7 ms·
The Birth and Death of the Office
- dnndev 4y agoI miss the office.
- acchow 4y agosame
- rhexs 4y agoI miss offices in reasonable locations. Instead they're all in the same 6-8 cities that all have increasingly bad homeless populations. No, I don't want to live in the Bay, New York City, Boston, Austin, or Denver. Please create small satellite offices in reasonable cities instead of mega campuses in towns that all seem to have public libraries that are now defacto homeless shelters. Tech imports most of the talent these days anyway, so I don't buy the "talent only wants to move to the Bay!" argument.
- mertd 4y agoThe US tried the suburban office park model. It's horrible.
- rhexs 4y agoDo I have to walk over feces and needles to get to work at a suburban office park model? Can I afford housing? Sure, sounds lame if I'm 23. What if -- crazy idea -- we have a variety of both options?
- mertd 4y agoUrban areas don't have to have lots of petty crime and homelessness. Let's not assume they come as a package. Certain sectors clustering together in a geographic region has nice advantages even for non-23yo non-single folk. One can hop jobs without uprooting the rest of the family.
- mathgladiator 4y agoIn Seattle, it became the norm. Honestly, my commute from an island required exiting a ferry terminal. On the way from the terminal to the office, I eventually went dead on the inside after stepping over sleeping homeless and wretched smells.
- hezralig 4y agoI used to work in San Francisco and after buying a house on Bainbridge Island, I now work in an office around the Westlake Center. It really isn't that bad mate. After living around the world (central Europe, SE Asia), Los Angeles, the mid west, I can say that people who complain about smells and the homeless are incredibly sheltered. I find they tell on themselves when they complain about seeing homeless people when the crime rate is down across the board from the last 20 years. If you are so offended by seeing someone in distress, who is probably more dead on the inside trying to survive in a world whose upward mobility is strongly diminishing, then perhaps you shouldn't be going into that community to begin with.
- mathgladiator 4y agoMy solution, at that time, was to stop walking beyond the terminal exit then hailing an Uber to pick me up. That tunnel under the highway was bad. It's perfectly fair to complain whilst having empathy for people. The lack of solutions or even enforcement is a problem, and I voted with my feet to live away from it.
- hezralig 4y agoEnforcement of what? Sit-lie laws?
- mike50 4y agoSorry but any suburb of a real city NYC Boston Miami Washington DC is just as unafordable or needle ridden as the city.
- jollybean 4y agoHorrible ? It works extremely well. It's one of the reasons America is so rich. It's 'horrible' from the '3rd space' perspective, in that it doesn't make for quaint high street shopping ... but it works really well for teams that want to get together every day and do stuff without the fuss of complicated little villages and twisty roads, no space for parking. Kind of like major highways, they're good at what they were designed to do. They just have externalizations. Bad one's depending on how you measure.
- lizknope 4y agoI've worked in suburban office parks for 23 of my 25 years of professional work. They're fine. Nothing great, nothing bad. Just fine.
- thwarted 4y ago> I miss offices in reasonable locations. Instead they're all in the same 6-8 cities... The majority of the US population lives in the same 6-8 metro areas; so it's "reasonable" to put offices in those metro areas. I've worked at places with offices in downtown areas (short public transit ride or walk), in close suburbs (the extent to where public transit goes), and in remote suburbs (that require driving to get there), and the further away from city centers they are, the more brutal going to them is unless you already live in or relocate to the sleepy suburb the office is in (and then you still need to spend a not-insignificant amount of time driving, even for going places that are not your office, because suburbs are not, almost by definition, navigable without a car). > Please create small satellite offices in reasonable cities instead of mega campuses Do a lot of large companies have "mega campuses" in city centers? That doesn't make much sense, a campus requires a significant amount of land, land which is not available in city centers. Google's "mega campus" in the Bay Area is in the suburban part of the Bay Area (in as much as the Bay Area is mostly suburban sprawl anyway), and has "satellite offices" in downtown areas because that's where a lot of the employees live. I suppose Salesforce Tower could count as a "campus" if it's heavily populated with Salesforce employees, although I don't think one thinks of Salesforce Tower when the term "campus" comes up. Maybe the handful of buildings around Salesforce Tower that contained Salesforce employees could be considered a campus in aggregate (generally, a single building does not make a "campus"). Going into a small satellite office and interacting with most coworkers remotely is not really much different than working from home and interacting with coworkers remotely. You get the burden of going into an office without any advantages of in-person interaction. However, one of the reasons I miss having a dedicated office is that I have found that having a different place to work than my house does wonders for my general heads-down productivity and work-life balance, but that's independent of the many other advantages and disadvantages of having a communal, shared space where people working on the same thing can congregate.
