10 ms·
Riding London’s unexpectedly fantastic Elizabeth line
- sofixa 4y agoI recently rode on it, for the fun, and although the signage could be a little clearer, it was quite a good experience. It's the same principle as the Parisian RER network ( suburban lines outside the city, new tunnels under the city center with few key stops) which started in the 60s, just with a newer and more modern ( platform screen doors, most notably) execution.
- nailer 4y agoYou’re right about the signage. Elizabeth line looks like the tube, feels like the tube, but technically isn’t the tube. So there’s no signs to other tube lines. Just signs on how to get to the tube which feels weird because you thought you were already on the tube. It would be better to explicitly spell out directions to what tube lines are available.
- richij 4y agoStrictly speaking (the best kind of speaking), it looks and feels like TFL. Which it is.
- nicoburns 4y agoI feel like it’s not at all unexpected that the Elizabeth Line is fantastic (although this is probably a little over exuberant by British standards of praise). Over budget but well implemented seems to have been the pattern for public infrastructure projects in the UK for some time now.
- samwillis 4y agoI think your right, however they don’t always pick the right projects to do. HS2 for example isn’t exactly thought of as the right place to spend a few 10s billion pounds.
- Arbortheus 4y agoPerhaps unpopular opinion but I think HS2 is the correct option. Firstly, more capacity is needed on the rail network and this is a key arterial route that is already running at/over capacity. Secondly, it'll allow freight to be added to the existing slower lines, which is key for decarbonisation. Finally, if you're going to build new railway lines, you might as well build something that isn't immediately obsolete. The alternative is to build something that is fast-but-not-quite-high-speed, which means not using what is essentially industry standard for new rail lines. It would be a bizarre choice.
- pharmakom 4y agoI support HS2 but as an alternative to more road building. Unfortunately the government seems to have chosen both!
- scrlk 4y ago>Firstly, more capacity is needed on the rail network and this is a key arterial route that is already running at/over capacity. I always found it bizarre that most of the press around HS2 never really mentions the capacity issues of the West Coast Main Line. Most people will ask "why spend £100 bn to shave 30 mins off London - Birmingham, can't you just upgrade the existing lines?", which IMO is a fair question to ask. They need to do a better job of explaining why it's not practical to upgrade the WCML & why building a new line is the better long term solution.
- chrisseaton 4y agoI use the WCML a lot and it's pretty rickety. Parts of it are like a rollercoaster. I'm not sure you can go any faster on it and I guess it can't be straightened and levelled as (like most of the UK) the terrain is congested.
- vinay427 4y agoOut of curiosity, which parts are these? I’ve used it up to Preston several times and didn’t notice much out of the ordinary (compared to trains in Switzerland, for instance).
- nbevans 4y agoIndeed - the expectations were very high for Crossrail before and during development. All that has happened is they have delivered the product exactly as described, albeit 4 years later and over budget. It should be noted that 4 years ago the BBC were running documentaries about how successful the Crossrail project had been after the tunnels were finished and most of the stations were almost done. It seems that nobody expected the software and signalling to take an additional 4 years of time. Somebody somewhere really messed up that part of the project. Everything else - the main civil engineering project - did go extremely smoothly and was even ahead of schedule at times.
- basisword 4y agoIt’s not like software engineers to underestimate how long something will take :)
- CraigJPerry 4y agoHow do we fix it though? I empathise with the developers involved - there’s an inclination to look at what they had to do as just engineer some software to manage some signals, some diagnostics and some trains. And to some extent that’s true but it overlooks the other part of their process which is more akin to painting a great artwork - when will you be done with that? I frequently see one answer fail - we just need to plan it more thoroughly, don’t just estimate, go through exactly what you’ll need, identify dependencies now not during coding. These efforts always fall for the same reason, when it comes time to implement, the plan is hopelessly out of date, incomplete and just plain naïve. It’s easy to deliver software on time up to around 10kLOC (i.e. single developer short project). Beyond that, the variables cascade and avalanche exponentially. The problem with this is all the interesting problems need >1dev and certainly more than 10kLoc! On balance I’m more persuaded by XP than by Royce but honestly i don’t think either approach makes or breaks, both can work well.
- nbevans 4y agoIt was a highly complex integration of 3 different railway signalling protocols. These are safety critical systems that need to be "proven" to be safe through extensive simulation tests and real-world testing. The Crossrail/Siemens team that worked on this integration split the project up into 4 parts. 3 parts for each signalling system. And then the final part to allow transitioning a train between each signalling system in a seamless way. They were testing the trains on the western, central and eastern parts of the line for years as a way of gaining confidence in their work. It has been reported that this is the first time anywhere in the world that a railway has been created to support multiple signalling systems and be able to transition seamlessly between them during service.
- Naga 4y agoI’d take that. The Canadian pattern is over budget poorly implemented.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mrec 4y ago> fantastic [...] is probably a little over exuberant by British standards of praise Indeed. "Quite good" is usually considered the absolute pinnacle of fawning adulation.
