3 ms·
This trope of "personal responsibility" needs to go away. Only a minority of people can withstand an onslaught of determined, highly paid professionals, workin
by oblio 4y ago
This trope of "personal responsibility" needs to go away.
Only a minority of people can withstand an onslaught of determined, highly paid professionals, working together to basically harm them.
Our brains have flaws. These people know those flaws and work actively every day of their working lives to exploit them. What hope can the always tired, always stressed out average person have of resisting, long term?
Personal responsibility is failing, just look at obesity rates in countries with reduced malnutrition rates.
We need systemic solutions, not blaming the poor idiot.
That's how we solved other collective problems like air travel safety and road fatality rates.
Your approach was the old, antiquated one, where we always blamed the pilot or the driver. Guess what? Even if the person is an idiot, we're all idiots. Let's make stuff that doesn't kill us even if we're idiots.
Similar principle here.
- thebean11 4y ago> Only a minority of people can withstand an onslaught... Is that true? Most people aren't addicted to anything let alone social media..I really don't buy the claim that people have literally no control over their actions. What's your solution? Ban sugar, alcohol and social media? Padding on the sidewalks?
- micromacrofoot 4y ago> Most people aren't addicted to anything let alone social media Even if it's just 5-10% (difficult to prove one way or the other, but some have estimated it's within this range) that's a massive amount of people on a global scale. That's enough to influence elections, for example. Scrutiny seems reasonable.
- thebean11 4y agoSure let's say it's 10%, is the conclusion you draw from that that free will doesn't exist? Do 100% of people need to give up the freedom of choice to lower that figure? Not sure what you're getting at about elections, are you saying that's a reason to intervene? I don't really want the government making policy for the purpose of influencing election outcomes.
- oblio 4y agoSo dramatic. 100% of people will need to give up some luxuries so that everyone can benefit, and especially <<vulnerable groups>> can benefit. Taxes work the same way. Laws in general work the same way (otherwise we'd assume everyone is smart, fair and calculated heck, perfect, all the time).
- thebean11 4y agoCan you be more specific then about what we're discussing, if it's not "ban things that the 10% is addicted to"?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 4y agoThey aren't talking about bans, but other controls. Cigarettes are not banned outright, but cigarette companies are banned from advertising in a lot of mediums and cigarette cartons have a warning label about the harmful effects of smoking them. For a long time there were PSAs about how bad they were for you too, to counteract the damage already done by the tobacco industry's marketing. And we tax them pretty harshly. People still smoke, it is still legal to smoke. We could do similar things for food and social media without outright banning it.
- thebean11 4y agoYeah that's fair. Like I alluded to in a sibling comment thread, though, I think doing the same thing for food is pretty dangerous given our still pretty limited understanding of what foods are actually bad for you. Eggs are still oscillating between healthy and unhealthy every few years (although I think we're settling on healthy? Who knows!). Cigarettes aren't needed to sustain life so there's not as much risk to meddling like that. The only thing I can really get behind is stricter controls on individual ingredients that are very clearly unhealthy and obviously don't need to be part of your diet (BPAs, trans fats, etc). Once you start messing with society's macros though it's fraught territory and very easy to do harm IMO.
- oblio 4y ago> What's your solution? Ban sugar, alcohol and social media? Padding on the sidewalks? There isn't "one solution". And bans generally are not a solution. But we need to fight with the same weapons they're fighting, for example, let's take sugar and unhealthy foods. They're presenting their food as fun and glamorous, let's blow that up, like we did for tobacco. No more mass advertising for it, anywhere. Horrible labels showing disfigured obese people that are suffering because of their addiction to junk food. The food is cheap because they use crap ingrediens? Let's tax food based on universal standards agreed upon not by the industry, but by healthcare specialists. The more you're off the mark from healthy food, the more you get taxed (excises, same as for alcohol and tobacco). Heck, I'd earmark those excises as funding for subsidies meant for producers of healthy, bio foods. These junk food companies are making their stuff cool, so let's prevent that and they're making it cheap by passing their externalities to us (diminished long term health) so let's make their food more expensive and let's make the healthy stuff cheaper. Ah, more than that, quotas of healthy food in every place serving or offering food. Get rid of food deserts. Poor people with low mobility should have access to healthy food at decent prices. Yes, this is all very complicates. Yes, it's very political. But doing nothing achieves nothing. Worse than that, doing nothing actively degrades the situation since these actors are actively harming people in very subtle ways.
