4 ms·
The idea is so manifestly ridiculous that I suspect those who think it is true, want it to be true. Something I notice more and more as I age is that there’s a
by Waterluvian 4y ago
The idea is so manifestly ridiculous that I suspect those who think it is true, want it to be true.
Something I notice more and more as I age is that there’s a type of person who regularly externalizes responsibility. They seem to need excuses to absolve themselves of responsibility.
Parenting has been made so difficult by ever increasing standards of health and living, in conjunction with the continued fracturing of the extended family. It makes me wonder if externalization is a way to reconcile the impossible situation foisted upon many parents.
My wife and I have two kids under 6. We have a lot of money but almost zero family support. We cannot even begin to comprehend how people raise larger families with less. It seems impossible given how we barely get by at a socially acceptable standard.
- philliphaydon 4y ago> We have a lot of money but almost zero family support. Relying on family support right now with like no money . I’m amazed at parents who have little money and no family support and sometimes work multiple jobs. Lot of respect for those people as it must be hard and they power on.
- starkd 4y agoIt may be surprising, but children care less about the extras than adults do. They may outwardly complain about not having things other children have, but when they are grown, their predominant memories are not going to be shaped by that. They are likely going to be more emotionally distressed at remembering how their parents never spent enough time with them, because they were too busy at work making the money to buy all the expensive accomodations. Kids are resilient, and have a great imagination. Much of the busy work we subject them to only suppresses the imagination. As my uncle used to say, everyone he knew grew up poor, but they didn't even know they were poor until they grew up.
- cyberlurker 4y agoI think things like tiktok and instagram have made it difficult to not know/think you are poor.
- rapnie 4y agoYes, so much content aimed at driving consumerism, creating trends and fads for the latest fashion and gadgets, peer pressure to follow them. I find it adorable when young children are presented with some expensive present, they cry out in delight.. and start playing with the wrapping paper, ignoring the gift.
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 4y agoThen perhaps kids shouldn't have unrestricted access to social media? There are a whole host of societal and sociological problems that things like tiktok bring (remember the tide pods fiasco, and any number of things since then?)
- vwcx 4y agoRelevant: https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2022/06/10/meta-faces-lawsuits-mental-health/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2022/06/10/meta-fa...
- AussieWog93 4y agoMaybe it's just the people I know, but my (male) cousins who use TikTok and Insta basically just find stupid/inappropriate memes to laugh at with their mates.
- dragonwriter 4y agoTikTok and Instagram expand people’s social context beyond what it would be otherwise because of geography plus the strong existing force of race, subculture, and class (both imposed- and self-) segregation, yes.
- dash2 4y agoOh man, I'm not sure about that. As a teenager, I went to school with kids who were much richer than me. They got a regular allowance, I didn't. It was so painful because I could never join in anything. I ended up with this huge feeling of powerlessness. I think a bit of cash would have made a big difference to me. Maybe that's a sad reflection of our society, or teenagers in the 80s.
- frereubu 4y agoI had a similar experience. Although I agree that not having the money to buy objects may not affect childhood memories too much, not having the money to spend on social experiences (and I suppose that includes being able to buy objects that allow experiences, like sports kit), does hurt. Experiences with peers are closely allied to experiences with parents and family.
- starkd 4y agoNot having money (or material resources) also incentives you to develop your own internal resources/skills. To some extent, it's part of life.
- AussieWog93 4y ago100% this. It persists into adulthood too. "Keeping up with the Joneses" is basically just spending your money on the mandatory luxuries to remain a part of your social circle.
- candiodari 4y ago(just replying to this general thread of thought, not necessarily to your comment specifically) All these differences in opinion, all of which are probably true. It's almost like kids are in fact a complex 100 billion neuron learning system that cannot be usefully described by generalizations.
- lupire 4y agoThat's because your parents put you in a bad environment with bad people and didn't give you tools to protect yourself.
- agumonkey 4y agoIMO kids need to be heard and accounted for, on semi heavy important topics. Friendship, passions, emotional intelligence, structure of society.
- sekh60 4y agoOur little one is only 2 and a half, but once she is old enough to see a therapist (I think we have one nearby specializing in children as young as 3) we plan to take her at least once a year. Both my spouse and I have mental illnesses, and we want to keep an eye open for that. Also being a kid is tough! Lots of big emotions and we want her to have someone she can confide in. Probably will increase frequency as she nears and enters her teens.
