5 ms·
This is a bizarre take. Most suburbs I’ve seen is actually amazing for walking in. Sure if there is no sidewalk it sucks, but if you walk where people live us
by refurb 4y ago
This is a bizarre take. Most suburbs I’ve seen is actually amazing for walking in.
Sure if there is no sidewalk it sucks, but if you walk where people live usually there is a nice walking path, minimal traffic, lots of families around. I’ve lived in dense urban centers and walking can suck with the crowded sidewalks, always having to cross streets with cars, the noise.
People aren’t walking in malls because of car culture. Usually they walk in malls because it’s too damn hot/cold outside.
- pnutjam 4y agoThis is simply not true, and it was less true in the 80's/90's.
- coastflow 4y agoThere might be two separate assertions under discussion. One is that it is typically difficult in a suburb to get to a landmark destination (e.g. to the grocery store, to the gym, to a coffee shop, and to work) just by walking, without a car. This is true. At the same time, suburbs with low rates of crime are typically nicer to walk around without a destination in mind. It’s typically easier to go outside for a jog or run in a suburb than in downtown, as there are fewer cars on the road and other pedestrians on the sidewalk.
- Retric 4y agoI have been in plenty of suburbs without sidewalks or almost worse where there are bits and pieces of sidewalks that don’t connect to each other. Walking on the road is possible, but can be quite dangerous in such places.
- alphabettsy 4y ago> At the same time, suburbs with low rates of crime are typically nicer to walk around without a destination in mind. I have to disagree here. In the suburbs there is nowhere to go and nothing to discover. Walking around the city I see new people, restaurants or other businesses that I find interesting. The suburbs where I grew up were always the same thing.
- throw0101a 4y ago> The suburbs where I grew up were always the same thing. Hence the title of the book The Geography of Nowhere: > The Geography of Nowhere: The Rise and Decline of America's Man-Made Landscape is a book written in 1993 by James Howard Kunstler exploring the effects of suburban sprawl, civil planning, and the automobile on American society and is an attempt to discover how and why suburbia has ceased to be a credible human habitat, and what society might do about it. Kunstler proposes that by reviving civic art and civic life, we will rediscover public virtue and a new vision of the common good: "The future will require us to build better places," Kunstler says, "or the future will belong to other people in other societies." * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Geography_of_Nowhere https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Geography_of_Nowhere
- matwood 4y agoYeah, people tend to take the worst suburb setup and compare it to the best city setup. The reality is, there's a lot in between. I live on the coast in a suburb about a 1/2 hour outside the downtown area. The long edge of my suburb is banked by a river with neighborhood supported docks, and large green spaces along the river. There's a grocery store at the entrance to the neighborhood (along with cleaners, bars, etc...) that people walk and ride bikes to. There are other large green spaces where kids play sports plus there's tennis and basketball courts, golfing, pools, etc... I'm not saying where I live is perfect, but as I started with, people like to take the worst mid-west suburban hell and compare it to the best city like NYC. When I see these discussion what I hear is all the more reason why people are migrating to the coasts.
- jjav 4y ago> One is that it is typically difficult in a suburb to get to a landmark destination (e.g. to the grocery store, to the gym, to a coffee shop, and to work) just by walking, without a car. > This is true. Could you post a few map links to suburbs (not rural) where you can't walk to, say, a grocery store or a coffee shop?
- pnutjam 4y agohttps://goo.gl/maps/fzso3eAFVVKKtsZb7 https://goo.gl/maps/fzso3eAFVVKKtsZb7 Scroll all over the east side of Indianapolis. This is near where I grew up.
- Ar-Curunir 4y agoWhile the streets are quiet, it’s really not fun to walk in neighborhoods where every house looks the same, and where there’s no visual variety. Personally I find a 15-minute walk in my suburban neighborhood feels much longer than a 15-minute walk in the town where my college was located. The other extremely irritating part is the completely ass-backwards design of suburban neighborhoods that makes walking to places much longer than necessary. Eg: there’s a grocery store literally right behind my house, but without a door in my backyard, it would take me 5+ minutes to walk there.
- listenallyall 4y agoHow is it ass-backwards for a grocery store not to install a door and entrance for the custom use of a single household?
- Ar-Curunir 4y agoNone of the houses on my street have easy access either. The point of that anecdote wasn’t that everyone should have backyard doors, but rather that the street design should make it easy to get to places, and not require circuitous routes that make life difficult for pedestrians.
