5 ms·
Truly great GUI design is very challenging. I've used very few applications which I think have a truly great UI that beats the CLI in terms of the efficiency o
by dekhn 4y ago
Truly great GUI design is very challenging. I've used very few applications which I think have a truly great UI that beats the CLI in terms of the efficiency of presenting options in orthogonal and conditional ways (orthogonal: two features which don't interact at all can usually be programmed independently and appear in distinct locations, while conditional: options that are only valid if another option is set to a specific value).
The best UI I've worked with so far is Fusion 360. Like most 3d modelling tools it has a fairly steep learning curve, but it does a fantastic job of making your life easier. It has a bunch of UI dialogs for parameter setting (some of which are better than others) that do a good job with both orthogonality and conditionality. I really wanted to like blender but just about everything in it feels rotated 90 degrees to how I'd do it.
- bsder 4y agoWhat you probably like most are the "Radial Menus". Which are a damn good GUI paradigm. That nobody uses outside of games. And Fusion 360 basically had to write their own entire GUI engine to do all the stuff they wanted. Infuriatingly, Fusion 360 doesn't provide a Linux version which should be stupidly easy to do since they wrote their own GUI.
- dekhn 4y agoIIRC Fusion 360 has radial menus (https://help.autodesk.com/view/fusion360/ENU/?guid=GUID-6514ABC1-CB75-4F0B-AB0E-316FAD36BA93 https://help.autodesk.com/view/fusion360/ENU/?guid=GUID-6514...), and I think it was a major part of Maya or another one of the older modellers. I was never a huge fan and the mouse model still trips me up (imho, mouse-button-1 drags should rotate, and shift/alt mouse-button-1 pan and zoom, respectively). Also, everything in Fusion 360 could be done in Qt5 without a lot of work, it's just that getting all the hints and the second level details (like maintaing the selection when you switch tools) is a real bear.
- meue 4y agoI work in industrial design and the use of Alias for surface modeling is quite prevalent (and has been for decades). It used to be called PowerAnimator, and marking menus were first added somewhere around the release of v6 (1995). Alias/Wavefront actually incorporated this functionality into their first release of Maya several years later, trying to innovate on the feature further with the use of hotbox menus [1][2]. Since Alias corp. was later acquired by Autodesk in the early 2000's, you can imagine Fusion 360 as being the symbolical evolution of it. Especially considering the current Alias UI has not changed much since 1999! [3][4] If interested more on this topic, fun HCI bath-time reading: Gord Kurtenbach's 1993 dissertation on The Design and Evaluation of Marking Menus [5]. Not surprisingly, from Alias/Wavefront he went on to head Autodesk Research for most of the 2000's. [1]: https://books.google.com/books?id=7wEAAAAAMBAJ&pg=PT89&lpg=PT89 https://books.google.com/books?id=7wEAAAAAMBAJ&pg=PT89&lpg=P... [2]: https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.86.8917&rep=rep1&type=pdf https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.86... [3]: https://youtu.be/cVusw4JNK0s https://youtu.be/cVusw4JNK0s (1999) [4]: https://youtu.be/323fmUgwMyI https://youtu.be/323fmUgwMyI (2022) [5]: https://damassets.autodesk.net/content/dam/autodesk/www/autodesk-reasearch/Publications/pdf/the-design-and-evaluation.pdf https://damassets.autodesk.net/content/dam/autodesk/www/auto...
- dekhn 4y agoCool, thanks- I had forgotten about Alias before Maya. I was introduced to radial when Maya came out (somebody demo'd in, I was interested by couldn't afford it). I think of Fusion 360 as being more descended from Inventor (which defined a lot of my early expectations for 3d modelling). I'm only a hobbyist and I used Fusion 360 with large (mesh) surfaces (it got significantly better at meshes recently) and it definitely got clunky, although the performance is fine when working with parameteric brep objects. I've been using Autodesk products (starting with 2D AutoCAD on a 286 running DOS) for quite a while (35 years).
- Ruq 4y agoKrita makes use of radial menus as an option.
- somat 4y agoRadial menus have the same problem(admittedly to a lesser degree) as icon fields(for example, a phone home screen, or most file explorers), they fail to be well sorted and as such are harder then they need to be to find things. A linear list with a search option, or better yet a table where you can sort by several attributes is a better option.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dataflow 4y ago> I've used very few applications which I think have a truly great UI that beats the CLI in terms of the efficiency of presenting options in orthogonal and conditional ways I can think of so many off the top of my head: Word, Excel, PowerPoint, Chrome/Firefox, Acrobat, Audacity... And this is before you get into stuff dealing with pictures, like Photoshop or literally almost every modern game. You can do most of these on the command line (see ffmpeg, imagemagick, etc.) but I'm pretty sure > 99.99% of people do not prefer a CLI version of such applications over the GUI forms. IMHO the power of CLI apps isn't in their orthogonality or presentation, but ease of automation and composability, and the ability to cram a ton of features into a single interface without really caring about how easy it is to use for 99% of people.
- dekhn 4y agoRather than listing several specific applications, what i'd do is generalize: Word processors: are a real improvement over using ed at the CLI, or really any scripting tool, to process large amounts of human-readable text. Although in many cases, simple markup on simple text in a simple text file can be excellent. Spreadsheets: for all that people complain about spreadsheets, they do a few things fairly well (cellular data model, dependency-graph-driven computations) PowerPoint: I should have mentioned that "sheets/slides/presentation" apps are one of the best examples of this; features like "Align vertically" are a great example of where UIs make certain operations very intuitive and easy Browser: I dunno, I prefer e-links :) Music editing: Actually, the whole world of track-based video and music editing. This is a such a huge improvement over any other system (musicians and video professionals may disagree), specifically the ability to quickly view, cut and paste, and combine multiple parts of longer videos. A lot of this depends on a concept that only really became feasible once disk storage really became huge: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-linear_editing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-linear_editing Composability and orthogonality go hand in hand- much of my argument rests on the idea that composing orthogonal features is trivial for UIs, whereas composing interacting features leads to combinatorial complexity and can really only be expressed in code (and possible visual programming- being used more and more commonly to give artists GUI control over complex code-like operations). The automation is the last interesting bit- will visual programming ever become ubiquitious, so that most people doing automation don't actually drop down to some CLI/text interface/programming language?
- tiben_ 4y agoHave the same feel when two months ago i switched from 10 years vim usage to intellij for code. The UI is so well designed, the "everyday's coder problem is so well understood in the UI layer its just a pleasure to work with this tool. The UI just reflect that. Everything is just so well organised. As a web UI developper, and despite material/responsive requirements i refer often to IntelliJ's GUI. Its just so well designed. OpenSSL can have this kind of UI. Its just a matter of understanding user requirements.