- agumonkey 4y agoGood to anticipate the situation. That said, don't let everything happen in a therapist office, kids need to be known to their parents IMO. Maybe not 100% but a lot.
- sekh60 4y agoGood advice. We definitely model open communication between my spouse and I and we talk to her about her feelings a lot. We just want to give her another outlet and ear.
- cyberpunk 4y agoThe entire psychotherapy profession is complete snake oil. I guarantee ‘Thud!’ Would still have the same results today. Please, look that one up. All they do is label and try to resolve symptoms, thus creating nice excuses for not fixing things that actually cause you some problems. It’s like how drug and alcohol abuse policies that blame the drugs or alcohol don’t work. Personally, I wouldn’t send my kids anywhere near such pseudoscientific charlatans; having experienced them myself as a child. You’d do better to spend the time and money elsewhere.
- 4y ago
- dazc 4y agoYou don't know you're poor unless people around you have more money than you do.
- waynesonfire 4y agoI grew up poor among wealthy as well. I think what helped with my perspective is I spent time with communities that were even poorer than I.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> It may be surprising, but children care less about the extras than adults do. They may outwardly complain about not having things other children have, but when they are grown, their predominant memories are not going to be shaped by that. I've known adults from lots of different economic backgrounds, both in absolute terms and relative to the people they were in immediate contact with, and the ones that grew up relatively deprived compared to their immediate social context definitely do not support your description.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- fatherzine 4y ago"socially acceptable standard" <=== the problem? Was listening recently to a rather successful young media personality (syndicated AM radio show, owns a fairly visible media company, etc.) talking about the material circumstances of his upbringing in the '90s: 2 bedroom middle class house in LA, family of 6: 2 parents, himself and 3 sisters. They somehow made it work. Not sure about extended family situation, but come to think of it he also mentioned he chose his own house within walking distance of a worship center, per religious prescription.
- bcrosby95 4y agoYes, I was going to say something similar. You don't need an extended family. But some form of community that doesn't hate kids helps a lot. We're lucky to have great neighbors and we all help eachother with things. It's a bonus that they don't call the police whenever we aren't behaving like helicopter parents. Beyond that, stop listening to (non expert) childless people about how you should raise your kids. They mostly don't know what they're talking about. Even if they are your friends.
- bjt2n3904 4y ago> The idea is so manifestly ridiculous that I suspect those who think it is true, want it to be true. It seems like a far fetched idea, but it's very much not. There's a large and popular trend today that "it takes a village" to raise a child. Much of the anti-racism propaganda from 2020 highlighted that the nuclear family was part of "white privilege", or "white culture". You can still find the Smithsonian's infographic, or watch the "$100 foot race" that makes these points. It's such a tangled mess of nonsense that it's difficult to unweave -- but the premises is that children don't actually need a nuclear family, but American society has artificially created a need for it. It is perfectly sufficient for children to be raised by many different people in their lives. However, they argue that American society has been specifically structured to make that difficult, or impossible, with the specific intention of putting the underprivileged at a disadvantage, to somehow maintain privilege for the upper class. Saying that the nuclear family was designed to oppress families without a father is like saying gravity was designed by thin people to oppress fat people. The fact of the matter is that children need parents -- but don't think that opposition to this idea is far fetched. It's quite a prevalent idea, they just do a very nice job of making it sound sophisticated and intelligent.
- thfuran 4y ago>but don't think that opposition to this idea is far fetched. It's quite a prevalent idea Those two concerns are orthogonal.
- lupire 4y agoChildren need grandparents and uncles too, and the nuclear family cuts them off from that.
- fatherzine 4y agoI grew up in a "nuclear family" and had plenty of regular contact with grandparents, uncles and aunts. Perhaps the American version thereof has more issues, as young people are expected/encouraged to move 1000s of miles from their parent's house to maximize their economic output? Oh, it's just a few hours flight, no worries. In practice, family reunions happen at best once a year.