- dijit 4y ago> The majority of the US population lives in the same 6-8 metro areas; so it's "reasonable" to put offices in those metro areas. Isn’t this self-reinforcing though? I moved to london because there were no jobs for people like me _anywhere_ else near where I came from. Thus, I contributed to the problem. When I broached the topic some years later with a company, they said that they moved to london because that’s where the talent is. It’s surely self-fulfilling.
- ciphol 4y agoAll the good jobs are in 6-8 cities because large cities have agglomeration effects that make them inherently more productive. The homelessness is simply a result of high housing prices [1] which in turn are the result of restrictive zoning. Remove restrictive zoning laws and most of the homelessness will go away. [1] https://twitter.com/aaronAcarr/status/1515774019685036033 https://twitter.com/aaronAcarr/status/1515774019685036033
- spicyusername 4y agoOnce remote working has been around long enough we'll probably see the rise of new social constructs that fill the void the office as the "second place" is leaving behind. The office was a crappy "second place" anyways.
- SoftTalker 4y agoBefore office work was the norm, what was this "second place?" Churches, probably? Taverns?
- iamstupidsimple 4y agoThose are 'third places'. The workplace was always the second place.
- yosito 4y agoChurches, pubs, town squares
- giaour 4y agoCoffeehouses, clubs (the kind Victorian gentlemen spent all day in), workshops for craftsmen
- Avicebron 4y agoI've always though those victorian clubs were pretty interesting, at least theyre portrayed in things like sherlock holmes, the old "adventure clubs" focused on exploring the world, north pole, antartica..etc
- marcosdumay 4y agoThe office + factory duo have been around for so long that many societal constructs don't exist anymore. I think the most common "second place" would be called "the neighborhood" nowadays.
- bell-cot 4y agoFields, pastures, village squares. A small boat if you happened to be a fisherman.
- itqwertz 4y agoSome people rely on their institutions to satisfy their basic socialization needs. Without the office, remote workers need to prioritize socializing as a need. Same deal with college. Once the institution is exposed for what it is, it is up to the participants to fulfill their own needs.
- seydor 4y agoSee that is a business opportunity. Soon you will see "Office simulators" opening up in your neighborhood, where you can enjoy a crowded crammed office with endless meetings and chatty employees over your shoulder. Special events such as life coaching, terrorist attacks, christmas parties, and random drama will make it an unforgettable experience for $20/day
- awsrocks 4y agoIt is less the death of the office and more the death of work. We just haven’t come to admit that. Death of work and “cold” relationships and the retreat to home, emotional connection, nurturing, caring. Once employers know it’s more about that and less about work then we will see things turn around.
- aaaaaaaaaaab 4y agoFound the manager.
- awsrocks 4y ago
- ironSkillet 4y agoRather than calling it the death of work, you could instead think of it as a change in the nature of our relationship to work. I am all for going into the office often, as I think complex collaborative projects need face-time to have a tight feedback cycle. But I'm also ok with it not being good or necessary for everyone.
- awsrocks 4y ago
- esotericsean 4y agoWFM is the greatest thing of my life.