- thebean11 4y ago20 years ago the sugar lobby told everyone that sugar was good and fat was bad. I'm all for banning specific ingredients and processes that are known poisonous (like BPAs for example are banned in many countries, deservedly) but unilaterally deciding what's healthy and having quotas for healthy foods is extreme. It will be the sugar vs fat thing all over and only the rich will benefit. Just to make sure I understand what you’re proposing, taco trucks and ice cream shops would be illegal in your ideal world yeah?
- oblio 4y ago> 20 years ago the sugar lobby told everyone that sugar was good and fat was bad. And we're 20 years from that and now we know better. Which lobby is it this time, the healthy living one, that's lying to us? ... > Just to make sure I understand what you’re proposing, taco trucks and ice cream shops would be illegal in your ideal world yeah? Did I stutter? Did I propose bans anywhere? And why is having quotas for healthy foods extreme? Sell 20% healthy foods out of your entire stock. How hard is that? We have quotas for all sort of things <<all>> the time. The roof hasn't fallen. Separate note: I guess this is the risk of arguing with libertarians :-) I'd venture you're one.
- Eupraxias 4y agoYounger, more libertarian-ish me would have disagreed. But humans have changed. The information age has changed us in deep ways. When Facebook appeared, all of the problems that have manifested over the past 15 years or so were immediately apparent to me. Facebook was so clearly toxic that I never touched the service. And I was an enthusiastic first-on-the-bandwagon type back then. Trying to warn others, which I embarrassed myself trying to do, was useless. It was senseless to try - I was under the assumption that people had control of their person. I was assuming that people had personal responsibility. Personal responsibility implies control of your person, which we have inadvertently relinquished in the Information Age, as we outsource aspects of our minds and persons to the technology that 'makes our lives easier'. Add to this the fact that these companies have experts dedicated to undermine your control of yourself, and it's hopeless for most people. Older, more exhausted me agrees with the parent comment. sigh
- Agamus 4y agoI'll reply on my own comment here to add that the same reasoning applies to gun rights. We need a critical mass of the populous to have personal responsibility, or we are missing parameters in the calculus of our right to bear arms. Until we are generally intelligent enough to understand this, the gun rights issue, and any other related ones like the parent here, will be played out as a surreal dance of contrasting political interests.
- ahallock 4y agoIt's not a trope. If you cannot learn to resist things and have a strong constitution, it will just be something else that swallows you up. > Only a minority of people can withstand an onslaught of determined, highly paid professionals, working together to basically harm them. This sounds so dramatic, as if these pros have actual mind control abilities. You're being hyperbolic. Also, how do you know it's a minority? Sounds like you just made that up to suit your argument.
- oblio 4y agoIt is a trope, especially in American and and by extension libertarian circles promoted by the US groups around the world. Personal responsibility is just one variable in this equation and a weak one at that. What do all developed countries have in common? A large, well run (in comparison to developing countries) government and an active civil society that operates at scale, through various collective actions (voting, protests, etc). Personal responsibility is maybe #5 on this list and is the number one thing being peddled by companies whose business interests are under attack. Look up Ralph Nader and auto companies. Whistleblowers in tobacco companies and tobacco companies. Etc, etc.
- throw10920 4y agoWhat really needs to go away is this epidemic of emotionally-manipulative special pleading that has drastically increased in density on Hacker News over the past five years or so. Comments like this one are antithetical to the goals of HN - curious, reasonable, intellectual discussion (including about topics that may be somewhat political in nature).
- oblio 4y agoOk, bring it on. We have obesity rates reaching 50% in many countries. Morbid (morbid comes from the Latin word for death...) obesity in the US is 7% and growing. Pray tell, how are you going to solve this epidemic through personal responsibility?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]