4 ms·
I suppose they could raise taxes to build a lot more jails and lock all the homeless up. Out of sight, out of mind. (Sorry if this is not obvious sarcasm. To b
by JKCalhoun 4y ago
I suppose they could raise taxes to build a lot more jails and lock all the homeless up. Out of sight, out of mind.
(Sorry if this is not obvious sarcasm. To be sure, I think a city where residents try not to make eye-contact with the man possibly dying in the street is a failed city, it seems the solutions on the other end of the spectrum are tragic as well. Is the middle-solution going back to pre-Reagan mental hospitals?)
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoThe cost of housing a non-functional (drug addicted or mentally ill) unhoused person with the services they need is around $100k/year. Jailing them for a crime they commit is actually cheaper, we aren’t saving money by keeping such people who commit crimes out of jail (regardless of whether that is the right thing to do or not).
- shkkmo 4y agoHow much of that price difference is those needed services not being available in jail? What is the difference in outcomes long term and do the associated long term savings of providing those services outweigh the short term costs of providing them. I convinced there are economic benfits (not just moral ones) of helping these people. The problem is that cities that work to help end up having the economic benefits stolen by cities that offload thier people in need on others. There is a sort of "prisoners dilema” game theory problem here that I think can only be solved at the national level.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoFor drug issues, jails solve that already by restricting freedom. However, the drug addict with socially provided housing is still free to continue using, even if they going to treatment at the same time. Economically speaking, most of these people will never be productive members of society again no matter how many resources we throw at them. Fentanyl destroys your mind fairly quickly. The moral question of giving them a chance to recover even though it is unlikely to succeed still remains.
- shkkmo 4y ago> For drug issues, jails solve that already by restricting freedom. However, the drug addict with socially provided housing is still free to continue using If you think drugs aren't available in jails, I have a bridge to sell you. The effectiveness of jail time on drug cessation is marginal at best. We need better options. > Economically speaking, most of these people will never be productive members of society again no matter how many resources we throw at them. This is an incredibly strong statement for which I know no evidence exists because we have never tried. Additionally, the bar for productive member of society is fairly low and is not the only goal. Simply getting some people into a stable, semi-functional state can improve their lives and reduce the long term state costs. > Fentanyl destroys your mind fairly quickly. I know an individual with significant brain damage resulting in severely impaired mental functioning who is a productive member of society. He does require ongoing support from the state and can't live independently, but does have a job and does contribute some back to society. I doubt we will see 100% recovery rates in our lifetimes, but don't be so quick to write people off before we even try. Practically speaking, drug use and living on the street form a vicious cycle. Each increases the likelihood and severity of the other.
- seanmcdirmid 4y ago> If you think drugs aren't available in jails, I have a bridge to sell you. They are available, just much harder to get. > This is an incredibly strong statement for which I know no evidence exists because we have never tried. This is from my own heartbreaking experiences. Once you get down that path, your chances of coming back are very slim even with lots of help. "Productive" means able to get a job at McDonalds or a grocery store, both of which are desperate for people but neither of which would consider the guy at the homeless encampment next door. It just isn't going to end well. > I know an individual with significant brain damage resulting in severely impaired mental functioning who is a productive member of society. He does require ongoing support from the state and can't live independently, but does have a job and does contribute some back to society. Not the same thing at all. If the individual you know is coasting down Highway 99 on a shopping cart while having a very bad Fentanyl trip, then I guess they are similar? These people are gone in a way that someone with brain damage isn't. > I doubt we will see 100% recovery rates in our lifetimes, but don't be so quick to write people off before we even try. We are trying it right now. We have a whole homelessness industrial complex that has sprung up to collect and spend massive amounts of resources on trying to help these people ($100k/year/person is actually an underestimate). They aren't making progress, perhaps intentionally (so they can continue collecting the money) but probably because progress can't be had here. It might be better just to cut our losses and focus on making sure people don't fall into the homeless/drug abuse trap at all, because once there coming back is really really hard. > Practically speaking, drug use and living on the street form a vicious cycle. Each increases the likelihood and severity of the other. Yes.