- arthurcolle 4y agoWhole Foods Market?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- doktorhladnjak 4y agoThe autocomplete in my browser says: * Work from mountains * Work from mobile * Work from metaverse Hmmm
- arthurcolle 4y agoWork from mountains is the only acceptable option here.
- burade 4y agoAs someone with lots of weird quirks, and who is very likely on the autism spectrum, working from home may have literally saved my career.
- ozim 4y agoIsn't it long term doing more harm? By no means I am on autism spectrum but interacting with people or having to deal with strangers takes my energy away. Staying at home is nice - but then I build up so much social anxiety that when I really have to go out and do something with people it is just awful. Putting myself out there for "training" helps so my issues don't build up.
- KronisLV 4y ago> Putting myself out there for "training" helps so my issues don't build up. That is a good point and probably a nice argument for venturing outside of one's zone of comfort occasionally. That said, what about people whose quirks make others reflect negatively upon them? Something like ticks that make other people uncomfortable (had a person occasionally grunt loudly at the office, really distracting), yet wouldn't really make their actual work performance any worse? If those ticks are involuntary, sometimes they might prefer to partake in remote work. Moreso, what about people who are anxious, agoraphobic or have avoidant personality disorder, or something like it? People who might socialize in a limited set of circumstances, but might have to deal with panic attacks or undue stress in larger meetings or other types of social situations? Dealing with all of that due to no alternatives might be pretty debilitating and demotivating and might not be something "solvable" (at least in the short term), yet the person still should be able to make money so they can survive. Of course, I cannot make claims for others, but personally it's nice that we can accommodate various types of people and their preferences, as long as they actually get things done at no significant expense to anyone else.
- UberFly 4y agoThe Office won't die but flexibility where it makes sense will take over. I'm glad such possibilities are presenting themselves. One of the silver-linings of covid.
- ultim8k 4y agoOffice sucks. Let me list a few things: - Hot desks - People laughing and constantly talking while you are trying to focus - Unstable temperature making you freeze or boil - Uncomfortable and unhealthy desks/chairs - Often lack of proper screens/equipment - Getting squeezed in trains to commute - spending at best an extra hour per day - Unhealthy and expensive dietary options around work - Contamination of diseases - Useless meetings and team activities that usually produce zero value Not to mention how bad this is for the environment. And no, a ping-pong or foosball table doesn't make the office cool. It's like adding chocolate syrup on a rotten fruit to make it edible.
- jmspring 4y agoWhile at Skype - open offices were a thing - someone thought it was beneficial to have people testing A/V as well as video standup areas (dispersed teams) in the same areas people were trying to get work done.
- alistairSH 4y agoTotally agree. I feel like the ideal balance would be 2x/month office visits to coordinate/meet/socialize. And WFH the rest of the time. But, at the same time, I don’t want to limit my hiring to the local market (and 4/6 of my team are fully remote), so WFH/remote it is. Really, I just miss social lunches and a bit of water-cooler gossip. I should try to convince my two local employees to meet for a snack sometime and call it good enough. Edit - I don’t remotely miss the open office at my employer. Worst idea ever. Directors and VPs hog the conference rooms, leaving me (line manager) to roam around looking for private spaces to talk to employees. Dumb dumb dumb. End rant.
- osigurdson 4y agoI don't think there is anything else more illogical in modern society than waking up in building A, hopping in a car and fighting traffic for an hour to get to building B just to sit in front of a computer for 8 hours (perhaps with a few minimally productive meetings here and there), then commute back to building A 8 hours later. Building B sits empty for 16 hours a day while Building A sits empty for 10 with both being heated/cooled for 24 hours. The employee wastes 2 of their 16 available waking hours in the non-productive commute while incurring significant financial costs (lease/insurance/fuel/energy) in order to support this patently absurd activity. Similarly the employer wastes time and energy negotiating leases, re-arranging offices, purchasing AV equipment for meeting rooms in building B, etc.,etc., in addition to paying the likely enormously expensive lease itself. The impacts on the environment, the number of hours of human life wasted in commute, the pointless buildings and associated costs to employers as well as the public infrastructure to support it (roads, trains, busses, etc.) are all incredibly wasteful. Surely, all of this could only be justified if physical presence had a dramatic impact on productivity. Yet, we cannot tell one way or the other if it actually improves outcomes.
