8 ms·
“Incidence rates for deaths directly attributable to medical care gone awry haven’t been recognized in any standardized method for collecting national statistic
by giantg2 4y ago
“Incidence rates for deaths directly attributable to medical care gone awry haven’t been recognized in any standardized method for collecting national statistics,”
That's because they're hard to standardize. What qualifies as a medical error? It's easy to go back after the fact and analyze a case where someone has a poor outcome and say 'we should have done this another way'. That doesn't mean there was any indication at the time that the other way would have been better or that the poor outcome could have been foreseen.
I do believe there are a lot of medical mistakes made. I'm a little skeptical that there are legitimately 250k that result in unnecessary death each year. I assume many of those 250k were being treated for serious illnesses that may have taken their lives anyways (not all medical interventions are 100% effective). It would be nice to have a standardized definition, but I'm not sure how that's possible unless we are only talking about treatment received was different than treatment ordered.
- peoplefromibiza 4y ago> It's easy to go back after the fact and analyze a case where someone has a poor outcome and say 'we should have done this another way' summarized by the meme it takes two wipes to know you need three, but three to know you needed two
- willcipriano 4y ago> What qualifies as a medical error? If we just classified things that are obvious. Wrong medication applied (ie paper says to deliver 10mg of Advil but you got a vitamin C tablet), wrong leg amputated, wrong patient data looked at leading to a bad diagnosis. We would likely find a large number of incidents, however no way on earth will you get the American medical cartel to report on them honestly.
- q1w2 4y agoCalling doctors, collectively, the "American medical cartel" isn't helpful language. It's just more polarizing politics that breaks down constructive dialogue.
- anamexis 4y agoI don’t see them referring to doctors as such.
- q1w2 4y agoWho do you think is making the majority of these diagnostic errors?
- willcipriano 4y agoDon't behave like a cartel if you don't want to be called one. From limiting residency slots, making it nearly impossible to hire foreign doctors and lobbying for safe medications that are sold over the counter in the rest of the world to be sold as prescription only in the US. Just to name a few, the AMA has served it's members well to the detriment of anyone buying healthcare in the United States. That to me is a cartel, they just use a "certificate of need" to enforce it's will rather than a gun.
- danachow 4y agoAnytime someone mentions the AMA I just have to ignore them completely. It’s not that the AMA hasn’t done some shady shit throughout the years (especially the 60s), it’s just that in 2022 they are so close to irrelevant that painting them as a boogieman merely shows that your name information is about 50 years out of date. The “medical cartel” as you call it is more and more getting shaped by a number or powerful interest groups none of which are the AMA that is pushing somewhat successfully for fewer doctors in most specialities.
- causi 4y agoI'm a little skeptical that there are legitimately 250k that result in unnecessary death each year From purely anecdotal experience, that number is totally believable. Again anecdotally, the medical field seems to only have two kinds of people, the extraordinarily competent and dedicated, and people who don't give a whiff of a shit. The medical bell curve looks more like a bathtub.
- rscho 4y agoI gather you are not a healthcare professional, hence the artificial dichotomy stemming from your perception as an outsider. Medical competency is very difficult to assess objectively. You're good/bad because people say so. There isn't any form of performance feedback.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoHow can that be? A patient gets diagnosed. There's treatment. There's an outcome. That can't be measured? And assessed? There's data flowing all over the place. But perhaps the lawyers and the insurance stand in the way of improvement?
- rscho 4y agoInsurance, precisely. Insurance companies are pushing for performance assessment to put pressure on prices. All well and good until you understand that you can't force hospitals/practitioners to all get a random sample of patients. So measurements are biased, and therefore people game the system. In practice, it means all healthcare providers will concentrate on easy cases to lower risk and maximize revenue. So as you see, free market thought doesn't really work in healthcare.
- nradov 4y agoIt's not a legal or insurance issue, it's a data gathering and classification issue. There is no such thing as a standard patient. Especially when it comes to surgical procedures, everyone is unique. We generally don't have ways to accurately assess the impact of factors like patient age, fitness level, body composition, and co-morbid conditions. So instituting a quality measurement system like you describe would have the perverse effect of causing physicians to keep their numbers up by refusing to take the riskiest patients on at all.
- q1w2 4y agoThe research fixates on the notion of "error/mistake" (because it's more easily quantifiable), but the reality is that most people do not get "optimal" care. In fact, in any given service, in any given industry, no one gets "optimal" care - that's just human nature. Doctors are humans. It's also completely inefficient. Humans make judgement calls based on available resources. If everyone over 45 received "optimal" care, they would all effectively live in hospitals.
- gitfan86 4y agoThere is a big difference between a perfectly healthy 18 year old accidentally receiving a lethal dose of fentanyl instead of 400mg of Tylenol AND a 95 year old not having a mole removal rescheduled after the Doctors office was closed for a day unexpectedly. Both things are errors. And both could lead to death.
- starkd 4y agoThe article stresses that all medical errors are not necessarily due to bad doctors. It's also bad coordination between different services, miscommunication, etc. Dr. Makary points out various process problems that are not necessarily the fault of any individual doctor.
- deltaonefour 4y agoIt's still doctors. Doctors are responsible for coordination and miscommunication. They define the process, it's still on them.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ren_engineer 4y ago>That's because they're hard to standardize there's a 4X difference between good surgeons and bad surgeons in terms of bad outcomes or complications. And the same study shows that surgeons are actually accurate in terms of assessing who is good and bad but there's really no way for patients to find out before surgery https://twitter.com/emollick/status/1520589431861878786 https://twitter.com/emollick/status/1520589431861878786