- cormullion 4y agonot too shabby
- nprateem 4y agoJust one notch above the almost exceptional "not bad"
- yetanotherloser 4y agoPlease. "Not bad at all, really."
- not2b 4y agoIf a Brit says that my presentation was "quite good", I know I am in trouble.
- OJFord 4y agoMy favourite thing (as a Brit) about 'quite' or rather trying to explain it, is 'quite good' vs. 'really quite good'. (The former can vary with tone sure, but typically I think quite slating, as parent describes. Somehow saying it's 'really' so though turns it around completely, making it impressive.)
- richij 4y agoYes! British English really is a tone language.
- kitd 4y ago"Over budget" gets forgotten about in a few years. "Well implemented" lasts its lifetime.
- samwillis 4y agoWhat will be of interest to HN readers is the reason for, well one of, the delay. The Elizabeth line (it was called Cross Rail during development) is the first train line that combines both the national rail infrastructure and the London Underground. Combining the signalling systems has be an incredible complex problem. There is quite a bit online to read about it: https://www.wired.co.uk/article/crossrail-delay-logistics https://www.wired.co.uk/article/crossrail-delay-logistics https://www.crossrail.co.uk/project/our-plan-to-complete-the-elizabeth-line/signalling-and-testing# https://www.crossrail.co.uk/project/our-plan-to-complete-the...
- Arbortheus 4y agoThis video also explains the problems: https://youtu.be/rtE0nlOrwGQ https://youtu.be/rtE0nlOrwGQ. In fact, it's not just the problem of combining the national rail and underground signalling systems, but there's even a third signalling system used by the Heathrow Express. So the trains will need to seamlessly transition between TPWS on the national railway lines, then CBTC in the London underground, and ETCS when going to Heathrow airport. I think this is what they call integration hell, and is responsible for delays of several years. When you consider the complexity, but also the safety-critical nature of these train signalling systems, it's no wonder it has overrun.
- steve_gh 4y agoHere's the basic problem. Network Rail (the UK's national rail track authority) runs a timetabled service. So they have planned where every train should be at any moment. The underground is a metro service. They are not trying to maintain an absolute timetable, but a constant interval between trains - for example if they have a problem with a train they will delay trains ahead to try and smooth the intervals between trains and stop platforms becoming dangerously crowded. So the "integration hell" is trying to integrate between services with completely different service strategies.
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoThese are not completely different service strategies. Both have planned where every trains should be at any moment. The difference is the amount of leeway you have to fix operational issues. You can think of the metro as a “timetabled” system where the density is so high you have no margin. When something happen you have to shift and cancel. Train lines start having exactly the same issues when they operate near capacity. Both systems have the same constraints. Trains can’t overtake. You can only have one per block. The integration difficulty is that they don’t manage blocks in the same way and use different signalling. You see the same issue on lines which are shared between SNCF and RATP in Paris. The A line used to require a driver change at the junction.
- formerkrogemp 4y agoWe wish we had decent rail lines in the US.
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoWe do, we just use it to move astonishing amounts of cargo instead of humans.
- formerkrogemp 4y agoThat's a nice little take to hide the fact we can't build or run anything as competently as we used to do. Our trains aren't the fastest, or haul the most commuters, or the most extensive, or the safest, but we sure do haul some tonnage of coal. FYI 70% of goods, ie cargo, in the US are transported by trucks. Our trains suck in the US and need massive investments to become more relevant.
- chrisseaton 4y agoThe US only has like 500 miles of modern rail track - between Boston and Washington.
- gumby 4y agoI wouldn’t call that “modern”: the “high speed” train has a top speed of 86 mph and in my experience only attains that for 15 minutes between Boston and NYC. On the NYC DC stretch, scheduled “high speed” service is only 20-30 minutes shorter than the much cheaper regular service that stops at every station.
- chrisseaton 4y ago> “high speed” train has a top speed of 86 mph Wikipedia says 150, but I guess if you live there you probably know better. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acela https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acela
- 4y ago
- Biologist123 4y agoLooking at the Wikipedia page for the project, I was interested to see that proposals for the project were drawn up between 1941-48. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crossrail https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crossrail
- gumby 4y agoCheck out the second ave subway in NYC which was planned in 1920. The first phase opened in 2017; the second phase construction. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Avenue_Subway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Avenue_Subway
- Biologist123 4y agoFascinating. (Aaarrghhhhh).
- rowanajmarshall 4y agoI took the Elizabeth Line last week for the first time, to get to Comic-Con. It was great, same vibe as the DLR only underground.
- cpncrunch 4y agoPresumably faster than the DLR!
- LightG 4y agoI'm sure others will disagree but, as a Londoner, I wish they'd spent the money on the rest of the system. There's a cohort of us that have to put our fingers in our ears on the approach to some stations as the grinding of wheels against tracks reaches an incredible volume. Pretty sure it must be illegal on some checklist somewhere. Not to mention the raggedy state of most of the other lines. I'll stop before this becomes a full blown rant.