- marcosdumay 4y ago> Yet, we cannot tell one way or the other if it actually improves outcomes. It very clearly improves the outcome of some work, and degrades the outcome of other work, and doesn't impact much some other kinds of work. It's only unclear for the people that insist on putting every work on the same bracket.
- 999900000999 4y agoThe point is to keep local economies alive. It's not about us, it's about the guy who delivers lunch, or the girl who owns the bagel shop. However, offices are straight up abelist , if you have mobility issues it's absurdly hard to commute. Commuting isn't really needed here, if I was in a wheelchair I'd take this to court. Full tin foil hat time, if remote work was the norm the entire commercial real estate sector would collapse. Most modern cities would collapse as well. So many industries are based around commuting, or supporting office workers. Hell, normalized remote work might destroy our entire economy.
- lizknope 4y agoI had an office with a door for 12 years. I switched jobs 3 years ago and everyone has a cubicle even the managers. Constant distractions with people talking loudly on conference calls. Then someone else talks even louder on their call. Before covid our site was mostly working on the same project. There was some fun collaboration in the conference room around white boards etc. We had a reorg to pool resources across projects across the country so now only 3 out of 10 people on my project are at my site. Most of us bought our own 40" 4K monitors so if I go in a conference room I can't even share my remote Linux desktop session properly because I'm scrolling within the window to find my applications to share. Because of that I just stay at my cubicle to share my screen and end up disturbing everyone else around me with my own conference call. Everything would be fine with offices and doors but instead we get stupid surveys about whether we want an open floorplan which is even worse. We are supposed to go in the office 3 days a week. The reality is most people at my site show up once or twice a week for half a day for the free lunch once a week and then go home by 3pm to get work done. We have 30 job openings and we hire about 1 person every 2 months. We lose 1 person about every 4 months. Management hasn't said anything about people not showing up probably because they don't want to push people to leave.
- dijit 4y agoI worked in open offices for 10 years. I’d kill for a cubicle. Everyone is different of course but open offices, lack of visual privacy, lack of personal space, it just drains me.
- waynesonfire 4y agoYeah, the bean counters really dug themselves in with the open office cost saving strategy. Just makes the office that much worse.
- zelos 4y agoI agree - in a UK open office I’m maybe 2 metres from a coworker if we both squeezed to opposite ends of our desks. Headphones are the only way to get any work done. Our US colleagues have acres of space in comparison.
- smackeyacky 4y agoFrom the article: "He constructs an office in his flat and whiles away his days copying and amending letters – he even ‘commutes’ via a walk around the block every morning. He dies ‘happy’: at his desk, halfway through penning a final document." I've worked from home for the last 5 years (startup founder). It bled into everything at home. At one point during covid, half of the upstairs of this house was filled with equipment, spare parts, workbenches and servers. Now that it's been mothballed I found a job that was advertised as "work from home" but I've been going into the office instead. Not sure if it is just the mental break of what I was doing before or something else, but I found it both refreshing and frustrating. It's nice to "dress up" a bit to go to work instead of just rolling out of bed and sit at a desk in whatever I grabbed. It's nice to interact with people outside the family. The downside is that I forgot just how intrusive/noisy other people can be. I think there is are a lot of people who thrive on that distraction (or distracting others) whose jobs might not require the concentration of a programmer. I guess a set of headphones might sort that out but that also seems kind of rude in an environment that is supposed to encourage interaction. I do like leaving it all at work when I come home. That is better in terms of mental health at least.
- ozim 4y agoI do dress up for work from home and I keep my morning routine just like I would be going out from home because when I "just rolled out of the bed" I was just tired after one week and totally demotivated. Dressing up is still casual, but I consciously pick t-shirt or polo shirt for the day.
