2 ms·
One problem with effective altruism is that it is highly utilitarian leading to hijacking of utility metrics as mentioned in the article. However, the author on
by imtringued 4y ago
One problem with effective altruism is that it is highly utilitarian leading to hijacking of utility metrics as mentioned in the article. However, the author only talked about people making arguments in good faith, hoping to improve metrics. What about people acting in bad faith? Longtermism has hijacked it's utility metric by assuming endless exponential growth of the human population in the future and therefore giving future lives more value, overriding all short term concerns which is then used to justify authoritarianism. It falls into the same trap as any ideology. People think it is going to save the world, so it must be adopted at any cost, even if people are going to starve and die. This has lead to the downfall of communism for example. The height of irony is that longtermism is purely about short term thinking.