- mcintyre1994 4y agoI’ll always remember that extremely hot summer when someone tweeted at the Central Line support twitter account about how bad it was, and got a cheery response that it’ll be sorted in “early 2030” when they get new trains with air conditioning.
- blibble 4y agoit's a difficult problem to solve as air conditioning doesn't produce cold, it only moves the heat elsewhere (producing more heat in the process) on a tube train there's nowhere to expel the heat other than the tunnel, which doesn't really solve the problem (plus the trains are small enough as it is, without large AC units)
- LightG 4y agoAnd yet, they manage it Tokyo ... It's a lack of funding and vision, not technology ... which returns us to my original point that I wish the money had goone on the existing network.
- blibble 4y agoit would require re-boring of all the deep-level tube tunnels to make them larger which essentially isn't possible, so that would require building an entire new London Underground this would cost probably a trillion pounds
- lostlogin 4y ago
- xedarius 4y agoIt is great and should be celebrated. For me the big win is no longer having to hand over high-way robbery amounts of money for the Heathrow express. Having a better and cheaper service to Heathrow terminals is brilliant. Byeeeee Heathrow express!
- joshvm 4y agoYes, I'm also curious what will happen there. The Express is still faster (20 vs 30 mins), but costs twice as much. And you have to get it from Paddington. It sits in a weird niche where the alternative rail routes weren't that much longer, but if you really had to get to the airport in a hurry (especially connecting from the West Country) it was a nice emergency option. Now you also have the option of doing Reading > Hayes > Heathrow entirely on the Elizabeth Line. My biggest gripe is that despite the high price, you spend the entire journey being force-fed live news on the TV and PR fluff about how it's the best rated line in the UK (no surprise, it goes between two stations).
- cannam 4y agoHeathrow Express has long been a bit lost. The original idea was that you would check in for your flight - including baggage drop - at Paddington before taking the Express. When the "lawn" area at Paddington was opened in 1999, the back wall (now a row of shops, from Boots to Fat Face) was a row of check-in desks with baggage facilities. I never used these and I kind of wish I had, because after 9/11 they closed and never reopened. [edit: Wikipedia tells me the check-in service ran until 2003 and "was withdrawn due to low usage and high cost of operation", nothing to do with 9/11. My mind must have filled in the more dramatic memory] Then a few years later the Heathrow Connect service opened, a slightly slower, much cheaper alternative to the Express (it changed names a few times but I believe is the same service as now constitutes the Elizabeth Line on that stretch) - so nobody who was coming from Paddington, planning ahead, and paying their own fare had much reason to take the Express any more.
- orev 4y agoHeathrow Express is likely used mostly by business travelers, who expense everything to their company. So the price doesn’t matter.
- dmurray 4y ago> ran from Paddington, where the great railways entered London from the west, to Farringdon, on the edge of the city The New Yorker sub-editors are notoriously anal about their house style, but you'd think the one who dealt with this article could have left it as "the edge of the City" rather than completely changing the meaning.
- randomcarbloke 4y agoAm I to infer they have ceased capitalising proper nouns?
- cja 4y agoThank you. I don't know much about London geography and this really confused me. I could believe neither that the underground line went outwards from Paddington nor that Paddington was outside the city at that time.
- stuaxo 4y agoFarringdon, the edge of "The City of London", certainly not the city named London.
- iqkznnft 4y agoWhy is it unexpected that it's fantastic? What a stupid thing to say.
- ksec 4y agoWell first thing is that the Elizebeth line, even on the World Stage is absolutely top class ( I know that doesn't sound very British XD ). And It is building on top or next to the oldest underground / railroad system. There are plenty of new infrastructures that aren't better than similar ones in Japan or South Korea. The second this is coming from Newyorker.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- United857 4y agoBit of trivia: the Elizabeth Line is actually run by a subsidary of Hong Kong's MTR, arguably one of the best transit systems in the world. https://www.scmp.com/news/world/europe/article/3179455/londons-new-elizabeth-line-running-and-its-being-run-hong-kongs https://www.scmp.com/news/world/europe/article/3179455/londo...
- hgomersall 4y agoThis highlights something that's amused me for a while about our "privatised" rail system - the private companies are mostly owned by foreign state transport companies.
- mhh__ 4y agoThe thing is that British (mainly Tory) politicians who believe in privatisation do not care about basically anything other than tax bills or giving contracts to conveniently nepotistic ventures. Sometimes there is nothing wrong with this, but equally we have lost vast amounts of skills within our borders basically because privatisation is aimed at the wrong kind of efficiency.
- karencarits 4y agoThis is also true in Norway, SJ - previously called the Swedish State Railways - is now managing trains several places after the privatisation of the rail system
- djhn 4y agoAnd the Finnish railways (VR) recently acquired a business serving Sweden.
- qgin 4y agoOver budget or not, this kind of project seems literally impossible in the United States.
- yur3i__ 4y agoMeanwhile the rest of the country languishes in underfunded, underdeveloped transport infrastructure. The divide between the south east and the rest of the country becomes more stark day by day.