- analog31 4y agoI've gone back to "the office" but I've realized that what I've really gone back to is the lab. And the lab is not the office. The lab has a door that closes, big Danger signs, and a flashing red light above the door. I also have a desk in a cubicle, but there have been some chances since the pandemic. Maybe others have alluded to it as well: Work life is a bit more relaxed. Our supervisor moved to his home town, and now manages us remotely. It's working out just fine. So the thing about being in the office so we can be watched is gone, if it ever was a thing. Folks have talked about sitting in the cubes and attending Zoom meetings (or Teams, whatever), but I think meetings have calmed down. Perhaps option of attending via Zoom has eliminated the attraction of calling everybody together into one big room. If the meeting gets too obnoxious, attendance will just evaporate, with people joining the meeting from their desk and "multitasking" to be charitable. If somebody's not around, you don't know if they're on vacation, or sick, or just working from home. The chance of finding someone at their desk has dwindled to where it's pointless to look for them, just for a chance to interrupt them.
- kqr 4y agoI spent a short time at a place where I had both an office desk and a desk in a lab room. I never figured out why I would ever work from the office desk; the lab was superior in every way. Judging from the people milling about the lab corridors, other people except the most senior ones and/or managers thought the same. And sure enough, if my current workplace had a lab room to offer, I'd be much more inclined to go there.
- analog31 4y agoI use my office desk as extended lab space.
- waynesonfire 4y agoOne if the things that made Ultima Online an incredible MMO gaming experience when it first came out and has since never been replicated is because it was the only choice. EVERYONE had to play it, all the various types of folks. It's this that made the game special. I wonder if the same affect is going to ruin the office experience. In that what made it special was that everyone had to go to the office. Nowadays, the only people that show up are the ones that "prefer" it or whatever. And, I don't know how to word this differently, maybe, I don't care for those folks. Just something I was thinking about. When I go into the office now, something is missing. No point even going in a day or two a week.
- bruce511 4y agoWe are in the early stages of a societal upheaval and I for one am not sure how it will play out. Firstly, it's clear that we've had a massive "short term" upheaval in which we got to clearly find out who could work from home, and who could not. Or perhaps more accurately who can work _at_ home (white collar) and who can work _from_ home (sales etc). We've learned that those who have space at home did better than those who were already cramped. We've learned that the number (and age!) of others in the house matter. It turns out not all homes, or offices, are created equal. Having small kids around can make life a lot harder. We've discovered that commuting time and money is a thing - I might live 5 minutes from work, you might easily spend 2 hours a day on transport - clearly we have different experiences with regard to WFH changes. Some offices are open plan, some have cubicals, some have actual offices with doors and individual climate control. We've started to learn that once you work at home, home can be anywhere. Time zone, and language, are the only hindrances to you living anywhere, or indeed your job going some where cheaper (without you.) What's my point? Well I guess that we are right at the beginning. Architecture of both offices, and homes, will adapt. Zoning will hopefully adapt. We'll start acknowledging that school is as much about day care as education. White collar jobs will (I suspect) end up paying less. Perhaps even a culling of "bullshit jobs". The secondary impact on density, and thus secondary jobs that rely on that density, will be significant. And perhaps in some ways less predictable. New businesses will form - new ways to socialise will emerge - new work boundaries may emerge, or maybe boundaries will disappear. However it shakes out these are interesting times - one thing is clear, the future doesn't look like 2019. Remember these times, 30 years from now they'll be as foreign as the 80s, or 50s, are to us now.
- Gollapalli 4y agoI almost think the solution would be to have people live in apartments in the cities during the week and have them go out to a larger place in the countryside on the weekends. Maybe have a 4 day workweek and have that be the rhythm of life. Homeownership wouldn't be about a glorified cubicle in the suburbs, but about landwonership proper. Apartments could be treated as the temporary "live near work/in the city" thing that they are, and the city could be a walkable mixed-use environment meant to support this overall rhythm of life.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- heyheysteve 4y ago