5 ms·
> SSNDOB listed the personal information for approximately 24 million individuals in the United States, including names, dates of birth, SSNs, and credit card n
by SoftTalker 4y ago
> SSNDOB listed the personal information for approximately 24 million individuals in the United States, including names, dates of birth, SSNs, and credit card numbers
Great, good to shut it down, but how long until its replacement springs up? It probably already has.
Instead of going through all this effort and expense to track the sellers of this information, it would be better to make "names, dates of birth, SSNs, and credit card numbers" valueless on their own. I'm not sure what the alternative looks like, but posession of this kind of personal information about someone should not be useful or valuable.
- rightbyte 4y agoPut it in a public phone directory and maybe SSN will finally not be used as some layer of security. Credit card numbers likewise.
- dqv 4y agoIt would certainly be a darkgrayhat move to do such a thing. It would be effective at deprecating SSNs as identifiers but would cause a lot of pain and suffering for a lot of people in the interim.
- grishka 4y agoCredit card numbers aren't supposed to be private, are they? We use them all the time to send money. It's the expiry date and the CVC that should be kept secret, but even then 3dsecure is a thing.
- rightbyte 4y agoWe give the cards to strangers in restaurants etc. The CVC or date should not be on the card really if it is some sort of safe guard. The whole credit card setup is quite insane when you think about it.
- duskwuff 4y agoThe checking system is so much worse. The only parameters needed to make an ACH payment are a name, a routing number, and the account number -- all of which are printed on every check. There is very little fraud protection, and it is difficult for an account holder to dispute an incorrect or fraudulent transfer.
- tremon 4y agoThere is very little fraud protection, and it is difficult for an account holder to dispute an incorrect or fraudulent transfer. I see a cause and effect here. Make it easier (by law) for the account holder to dispute a transfer, and I'm sure the banks will suddenly spend more effort on fraud prevention.
- Tagbert 4y agoThere is a whole layer of security and compliance around the handling of credit card numbers that anyone who processes them has to go through. They are not considered publish information.
- bombcar 4y agoSSNs are coincidentally almost the same number of digits as US phone numbers, so just make it so you can register your SSN as an alternate phone number for your cell phone. You'd probably need a separate country code for it ...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- svachalek 4y agoYup. This stuff is all so deeply compromised at this point it's almost surprising you can still sell it. I guess fraud is still rare enough that companies would rather ask for SSN and say "hey we tried" than actually bother to look deeper.
- yieldcrv 4y agoFULLZ (a text file containing this information) sell for about $.99 per file/person on darknet markets, mostly to build up the seller's reputation. There are 20,000,000 from just this one source and sellers seemingly randomly chose them. Thats just a lot of people. The buyer can use the same social security number for a different purpose than the last buyer. Like, maybe the prior buyer wanted to try something easy like opening a credit card. The compromised person has a low but improving chance of noticing and locking their credit report, making their social security number useless(-ish) for credit card applications. The next buyer though may have never considered that and might just open a bank account with an online bank. You wouldn't know if a bank account has been opened in your name. And the account itself doesn't have to be used for anything flag worthy or that could frame you (I wanted to say "anything criminal" but obviously some laws are being violated even if the funds are clean). On darknet markets, many people chose to skip laundering money, and just open bank and brokerage accounts in any developed nation under anyone's name. They just trade stocks and accumulate dollars. Eventually, whenever they want, they will laundering to cash out completely. But people can fly under the radar for a very long time, staying liquid, and not really doing any kind of consumptive spending from those accounts. So the same social security numbers can be used many times, and there are also too many social security numbers for the level of interest in this, for now.
- kube-system 4y agoPlaces that ask for your SSN are usually not doing so for auth, it's mostly as a taxpayer ID, or a unique identifier because names aren't unique. (banks, employers, etc) For fraud prevention they typically do behavior analysis or use a composite of personal data. SSN + DOB + Name + last address you lived at + etc.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y ago"Don't hold criminals accountable because there will always be more criminals"
- haswell 4y agoThis is an unnecessarily reductionist interpretation. “Don’t clean and bandage the gaping wound because it’ll just keep bleeding” The point isn’t to stop going after criminals, the point is that just going after criminals is as pointless in the long run as just dressing a wound that actually requires a different solution - stitches. Given limited resources, addressing the root of the problem would be more valuable than continuing to go after the symptoms. Since I doubt the same agency would be part of a real solution, it probably becomes a conversation about where funding is directed.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoI agree with the core of your argument but I think it's more complicated. If SS weren't important criminals would move onto something else. If you stop going after criminals would there be more or less SS theft? If the solution is to phase out whatever criminals are using against people then you'll just be on a different path that never ends.
- haswell 4y agoI think this is fair. The ideal path is probably not just one or the other, but a combination of both.
- everforward 4y agoThe problem is that a SSN was designed to be secret, and then everyone decided to use them as a UUID for people, which are generally not secret. The solution is to split them. Give everyone some kind of citizen ID number that isn't private, but is unique. Then give everyone some kind of auth mechanism that identifies a person when combined with their ID number. What we currently do is using SSN as the identifier, with DOB as the auth mechanism. That's terrible because the SSN is supposed to be secret, and DOB is basically public knowledge at this point. They also can't be easily re-issued, which is it's own problem. There are obvious and substantial differences between SSN and some of the newer cryptography-based ID cards other countries are using.
- kube-system 4y agoWhatever tokens you use to identify someone will be a target for identity theft. You can make the tokens harder to guess or harder to replicate, but with an associated decreased accessibility. The convenient thing about names and DOBs is that most people have them, and most people remember them. The issue with most surrogate tokens is that a remediation process is necessary for when people lose or forget them, and those processes fall back on, you guessed it, name/DOB, etc. Fraud is just a very difficult problem to solve.
- f38zf5vdt 4y agoNo, it's not. Estonia solved it by issuing ID cards with a private key that signs for a public key identifier. [1] Then proving your identity requires the presence of the physical token rather than just the identifier. Unfortunately most Western nations are so embroiled in bureaucracy that this obvious solution will not be available for a long time. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estonian_identity_card https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estonian_identity_card
- 8note 4y agoWhat do you do when you lose it though? Or it burns in a fire? A surrogate token still needs a replacement mechanism
- bombcar 4y agoIt's pretty easy to implement that if you have a central authority to manage the public keys, which a government can do. A bigger issue is how to handle it being stolen (if the "card" also needs something like a passphrase it can reduce this risk, but it's probably better to make it relatively easy to "cancel" if you lose yours, and then you have to head to the DMV or whatever to procure a replacement). Certainly better than knowing 10 digits and where you were born and to whom.
- kube-system 4y ago"Better" depends on which specific problem that someone is experiencing. If your problem is that someone stole the token, then you're better off with a PKI token. If your problem is that you have lost your token, then you're better off with a non-PKI memorable token.
- hakfoo 4y agoIdentity theft can be solved by going more hands-on. Make KYC really mean KYC. If you couldn't get a line of credit without an in-person appearance and fingerprint, that form of identity theft becomes unviable. You have detailed info as to who tried to commit fraud, that can immediately be used for prosecution or tracking repeat offenders.