5 ms·
What is the new line of commentary going to be after they turfed out Boudin but nothing changes because the problem is the SFPD won’t do their jobs?
by jeffbee 4y ago
What is the new line of commentary going to be after they turfed out Boudin but nothing changes because the problem is the SFPD won’t do their jobs?
- tharne 4y agoYou don't think having a DA who didn't believe in the mission of his own organization had any influence on police morale? Why would officers risk their safety arresting people they know the DA's office had no intention of charging?
- jeffbee 4y agoThe rate at which the DA’s office has charged arrestees has been about the same for decades and is slightly up under Boudin compared to his immediate predecessor. The rate at which the SFPD solves crimes stands at an all-time low.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wusher 4y agoBoth your statement and the parent statement can be true
- alphabettsy 4y agoIt’s what they’re paid to do. They’re not volunteers. Why are we taking the police narrative at face value? It’s usually not correct.
- jakear 4y agoIf you were paid to write PR’s knowing full well that absolutely 0 of them would get merged, and you’d make the same money whether you wrote any or not, what would you do?
- alphabettsy 4y agoI can’t imagine a job where doing nothing would be acceptable. If we’re going to use faulty analogies I’ll add one of my own. Imagine doctors deciding they won’t help an addict because they’ll just keep using. The officers choosing to do nothing are guaranteeing a given outcome with inaction.
- tharne 4y ago> Imagine doctors deciding they won’t help an addict because they’ll just keep using. This happens all the time. If you're an alcoholic no doctor is going to give you a liver transplant. I personally know several dentists who will not work with meth addicts because they feel it's unethical to take money to fix someone's teeth when they know full well that person is just going to destroy them in short order.
- kodah 4y agoI don't think the public issue was with Chesa Boudin and the police. It was his own prosecutors, that campaigned with him, that started the recall.
- lazide 4y agoPlenty of SFPD folks would love to do arrests, but when called made it clear that was no point because the DA would refuse to prosecute. At least that’s what they said on scene. I guess we’ll find out.
- __derek__ 4y ago> Plenty of SFPD folks would love to do arrests, but when called made it clear that was no point because the DA would refuse to prosecute. At least that’s what they said on scene. Assuming that there are legitimate grounds for arrest, this is what it means for police not to do their jobs. AFAIK, there is no "aw, what's the use, anyway?" exception.
- rhino369 4y agoI don't want to defend the cops, but when the DA expressly states they aren't going to enforce certain laws, then its really not their job to arrest people for that anymore. At that point the DA has made is clear that its not a legitimate grounds for arrests even if the law is on the books.
- shkkmo 4y ago> then its really not their job to arrest people for that anymore. Did they quit? If they are still recieving a paycheck then it is quite literally still their job. Instead of doing their job, the police decided to try to do the DA’s job, which is deciding which cases should be prosecuted.
- rhino369 4y agoIf the cops aren't enforcing any law at all, then I'd agree they aren't doing their jobs. But if they are doing the rest of their job, but not arresting people for crimes the DA won't charge, that is doing their full job.
- __derek__ 4y agoI don't know how SF's chain of command is structured, but it would be unusual for the DA to be in there between the city council and SFPD leadership.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoI suppose they could raise taxes to build a lot more jails and lock all the homeless up. Out of sight, out of mind. (Sorry if this is not obvious sarcasm. To be sure, I think a city where residents try not to make eye-contact with the man possibly dying in the street is a failed city, it seems the solutions on the other end of the spectrum are tragic as well. Is the middle-solution going back to pre-Reagan mental hospitals?)
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoThe cost of housing a non-functional (drug addicted or mentally ill) unhoused person with the services they need is around $100k/year. Jailing them for a crime they commit is actually cheaper, we aren’t saving money by keeping such people who commit crimes out of jail (regardless of whether that is the right thing to do or not).
- shkkmo 4y agoHow much of that price difference is those needed services not being available in jail? What is the difference in outcomes long term and do the associated long term savings of providing those services outweigh the short term costs of providing them. I convinced there are economic benfits (not just moral ones) of helping these people. The problem is that cities that work to help end up having the economic benefits stolen by cities that offload thier people in need on others. There is a sort of "prisoners dilema” game theory problem here that I think can only be solved at the national level.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoFor drug issues, jails solve that already by restricting freedom. However, the drug addict with socially provided housing is still free to continue using, even if they going to treatment at the same time. Economically speaking, most of these people will never be productive members of society again no matter how many resources we throw at them. Fentanyl destroys your mind fairly quickly. The moral question of giving them a chance to recover even though it is unlikely to succeed still remains.
- danso 4y agoSure, the SFPD should absolutely be judged if nothing changes despite a new DA, and obviously, especially if it's clear that it's because they are the ones dropping the ball. And the new DA should likewise be judged. District Attorney is at its core a political job, and being able to win over/beat an antagonistic bureaucracy is one of the requirements.
- fzeroracer 4y agoThe next line of argument would be that the police are underfunded and understaffed and that they need a larger budget. It's the same thing they do everywhere else. Here in Austin the police do absolutely nothing even when you have hard evidence of someone committing a crime, partially because the police union's realized they could use 'doing nothing' as a bargaining chip for larger budgets. It's maddening that you can simply not do the job you're paid to do and use that as a way to get paid more.