4 ms·
When has progressivism ever led to a different outcome? ISTM that you're quite simply in denial about what progressive policies entail, as a matter of fact. T
by zozbot234 4y ago
When has progressivism ever led to a different outcome? ISTM that you're quite simply in denial about what progressive policies entail, as a matter of fact. The Progressive movement, starting from its earliest origins in the late 19th and early 20th c., has consistently been pro-elite and opposed to meaningful, grassroots-led improvement for "the little guy".
- api 4y agoThere seems to be a certain species of naive leftist who is about as clueless about economics and how to get things done as some rightists are about things like womens' reproductive health. Stuff like "we need to subsidize mortgages to bring down housing costs" or "stop evil developers! housing is too expensive!" is the same level of ideologically driven willful stupidity as "a woman can't get pregnant from rape."
- wussboy 4y agoIt’s almost like one side doesn’t have a monopoly on effective policy. It’s too bad we can’t have laws based on efficacy, regardless of which side of the aisle they come from. “If either the left wing or right wing got control of this country, it would fly around in circles.” Most frustrating of all to me is the Enlightened Centrism memes which equate a rational middle position with agreeing exactly half with both sides and poisons the well for anyone trying to find policy that is effective, regardless of its origin.
- api 4y agoI've been saying for years that we need an "American competence party" that takes a centrist position on culture war issues and focuses on actually fixing things in the real world. A big part of why our politics is so broken is the culture war. It's a godsend to incompetent and corrupt politicians since it allows them to pay lip service or toss low-cost political bones to their "base" while freeing them from the need to do anything hard or get any real results. With the culture war politicians don't have to be competent or earn your vote. Works for both "red" and "blue" sides. There are terribly run places with all-Republican single party rule. Unfortunately the trend has been toward hyper-polarization on culture war issues, making it even harder to select for competence over "correct" cultural alignment with the base. The right likes to bash political correctness but they have their own form of it as well as their own "safe spaces" where only their speech is tolerated. It's definitely a both-sides problem.
- wussboy 4y agoHave you read this?: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superforecasting:_The_Art_and_Science_of_Prediction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superforecasting:_The_Art_and_... I found it fascinating and I think would form the base of your "American Competence Party". Sign me up!
- JaimeThompson 4y agoHow are you using progressivism here? I ask because it seems to have a lot of different meanings depending on who is using it.
- harpiaharpyja 4y agoThis is a really consistent pattern in HN comments. Someone says, "X isn't producing the results people who advocate for X wanted." Then someone else inevitably chimes in, "X was never intended to produce those results from the beginning! It was a plot to benefit a few at the expense of everyone else all along!" X is variously Capitalism, Communism, in this case Progressivism... What is the point of making comments like this? It seems very useless and gets us no further towards a discussion of things that might work. Please drop the rote attempts at agitation. Agitation has never motivated anyone to make the world better. Only a vision of how things could be instead can do that.
- zozbot234 4y agoIdentifying things that cannot possibly work is a necessary part of discussing things that might work.
- justin66 4y ago> The Progressive movement, starting from its earliest origins in the late 19th and early 20th c., You are not thinking clearly about the history of American politics if you group all the movements that called themselves "progressive" together as one.
- the_only_law 4y agoGP likely very of aware of the intended meaning.