- Al-Khwarizmi 4y agoI suspect the economic system as a whole wants it to be true. The system wants parents working and yielding maximum economic output at all costs, kids be damned. It was very visible with the COVID-19 pandemic. At least in my country, a minor research paper with small sample size finding that kids in some age groups spread the virus less than adults (while kids in other age groups spread it more) was prominently featured in the media saying simply that "scientists had found that kids don't spread the virus", while other contemporary studies saying that of course they do (as common sense suggests) were never mentioned. Of course, this was used as an argument to open schools and nurseries as soon as possible so parents could go to work (in theory it was because of education... yeah, sure). The following I suppose is more country-specific, but in recent years, in my country, nursery schools have been officially renamed to "children's schools", with years having numbers (1st from 0-1 year, etc.) so it's indistinguishable from the latter school where they actually, you know, teach them things, and even uttering the word equivalent to "nursery school" is increasingly frowned upon by people who says "it's not nursing, it's education". And of course, language shapes reality so the underlying convenient idea is catching on, I have already heard parents who have the time to take care at their kids at home taking there instead because "they will learn more", "it's for their education" and such things, when anyone who has had a 1-year-old knows that what they most need is the undivided attention that they won't have in a room with 6-7 more kids and a single adult. The public discourse becomes more and more focused on making us think that parenting has to take a back seat to today's work culture (lest we start to think that maybe we should change work culture to accommodate parenting) so I'm not surprised in the least that convenient scientific results start coming up on how parenting doesn't matter. (Not accusing the scientists behind the study of anything, by the way. Different scientists can legitimally reach different conclusions, but then the media chooses what to feature and how to frame it, like in the COVID example above).
- candiodari 4y agoOne thing I do agree with: society and extended family used to take care of kids. Helping with everyone's kids, 150 years ago, was a non-negotiable part of simply living in a village. Kids played in the village, anywhere, and everyone watched out for their safety, behavior, and food, eating with anyone, was just not a big deal. Pestering the adults, even causing minor damage was normal and retribution was NOT allowed. Now society hates kids and throws all responsibility, whatever happens, on the parents. And this goes pretty far: from poverty to being out of immediate reach when something happens, from learning difficulties to serious behavior problems. It's all both the parents fault, and parents are THE ONLY ONES responsible for help. Youth services embodies this idiotic attitude perfectly: they enforce an ever-higher standard on everyone ... except, of course, on themselves. Anyone living in youth services lives in poverty, in an abusive, attention-starved environment where most are confronted with trauma, drugs, crime, even prostitution (and let's not get started on the abuse situations IN youth services. If you want a kid to abuse, foster care is an easy way to get a kid the police won't believe. A parent using an isolation cell on their own kid will get thrown in prison, but they're the norm in youth services, even in "open" institutions) The situation within youth services is that way ... to save money (but loads of money is spent finding more kids to throw into youth services, taking care of them once there, THAT cannot be allowed to cost anything. But it seems to me getting hit daily at home is preferable to the situation in a lot of youth care institutions). Parents are punished if a kid even witnesses a small crime, like a fight. For punishing parents, suspicion is enough (no need for proof). That a kid becomes pregnant at 13 while coming back drunk daily is NOT a reason to take a kid OUT of youth services ... but a parent insisting kids take public transport to school in the morning against the wishes of a social worker IS reason to use violence against the kids and parents to throw them into youth services.
- dahart 4y ago> We cannot even begin to comprehend how people raise larger families with less. Yes. The financial well being of the parents matters! I was surprised the article didn’t even mention this. Some of the for and against examples can be explained by the presence or absence of money, education in later life, and simple nutrition early in life, for example. The authors didn’t really explain what parenting matters for, nor what the theory they’re countering is claiming exactly. But if what we’re talking about is financial outcomes (and there’s some evidence it is: “Twenty years later, those children were still earning more than the control group.”) then it does need to be stated that financial outcomes of children correlates highly with the socioeconomic status of their parents. > The idea is so manifestly ridiculous that I suspect those who think it is true, want it to be true. FWIW, I usually try to take that as a sign that maybe nobody thinks it’s true, and/or the author is exaggerating or oversimplifying history, and/or that I might have misunderstood what the idea is. My sense for the first two at least was tingling a little while reading this.
- em-bee 4y agoTwenty years later, those children were still earning more than the control group i thought this was related to: mothers of growth-stunted children in 1980s Jamaica were taught how to engage their children with home activities to provide cognitive and psychosocial stimulation, their children caught up with their peers. i understood this to be a study where all parents had the same socioeconomic status, but the kids whose parents were taught how to engage them ended up being better off.