- gsk22 4y agoThis is true in certain American suburbs, but definitely not all. Older and less affluent suburbs, in particular, often have abysmal walking infrastructure. I'm not sure this fits the prototypical suburb -- but I have spent a lot of time in southern Texas, and look at this amazing pedestrian infrastructure: https://www.google.com/maps/@26.1413614,-97.9581625,3a,75y,317.31h,81.77t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sZHfJ6aw3cVuEcUeF3rhH-w!2e0!6shttps:%2F%2Fstreetviewpixels-pa.googleapis.com%2Fv1%2Fthumbnail%3Fpanoid%3DZHfJ6aw3cVuEcUeF3rhH-w%26cb_client%3Dmaps_sv.tactile.gps%26w%3D203%26h%3D100%26yaw%3D345.7721%26pitch%3D0%26thumbfov%3D100!7i16384!8i8192 https://www.google.com/maps/@26.1413614,-97.9581625,3a,75y,3... They recently (past ~5 years) installed new ADA-compliant pedestrian crossings from which you can walk...nowhere. But you can circle the 4 corners of the intersection all day! (Incidentally, the restaurant on the SW corner of the intersection is amazing!)
- bombcar 4y agoI mean that area almost looks rural - if you go over to where the houses are they actually have some sidewalks. The street names also imply it’s rural or was rural very recently.
- gsk22 4y agoYeah, I'm not sure the right terminology for the type of urban landscape it is. There's uninterrupted development for a 30 mile stretch between McAllen and Harlingen, with densities ranging from suburban to exurban. So not quite typical American suburbia, but similar sprawl and car uber-dependence.
- joebob42 4y agoThere's also what looks like a perfectly lovely park a few blocks away
- muti 4y agoI think the point about suburbs promoting car dependence over walking is more about walking somewhere Sure, it can be nice to go for a walk around the neighborhood, but mostly only in a loop, there is no destination. One of the reasons I moved where I live is due to the walkability. I'm technically in the suburbs of a medium sized city, but happen to live close enough to a small retail center that I can walk to shop for groceries, get a hair cut, go to a pharmacy and many other things. It's really nice to be prompted to go for a nice walk instead of hop in a car when I need to run an errand.
- morsch 4y agoNice places for a walk: the forest, a river bank, a park, walkable (zero car) city center. Poor places for a walk: anywhere there are cars, anywhere that is indoors. I get that there are places with inhospitable climate where it's too hot even in a shady forest or too cold even with the right clothes. Those places just don't have truly nice places for a walk.
- csydas 4y agoI'm not sure this is a universal experience. The suburbs my family lived in were quite hostile towards pedestrians, as the lack of sidewalks had two primary outcomes: 1. People just rarely walked 2. As a result of 1, drivers became unaccustomed to pedestrians and adjusted to a driving style that assumed no pedestrians I absolutely don't really fault the drivers too much, as it's reasonable -- the road is for cars and in most situations with roads it's not expected to have pedestrians except at crosswalks. But it's not universal that suburbs are pedestrian friendly. Especially growing up in the midwest, even suburbs with sidewalks were not very pedestrian friendly. Despite laws requiring maintenance and upkeep of the sidewalks (including snow shoveling during winter), it's not feasible for able-bodied persons to walk across many suburbs because of how awful the upkeep of the public sidewalks are, neverminding people persons with disabilities or injuries. The heat is inconsequential -- where I live now, since about May it's been 34º or higher real temperature (feel is close to 40º or higher), and yet everyone is accustomed to it and still out and walking. It's easily changeable, but the main difference is the city has many walkable elements, many small parks with shade, public fountains to cool off, and so on. Getting to a shop to get a cheap bottle of water (or beer, why not?) is a matter of walking 50 meters in any direction; the last US city I lived in, even though it was better than _many_ US cities, it was still almost 2 Km to get to the nearest store that had anything small to drink/refresh yourself (and you had to cross an 8 lane road that fed into I5, so it was pretty busy). My takeaway as a US native is that US cities really did get ruined by the influence of car culture, and the cities are exceptionally hostile towards pedestrians. Even the quaint suburb-style cities ( < 500k population) which advertise their closeness and small town feel are ostensively pedestrian hostile just due to poor planning which prevents you from getting around by foot or by reliable, cheap, and safe public transportation.
- phil21 4y ago> People aren’t walking in malls because of car culture. Usually they walk in malls because it’s too damn hot/cold outside. People (most) are walking in malls entirely due to car culture. No one where I live in Chicago is going to the mall to walk - because they walk every day just by default to get things done. When you use a car to go literally everywhere, you don't have that exercise baked in. It's difficult to commute here and walk less than a mile a day, usually much more. When I lived in the suburbs this might be measured in hundreds of feet. Very few people go walking for the sake of it, regardless of location or weather. If you're not walking on a daily basis simply for practical reasons - odds are you don't walk regularly at all. The rest is subjective - but I highly prefer "pleasure walks" in the city as well. After a month or two in the suburbs you've seen literally everything there is to see within a 1 mile radius of your home, and it almost never changes. A living city is a much different experience, and it's rare a walk won't result in some novel discovery or meeting a neighbor. This personally motivates me walking new routes far more than the endless sterile lawns in the suburbs. Not to mention how insanely anti-pedestrian many suburban populations are - you will absolutely be harassed unless you are on designated walking trails in my experience. I did live in one inner-ring suburb that was a far better experience, but I feel most here would consider that to be light urban vs. suburban.