5 ms·
China 'must seize TSMC' if the US were to impose sanctions
- systemvoltage 4y agoI'm really interested in how Taiwan would destroy its fabs. Like boots-on-the-ground mechanics of how this would work. C4 charges implanted in server rooms and the entire fab? Or a special task force steps in and wires the whole building with explosives? Air strike after evacuating the Fab? Close by Ground-to-ground artillery/guided missiles? Digital keys that disable all equipment and wipe out all data/IP? I'd love to be a fly on the wall in these military rooms if something like this is going on. Even better to be part of the team in charge of handling this scenario. That kind of sounds like a whole lot of fun.
- kryptiskt 4y agoJust about all the equipment in fabs is tremendously sensitive to contamination. You could probably put one out of action for months just by opening the doors to outside air.
- plmpsu 4y agoBut what about reverse engineering?
- salawat 4y agoDing ding ding. Just knowing something is possible is often a great breakthrough to advancing understanding
- 7speter 4y agoThe chinese would still have tangible examples of ip to reverse engineer. The thing is that TSMC is building fabs in the US and in Europe (iirc), so even if China starts producing products replicating TSMC, the west can’t be held economic hostage in such a scenario for much longer.
- bergenty 4y agoThat still leaves it open to reverse engineering though. You would atleast have to bomb the place.
- everforward 4y agoI'm not an expert, but my impression was that chip fabs are incredibly sterile places. You could probably disable one for a long time by just chucking a barrel full of dust into the cleanroom. If it were total destruction, my money would be on artillery. Wikipedia says the range for modern artillery is 15-300km, which gives a very wide radius in which artillery could be hidden (ignoring local geography). If the artillery was preemptively dialed into the fab, it could be fired at very short notice, and I don't think anyone would be able to stop the shells mid-flight.
- oceanghost 4y agoI worked in a clean room for a couple of years-- you are correct that any contamination could cost months of cleaning. Possibly even losing environmental control of the facility. A lot of people don't realize clean rooms have temperatures/humidity factors that must be maintained. That being said I'm sure the real risk is the Chinese capturing the machines-- it is acknowledged they are about 15 years behind the state of the art.
- shrubble 4y agoOpen barrel of fluorantimonic acid. Turn on humidifier. Leave the area!
- fakethenews2022 4y agoIf they really wanted to destroy the capability, wouldn't they have to kill the engineers and technicians or at least evacuate them? Just look at history with operation Paperclip where German rocket scientists surrendered to the Allies. Those German scientists formed the core of NASA. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Paperclip https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Paperclip
- squarefoot 4y agoChina would probably have the workforce and technology to rebuild it almost quickly, unless the physical destruction is also accompanied by all engineers fleeing to western countries carrying all IP with them. That would represent quite a damage.
- wil421 4y agoThe military bombs it.
- Maursault 4y agoRansomeware.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago"However, she then claimed the US was seeking to isolate China, citing the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) and Trans-Atlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) agreements as attempts by the US to create two large 'anti-China' trade bodies, although the US pulled out of the former and the latter was cancelled because of disagreements." This is either a nonsense article or the speaker is saying nonsense to appease a domestic constituency. The only thing I can think of is Xi's upcoming Hong Kong visit.
- sonotathrowaway 4y agoWhat about those claims exactly do you consider nonsense?
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> What about those claims exactly do you consider nonsense? Raising hackles over moot agreements, one from which the U.S. withdrew, the other which is dead.
- zardo 4y agoJust because they failed to implement doesn't mean the effort is dismissed. They indicate Washington's intent.
- sdfhdhjdw3 4y agoConcur.
- sdfhdhjdw3 4y agoBut your honor, my client didn't actually succeed in robbing the bank. Bang - case dismissed.
- wahern 4y agoThe U.S. pulled out because it doesn't want to "create two large 'anti-China' trade bodies". For better or worse (worse, IMO) U.S. preference for the past couple of decades has been a multitude of bilateral agreements, which by their nature would be neither pro- nor anti-China. And the TPP was ratified (as the TPP11) without the U.S. Should we now consider all of Australia, Brunei, Canada, Chile, Japan, Malaysia, Mexico, New Zealand, Peru, Singapore, and Vietnam anti-China? I don't think China gets any warm fuzzies from Australia and Japan, but what about all the rest? In any event, what does China expect when its official industrial policy is to milk trade agreements for all their worth without relinquishing any markets to outsiders. OTOH, conflating (as this Register article does) the proposals of some Chinese economist, no matter how domestically renowned, with official Chinese policy definitely smacks of alarmism and, perhaps, anti-China bias.
- srvmshr 4y agoFor a supposed economist of national repute, juxtaposing TSMC with Taiwan is facepalm meme worthy. China's interest in Taiwan predates TSMC & mobile chips. 'Semiconductor wars' are just the pretex of doing something military and stupid. Surely she is not serious. In my observation, overzealous nationalism has occasionally paved way for intermittent insanity The good (or the bad, depends) news is that China will be shooting itself in the foot. And onto the foot of every manufacturing country ready to answer back loudly either as sanctions or trade blockades. (Assuming US doesn't do anything except looking away). Any invasion will certainly create enough chaos to halt the factories at the least - and utter destruction in the usual scheme. Besides they don't gain any trade secrets - those lie with ASML, sitting comfortably in NL. Net gain is negative for China. Factory inoperable? Check. Unnecessary war? check. Economic sanctions & international pariah? check. CCP politburo members sure see this forecast in their calculus. Semiconductor production is moving closer to being reality in US, for all the obvious geopolitics & supply chain. Invasions or plans thereof will have no bearing on their deployment, rather pace it faster.
