3 ms·
> we also need a short term solution of preventing people who shouldn't have access to guns in the first place. The republicans are that way because a lot of m
by bluGill 4y ago
> we also need a short term solution of preventing people who shouldn't have access to guns in the first place.
The republicans are that way because a lot of measures to "preventing people who shouldn't have access to guns in the first place" use the large hammer of just banning guns for everyone instead of only those who should. Now they are scared of any attempt to do anything because historically it has taken away guns from safe gun owners who just enjoy them.
There is also the moral hazard: who decides who is safe to have a gun - with careful work you can take guns away from people you don't like.
- vouwfietsman 4y ago"safe gun owners who just enjoy them" Exactly, this is most important point that people forget. It's all about freedom. Personally I'm a safe cruise-missile owner who just enjoys it. Who are you to tell me what to do. If I wanna fire my cruise missiles in my own backyard I'm gonna do it. It's my God-given right. Sure, some people use their cruise missiles to blow up schools, but cruise missiles don't kill people, people kill people. We should just get every school to have a cruise-missile shield, and accompanying cruise-missile bunker. Discount coupons included free in the biology literature package.
- ModernMech 4y ago> Discount coupons included free in the biology literature package. Come on now, your post seemed reasonable until the very end; there would never be a discount.
- roenxi 4y agoIt is an interesting situation because an honest opinion - "the benefits outweigh the costs" - is going to make the people saying it look like monsters (dons flak jacket). There is a reason that the US has anomalously high HDI, income and wealth stats for a country that large. It is because they are all in on freedom, letting individuals better themselves if they can think of a way and putting lots of roadblocks in the way of government (one of which is allowing ordinary people to arm up to the teeth). Trading away that freedom will probably a regression to the mean and worsting circumstance. Out of control governments are much more likely to leave trails of corpses behind them then rogue gunners.
- TMWNN 4y ago>There is a reason that the US has anomalously high HDI, income and wealth stats for a country that large. To put another way, every country with higher average per capita GDP than the US (<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)_per_capita https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)...>) has a population smaller than that of Orange County, California.
- dwallin 4y agoThere's no way one can look at the existing situation and realistically think that gun owners are some sort of persecuted minority, that voting bloc is the golden sheep of the republican party. There's a bit of a distortion field here where we as a country have not been able to pass any sort of meaningful gun control measures in decades, have some of the loosest gun control regulations outside of third world countries, and have significant repeated issues with gun violence. Yet somehow a small but significant group of people have become locked into this messaging as if there's any validity to it and have become single issue voters. Really the two groups who benefit and perpetuate this are from this are the gun industry, who has spent lots of money propagating this messaging over decades, and politicians on the right, who are able to with one hand to fill their election coffers with industry funds and with the other have a reliable bloc of voters that will never vote democrat.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ThrowawayR2 4y ago> "Really the two groups who benefit and perpetuate this are from this are the gun industry ... and politicians on the right ..." And those who want to want to own firearms of course: https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2017/06/22/the-demographics-of-gun-ownership/ https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2017/06/22/the-dem... There's significant ownership of firearms among suburbanites and urbanites and there's significant ownership of firearms among moderates and even among the left. And, of course, purchases of firearms, including first time buyers, increased during the recent pandemic: https://www.usnews.com/news/health-news/articles/2021-12-21/5-million-more-americans-became-gun-owners-during-pandemic https://www.usnews.com/news/health-news/articles/2021-12-21/.... Continuing to blame the traditional conservative bogeymen and ignoring that there is broad support for firearm ownership by the voting public is just sticking one's head in the sand. Until that unwelcome reality is faced and legislation crafted that the public wants (e.g. not bans), gun control is going to remain stalled.
- dwallin 4y agoDo you realize you are agreeing and providing supporting evidence for the point I was making? There is significant gun ownership in this country and support for guns. The idea that gun owners are some persecuted minority is ridiculous. "They are coming for your guns" has been consistent messaging put out by those with an intrenched interest with no basis in reality.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 4y ago> There is also the moral hazard: who decides who is safe to have a gun - with careful work you can take guns away from people you don't like. Yeah, that's my biggest problem with the "in the wrong hands" wording, far too often those words have been code for "in the hands of black people". Pretty much any seemingly reasonable requirement we come up with can be manipulated this way. It's a lot like voter IDs, where the problem is that you can get them at a DMV for free, provided you can take off of work and drive 50 miles to the nearest DMV because the republican governor shuttered the ones near black neighborhoods. Unfortunately I think the only solution is going to come in the form of applying restrictions to everyone. As someone who believes in the second amendment for a variety of reasons, and who owns firearms, I've come to the conclusion that this is preferable to the status quo.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoWe could actually do a lot without gun restrictions by simply limiting supply. 13 million a year domestic gun production is simply too much, and not all of those guns are being smuggled into Mexico and Latin America.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 4y ago> We could actually do a lot without gun restrictions by simply limiting supply. Which would drive up costs, which would again just make it a thing only the wealthy effectively had access to.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoSo? Right now any 18 year old can scrounge up $300 to buy a gun. We make it too easy. Gun control obviously isn’t working, so let’s just ratchet down the supply instead. We just don’t need 13 million new guns a year in this country.