said, they still had qualia while without the ability to form a narrative, and another person has said it was hard to remember, because narratives act as a mnemonic. Having experienced ego-death myself, I can confirm that I still have a memory of the experience, but that it is more of disjointed impressions (hard to maintain memory of the chronology, which a narrative might be able to cement). But I was still conscious and experiencing things; that is precisely the weird part. You may have a point in some way (not specifically narrative alone, though): It is true that certain anesthetics don't even render us unconscious, but just make us forget what we were perceiving while having our CNS motor functions paralyzed... and maybe deep sleep is similar--while paralyzed maybe we forget our senses moment by moment. But ego death from psychedelics is not the same thing: it doesn't completely erase your ability to recall impressions and images. Either way none of this explains how qualia can arise other than it helps to remember things for us to have a sense of chronology/persistence of experience, and so I doubt a machine that can come up with a narrative of what it is sensing would magically have qualia (we would have no way of knowing, even if it claimed it did--all we could know is that WE are consciously observing an apparently conscious thing). I sometimes think that persistence of experience is an illusion maintained by memory. That every time we lose consciousness then regain it, "it" is simply a new instance that is a clone of the old instance with the illusion it is the same person due to memories and being in the same body. Like "the prestige" the man drowns each night and experiences death, but the clone has the illusion that it has been alive up until the point it was created. In this case I see consciousness and qualia as a temporary instance/shape of neurons activating in unison that is suddenly conscious, but can lose residency, and when it re-forms has the illusion "it" is the same thing and maintains an identity. Considering it takes many depths of artificial neurons to simulate a single human neuron, and the speed at which learning can regress is so slow now, I think we are a very very long way from having such an instance of consciousness appear in an active neural network. Such a network would need to be so analog that it would be effectively the same thing as actual grey matter, and you may as well just have a baby. At least with a baby you would have a true sense of the responsibility you have in creating such an instance (or persistent series of instances that creates an identity).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mikewarot 4y agoWhy would you want to remember something as close to a near-death experience as you can get? You're comfortable, then all the sudden, compressed through way too small an opening into a cold, loud, bright world, and find yourself suddenly forced to breath for the first time. If you could remember that, you'd have PTSD for life. It's too much like waterboarding.
- incanus77 4y agoMy earliest memories are from age 2 years, 8 months. They involve a cross-country bus trip and remembering a few things like my pillow on the bus, a kind of cereal I got to eat, and a carpet. I never brought them up with my parents (my mom took me on this trip) until 20-25 years later, at which point they didn’t remember these details. I’m able to date the trip, however, and thus my age. I have a number of other memories from the ~3 year age range, including my brother being brought home, and they are still pretty vivid, though of course I have played them back in my head many times.
- shsbdncudx 4y agoI remember being in the womb. I remember being born. And I remember many infant events. I don’t think it’s as black and white as the article makes out.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tiffanyh 4y agoIt’s like learning the VIM commands/language. I used VIM for a long time in read-only mode (not saving / creating memories). Then one day I finally learned the VIM language command “:w”, which allows me to save a file (save a memory). I wonder if memories are highly dependent upon learning a language/commands. Once you learn a language, it allows you to create and save.
- all2 4y agoI used to have nightmares of darkness, a heartbeat, and then things were growing brighter. I was very scared in those nightmares. I'm convinced that I would dream of being born when I was 3-5 years old.
- mildavw 4y agoI understood "infant amnesia" but wondered how far back my kids could remember when they were little. As soon as they could start to communicate with words (around 12 months?) I asked both kids about being born, and being in mommy's belly. They both gave descriptions I'd call accurate! "Wimming" my son said, meaning swimming inside of mommy's belly. And my daughter said "coooold!" when I ask if she remembered coming out of mommy's belly. I remember thinking "Holy shit, they remember it all."
- mod 4y agoIt would be cool to have that on video to show them eventually. If they're young enough, I'd do that!