- dahart 4y agoThat’s a good point, you’re right. But the ability to “intervene” may depends on financial resources, right? And my point was that the metic being used is financial outcome. It’s true that financial outcome correlates with parental SES.
- em-bee 4y agowell, outside of that study, the socioeconomic status very well influences whether parents have access to that sort of knowledge. obviously. the study is simply unrelated to that issue. but it also shows that adult education can have a positive impact. when we are debating how we can raise the socioeconomic status of a group of people, the talk is mostly about better schools for the kids, but i have come to believe what we really need is additional education and support for parents.
- klenwell 4y agoI was introduced to Harris's theory in Pinker's books (I'm guessing How the Mind Works was the main one though I've read a couple of his books and wouldn't be surprised if he returns to the topic in a number of them). I think this article ignores one key leg of "Parents Don't Matter" team's argument. It's not that parents don't matter so much as peers matter a whole lot more. From Harris's Wikipedia article: Harris argues that children identify with their classmates and playmates rather than their parents and other adults, and that personality is formed both through efforts to fit in with the group or to compete with specific others. Kids are more interested in impressing their peers than their parents. Especially, in my experience, starting around puberty. So obviously parents can have a huge impact on their child's development by, say, locking the child in a closet for the first three years of his life. But in most cases, the argument goes, parents' ability to mold their child to their fondest ideals will be greatly circumscribed by these genetic and social factors. For a parent to overcome these forces requires extraordinary measures (see the Tiger Mom).
- michaelchisari 4y agoWouldn't it make sense that peers set the short-term expectations but parents set the long-term expectations? My values at 15 were almost entirely dependent on my peers, true. But decades later, those have fallen aside and the values of my parents have endured in a way those of my peers did not.
- orwin 4y agoOr extraordinary will. You should read Judith Polgar autobiography, or if you're okay with really weird experiments, her father's book on his daughters. It's probably the most disturbingly rational book, and an interesting view on feminism, but also show that you can mold your children however you want, at least pre-teens.
- iqkznnft 4y ago> there’s a type of person who regularly externalizes responsibility. They seem to need excuses to absolve themselves of responsibility. I've had this feeling for a long time, but you have articulated it very well, thank you.
- AussieWog93 4y ago>Parenting has been made so difficult by ever increasing standards of health and living, in conjunction with the continued fracturing of the extended family. Not just extended family, but community too! Who still talks to their neighbours? >It seems impossible given how we barely get by at a socially acceptable standard. This kills us too (one kid, almost 2). The worst bit is that so much of the "good mother" performance doesn't at all lead to positive outcomes for the kid. If anything, it just creates burnout and resentment in the parents.
- brnt 4y ago> If anything, it just creates burnout and resentment in the parents. That's something I find myself reminding my partner of from time to time: whatever we do, it must be bearable for us for some time, possibly long. So let's not make a habit of burning ouraelves up; sometimes we need to do less so we can do more.
- sircastor 4y ago> We have a lot of money but almost zero family support. We cannot even begin to comprehend how people raise larger families with less. My wife grew up in a big family with a lot of extended family very nearby. She’s frequently frustrated by the lack of support that get from my side, and I grew up very far from extended family. We are in the final steps of getting an Au Pair to ease the burden on her.
- clairity 4y agoany time you face a false dichotomy like nature/nurture, choose both. unproductive debates like these (>100 comments so far) stem entirely from a fallacious base. it's tiresome and boring (which technically makes it against hn guidelines). if your impulse is to argue for one or the other position, you haven't thought enough about it and/or haven't had enough life experience to internalize the complexity that the false dichotomy dumbs down and tries to gloss over. it's also a tool of division and diversion at a societal level to keep retreading tired and useless arguments rather than things that matter or are actually productive. any time you face a pat duality like this (most news, politics, etc.), don't jump into the mirage blindly, instead step back and reject the premise entirely.
- JackFr 4y ago> It seems impossible given how we barely get by at a socially acceptable standard. There’s a lot hidden in plain sight in that sentence.
- giardini 4y agoWaterluvian says >"We cannot even begin to comprehend how people raise larger families with less. It seems impossible given how we barely get by at a socially acceptable standard."< This is a bit snarky but your "comprehension" is seriously lacking! You're looking right at the situation and not seeing it: people do with less by spending less. They "make do." You don't need to "comprehend"; you need to meet some people who aren't as well-off as you and socialize with them.