- NicoJuicy 4y agoASML in the Netherlands and Imec in Belgium fyi. For the rest, i fully agree it will be borderline chaos. They can't even manage COVID with their propaganda.
- dirtyid 4y ago> not serious > is moving closer to being reality This article has less to do with TW soverignty but US/PRC tech war. Chen explicitly already presumes rebellious TW to be Chinese territory and TSMC to be a Chinese company under hostile governance that's giving up crown jewels to the enemies (western efforts to get production off island). Proposal is stating the obvious: current sanctions has trapped PRC a few nodes behind. If US tries to increase the gap via additional sanctions before they reshore substantively, PRC can deter by threatening to deny US access to TW expertise and IP to cripple nascent efforts to reshore (via force). It's short term signally that if US goes full out on severe PRC tech sanctions (i.e. Russia tier), forget getting any TW experts to help spin up Arizona fabs. It's recognizing that both sides need time, PRC needs 5-10 years to build indigenous sanction proof supply chain and US needs as much time to reshore from TW (CHIPS act projects account for like 5% of current TSMC production), but if US tries to make things too difficult for PRC, PRC will spoil US efforts as well. It's trying to maintain current status quo that works / doesn't work in anyone's favour. Proposal essentially within bounds of strategic thinking in PRC circles. TLDR is short/medium term US via origin tech controls has leverage during peacetime via sanctions. But PRC has leverage during war time simply because they can destroy TW and in worst case scenario, East Asian semi supply chain. Yeah PRC will suffer, but most of semi production profits goes to western companies, and has disproportionate knock on affect in advanced western industries, like 10s of trillions in productivity for short/medium term. Ultimately she's being polite and ignoring the raze TSMC to the ground option - PRC's mutually assured destruction card to reset everyone to 2000s tech for a few decades. Meanwhile PRC is one of the few countries, if not only, trying to create a wholey indigenous semi supply chain, even if stuck a few nodes behind. It's resetting the gap to same level if not in PRC favour. As for whether she's serious, the interview was posted on guancha not global times. At least in terms of threat/messaging (directed at US), it's somewhat serious. Like her opinion isn't controversial, but it is someone with visibility saying quiet part out loud.
- namlem 4y agoThe idea that TSMC is the main reason why China wants control of Taiwan is ridiculous. It factors in of course, but the issue goes way deeper than computer chips for China. One, it's a point of national shame that factors heavily into CCP propaganda. It's seen as a loose end from the Civil War. And two, capturing Taiwan would give the Chinese navy unlimited access to the Pacific.
- JoeyBananas 4y agoA lot of people may not realize that Taiwan has prime real estate for submarine bases. There is a coastal shelf around mainland China that limits their ability to have submarines.
- kwatsonafter 4y agoI don't think there's currently a political impetus to impose rigid sanctions on China despite human rights violations or perceived economic competition. As far as Taiwan is concerned I think Xi might take a lesson from Putin's failings in Ukraine; China has peaked economically (Google, "birth rates/high school graduation rates China") for the most part and making China the boogeyman of the world for what is mostly symbolic gains (semiconductor industry not withstanding) is foolish. China isn't replacing the U.S./NATO/Mob Boss for another few hundred years.
- nsonha 4y agowhere is this "must seize TSMC" quote? A month ago there was also some discussion in which the media alleged Putin of saying "nuclear deterence" when he just said "deterence". Do the journalists think their job is to read people's mind and word it whatever way they see fit to manufacture consent for going to war with China?
- akeck 4y agoI read rumors a while back that the US would bomb TSMC if it looked like China could get it. It reminded me of the 1177 Bronze Age collapse - except with chips instead of bronze. (Btw, the Throughline podcast on 1177 is excellent).
- akomtu 4y agoQuote: “Crush the enemy” is a key strategic tenet of Sun-tzu, the fourth-century-B.C. author of The Art of War. If, in your struggles with them, you stop halfway or even three quarters of the way, out of mercy or hope of reconciliation, you only make them more determined, more embittered, and they will someday take revenge. Mao Tse-tung, a devoted reader of Sun-tzu and of Chinese history generally, knew the importance of this law. In 1934 the Communist leader and some 75,000 poorly equipped soldiers fled into the desolate mountains of western China to escape Chiang Kai-shek’s much larger army, in what has since been called the Long March. Chiang was determined to eliminate every last Communist, and by a few years later Mao had less than 10,000 soldiers left. By 1937, in fact, when China was invaded by Japan, Chiang calculated that the Communists were no longer a threat. He chose to give up the chase and concentrate on the Japanese. Ten years later the Communists had recovered enough to rout Chiang’s army. Chiang had forgotten the ancient wisdom of crushing the enemy; Mao had not. Chiang was pursued until he and his entire army fled to the island of Taiwan. Nothing remains of his regime in mainland China to this day.
- unmole 4y agoI cringe everytime someone frames geopolitics in terms of what the Art of War, The Prince or the Arthashastra supposedly said. I really don't understand what purpose it is supposed to serve.