- deanCommie 4y agoKids from age 1-4 also have an incredibly vivid imagination for fantasy, and can't tell apart the difference between reality and imagined scenarios sometimes. The prototypical scenario in which this is relevant is the whole "there is a monster in my closet". Sure, they just imagined it. But the visual feels just as real as if they had actually seen it. It's easy to dismiss this as an adult, but modern parental advice is to treat these flights of fancy very earnestly, and engage it on it's own rules ("I went inside the closet and I chased the monster away" is a much better strategy than "There's no monster in your closet") [this isn't advice for you, I'm sure you don't need it, but any non-parent reading that may find it interesting] My 2 year olds frequently tells me and my wife stories that we know are factually inaccurate. (Like something that happened on a walk with one of us so we know for sure it didn't happen) The best leading theories about infant amnesia is that language IS what causes it. Memories are indexed by different keys until language is developed. Once language comes in, it becomes the only key function for accessing memories, and the ones mapped before language just become unsearchable. I hope I'm wrong. It would be super cool if your kids actually remembered these things for real. But I doubt it.
- unsafecast 4y ago> The best leading theories about infant amnesia is that language IS what causes it. Memories are indexed by different keys until language is developed. Once language comes in, it becomes the only key function for accessing memories, and the ones mapped before language just become unsearchable. That actually makes a ton of sense. Also a bit eerie to think that my brain holds information that I just can't search for. I wonder if certain triggers could cause that information to surface, since even though our memories are searched through language, maybe there are other 'pathways' that can reach those spots. Kinda like memory that's not mapped in any pages, it's physically there but you can't normally address it.
- m463 4y agoI had a friend whose sister was mentally ill. When she wasn't on medication, she did not behave in a normal fashion. But then she took medication, and she was entirely normal. Thing is - her memories seemed to be locked to her frame of mind, so she could only remember what she did off medication -- when she was off medication.
- eurasiantiger 4y agoSome antipsychotics work by essentially blocking the activation of most neurotransmitter receptors, preventing neural circuits from firing. Newer ones also activate one or two specific receptors. It seems plausible that these two ”frames of mind” are two completely separate neuronal networks, and because one of them is entirely blocked while on medication, it tends to overfire when off medication.
- kgeist 4y agoI also wonder how much of what we remember is false memories. For example, I vividly remember my first steps when I was around 1 year old. But the details don't match what actually happened. It happened in a different house, for example. I think what actually happened is that my parents loved to tell this story every birthday of mine, I imagined how it might look like, and my brain formed a false memory. I read somewhere that a lot of what we remember is false memory (made up or distorted) and we are completely unaware of it.
- mikeywazowski 4y agoWhen I was little, my older brothers repeatedly told me that I'd pushed over a motorbike one day. I eventually believed them and formed a vivid memory of the incident, and it wasn't til my 21st birthday that my brothers came clean. 15 years later, I still have some recollection of pushing the motorbike over, but I think it's more like a memory of a memory now, since I know it didn't really happen. I don't think I'm particularly prone to suggestion (although I was young at the time). I feel like if it can happen to me, it must happen to other people also, and I too wonder how much of what we remember is false memories.
- eurasiantiger 4y agoThat’s straight up gaslighting.
- Doxin 4y agoYes. Children can be (unintentional) little shits. I could go on for hours about all the shit me and my brothers did to each other much worse than just gaslighting.
- unsafecast 4y agoWhen I was in kindergarten, I can't know how old I was, I clearly remember going to the window in our apartment and seeing my grandmother looking up at me, so I jumped and she caught me. Obviously not a true memory. I remember remembering it, and that feels weird, because I don't actually remember it happening anymore (saying that makes me realize that the false memory is either me remembering that, or me remembering remembering that). I think it came from a weird dream. It may have something to do with my mother telling me not to go near the window because I could fall. My grandmother used to visit us there a lot too, and I liked that. The brain is super weird.
- _han 4y agoI see it as follows: Infants have little concepts/constructs that can serve as foundation for thoughts. Being able to 'ground' thoughts in constructs that are understood helps with recalling the thoughts. At some point, the more basic constructs (the ones you created as an infant) are not as useful anymore, as your thoughts are now grounded in the more advanced constructs. This causes you to forget about the more basic constructs, as they are not used anymore; the basic constructs have served their purpose and you moved on to the more advanced ones.
- hoseja 4y agoI like the explanation it's because the network is only just assembling itself and is too soft and flexible to retain specific shapes (memories).
- chewonbananas 4y agoI have a clear memory of my first word "tractor" that I uttered upon having a green toy tractor, but although the toy and the word are correct per my parents' memory the word I spoke was more like "Tatogli".