8 ms·
If this was happening as often on Volvos or GM vehicles don’t you think they would be looking into it too?
by MBCook 4y ago
If this was happening as often on Volvos or GM vehicles don’t you think they would be looking into it too?
- toomuchtodo 4y agoOther automaker AEB (automatic emergency braking) systems have the same stationary object detection deficiency and specifically indicate that the system can fail under these circumstances [1]. Tesla gets called out because their autosteer is so good at lane keeping, comparatively speaking. Their new high resolution radar [2] (Phoenix) they’ve registered with the FCC, as well as a retrofit campaign across the fleet, will likely resolve this gap. If so, I’m unsure what happens when other automakers continue to have this deficiency as their autosteer capability improves but they don’t have high res forward facing radar. Will NHTSA hold legacies to the same standard? [1] https://www.caranddriver.com/features/a24511826/safety-features-automatic-braking-system-tested-explained/ https://www.caranddriver.com/features/a24511826/safety-featu... [2] https://www.autoevolution.com/news/tesla-backpedals-on-the-use-of-pure-vision-in-its-vehicles-files-to-use-a-new-radar-190789.html https://www.autoevolution.com/news/tesla-backpedals-on-the-u...
- ra7 4y ago> Their new high resolution radar [2] (Phoenix) they’ve registered with the FCC, as well as a retrofit campaign across the fleet, will likely resolve this gap. Is a retrofit confirmed or is it just your assumption? They even sold hundreds of thousands of "vision only" cars (including mine) with Musk and Karpathy claiming radar is useless for them. Funny how they've walked it back with this new radar news.
- mike_d 4y agoI was always _shocked_ that Musk was such a genius that he figured out how to do self driving without RADAR or LIDAR. If only the hundreds of engineers at Google and Cruise could have made the same discovery. /s
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 4y agoStrong assumption NHTSA will issue a recall due to the severity of the issue and Tesla offers up sensor fusion as the fix. Tesla Vision was a successful strategy to keep shipping units during supply chain issues (inability to source radar units), but it is clearly not sustainable based on the Vision codebase maturity reflected by operational performance.
- kube-system 4y agoAEBs and lane-keeping systems on other automakers vehicles are much more conservative in their function, and therefore aren't as conducive to passive driving behavior. The driving dynamics of different vehicles result in different outcomes not just due to those dynamics themselves, but also in the driving behavior they elicit. (and even further, in that drivers of different driving habits often exhibit selection bias in the vehicles they choose)
- itsoktocry 4y ago>Tesla gets called out because their autosteer is so good at lane keeping, comparatively speaking. Yeah, Tesla gets "called out" because their technology is so good, not because their implicit marketing claims the cars can drive themselves. There are full time shills whose entire focus is demonstrating on YouTube how the cars can drive themselves. You don't think that has something to do with this? Arguing "That's FSD this is Autopilot" misses the entire point. Elon has 100M followers on Twitter; go scan through any thread. People think they've solved FSD, people think they have humanoid robots, people think he already owns Twitter for crying out loud. So, yes, if Mary Barra got in her Chevy Bolt and told a reported the car can drive itself and someone died doing the same thing, I think GM would be held to the same standard.
- windowsrookie 4y agoGM's "Super Cruise" uses lidar map data, radar, cameras, and has an interior camera monitoring the driver to make sure they are paying attention. Tesla's don't.
- D13Fd 4y agoIt’s not just the feature that’s unsafe, it’s the feature plus the marketing. If the other manufacturers start throwing “full self-driving” around to describe their cruise control/lane keeping/automatic breaking, and people start crashing because they rely on that, then yes. I expect there would be some regulatory activity.
- aeternum 4y agoI don't. You rarely see crashes of other vehicles make the press, but with Teslas you do. Tesla articles get views because of both the Tesla haters and fanboys, makes financial sense for news sites to publish them. That increased press leads to increased investigations.
- polski-g 4y agoTesla has sold more self driving cars than all other manufacturers combined. Of course you would hear more about Tesla.
- gkop 4y ago0 > 0*n == false
- InitialLastName 4y agoTo be fair, they didn't say Tesla has delivered any self-driving cars. Everyone knows a huckster is at their happiest with an internet horde making excuses for their incapacity to fulfill their promises.
- gkop 4y agoHeh, good point. The best correct is technically correct and all that.
- MengerSponge 4y agoHahahaha Tesla has sold zero Level 5 cars. They've sold a bunch of Level 2 automated cars, same as VW, GM, Volvo, Subaru, etc. Those other manufacturers have more robust legal teams, so they advertise their cars capabilities a bit more honestly.
- kaba0 4y agoThere are robot vacuums with better self driving capabilities than teslas.
- 4y ago
- codefreeordie 4y agoProbably not. Volvo and GM are in with the crowd in charge of who gets investigated. Must is not.
- Manuel_D 4y agoDo neglectful people turn on cruise control and then rear-end other cars in their Volvos and GMs? I'm going to guess that there's plenty of such instances, but they're not as headline-prone as crashing Teslas. Hence, why this data would be useful for comparison.
- PKop 4y agoIs Autopilot different than cruise control? Is it used differently? If they're not the same thing why equate them?
- Manuel_D 4y agoThey are very similar in my view: they automate part of driving to reduce load on the driver. Traditional cruise control just maintains velocity. My Subaru's adaptive cruise control maintains velocity and controls distance relative to the car ahead. Tesla also keeps your car centered in lane, but is otherwise just adaptive cruise control. There's some more features in the "self-driving" cars, like auto-parking and overtaking - I don't have much experience with those, I've only used non-self-driving Tesla autopilot. For the normal Tesla autopilot, though, "adaptive cruise control plus lane-centering" seems to accurately describe it.
- PKop 4y agoYes so technically, and as marketed, they are not the same. A dumb setting that fixes velocity is not the same, in any way, as a sophisticated self-driving mechanism that aims to recognize the world around it and adjust multiple parameters dynamically. More surface area for errors, and a misguided sense in the driver that their car is smart and can manage this process itself without the same attention as a fixed-speed (and nothing else), dumb cruise control
- Manuel_D 4y ago> A dumb setting that fixes velocity is not the same, in any way, as a sophisticated self-driving mechanism that aims to recognize the world around it and adjust multiple parameters dynamically. Except plenty of modern cars don't just have fixed velocity cruise control. They have adaptive cruise control that will speed up or slow down to match the velocity of the car ahead of you. They also have lane centering that will keep your car in its lane. That sounds an awful lot like Teslas.