4 ms·
How is this reasonable, if not criminal behavior? If your jailers keep you without explaining what you are detained for, or if that reason turns out to be inco
by Aeolun 4y ago
How is this reasonable, if not criminal behavior?
If your jailers keep you without explaining what you are detained for, or if that reason turns out to be incorrect, it aught to be a crime.
- notch656a 4y agoOnce you're in a cell, whether it is reasonable or not becomes irrelevant (or at least not too useful to fixate on in the short run). You deal with the reality and debate the reasonableness after you attain freedom.
- ChrisKnott 4y agoDo you have any links to explain this. I don't understand what gives them the power to detain you...?
- BrianHenryIE 4y agohttps://reddit.com/r/acab https://reddit.com/r/acab The guns and support they have give them the power. The law does not always support them, but often does. Watch the videos in the link and the corresponding lack of justice to understand what our reality is.
- wombatpm 4y agoThe Constitution does not apply at the borders
- sky-kedge0749 4y agoThat's not true, see: https://www.aclu.org/other/constitution-100-mile-border-zone https://www.aclu.org/other/constitution-100-mile-border-zone. In fact "the Constitution doesn't apply at the borders" is what border cops want people to think, so repeating it is doing their work for them.
- notch656a 4y agoUnfortunately authority 'given' to CBP at the actual border (for crossers) significantly exceeds that of the 100 mile zone. They can basically detain you indefinitely without charging you with a crime and meanwhile strip search you, finger print you, toss you in a cell, etc. The constitution doesn't apply at the border. Maybe in theory it does, but in reality it doesn't. CBP Officers specifically told me "I consent to whatever happens afterwards when I cross the border." [ Also been told once, me a US citizen with a passport, that they had decided not to let me in my own country. Was not let through until an HSI detective came to "make sure I wasn't ISIS." ] You get no attorney. You can't contact anyone. You can't touch your phone, if you have one. You can be tossed in custody without any oversight, and without being mirandarized. I have been booked, finger printed, tossed in a cell as a US citizen who provided a legal passport and violated no laws. You can be tossed in a van, cuffed and shackled and driven wherever they like, including hospitals where they will try to convince doctors to anal probe you (this is a real example from my personal experience). I've studied the court cases involving US citizens, including a woman who had her orifices brutally penetrated until they were raw by a doctor[0]. THe federal docket shows no real result, and that the CBP investigated themselves and determined they did nothing wrong. In the end the courts don't give a fuck, and most Americans don't even have a passport. I'm quite sure a good 10% of Americans would go along with a proposal that said "We should allow border patrol to shoot any suspicious persons at our borders." Border and immigration are notoriously dystopian arms of the government, because citizens either have bigger concerns or just don't give a shit what happens there. If you contact a lawyer regarding border abuse, they will basically refer you to the (swamped) ACLU, because they know it's a waste of their time to even try. [0] https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.azd.985537/gov.uscourts.azd.985537.1.0.pdf https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.azd.985...
- sky-kedge0749 4y agoI'm sorry that all happened to you, that sounds really bad. I'm not doubting your experience. However I think it's important for Americans in particular to maintain the distinction between "the Constitution applies and border police are acting illegally" and "the Constitution literally has no force in these situations" when discussing these problems in forums like this one. A lot of the recent creeping fascism involves the fascists treating the law as if it didn't exist, but when actually called on it they back off. Of course as a practical matter anyone crossing a U.S. border should understand the risk of arbitrary violence, deportation, detention, or having all your stuff taken.
- Sohcahtoa82 4y agoBecause half the country thinks it's a great system.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- car_analogy 4y agoWhich is why law & justice style TV shows display and glorify this kind of psychopathic, picking on the weak and helpless behavior, right? Or do they show the criminal justice system as staffed by noble individuals that, on the rare occasion they cross a line, it is done with the best intentions, and bad apples and mistakes are a rare exception? The system they think is great is imaginary, not the system you actually have. Try and think things through before you so casually condemn people.
- 93po 4y agoI cannot watch any sort of cop show or Law & Order for this exact reason. It's a bunch of glorification of the government infringing on people's rights and normalizing it as some sort of reality of how the justice system should work. I wish there would be a version of law and order where no one ever talks to them without a lawyer present and they constantly get frustrated with their lack of progress despite their best efforts to circumvent the legal process.